Location of Repository

Reform of ‘non-disclosure’ in UK marine insurance law: Exotic Approach or Original Understanding?

By Poomintr Sooksripaisarnkit

Abstract

A marine insurance contract is a contract of utmost good faith (uberrimae fidei), which requires the duty of disclosure prior to the conclusion of a contract. This is essentially stated in ss. 17 and 18 of the Marine Insurance Act 1906. Despite the 100-year application of these provisions, the defects are shown and the injustice occurs. The voluminous case laws and their complexity suggest nothing else apart from that this area of law is highly problematic. The criticisms are essentially rested upon two grounds: (1) the material fact which rests upon the view of the ‘prudent insurer’ makes it difficult for the assured to determine for himself the fact to be disclosed (2) in case of non-disclosure, the remedy of avoidance applies regardless of culpability of the party in breach. As such, the reform to the law is inevitable and the purpose of this thesis is to suggest how reform can be achieved.\ud Two possible ways to bring the change to the law are considered. These are (1) to adopt the alternative solutions identified in other jurisdictions or (2) to re-consider whether the law on duty of disclosure as has been recognised since the seminal judgment of Lord Mansfield in Carter v. Boehm (1766) 3 Burr. 1905 has been correctly applied.\ud This thesis concludes that the judgment of Lord Mansfield has been misunderstood in the UK and that, to constitute non-disclosure, only the deliberate intention is required and that the remedy of avoidance is justifiable upon the public policy ground. Such duty should be based upon the broad notion of good faith (bonae fidei), a flexible concept of fairness and justice. In the end, the draft provisions are formulated to reflect these suggestions

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 2006
OAI identifier: oai:lra.le.ac.uk:2381/8661

