Location of Repository

Repair in Web-based Conversation: A Case of Chinese Academic Discussion

By Ruowei Robin Yang


This study examines Web-based conversation, focusing on Chinese academic discussion, from a Conversation Analysis (CA) perspective. The research investigates repair in asynchronous talk-in-interaction on the Web and compares this with repair in ordinary conversation in English, as analysed by Schegloff et al. (1977). It also explores the reasons for any differences which arise from the setting in which this study takes place.\ud The research analyses naturally occurring written interaction on Web-based discussion boards from two education courses offered by the Open University of Hong Kong. Over 4,000 po stings, with nearly half a million Chinese characters, which were contributed by 400 participants were captured and analysed.\ud The study adds fresh data to existing CA work on repair and talk-in-interaction, and provides new information about how repair is organized in asynchronous conversation in Chinese through the Web - an area in which very limited work has been carried out to date. The research shows that repair systems exist in Web-based conversation and that, while the basic possible structures for repair are the same as in ordinary conversation, some operations in the system are different. Seven forms of initiation techniques for repair and ten repair patterns in Web-based conversation are identified and exemplified. The analysis of 351 instances of repair shows that the majority (63.2%) are other-repairs, which demonstrates that preferences in repair in Web-based academic discussions are very different from those which have been proposed for ordinary conversation.\ud The study deals with three external factors that have an impact on repair in Web-based conversation, namely the medium of the Web, asynchronous interaction, and the written form of language use, of which the first is the central, as the latter two are determined by it.\ud The study concludes by discussing some possible implications of the findings for distance learning and teaching, and also for developing technology for human communication through the Internet, in particular the Web

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 2006
OAI identifier: oai:lra.le.ac.uk:2381/8827

