Location of Repository

Strategic Management and Strategic Planning at Ruskin College

By Christopher Wilkes


The thesis explores strategic management and strategic planning at Ruskin College, an adult education college with a long history of contributing to lifelong learning and social inclusion. It has been written during a period of turbulence in the college - the collapse of a property strategy, the departure of a Principal, a failed inspection, the appointment of a new Principal and a successful re-inspection. Turbulence is a theme of the thesis and underpins some of the models for understanding strategy provided in the literature- The thesis reviews the literature, particularly that relating to further and higher education, on strategic thinking, strategic planning, strategic intent, organisational culture, mission and vision, governance, quality and inspection and how these relate to strategic management. These themes generate the research questions, which are explored using a triangulation of methods - documentary analysis, questionnaires, semi-structured interviews and observations - and respondent triangulation, involving all levels of staff and governors. The research findings show the strategy development process operates within a strong cultural dimension, but is subject to strong external forces. Internal and external perspectives of the college's experience of strategic planning are largely negative. Staff and governors take a cultural perspective on strategy and recognise how concepts of strategic management, such as strategic thinking and strategic conversations, might link to vision and mission. The culture of the governing body and its' changing role in strategic management are identified as significant. The research shows that the relationship between quality and strategic management is unclear and varies according to the definitions of these concepts. It shows that the inspectorate has sought to influence strategic management but the inspection framework does not recognise culture. The conclusion proposes a way forward for strategic processes and approaches in the college as well as for future research on strategic leadership

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 2006
OAI identifier: oai:lra.le.ac.uk:2381/8812

