Location of Repository

An Investigation into Teachers' Questions and Tasks to Develop Reading Comprehension: The Application of the Cogaff Taxonomy in Developing Critical Thinking in Malaysia

By Ghazali Mustapha


Malaysian teachers are constantly seeking ways to improve their students' reading in English and thereby enhance the learning of their students. One method of doing this is to bring critical and creative thinking to the forefront of the curriculum. This has been emphasized by the Malaysian Ministry of Education via the KBSM syllabus in order to teach these skills by considering the use of programmes like Bloom's Taxonomy of Educational Objectives in classroom practice. This study demonstrates how the higher-order skills can be integrated into the secondary school reading curriculum. The main aim of the study is to investigate how teachers design Reading Comprehension Questions (RCQs) and Tasks (RCTs) in relation to the demands of higher-order thinking to produce students with critical minds. It focuses primarily on the use of the Cogaff Taxonomy (a cognitive-affective taxonomy, adapted from Bloom's and Krathwohl's) to formulate higher-order RCQs and RCTs as a means to develop critical and creative thinking. In a pilot study in Britain (with 40 Malaysian teachers) and in the main field study in Malaysia, 150 subjects (teachers and student teachers) yielded about 1000 RCQs and 1000 RCTs. In line with many research findings of question and task design, 91.2%f the RCQs and 83.6% of the RCTs produced during the pretest were of low-order (literal) types. Subjects attended a workshop emphasizing question and task designing with the Cogaff Taxonomy. Dramatically, during the post test in the main study, 74.4% of the RCQs and 80.6% of the RCTs were transformed into higher-order inferential forms. These results demonstrate that the teachers can potentially change the cognitive (and affective) demands of the comprehension questions and tasks they design. In a smaller subsidiary study, units from two English textbooks used in Malaysia arc analysed to determine the levels of their RCTs and RCQs. The textbooks use a much broader range than the teachers did in the pretest. Implications for the teaching of Reading Comprehension and training of teachers in Malaysia are discussed

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 1997
OAI identifier: oai:lra.le.ac.uk:2381/8497

Suggested articles



  1. 16,1997. Kuala Lumpur: Berita Harian Publication.
  2. (1982). A Communicational Approach: Games U.
  3. (1975). A Communicative Grammar of English.
  4. (1961). A design for thinking.
  5. (1964). A field for Many Tillings: Educational Research in Australia Today. Hawthorn: Australian Council for Educational research.
  6. (1982). A Guide to Questioning - Classroom procedures for teachers.
  7. (1984). A History of
  8. (1975). A Language for Life,
  9. (1985). A Logical Basis forMeasuring Thinking Thinking Skills.
  10. (1981). A Meta-analysis of Experimental Research on Teacher Questioning Behaviour.
  11. (1976). A psychometric approach to job performance: Fire fighters.
  12. (1957). A Review of Bloom's Taxonomy of Educational Objectives
  13. (1985). A role for instruction in second language acquisition: Task-based language training
  14. (1984). A schema-theoretic -view of basic processes in reading comprehension. In
  15. (1962). A System for classing Thought Processes in The Contect of Classroom Verbal Interaction.
  16. (1993). A Thinking Skills Approach to the Humanities.
  17. (1982). Acquisition of cognitive skill. Psychological Review.
  18. (1965). An Analysis of Questions Asked in Third Grade Reading Classes., Master's Thesis,
  19. (1960). An Analysis of the Oral Questioning Activity in Selected Colorado Primary Classrooms (Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation,
  20. An Assessment of Teachers' RC Questions and Tasks: A pilot
  21. (1969). An operational definition of comprehension instruction.
  22. (1968). and Change in reading Instruction. 67th Yearbook of the National Society for the Study of Education, Part H. Chicago:
  23. (1986). Approaches to Methods in L ngua9e Teaching: A -description and An lYSis.
  24. (1984). Asking Questions,
  25. (1984). Asking Questions, in Wragg,
  26. (1953). Assessing Social-emotional Climate in the Classroom by Withall's Technique. Psychological Monographs,
  27. (1982). Atlas ofManagement of Thinking.
  28. (1972). Beginning Reading. London:
  29. (1994). Bloom's Taxonomy: Philosophical and Educational Issues.