Suggested articles



  1. ($/1~~)(1996) Analysis of repair structure in conversation,
  2. (2003). ($f~) (2001) 11m B 'M.~ii r:p B"Jfm{gfX~fI~, Master degree dissertation,
  3. (faJ~~~~)(1989) Introduction to Pragmatics (§-gm~m:~),
  4. (1998). A discourse analysis of contrastive connectives in English, Korean and Japanese conversation: with special reference to the context of dispreferred responses,
  5. (1992). A phonetic description of some repair sequences in Akan conversation,
  6. (1984). A reexamination of conversational repair.
  7. (1974). A simplest systematics for the organization of tum-taking for conversation,
  8. (1994). A=t;Zt1E. J:.tB~:ff.~ii7tifJT, Master degree dissertation,
  9. (1981). Adults corrections of children's mistakes,
  10. (1985). An Introduction to Discourse Analysis (2nd edn), London and
  11. Analysing single episodes of interaction: an exercise in conversations tum-taking organization,
  12. (1994). Approaches to DiscourLce, Blackwell Textbooks in Linguistics.
  13. (1999). April) Conversations that Lead to Learning in a Computer Age: Tracking how individuals make sense of socially shared classroom conversations, paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association,
  14. (1985). Composition as conversation: the computer terminal as medium of communication,
  15. (1993). Computer Conjerencing: The last word, Beach Holme British Columbia,
  16. (1984). Computer mediated communication as a force in language change,
  17. (1986). Computer networking: making connections between speech and writing ERIC/CLL,
  18. (1998). Computer-mediated communication and scholarly discourse: forms of topic-initiation and thematic development,
  19. (1996). Computer-Mediated Communication: Linguistic. social and cross-cultural perspectives. AmsterdamlPhiladelphia,
  20. (1985). Computer-mediated interpersonal communication,
  21. (1990). Computers and Conversation.
  22. (1987). Concurrent operations in talk: notes on the interactive organization of assessments,
  23. (1969). Content Analysis/or the Social Sciences and Humanities.
  24. (1996). Context-sensitivity in conversation analysis: eye gaze and the German repair initiator bitte?,
  25. (2002). Contingent achievement of co-tellership in a Japanese conversation: an analysis of talk, gaze, and gesture.
  26. (1995). Conversation Analysis,
  27. (1995). Conversation analysis: methodological aspects,
  28. (1998). Conversation Analysis: Principles, Practices and Applications,
  29. (2001). Conversation and Technology: From the telephone to the Internet. Cambridge,
  30. (1991). Conversation for Action: The computer terminal as medium of communication,
  31. (1981). Conversational Organization: Interaction between speakers and hearers,
  32. (2003). Dangdai Yuyongxue(M1~~m~),
  33. (1982). Decolonising the Filipino payche, Quezon City, Philippine Psychology Research House, quoted
  34. (2003). Developing self-direction in an online course through computer-mediated interaction,
  35. (1992). Die earste Begenung: eine conversations -und inhaltsanalytische Untersuchung der Interaktion im Psychoanalytischen Erstgesprdch,
  36. (1983). Discourse Analysis,
  37. (1982). Discourse Strategies, Cambridge,
  38. (1997). Discourse,
  39. (2003). Discussing Conversation Analysis: The work of Emanuel A Schegloff,
  40. (1996). Distance Education: A systems viell',
  41. (1999). Doing Conversation Analysis: A practical guide,
  42. (1997). E-mail discussion lists: a new genre of scholarly communication?,
  43. (1997). Electronic Discourse: Linguistic individuals in virtual space,
  44. (1996). Electronic language: A new variety of English,
  45. (1999). Electronic mail- a new style of communication or just a new medium? An investigation into the text features of E-mail, English/or Specific Purposes,
  46. (1974). Error correction as an interactional resource,
  47. (1994). Ethnomethodologische Konversationsanalyse, in
  48. (1979). Exchange Structure, Discouse Analysis Monographs, 5,
  49. (1988). Explanations as accounts,
  50. (1987). Forgetfulness as an interactive resource,
  51. (1994). Functions of the connective fatte in Japanese conversation,
  52. (1984). Garfinkel and Ethnomethodology,
  53. H.(1985) The interference-making machine' notes on obs b'l'
  54. (1994). Identification and recognition in Swedish telephone conversation openings,
  55. (1988). In the Age o/the Smart Machine,
  56. (1989). Information withholdin2 as a manipulative and collusive strategy in Nukulaelae gossip,
  57. (1993). Interpersonal communication and human-computer interaction: an examination of the use of computers in medical consultations,
  58. (2004). Introduction: theory and practice in distance education,
  59. (1989). Japanese Conversation: Self-contextualization through structure and interactional management,
  60. (2003). Joint Utterance Construction in Japanese Conversation / Makoto Hayashi,
  61. (1998). Keeping the thread: helping distance students and instructors keep track of asynchronous discussions,
  62. (1993). Knee-jerk anti-LOOPism and Other-Email Phenomena: Oral, written and electronic patterns in computer-mediated communication, MIT Sloan School Working Paper No.3578-93. quoted in Murray.
  63. (1986). Language and power: a critical review of Studies in the Theory of Ideology by
  64. (2001). Language and the Internet, Cambridge,
  65. (1996). Linguistic and interactional features of Internet Relay Chat,
  66. (1994). Management of repair in human-computer interaction,
  67. Maximum no of ~ssages/ day i 51!
  68. (1983). Mediated interpersonal communication: toward a new typology,
  69. (2003). Modes of interaction,
  70. (2002). Moving towards closing: Greek telephone calls between familiars,