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1901). A Digest of the Law Relating to Marine Insurance (Williams Clowes
  2. (1844). A Lecture on the Law of Representations
  3. A v. Oceanus Mutual Underwriting (Bermuda) Ltd. (The "Eurysthenes") [1977] 1
  4. (2000). Actionable Misrepresentation (4a' ed., Butterworths,
  5. Agency) Ltd v.
  6. (2002). Agnew (The "Aegeon ")
  7. (2001). An Insurance Contracts Act for a new century? "
  8. (2003). and General Insurance Ltd and Others v. Chase Manhattan Bank and Others
  9. (2003). Anr v. Aseguradora Colseguros S. A & Anr.
  10. Assicurazioni Generali Spa v.
  11. Associated Oil Carriers, Limited v. Union Society Insurance of Canton, Limited [1917] 2
  12. (2002). Australian Proposes Marine Insurance Reform"
  13. (2005). Axa General Insurance Limited v.
  14. (1913). Bishop of London
  15. (2000). Bona Fides in Roman Contract Law"
  16. Cantiere Meccanico Brindisino v.
  17. Cantiere Meccanico Brindisino v. Janson [1912] 3
  18. Certain Lloyd's Underwriters subscribing to Lloyd's Policy No.
  19. (1999). Change and Continuity-Statute, Equity and Federalism (Clarendon Press,
  20. (2005). Classification of Terms in Marine Insurance Contracts in the Context of Contemporary Developments" (Paper presented at the International Colloquium on Marine Insurance Law,
  21. Co-Operative Insurance Society Limited [1975] 2 Lloyd's Rep.
  22. (1903). Codification of Mercantile Law"
  23. (1990). Common Law Materiality-an Australian Alternative" [
  24. (2003). Compagnie Noga D'Importation et D'Exportation S. A v. Ms. Maryam Abacha, Mr. Mohammed Sani Abacha as the Personal Representatives of General Sani Abacha Deceased
  25. (1954). Company et al v. Fireman's Fund Insurance Company
  26. (2005). Comparative Lessons derivable from The Norwegian Marine Insurance Plan 1996" (Paper presented at the International Colloquium on Marine Insurance Law,
  27. (2003). Continuing Duty of Utmost Good Faith in Insurance Contracts: still alive? "
  28. Crawford [1939] 3
  29. (1913). De Officiis (William Heinemann Ltd,
  30. (1992). Do Insurers Know Best? An Empirical Examination of the Extent that Insurers comply with their Statements of Practice and whether they are satisfactory substitute for reform of the law"
  31. (2004). Dornoch Limited on its own behalf and on behalf of all members of Syndicates 588,861 and 1209 subscribing to Policy Number: F990678 and as the representative Underwriter for the following Lloyd's market each for their own share,
  32. (2001). Doubts About Insurance Codes"
  33. (2001). Doubts from the Dark Side-The Case Against Code"
  34. Eagle Star Insurance Co.
  35. (2004). English Common Law in the Age of
  36. (1984). Equity Doctrines and Remedies (2"d ed., Butterworths,
  37. (1988). Failure to Disclose and Failure to Legislate-is it material? -II"
  38. (1998). Faith and Insurance Contracts (LLP,
  39. (1985). Federal Ins v. Oudtshoorn Municipality
  40. Financiere de la Cite &A (Formerly named Banque Keyser Ullman En Suisse S. A) v.
  41. Fir Shipping Company Ltd v.
  42. General Reinsurance Corporation and Others v. Forsakringsaktiebolaget Fennia Patria [1982] 1 Lloyd's Rep.
  43. (1996). Good Faith in Insurance Contracts-Some Lessons from Australia"
  44. (2004). Good Faith in The Reform of Insurance Law"
  45. Held Covered Clauses in Marine Insurance"
  46. (1954). Historical Introduction to the Study of Roman Law (2"d ed.,
  47. Inc and Reliance Group Inc v. Oceanus Mutual Underwriting Association (Bermuda) Ltd. [1982] 2 Lloyd's Rep.
  48. Inc and Reliance Group Inc v. Oceanus Mutual Underwriting Association (Bermuda) Ltd. [1984] 1 Lloyd's Rep.
  49. (1987). India v. Lips Maritime Corporation (The "Lips ") [
  50. (1985). Insurance and Good Faith: Exit Uberrima Fides-Enter What? "
  51. (1925). Insurance Co. of New York v.
  52. (2004). Insurance Company Limited v.
  53. (1994). Insurance Law and Practice (LLP,
  54. (2003). Insurance Plc v. Provident Insurance Plc
  55. Insurance Plc v. Provident Insurance Plc [2003] EWCA Civ. 1834; [2004] 1 Lloyd's Rep.
  56. (1985). Insurer's Agreements not to enforce strict legal rights: Bargaining with government and in the shadow of the law"
  57. (1988). Insurers not liable in damages for failure to disclose"
  58. (2005). Insurers, Claims and the Boundaries of Good Faith"
  59. (2002). International Maritime and Admiralty Law (Yvon Blais,
  60. K'S Merc-Scandia XXW1 v. Certain Lloyd's Underwriters subscribing to Lloyd's Policy No.
  61. (2005). Kaur Mundi v. Lincoln Assurance Limited
  62. (1985). Law Reform: Process and Problems"
  63. Liberian Agency Inc v.
  64. Life & Pension Ltd v.
  65. London General Insurance Company Limited v.
  66. (1981). Lord Fuller and Substantive Natural Law"
  67. (1991). Ltd and Others v.
  68. (2001). Ltd v.
  69. (1974). Ltd v. Pegler and Another
  70. (1999). Ltd v. Royal Insurance Australia Ltd and Others
  71. Ltd v. Style [1958] 1 Lloyd's Rep.
  72. Ltd v. Sun Alliance Office Ltd. (The "Sageorge ")
  73. Ltd v. Uni-Polaris Insurance Co. Ltd and La Reunion Europeene (The "Star Sea ") [2001] UKHL/1; [2001] 1 Lloyd's Rep.
  74. Ltd v. Uni-Polaris Insurance Co. Ltd and La Reunion Europeene (The "Star Sea')
  75. Manufacturers Insurance Company, Limited v. Charles and John Hunt (an infant) and Percy Thorne and Matilda Thorne [1914] 1
  76. (1999). Mapping the Doctrine of Utmost Good Faith in Insurance Contract Law"
  77. (1999). Marine Insurance in the United States: The U. S. Supreme Court's Wilburn Boat decision and its impact on marine insurance"
  78. (2002). Marine Insurance Law in Australia: Australian Law Reform Commission Proposals"
  79. (2002). Marine Insurance Law: A San Andreas Fault Between the Common Law and the Civil Law"
  80. (2000). Marine Insurance Legislation (2"'