  30. (1973). c; iýities: QCLT trag«ºý, ý activities occur t:. rouý; ^, o;: t the year. For a more j and Understanding to improve Learning and Thinking http: //www.
  31. (1991). Can we teach intelligence? A comprehensive evaluation of Feuerstein's Instrumental Enrichment Programme.,
  32. (1993). CDC Model of Thinking. Kuala Lumpur: Ministry of Education.
  33. (1993). CDC Model of Thinking. Kuala Lumpur. Ministry of Education.
  34. (1973). Changes in Means Levels of Thinking in Grades 1-8 Through Use of an Interaction Analysis System Based on Bloom's Taxonomy.
  35. (1997). Changing Patterns of Questioning. In
  36. (1987). Children With Lana11802-Disabilities. Milton Keynes:
  37. (1983). Classifying Teachers' Beliefs about Reading. The Reading Teacher.
  38. (1968). Classroom Questions: What kinds?
  39. (1966). Coding Teachers' verbal Behaviour in the Classroom. A Manual for users of OSCAR 4V
  40. (1966). Cognitive Analysis of a Curriculum: An Application of Taxonomy of Educational Objectives: Handbook 1; Cognitive Domain to Science -A Process Approach. Doctoral Dissertations. Columbia University.
  41. (1967). Cognitive Objectives Revealed by Classroom Questions Asked by Social Studies Student Teachers.,
  42. (1981). Communicative Language Teaching. Cambridge:
  43. (1984). Communicative MethodoloYY_ in Language Teaching. Cambridge:
  44. (1978). Communicative Syllabus Design. Cambridge: CUP
  45. (1986). Computer assisted cooperative learning.
  46. (1972). Creative Learning In Perspective.
  47. (1995). Creative Problem Solving and Opportunity
  48. (1995). Creative Thinking Activities. Curriculum Frameworks Network.
  49. (1964). Creativity in the Classroom: asking Provocative Questions.
  50. (1967). Creativity. London: Longmans Curriculum Committee (Kertas Bil.
  51. (1994). Critical Approaches to Adult Education. The International Encyclopedia of Education. Oxford Pergamon
  52. (1993). Critical thinking and English Arts instruction. In
  53. (1990). Critical Thinking in Social Studies: A Model of Infused Lessons for the Intermediate Grades. (Unpublished
  54. (1992). Critical Thinking Skills In a
  55. (1990). Critical Thinking Through Literature: A Dialogue Teaching Model. M. A Thesis.
  56. (1952). Critical Thinking.
  57. (1996). Cultures of Learning: Language Classrooms in China. In
  58. (1989). Curriculum Specifications - English Language (Forms 4 and 5). Kuala Lumpur: Ministry of Education.
  59. (1996). de Bono's Thinking Course.
  60. (1992). Developing expertise in reading comprehension.
  61. (1991). Developing Listening Skills. Hong Kong: Modern English Publications Rost,
  62. (1981). Developing reading Skills. Cambridge:
  63. (1977). Developmental Parameters of Reading Comprehension.
  64. (1967). Diagnostic Reading Instruction in the Elementary School (2"d Ed).
  65. (1988). Dimension for Thinking: aframeworkfor curriculum and instruction,
  66. (1979). Does answering higher-level questions while reading facilitate productive learning?
  67. (1995). Education, Examination Syndicates
  68. (1971). Educational Research: An Introduction.
  69. (1982). Effective Questioning: A teaching Skills Workbook London: Macmillan Education (teacher Education Project).
  70. (1982). Effective Teaching. London and new
  71. (1995). ELTMethodology: Principles and Practice. Kuala Lumpur: Penerbit Fajar Bakti Sdn.
  72. (1975). English as a Foreign Lanua e.
  73. (1989). English forAges 5 to 16, the Cox Report,
  74. (1995). English-as-a-Second-Language Learners' Cognitive Reading Processes: A Review ofResearch in the United States.
  75. (1986). Enol ish as a Second/Foreican Language.
  76. (1974). Error Analysis= Perspectives on second LanguageAcguisition.
  77. (1984). Evaluating and Selecting EFL Teaching.
  78. (1994). Excepts from the taxonomy of Educational Objectives, The Classification of Educational Goals, Handbook 1: Cognitive Domain. In
  79. (1963). Experimental and Quasi Experimental Designs for research.
  80. (1982). Expertise in problem solving.
