Location of Repository

From Revolution to Commie Kitsch: (Re)-presenting China in Contemporary British Museums through the Visual Culture of the Cultural Revolution

By Amy Jane Barnes

Abstract

To date, the study of communist visual culture in the museum environment has been limited. While interest in revolutionary art continues to develop thanks to its twenty-first century appropriation and ‘kitschification’ in Western contexts, communist art remains problematic. Taking Saidian discourse as a theoretical starting point, this thesis explores the collection, interpretation and display of the visual culture of the Chinese Cultural Revolution (1966-1976) in contemporary British museums. It explores the image of China in the popular consciousness and looks for intersections between the contemporary political Sino-British relationship and interpretive approaches to this material. The historiographical survey analyses contemporary primary sources to reveal images of the Cultural Revolution during three periods which correspond with mind shifts in the British response to China. Interviews with key members of curatorial staff situate the thesis in contemporary practice. \ud The thesis is divided into three sections. The first, the ‘pre-historical’ context to the main body of the thesis establishes a methodological approach, theoretical grounding and surveys the Sino-British relationship from the Enlightenment to the foundation of the People’s Republic of China in 1949. Section 2 looks at the contemporary British response to the Cultural Revolution and how these visions of China were translated into exhibitionary practice. Section 3 explores the collections and practice of three case studies. It examines the different and diverse reasons for the establishment of these collections and how they have interpreted (as art, artefact or document). The thesis concludes with the argument that museums and collecting institutions have a key role to play in the difficult debate which envelopes the West’s historical response to communism and the legacy of the Cultural Revolution, in the light of challenges to the grand narrative

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 2010
OAI identifier: oai:lra.le.ac.uk:2381/8282