  81. (2000). Marine Insurance Reform in Australia-Start, Pause and Go Where? "
  82. (1999). Marine Insurance"
  83. (2002). Marine Warranties: Old Rules for The New Millenium? "
  84. (1996). Misrepresentation and Non-Disclosure in Insurance Law-Identical Twins or Separate Issues? "
  85. (2003). Mutual and Federal Insurance Co. Ltd.
  86. (1992). Natural Law and the Separation of Law and Morals"
  87. (1999). Norwegian Marine Insurance Plan of 1996" in Huybrechts, M., et al (eds),
  88. (2004). Of inducement and non-disclosure in insurance contracts"
  89. (1991). Of reciprocity and remedies-duty of disclosure in insurance contracts"
  90. (1996). Official Publications UK Invisible Earnings: The UK's hidden strength,
  91. Pan Atlantic Insurance Co. Ltd and Another v.
  92. (1995). Pan Atlantic-Yet More to Disclose? "
  93. PCW Syndicates v. PCWReinsurers [1996] 1 Lloyd's Rep.
  94. (1995). Pioneer Concrete (SA) Pty Limited
  95. Plc v.
  96. (2005). Post-Contractual Good Faith-A Further Change in Judicial Attitude"
  97. (2003). Post-Contractual Good Faith-Change in Judicial Attitude? "
  98. (2005). Proximate Causation in Insurance Law"
  99. (1906). Prudent Insurer' (MIA
  100. (1995). Rationality in the House of Lords"
  101. (2000). Reform of the Marine Insurance Act Options and Constraints' (Paper presented at the Maritime Law Association of Australia and New Zealand Annual Conference,
  102. (2003). Refusing Rescission? Contracts of Utmost Bad Faith"
  103. (2003). Remedies for failure to observe the utmost good faith"
  104. (1996). Roman-Dutch law in its South African Historical Context"
  105. (1999). Royal Insurance (UK) Ltd. [
  106. Shipping Corporation and Wayang (Panama) S. A v. Mark Ranald Massie (The "Litsion Pride) [1985] 1 Lloyd's Rep.
  107. (1999). Shipping Law &
  108. (2002). Strive Shipping Corporation v. Hellenic Mutual War Risks Association (Bermuda) Ltd. (The "Grecia Express')
  109. (2000). The "Utmost Good Faith" in Marine Insurance Law on the Continent"
  110. (1982). The Australian Law Reform Commission, `Insurance Contracts,
  111. (1909). The Australian Law Reform Commission, `Review of the Marine Insurance Act
  112. (1979). The Australian Law Reform Commission, Discussion Paper No. 7, Insurance Contracts
  113. (2005). The Confused Post-Formation Duty of Good Faith in Insurance Law: From Refinement to Fragmentation to Elimination? "
  114. (1986). The Decline, Revival and Future of the Roman-Dutch Law of Marine Insurance
  115. (1969). The Doctrine of Uberrima Fides in Insurance Law-A Critical Evaluation"
  116. (1996). The Duty of Disclosure in Insurance Contract
  117. (1989). The Duty of Disclosure La Banque Financiere v. Westgate; The Good Luck" [
  118. (1998). The Duty of Utmost Good Faith in Marine Insurance Law: A Comparative Analysis of American and English Law"
  119. (2002). The duty of utmost good faith-the great unknown of modem insurance law"
  120. (1985). The Duty to Disclose in a Pre-Contractual Context-Good Faith and the Role of the Reasonable Man"
  121. (1994). The Equity of the Statute and Ratio Scripta: Legislative Interpretation Among Legislative Agnostics and True Believers"
  122. (1995). The Future of Marine Insurance Law", The
  123. The Governor and Company of the Bank of England v.
  124. (2001). The Insured's Non-Disclosure in the Formation of Insurance Contracts: A Comparative Perspective"
  125. (1988). The Law and Practice of Marine Insurance and Average Volume I (Stevens
  126. (1991). The Law Commission and The Scottish Law Commission, Rights of Suit in
  127. (1980). The Law Commission Report on Insurance Law: non-disclosure and breach of warranty,
  128. (1979). The Law Commission working paper no. 73 on Insurance Law: non-disclosure and breach of warranty
  129. (2003). The Law of Contract
  130. (2002). The Law of Insurance Contracts
  131. (1996). The Law of Marine Insurance
  132. (1998). The Law Relating to Non-Disclosure, Misrepresentation and Breach of Warranty in Contracts of Marine Insurance A Case for Reform, Thesis submitted in fulfillment of the requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in The University of Queensland,
  133. (2000). The nature of an insurer's obligation"
  134. (2001). The Overarching Duty of Good Faith in Insurance Contracts: Where Does the Buck Stop? "
  135. (2005). The post-contractual duties of good faith in marine insurance policies: The search for elusive principle" (Paper presented at the International Colloquium on Marine Insurance Law,
  136. (1996). The Roots and Future of South African Law of Marine Insurance"
  137. (2002). The saga of the continuing duty of utmost good faith-the sequel"
  138. (1983). The Search for Principle"
  139. (1999). The Transformation of `Good Faith' in Insurance Law"
  140. (1997). Time for an English Commercial Code? "
  141. (2005). Trends in the interpretation of marine insurance contracts" (Paper presented at the International Colloquium on Marine Insurance Law,
  142. (1987). Uberrima Fides in Modem Insurance Law"
  143. (1961). Uberrima Fides"
  144. (1976). Uberrimae Fidei Strikes Again"
  145. (1957). UK Balance of Payments First Release Q4 2005' httu: //www. statistics. opL v.
  146. (2006). uk/pdfdir/bop03O6. pdf> accessed 29
  147. (1999). Utmost Good Faith in Marine Insurance Contracts"
  148. (1995). Utmost Good Faith in the House of Lords"
  149. (2005). Utmost Good Faith-forward to the past"
  150. (1996). Utmost Good Faith, Materiality and Inducement"
  151. Ventouris v. Trevor Rex Mountain (The "Italia Express
  152. Westgate Insurance Co. Ltd (Formerly Hodge
  153. (1902). What is the Law Merchant? "
  154. (1983). What is the Law to be Applied to a Contract of Marine Insurance in -terms of
  155. (1975). Zorro

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.