Suggested articles



  1. (2001). (2001b), Strategic plan textual update, Oxford, Ruskin CollegeRuskin College (2001c), Community short residential courses,
  2. (1984). A History of Ruskin College,
  3. (2004). A new approach to strategic leadership: learningcentredness, connectivity and cultural context in school design',
  4. (1998). A voice in the wilderness: meetings as ritual in a cross-cultural context'.
  5. (1994). Analysing documents and records'.
  6. (2002). Analysing narratives and documents'.
  7. (2004). Association of Colleges and DfES
  8. (2001). Beyond the Rational: The Strategic Management Process, Cultural Change and Post-incorporation Further Education',
  9. (2002). Classification' and `Judgment': social class and the `cognitive structures' of choice of Higher Education".
  10. College (2000a), Quality Assurance Policy and Procedures.
  11. College (2000b), Self-Assessment Report,
  12. College (2002a), Curriculum Development Strategy Oxford,
  13. College (2002b), Self-assessment report,
  14. College (2003a), Governance Action Plan.
  15. (2003). College (2003b), Governing Executive Minutes,
  16. (2004). College (2004a), Governing Executive Minutes.
  17. (2004). College (2004b), Governing Executive Minutes,
  18. College (2004c), lnsMtion Action Plan,
  19. College (2004d), Recovery Plan,
  20. (2001). Community College Leadership Programme', Block Guide,
  21. (1978). Conducting and Analysing Interviews,
  22. (1997). Contested Values in Further Education: Findings From a Case Study of the Management of Change',
  23. (1996). Contributing to an epistemology of quality management practice'.
  24. (1982). Corporate Rituals: The Rites and Rituals of Corporate Life,
  25. (1989). Creating an Excellent School: Some New Management Techniques,
  26. (1991). Culture and Organisations: software of the mind,
  27. (2003). Culture Change: The Case of Sixth Form and General Further Education Colleges',
  28. (1998). Decision Making: An integrated Approach, 2od edition,
  29. (2000). Developing comparative and international educational leadership and management: a crosscultural model'.
  30. (1997). Developing managers in further education. Part 1: the extent of the task',
  31. (1997). Developing managers in further education. Part 2: the process of development',
  32. (2003). Developing strategic thought: a collection of the best thinking on business strategy, London,
  33. (1998). Discovering and defining the process of strategic development'.
  34. (2001). Dominant logics of strategy in FE colleges, paper for SCRELM special edition of Research
  35. (2003). Education and Skills (DfES)
  36. (2000). Education, Policy and Ethics,
  37. (1996). Effective governing bodies, effective schools? '
  38. (1993). Essential School Leadership: Developing Vision and Purpose in Management,
  39. (2002). Ethics of research in education'.
  40. (2002). Exploring, Corporate Strategy, 6'h edition,
  41. (1999). Exploring, Corporate Strategy: Text and cases, 5"h edition,
  42. (2004). Feel free to use the "F" word', Times Educational Supplement,
  43. (1994). From vision to reality through values',
  44. (2001). Funding Council for England
  45. (1998). Funding Council for England (HEFCE)
  46. (2001). Further Education Funding Council
  47. Further Education Funding Council (1992a), Circular: College Strategic Plans, Coventry, FEFC. Further Education Funding Council (l 992b), Funding Learning,
  48. Further Education Funding Council (1997a), Quality and Standards
  49. (2004). Further Education Middle Managers: Their Contribution to the Strategic Decision-Making Process',
  50. (2001). Further Education National Training Organisation (FENTO)
  51. (1991). Generating Income for Educational Institutions: A Business Planning Approach,
  52. (2001). Global trends in tertiary education quality assurance',
  53. (2003). Governance healthcheck for Ff: college boards 2001/02, London, Learning and Skills Development Agency.
  54. (2001). Governance issues: raising student achievement, London, Learning and Skills Development Agency.
  55. (2002). Governance, Automony and Accountability in Education'.
  56. (2001). he performance of governing bodies'.
  57. (2004). Healing hand at the helm'.
  58. (1999). Helping practitioners explore their school's culture'.
  59. (2004). Higher Education in Further Education: delivering higher education in a further education context -a study of five South West colleges',
  60. (1995). Ideology, quality and TQM'.
  61. (1986). Images of Organisation,
  62. (1990). Implanting Strategic Management (2"d edition),
  63. (1995). Implementing College Strategic Plans,
  64. (1984). In the Field: An introduction to Field Research:
  65. (1997). Increasing Effectiveness: a Guide to Quality Management,
  66. (1993). Industry and higher education: a question of values',
  67. (1994). Innovations in Caribbean school systems: why some have become institutionalised and others have not',
  68. (2003). Inspection Report: Ruskin Collegee,
  69. (2004). Introduction to the Special Edition on Strategy and Strategic Leadership in Schools',
  70. (2003). Labour pains',
  71. (2003). Leaders or Followers? Governing Bodies and their Role in School Leadership',
  72. (1984). Leadership and QMMisational Culture Chicago,
  73. (2003). Leadership in further education'.