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1977). (2 nd edition). Peasant Paintings from Hu Country,
  2. (1970). (2 nd edition). Red China Today.
  3. (1999). (2 nd edition). Western Images of China.
  4. (1980). (3 rd edition). Scratches On Our Minds: American Views of China and India. Armonk and
  5. (2005). (3 rd edition). The Sage Handbook of Qualitative Research. Thousand Oaks,
  6. (2000). (sixth edition). „The Rise of Modern China‟.
  7. (1997). 100 Great Chinese Posters: Recent examples of “the people‟s art” from the People‟s Republic of China,
  8. 1966b. „Mao beats The Beatles in Hong Kong‟.
  9. (1967). 1967a.„ “Terror” in China as riots rage on‟.
  10. (1967). 1967b.„Violence in Portland Place‟. The Times.
  11. 1989b.„China‟s old men use force to stay in power‟..
  12. (2004). 2 nd edition. Qualitative Research: Theory, Method and Practice.
  13. (1999). 2 nd edition. The Search for Modern China.
  14. (1970). 2nd edition. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions.
  15. (1967). A Babel of reports from China‟.
  16. (1997). A Grand Design: The Art of the Victoria and Albert Museum.
  17. (1997). A last hurrah and an empire closes down.‟
  18. (1984). A Teaching Guide to Films on the People’s Republic of China. Oxford Polytechnic, Discussion Papers in Geography,
  19. (1997). A Tearful Salute to the Last Jewel in the Crown‟. Daily Mail.
  20. (1974). A thousand cuts.‟
  21. (2000). After Da Gama: Europe and Asia since 1498‟. Modern Asian Studies.
  22. (2003). After the Flood‟. In
  23. (1999). All Dressed Up: The Sixties and Counterculture.
  24. (1961). An Introduction to Chinese Art.
  25. (2008). An Olympic Evaluation‟. The China Beat.
  26. (1980). Arguments Within English Marxism.
  27. (1996). Art and Artists of Twentieth-Century China.
  28. (2008). Art and China’s Revolution.
  29. (1998). Art and Politics in China, 1949-1984. Hong Kong: The Chinese
  30. (2008). Art and Revolution: Looking Back at Thirty Years of History.‟
  31. (2008). At war with the utopia of modernity.‟
  32. (1939). Avant-Garde
  33. (2006). Backlash as Google shores up great firewall of China‟.
  34. (1944). Battle Hymn of China.
  35. (1972). Bibliography Archive material: ACA: Arts Council of Great Britain records, 1928-1997, held by Archive of Art and Design,
  36. (2001). Biography of a Chairman Mao Badge: The Creation and Mass Consumption of a Personality Cult.
  37. (1989). Bloodbath in Tiananmen‟.
  38. (1950). Britain and China.‟
  39. (2002). Britain’s Chinese Collections, 1842-1943: Private Collecting and the Invention of Chinese Art. Unpublished DPhil,
  40. (2001). British Social Movements since 1945: Sex, Colour, Peace and Power.
  41. (1966). Brutal Struggles‟ in Peking University‟. In The Times.
  42. (2006). Caring for our collections‟. Memorandum submitted to the Select Committee on Culture,
  43. (1995). Celebrating Twenty-Five Years in the Far Eastern Collection of the Victoria and Albert Museum‟. In Orientations.
  44. (2008). Chairman Mao Badges: Symbols and Slogans of the Cultural Revolution. London:
  45. (2002). Challenging Myths of the 1960s: The Case of Student Protest
  46. (2008). China bans loans to show on Cultural Revolution.
  47. (2005). China Crisis: threat to the global environment.‟
  48. (1938). China Fights Back.
  49. (1998). China in Britain: The imperial collections‟.
  50. (2005). China to 'tidy up' trade in executed prisoners' organs.‟
  51. (2002). China to Chinatown: Chinese Food in the West. London: Reaktion Books.
  52. (2007). China: Tiananmen Legacy Defies Olympic Gloss‟,
  53. (1996). China’s Cultural Revolution, 1966-1969: Not a Dinner Party.
  54. (1976). China‟s Big Battle for a New Mao‟.
  55. (1971). China‟s missing heir‟.
  56. (1972). Chinese agitscape‟.
  57. (1980). Chinese Art.
  58. (1972). Chinese confirm Lin Piao‟s death after „plot‟‟. The Times. Saturday,
  59. (1998). Chinese material culture and British perceptions of China in the mid-nineteenth century‟.
  60. (1960). Chinese Painting. Geneva: Editions d‟Art Albert Skira S.A.
  61. (1997). Chinese Papercuts from the Cultural Revolution at the Victoria and Albert Museum.‟ In Orientations. November-December
  62. (2007). Chinese Posters: Art from the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution. San Francisco:
  63. (2007). Chinese Posters: Art from the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution. San Francisco: Chronicle Books
  64. Chinese Prints 1950-2006: In the Ashmolean Museum.
  65. (1961). Chinoiserie: The Vision of Cathay. London:
  66. (1995). Civilizing Rituals: Inside Public Art Museums. London and
  67. (1966). Cleansing Sludge.‟ In Far Eastern Economic Review.
  68. Cold War Modern. Visitor Guide.
  69. (2000). Collecting Chinese Art: Interpretation and Display.
  70. (2007). Collecting Futures in the Trajectories of the Past‟, Extreme Collecting: Intellectual Foundations of ‘Difficult Objects’,
  71. (1997). Collecting the Twentieth Century.‟ In