  81. (1991). Explicit Integration of Critical Thinking Skills into Content Area Instruction. M. A Thesis.
  82. (1983). Frames ofMind. " The Theory ofMultiple Intelligences.
  83. (1960). Frontier in Thinking That Teachers Should Know About. The Reading Teacher,
  84. (1990). Genre Analysis. Cambridge:
  85. (1993). Ghazali Mustapha and Rosli Talif
  86. (1997). GSUMaster Teacher Program: On Critical Thinking.
  87. (1967). Guiding Learning Through Skilful Questioning.
  88. (1983). Higher education in developing countries: a question of relevance.
  89. (1983). Higher Education in developing Countries: A Question of Relevance. In
  90. (1984). How do you relate comprehension taxonomies to the designing of reading comprehension
  91. (1996). How Now Mad Cow.
  92. (1972). How to construct achievement tests to assess comprehension.
  93. (1958). How to Read Better and Faster.
  94. (1910). How We Thinly
  95. (1976). Human Characteristics and School Learning.
  96. (1991). Huraian Sukatan Pelajaran: Bahasa Inggeris Tingkatan Lima. Kuala Lumpur: Pusat Perkembangan Kuiikulum.
  97. (1995). Hypertext learning environments, cognitive flexibility, and the transfer of complex knowledge: An empirical investigation.
  98. (1987). Improving Thinking Through Instruction.
  99. (1987). Incorporating Literature In ESL Instruction.
  100. (1995). Individualism & Collectivism,
  101. (1993). Infusing Critical and Creative Thinking into Content Instruction. Critical Thinking Press and Software.
  102. (1980). Instrumental enrichment.
  103. (1987). Interactive Lanauage Teaching. Cambridge:
  104. (1981). Introduction To Applied Linguistics.
  105. (1966). Justification of Bloom's Taxonomy by Factor Analysis. Paper read at the annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association.
  106. (1991). KBaf English Form S. Petaling Jaya: Mutiara Tlmu Sdn.
  107. (1991). KBSM English Form 4. Petaling Jaya: Mutiara Ilmu Sdn.
  108. (1990). KBSR: Harapan dan Cabaran. Jumal Pendidikan, Kementerian Pendidikan Malaysia
  109. (1994). Kemahiran Berfkir secara Kritis dan Kreatif (KBKK). Kuala Lumpur : Kementerian Pendidikan Malaysia..
  110. (1994). Kemaliiran BerfIkir secara Kritis dan Kreatif (KBKK). Kuala Lumpur: Kementerian Pendidikan Malaysia..
  111. (1997). Kuala Lumpur. The Star Publication.
  112. (1970). Language and Learning: The Importance of Speech in Children's Development.
  113. (1970). Lateral Thinking: A Textbook of Creativity. London: Ward Lock.
  114. (1973). Lateral Thinking: Creativity Step by Step.
  115. (1987). Learner contributions to task design.
  116. (1968). Life in classrooms.
  117. (1986). Literature and Language Teaching. London:
  118. (1989). Literature and the Language Learner: Methodoloaica1_ Aporoaches. London: Macmillan and British Council.
  119. (1987). Literature in the Language. Cambridge:
  120. (1984). London: Longman Group Limited. 334 f rz Ur, Penny.
  121. (1970). Macro- and micro approaches combined for curriculum process analysis: A Swedish educational field project.
  122. (1992). Metacognition and Self-Monitoring Strategies. In
  123. (1980). Metacognitive development and reading. In
  124. (1957). Models of Man.
  125. (1994). National Examinations Reports. Pejabat Pendidikan, Negeri Sembilan.
  126. (1956). Non- Parametric Statistics for the Behavioral Sciences.
  127. (1970). On Public School Research.
  128. (1985). One second of reading: Postscript. In
  129. (1984). Paradigm & Ideology in Educational Resaerch. The social functions of the intellectual, London: The Falmer Press Postman,
  130. (1976). Perkembangan Pemikiran Kreative di Kalangan Pelajar Malaysia. Jurnal Pendidikan. Kuala Lumpur: Kementerian Pendidikan Malaysia
  131. (1992). Practical Strategies for the Teaching of Thinking.
  132. (1989). Process Writing: A Comprehensive Methodology for Teaching Thinking and Learning
  133. (1965). Productive thinking in gifted children.
  134. (1990). Pukal Latihan KBSM. Kuala Lumpur: Kementerian Pendidikan Malaysia.