  74. (1996). Leadership, planning and resource management in four very effective schools. Part II. Planning and performance',
  75. (2001). Leadership: The Challenges for All, London, Institute of Management.
  76. (2003). Leading and Managing Education: International Dimensions,
  77. (2005). Leading the strategically focused school'.
  78. (1983). Management of higher education in a period of contraction and uncertainty'.
  79. (2001). Managing Further Education: Learning
  80. (1997). Managing Quality in Schools. 2"d edn.,
  81. (1990). Managing Quality,
  82. (2000). Managing Strategy,
  83. (1994). Managing to be Independent:
  84. (2005). Micro Strategy and Strategizing: Implications for Strategy Process Research'.
  85. (1998). Middle management - the key to organisational success? '
  86. (1994). Mission and Change: Institutional Mission and its Application to the Management of Further and
  87. (1996). Monitoring Education: Indicators, Quality and Effectiveness.
  88. (1998). ne place of external inspection'.
  89. (2002). Observation as a research tool'-
  90. (1994). Observing and recording meetings'.
  91. (1997). of Inquiry into Higher Education (NCIHE)
  92. (2002). Ofsted and School Improvement: teachers' perceptions of the inspection process in schools facing challenging circumstances',
  93. (1998). Organisational culture and strategic management'.
  94. (1990). Organisational Culture, Blagdon, Mendip Papers.
  95. (1982). Out of the Crisis: Quality Productivity and Competitive Position,
  96. (2002). Oxford row over land sale',
  97. (2003). Preparing for turbulence: the changing relationship between strategy and management development in the learning organisation'.
  98. (2003). Principal to move on', The Oxford Times,
  99. (2003). Principled "Bastard" Leadership? A rejoinder to Gold, Evans, Earley, Halpin and Collarbone',
  100. (2003). Principled Principals? Value-Driven Leadership: Evidence from Ten Case Studies of "Outstanding" School Leaders',
  101. (1993). processes of managing strategic change'.
  102. (1988). Quality Control Handbook,
  103. (1997). Quality management in education'. In
  104. (1997). Research Methods for Managers,
  105. (2002). Rethinking Schools and School Leadership for the 21 st Century: Changes and Challenges',
  106. (2003). Review of Financial Management and Governance Frameworks at Ruskin College,
  107. (2003). Ruskin left in lurch as site deal collapses', The Times Higher Education Supplement,
  108. (2003). Ruskin vacancy follows sell-out row',
  109. (1996). Schools' experience of inspection'.
  110. (2001). Skills Development Agency
  111. (1998). Strategic leadership in education: becoming, being, doing'.
  112. (2005). Strategic Leadership'.
  113. (1998). Strategic management in education: an overview'.
  114. (1991). Strategic Planning and Management, Blagdon, The Staff College.
  115. (2001). Strategic Planning in a New University',
  116. (1997). Strategic planning in African universities',
  117. (1999). Strategic planning in further education: the business of values',
  118. (1998). Strategic planning in further education'.
  119. (2003). Strategic planning in schools: a critical perspective'. In
  120. (1997). Strategic planning in schools: some practical techniques'.
  121. (1992). Strategic planning: managing colleges into the next century'.
  122. (2003). Strategic thinking as "seeing"'.
  123. (1997). Strategy and management in the further education sector'.
  124. (1994). Strategy, policy and planning'.
  125. (2002). Surveys and sampling'.
  126. (1999). Teacher identity in popular culture'.
  127. (2001). The changing face of college governance'.
  128. (2003). The Contribution of Inspection, Self-assessment, Investors in People and the Inclusive Learning Quality Initiative to Improving Quality in Further Education Colleges: an initial exploration',
  129. (1999). The Corporate Culture Survival Guide,
  130. (1994). The Empty Raincoat: Making Sense of the Future,
  131. (1996). The Leadership Challenge,
  132. (1992). The nature and use of mission statements in Singaporean schools',
  133. (1996). The organisational culture saga - from OD to TQM: a critical review of the literature'.
  134. (1994). The Philosophy of research design'.
  135. (2001). The processes of strategy development in the public sector'.
  136. (1998). The strategic role of governors in school improvement'.
  137. (1993). The Strategic Toolkit,
  138. (1985). The symbolism of effective schools'.
  139. (1996). Total Quality Management in Education, 2"d edn.,
  140. (1993). Total Quality Management in Schools, Buckingham,
  141. (1997). Towards a cultural and political perspective'.
  142. (1992). Triangulation in research: two confusions',
  143. (1995). Using Observations in Small-Scale Research: a Beginner's Guide,
  144. (1995). Using Semi-Structured Interviews in Small-Scale Research: a Teachers' Guide,
  145. (1996). Values and Further Education',
  146. (1998). Vision and mission'.
  147. (2002). Vision and Strategic Planning',
  148. (2001). What Are the Essential Capabilities for Those Who Manage Training _Organisations?,
  149. (1985). What is Total Quality Control? The Japanese Way,
  150. (1992). What's Worth Fighting for in Your School? Buckingham,
  151. (1992). Whole School Curriculum Development,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.