Location of Repository

'Swords trembling in their scabbards': A study of Indian officers in the Indian Cavalry, 1858 – 1918

By Michael John Creese

Abstract

The Indian army under British rule was unique in that it had two sets of officers, one British and one Indian. The Indian officers played a vital role within their regiments but could never proceed to the higher levels of command. Even the most senior and experienced Indian officer was subordinate to the most newly-arrived British subaltern and Indian officers were never allowed to command British troops. This study, believed to be the first of its kind, explores the education, selection and training of Indian officers together with their changing role in the period 1858 to 1918 with a brief coda covering changes up to Indian Independence in 1947.\ud The study focuses on the careers of the Indian officers of four cavalry regiments and their achievements during this period. Letters sent to and from them while they were serving in France during the Great War are used to personalise the story and, in particular, use is made of previously unpublished material from the diary of Amar Singh. He had a very varied military career which illustrates the difficulties facing Indian officers at this time.\ud The study concludes that although the Indian officers were undoubtedly very courageous and effective troop and squadron commanders, they were held back by their lack of a basic general education. Racial stereotyping by many of their British commanders of the period led to their refusal to believe that Indians could be, at least potentially, as capable as themselves. This prejudice was part of the wider social gulf between the two races.\ud In spite of these difficulties, the Indian officers made a very significant contribution to the overall effectiveness of the Indian Army of this period

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 2007
OAI identifier: oai:lra.le.ac.uk:2381/8635