  135. (1992). Pukal Latihan KBSM. Kuala Lumpur: Pusat Perkembangan Kurikulum.
  136. (1991). Pukal Latihan Kurikulum Bersepadu Sekolah Menengah (KB SM)
  137. (1991). Pukal Latihan Kurikulum Bersepadu SekolahMenengah (KBSM)
  138. (1972). Questioning Strategies and Techniques.
  139. (1991). QUILT (Questioning and Understanding to Improve Learning and Thinking) programme.
  140. (1980). Reading and learning from text.
  141. (1973). Reading and Writing.
  142. (1917). Reading as Reasoning: A Study of Mistakes in Paragraph Reading.
  143. (1984). Reading Between the lines: Integrated Language and Literature Activities. Ca, bridge:
  144. (1992). Reading, inferencing and problem identification: Do experts and novices differ in all three? Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association,
  145. (1970). Reading: A psycholinguistic guessing game. In
  146. (1967). Reading: A Psycholinguistic Guessing Game. The Reading Specialist.
  147. (1988). Reading. Analysing and Teaching Literature.
  148. (1986). Redefining RemedialEducation.
  149. (1994). Reflections on the Development and Use of the Taxonomy.
  150. (1965). Rewarding Creative Behaviour. Englewood Cliffs,
  151. (1970). Simultaneous Use of Four Different Observational Systems To Assess Student Teacher Classroom Behaviour. Paper presented at the annual meeting of AERA,
  152. (1978). Slow Learners: A Break In The Circle.
  153. (1982). Sociolinguistics: An Introduction.
  154. (1980). Sociolinguistics. London:
  155. (1976). Sociolinguistics. London: Billing and Sons.
  156. (1972). Sociolinguistics. United Kingdom: Hazel Watson and Viney.
  157. (1988). Somerset Thinking Skills Course (Modules 1- 5),
  158. (1993). Somerset Thinking Skills Course: Teachers' Handbook,
  159. (1994). Specific Learning Difficulties (Dyxlexia): A Handbook for Study and Practice.
  160. (1995). Stance, Meaning and Voluntary Reading. In
  161. (1975). Studies of problem soling, judgment and decision making: Implication for educational research.
  162. (1983). Sydney microskills Redeveloped, Vol 1-4, Sydney;
  163. (1986). Task Classification: A Cross-disciplinary Review,
  164. (1964). Taxonomy of Educational Objectives: The Classification of Educational Goals. Handbook II: Affective Domain.
  165. (1972). Taxonomy ofReading Comprehension. Reading 360 Monograph.
  166. (1967). Teacher Questioning and Reading. The reading teacher, XXI
  167. (1967). Teacher's objectives and questions in primary reading. The Reading teacher,
  168. (1984). Teachers' Classroom Decision Making.
  169. (1986). Teachers' Thought Processes.
  170. (1975). Teaching as clinical information processing
  171. (1995). Teaching Critical Thinking. A Paper presented to Linda Cannel, Professor of Learning and the Art of Teaching, Regent College.
  172. (1969). Teaching English as a Second or Foreign Language.
  173. (1978). Teaching Language and Communication.
  174. (1991). Teaching Literature.
  175. (1990). Teaching Oral English.
  176. (1983). Teaching Practice Handbook.
  177. (1975). Teaching Prereadi na Skills.
  178. (1991). Teaching Questioning and Learning:
  179. (1991). Teaching Reading Comprehension Processes.
  180. (1978). Teaching Reading Comprehension.
  181. (1990). Teaching reading comprehension. Milton Keynes:
  182. (1966). Teaching Strategies and Cognitive Functioning
  183. (1988). Teaching the Spoken Language. Cambridge:
  184. (1991). Teaching Thinking: A survey of programmes in education (2°d edition),
  185. (1990). Teaching Thinking: an introduction to the research literature, Spotlights no. 26, Scottish Council for Research in Education.
  186. (1976). Teaching Thinking.
  187. (1980). Teachinn Written English. London: Allen and Unwin.
  188. (1993). Techniques and Procedures for Assessing Cognitive Skills.
  189. (1971). The Application of Bloom's Cognitive Taxonomy to Selected Professional Education Competence.
  190. (1979). The Communicative Approach to Language Teaching.