  71. (1999). Negotiating Agreement and Disagreement in Japanese: Connective expressions and turn Construction,
  72. (1999). Notation systems in spoken language corpora,
  73. (1996). On interobjectivity,
  74. (1996). On repeats and responses in Finish conversations,
  75. (1991). On the organization of corrective exchanges in conversation.
  76. (1987). On the preferences for agreement and contiguity in sequences in conversation in
  77. (2002). On the telephone again! Telephone conversat'
  78. (1997). Open' class repair initiators in response to sequential sources of troubles in conversation,
  79. (1996). Oral and written linguistic aspects of computer conferencing: a corpus based study,
  80. (1982). Orality and Literacy: the Technologizing of the Word,
  81. (1996). Organization of repair
  82. (1993). Other-initiated repair sequences in Korean conversation as interactional resources,
  83. (1988). Outline o/Pragmatics (§-gm~~l~),
  84. (1980). Paralanguage in computer mediated communication,
  85. (1995). Parties and talking together: two ways in which numbers are significant for talk-in-interaction, in
  86. (1999). Phrasal unit boundaries and organization of turns and sequences in Korean conversation,
  87. (1983). Planning and Understanding: A computational approach to human reasoning,
  88. (1987). Plans and Situated Actions, Cambridge,
  89. (1997). Practices and actions: boundary cases of other-initiated repair,
  90. (1996). Practices in the construction of turns: the 'TCU' revisited,
  91. (2002). Pragmatics and Discourse,
  92. (1997). Pragmatics in Chinese Culture: Speechology in humanistic networks (11~B:x1t~m~) ,Beijing, Tsinghua
  93. (1993). Pragmatics,
  94. (1983). Pragmatics, Cambridge,
  95. (2000). Pragmatics: Theories and applications,
  96. (1988). Pre sequence and indirection: applying speech act theory to ordinary conversation,
  97. (2003). Presenting Emanuel Schegloff,
  98. (2000). Protean communication: the language of computer-mediated communication,
  99. Q (~CJ1rf=t) (2000) Pragmatics: Theories and applications,
  100. (1983). Real and non-real time interaction, unraveling multiple threads of discourse,
  101. (1989). Recalling someone from the past, in
  102. (2002). Recognition and identification in Japanese and Korean telephone conversation openings,
  103. (1993). Reflections on quantification in the study of conversation,
  104. (1992). Repair after next tum: the last structurally provided defense of intersubjectivity in conversation,
  105. (1995). Repair in natural conversation of Beijing Mandarin,
  106. (1995). Repair strategies in conversational Kickapoo,
  107. (1998). Reply to Wetherell,
  108. (1996). Resources and repair: a cross-linguistic study of syntax and repair,
  109. (2001). Responding in Conversation: a Study of Response Particles in Finnish,
  110. (1984). Social psychological aspects of computer-mediated communication,
  111. (1997). Some interactional achievements of other-initiated repair in multiperson conversation,
  112. (2004). Stance in Talk: A conversation analysis of Mandarin final particles.
  113. (1993). Structural Analysis of Japanese Discourse,
  114. (1984). Structure o/Social Action: Studies in conversation analysis, Cambridge,
  115. (1992). Talk at Work: Interaction in institutional settings, Cambridge,
  116. (1988). Talking Culture: Ethnography and conversation analysis,
  117. (1989). Telephone openings and conversational universals: a study in three languages,
  118. (2002). The Content Analysis Guidebook,
  119. (1990). The Mode of Information, Cambridge,
  120. (1978). The Network Nation: Human communication via computer.
  121. (1902). The number of members as determining the sociological fonn of the group,
  122. (1990). The organization of repair in classroom talk,
  123. (1977). The preference for self-correction in a Thai conversational corpus,
  124. (1977). The preference for self-correction in the organization of repair in conversation,
  125. (1979). The relevance of repair to syntax-for-conversation,
  126. (1992). The routinization of repair in courtroom d' . D . IScourse, III urantI, A. and Goodwin (eds) Rethinking Context Cambridge Cambn'dge
  127. (1995). The Social and Interactional Dimensions of Human-Computer Interfaces, Cambridge,
  128. (1986). The Structure of Written Communication: Studies in reciprocity between writers and readers,
  129. (1986). The virtual classroom? Using computer-mediated communication for university teaching,
  130. (2000). Theme and intertextuality in scholarly e-mail messages,
  131. (2000). Theoretical challenges for distance education in the 21 st century: a shift from structural to transactional issues,
  132. (1977). Therapeutic Discourse: Psychotherapy as Conversation,
  133. (1999). Tone-choice repair in conversational Mandarin Chinese,
  134. (1975). Towards an Analysis of Discourse: the English used by teachers and pupils,
  135. (1991). Transcription design principles for spoken discourse research,
  136. (1995). Transcription systems for spoken discourse, in
  137. (1997). Transforming participation frameworks in multi-party Mandarin conversation: the use of discourse particles und body behavior,
  138. (1996). Transparent vision, in
  139. (1985). Turns and discourse units in everyday conversation,
  140. (2003). Users' interpretations at a computer tutorial: detecting (causes) of misunderstandings,
  141. (1990). Utterance Particles in Cantonese Conversation,
  142. (1990). What is human-machine communication, in
  143. (1989). When the medium determines turns: tum-taking in computer conversation,
  144. (2002). Written interaction: a key component in online learning,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.