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1988). 16 Chevenix-Trench c., The Indian Army and the King's Enemies 1900-1947,
  2. (1907). 56th Punjab Rifles FF. Native officers of the Indian Army, Vol
  3. (1915). 8), 20 years service. Slightly wounded
  4. (1974). A Matter of Honour,
  5. (1990). Annals of Sandhurst: A Chronicle of the Royal Military College
  6. (1989). Armies of the Raj From the Mutiny to Independence 1858 to 1947,
  7. (1888). Battalion, 9th Jat Regiment Leslie-Jones, Colonel R E, served with Royal Bombay Sappers and Miners Keown, Captain, Probyn's Horse Montagu, Lt Col.
  8. (1993). Fakhr-E-Hind' The Story of the Poona Horse, (Dehra Dun, Agrim Publishers,
  9. (1993). Fidelity and Honour: The Indian Army from the Seventeenth to the Twenty-first Century (New Delh~
  10. (2000). General Histories relating to the Indian Army Allen, C., Soldier Sahibs: The Men Who Made the North- West Frontier. doi
  11. He became RM in 1915, retiring in 1917 with the honorary rank of Captain and a jaghir grant ofRs 600 per year. For his service in France he was twice mentioned in despatches and awarded the OBI 1 st Class.
  12. He was awarded the Indian Order of Merit in 1903 for capturing, while on leave, two members of a gang of outlaws who had murdered his brother.
  13. Historical Records of the Poona Horse (Published in 1882 but no indication of where published or by whom).
  14. History of the 15th (IS) Cavalry during the Great War 1914-18,
  15. (1946). History of the Jodhpur State Forces in the War 1939-45
  16. (1928). Hodson's Horse.
  17. India's Army. Published in London in 1940, publisher unkno~ based upon articles which had previously appeared in the Statesman in India in 1938/9.
  18. (1959). Indian Cavalryman (London, Jarrolds Publ~shers~
  19. (1918). Indian Order of Merit, 2nd Class Risaldar Sardar Khan, IDSM. For the action near Cambrai when he was Woordie-Major. Also awarded a grant of land Jemadar Bhagwan Singh. For a raid on a Turkish position 22/23
  20. (1914). Lists The Bengal Army List, January 1877 India Army List July,
  21. (1990). Maj-Gen, Military Leadership in India: The Vedic Period to the IndoPak wars. (New Delhi, Lancer Books,
  22. major in 1921, 2nd Lieutenant in 1922 & Lieutenant in 1924 Harditt Singh (6, 7) 6 years service. Promoted to ressaidar, he was mortally wounded 4.12.17. Buried La Chaplette British and Indian Military Cemetery Peronne. (See photograph)
  23. (2004). Martial Races: The military, race and masCUlinity doi
  24. (1900). Martial' Indian Aristocrats and the Military System of the Raj: The Imperial Cadet Corps, doi
  25. (1917). Military Operations in Palestine from
  26. (1917). OBI 2nd Class, honorary rank of lieutenant Indian Order of Merit 1st Class Risaldar Nur Ahmed Khan MC. Awarded the 10M, 2nd class tor a 'well-planned & executed night raid'4 18/19
  27. (1993). post Independence, both of whom won the Param Vir Chakra, the 22 Kunju N., Subedar-Major (retd), The Indian Army, pp. 53 et seq.
  28. Punjabis Recruits and Recruiting in the Indian Army,
  29. (1997). Raj: The Making and Unmaking of British India
  30. (1787). Recommendations following the India Sandhurst Report,
  31. (2005). Remembering Forgotten Heroes,
  32. (1928). Report of the India Sandhurst Committee,
  33. (1785). Report of the India Sandhurst Committee, evidence from Risaldar Sardar Khan Indian ,
  34. (1785). Report of the India Sandhurst Committee; evidence of Col Walshe, commanding RA, Eastern and Western Command,
  35. (1908). Report on Brigade Training, Bannu Brigade (Pioneer Press, Allalabad
  36. (1993). Roberts in India: The military papers of Field Marshal Lord Roberts 1876-1893 (Stroud, Alan Sutton for the Army Records Society. doi
  37. (1928). Robson (ed) The Military Papers of Lord Roberts
  38. (1917). Rt Hon Sir F., The Indian Corps in France (London,
  39. (1987). Sandhurst: A Documentary,
  40. (1999). Sepoys in the Trenches: The Indian Corps on the Western Front 1914-15. doi
  41. (1983). So they Rode and Fought (Tunbridge Wells, Midas Books,
  42. Soldiers' Institutes for the Native Army of India;
  43. (1903). Sons of John Company: The Indian and Pakistan Armies
  44. (1991). Subedar-Major (retired), The Indian Army: A Grassroots Review, (Delh~ Reliance Publishing House,
  45. (1888). Talesfrom the Hills (Calcutta, Thacker and Spink,
  46. (1911). The Armies Of India (London, A and
  47. (1990). The Bengal Native Infantry: its organisation and discipline doi
  48. (1939). The Deccan Horse in the Great War (Aldershot, Gale and Polden,
  49. (2000). The diaries ofKanwar Amar Singh, typescript copies kept together with the original at Kanota, Jaipur by kind permission of the late Mohan Singhji of Kanota Extracts from these diaries have been published in two books:-Rudolph
  50. The Higher Training of
  51. (1983). The Imperial Reserve: The Indian Corps on the Western Front doi
  52. The Imperial Reserve: The Indian Corps on the Western Front 1914-15. doi
  53. (1914). The Imperial Reserve: The Indian Corps on the Western Front, doi
  54. (1900). The Indian Army and the King's Enemies
  55. (1990). The Indian Army: The Garrison of British Imperial India 1822-1922 (Lood~ David and Charles.
  56. (1974). The Indian Army: The Garrison of British Imperial India 1822-1922, doi
  57. (1981). The Indian Cavalry: The History of the Indian Armoured Corps until 1940. (New Delh~ Vision Books,
  58. (2002). The Indian Corps on the Western Front: A Reconsideration
  59. (1973). The Indian Mutiny ( London, Book Club Associates,
  60. (2002). The Indian Mutiny 1857, doi
  61. (1986). The Indianisation of the Indian Army History Today Volume 36
  62. (1917). the Jodhpur I S Lancers.
  63. (1926). The Life ofLt-Gen HH Sir Pratab Singh (London Oxford
  64. (1932). The Martial Races of India,
  65. (1985). The Men who ruled India (New Delhi,
  66. (1970). The Military Book Society, doi
  67. (1933). The Poona Horse (11h QVO Cavalry)1817-1931,
  68. (1926). The Scinde Horse 1839-1922 ( Published by a Regimental Committee,
  69. (1998). The Sepoy and the Company: tradition and transition
  70. (1940). The Sepoy and the Raj: The Indian Army 1860 - doi
  71. The Sepoy War in India, (London, W HAllen 1870-76), two volumes.
  72. (1977). The Sword of the Raj: The British Army
  73. (1922). The Training of Indian Platoon Commanders, Volume Lll, No 229,
  74. (1914). The Victorian Army and the Staff College doi
  75. (1965). Tips from the Subedar Major, OctlDec
  76. Tracts on the Native Army of India; its organisation and discipline.
  77. (1920). two volumes.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.