  191. (1966). The Construction and Validation
  192. (1971). The Development of Comprehension Skills In Selected Basal Readers (Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation) The Ohio State University.
  193. (1964). The Development ofMethod forAnalysis of Questions Asked by Teachers in the Classroom Discourse (Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation,
  194. (1982). The episodic/semantic memory distinction in heuristic in the study of instructional effects on cognitive structure.
  195. (1972). The Hague:
  196. (1966). The influence ofAnalysis and Evaluation Questions On Critical Thinking and achievement in Six Grade Social Studies. Unpublished doctoral dissertation,
  197. (1989). The Inward Ear: Poetry in the Language ClassroomCambridge:
  198. (1967). The Methodology of Evaluation, Perspectives of Curriculum Evaluation.
  199. (1967). The Nature of Human Intelligence.
  200. (1952). The Origin of intelligence in Children.
  201. (1983). The Practice of English Languaoe Teaching.
  202. (1979). The Process and purpose of Reading.
  203. (1908). The psychology and pedagogy of reading.
  204. (1963). The Psychology ofMeaningful Verbal Learning.
  205. (1912). The question as a measure of efficiency in instruction, Teachers'
  206. (1988). The Reading Process. In
  207. (1983). The Reflective Practitioner - How Professionals Think in Action. London:
  208. (1991). The Relationship of Empathy to Effective Speaking: Critical and Creative Thinking in the Speech Process. M. A Thesis.
  209. (1963). The Role of the Teacher in The Classroom. Minneapolis: Amidon and associates,
  210. (1988). The SPSS GUIDE to Data Analysis for SPSS. Chicago:
  211. (1997). The Star, March 16,1997. Kuala Lumpur: The Star Publication.
  212. (1974). The Study of Teaching.
  213. (1992). The Tapestry of Lanauaae Learning.
  214. (1992). The Tapestry of Language Learning. The Individual in the communicative classroom.
  215. (1975). The Tasks of Teaching Reading.
  216. (1965). The Taxonomy of Educational Objectives, The Classification of Educational Goals. Handbook 1: Cognitive Domain.
  217. (1996). The teaching of constructive thinking skills in education. Conference Paper,
  218. (1981). The Teaching of English as a International Language.
  219. (1965). The Teaching of Thinking. Elementary English,
  220. (1985). The Transactional Theory of Literary Work: Implications for Research. In
  221. (1970). The use of questions in teaching.
  222. (1966). The way teaching is.
  223. (1966). Theoretical issues in reading comprehension: Perspective from cognitive psychology; linguistics, artificial intelligence and education
  224. (1971). Thinking about the curriculum. The curriculum context,
  225. (1993). Thinking Skills, Concept, Models and strategies of Teaching and Learning. Kuala Lumpur. Kuala Lumpur: Ministry of Education,
  226. (1985). Thinking Skills: A Conceptual Framework Mid-continent Regional Educational Laboratory.
  227. (1959). Three Faces of Intellect.
  228. (1974). Torrance Tests of Creative Thinking,
  229. (1985). Toward a cognitive theory for the measurement of achievement. In
  230. (1985). Toward a theory of automatic information processing in reading.
  231. (1993). Toward a Theory of Instruction.
  232. (1985). Toward an interactive model of reading. In
  233. (1979). Towards a Theory ofDrama in Education.
  234. (1987). Towards task-based language learning.
  235. (1997). Training teachers to ask questions.
  236. (1983). Unlocking the Brain's Two Powerful Learning Systems.
  237. (1997). Values and Citizenship Education in Malaysia. In
  238. (1982). Watson-Glaser Critical Thinking Appraisal.
  239. (1977). Way Beyond the I. Q. Creative Synergetic Associates.
  240. (1990). Ways of Evaluating Teacher Cognition: Inferences concerning the Goldilocks principles.
  241. (1978). What Classroom Observations Reveal About reading Comprehension Instruction. Reading Research Quarterly,
  242. (1968). What is "Reading": Some Current Concepts.
  243. (1987). What Research Has to Say About Reading Instruction.
  244. (1992). What Teachers in Training are Taught about Reading. The Working Papers. National Faoundation for Educational Research (NFER)
  245. (1978). Writing as a Thinking Process.
  246. (1978). Writing for a Purpose London:
  247. (1978). Yeis. They Cans A Practical Guide for Teaching The Slow Learner. Molton Keynes: The open

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.