  72. (2007). Collectors, Collections and Museums: The Field of Chinese Ceramics
  73. Colonialism and Culture. Ann Arbor:
  74. (1991). Creativity and politics.‟
  75. (2000). Dark Tourism: The Attraction of Death and Disaster. London and
  76. (2007). Diaz apologises for Maoist slogan‟.
  77. (1994). Disgraced Monuments.
  78. (1975). Does a serious paper hire a critic only because it can be sure his views will match what is vaguely felt to be its public‟s, or does it hire him for his knowledge and ability to argue a case.‟ In Guardian.
  79. (2004). Doing things with documents‟.
  80. (1976). Dying Mao was “nagged by wife”‟.
  81. (1977). Editor‟s Notes‟, in
  82. Edward W.1995. Orientalism: Western conceptions of the Orient.
  83. (2003). Elective Affinities: Collecting the Modern World for the British Museum‟. Collecting Now:
  84. (1998). English and the Discourses of Colonialism. London &
  85. (1995). Enlightened Decisions: The Founding of the V&A‟s „Far Eastern Department.‟ In Orientations.
  86. (1997). Even the Heavens Kept on Weeping, Tearful Farewell to Hong Kong, the Hand Over of Hong Kong to the Chinese.‟
  87. (1997). Examples of revolutionary papercuts in the V&A collection (1965-1970). From
  88. (1999). Excess and Enthusiasm.‟ In
  89. (1972). Family strife‟.
  90. (1992). for a detailed history of the development, and previous incarnations, of the Joseph E. Hotung Gallery.
  91. (1973). Forensic secrets of an old Chinese lady.‟
  92. (2006). Four Types of Visual Culture‟.
  93. (1982). From China, with Disdain: New Trends in the Study of China‟, Asian Survey.
  94. (1967). From Russia – with style‟.
  95. (1994). Fu Manchu and the ‘Yellow Peril’: The Making of a Racist Myth. Stoke-on-Trent:
  96. (1991). Gallery Report: The New T.T. Tsui Gallery of Chinese Art at the Victoria and Albert Museum.‟ In Oriental Art. Summer
  97. (1999). Gill Perry with Nicola Durbridge.
  98. (1990). Gone Primitive: Savage Intellects, Modern Lives.
  99. (2008). Gritty renegade now directs China‟s close-up‟.
  100. (2000). Hand Grenade Practice in Peking: My part in the Cultural Revolution. London:
  101. (1949). He will be the Emperor of China.‟ In Daily Mirror.
  102. (1997). Hong Kong handover: Patten wipes a tear as Last Post sounds.‟
  103. (2007). If You Go Hanging Pictures of Chairman Mao, You Ain't Gonna Make It with Anyone Anyhow‟.
  104. (2003). Images of War‟. Collecting Now:
  105. (2008). In the Image of Revolution.‟
  106. In the West, perhaps they would be Scouts and Guides‟. Daily Mirror.
  107. (2000). Inventing China: The Use of Orientalist Views on the Chinese Language‟. In interventions.
  108. (1971). Is China really coming out of the cold?‟
  109. (2008). It's time to question our cultural rage for China.‟ In Guardian.
  110. (2003). John Chinaman’ and ‘Fu Manchu’: Chinese Immigration,
  111. (1996). Key Debates in Anthropology,
  112. (2002). Left Shift: Radical Art
  113. (1974). Lei Feng
  114. (2003). Lily Briscoe’s Chinese Eyes: Bloomsbury, Modernism,
  115. (2006). Look back for anger.‟ BBC News Magazine. http://newsvote.bbc.co.uk/mpapps/pagetools/print/news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/magazine/506064 0.stm (05/07/2006) Croizier, Ralph. „Chinese Art in the Chiang Ch'ing Era‟,
  116. (1994). Loot‟s Fate: The Economy and Plunder of The Moral Life of Objects “From The Summer Palace of The Emperor of China”‟.
  117. (1999). Looting Beijing: 1860, 1900‟. In
  118. (2001). Lost and found‟.
  119. M.1995. Orientalism: History, theory and the arts. Manchester and New York:
  120. (1971). Major shift in diplomatic alignments: China buries the hatchet‟.
  121. (1991). Mao Tse-tung‟s thought from 1949 to 1976‟.
  122. (2006). Mao’s Last Revolution.
  123. (1967). Mao‟s Dilemma: Whether to Unleash the Great Purge‟.
  124. (1966). Mao‟s swim given wide publicity‟.
  125. (2001). Maoism in the Developed World.
  126. (2007). Memorial Museums: The Global Rush to Commemorate Atrocities.
  127. (2006). Modern Chinese Artists: a biographical dictionary.
  128. (1996). Modern Chinese Paintings: The Reyes Collection in the Ashmolean Museum,
  129. (1971). Mr Benn‟s inside report on China today‟.
  130. (1992). Museums and the Shaping of Knowledge. London and
  131. (2005). New Keywords: A Revised Vocabulary of Culture and Society.
  132. (1971). New Washington report that Lin Piao is dead‟. In The Times.
  133. (1981). of the Communist Party of China.
  134. (2008). Olympic art and artifice‟. The American Interest. JulyAugust
  135. (1995). On Collecting: An Investigation Into Collecting in the European Tradition.. London and
  136. (1967). On guard‟.
  137. (1967). On Literature and Art.
  138. (2006). One powerful owner‟.
  139. (2008). One World, One Dream: China is playing these Games to win; Yesterday's Olympic opening ceremony shows that the Chinese are happy to glorify their own culture (so long as communism doesn't get a mention)‟. The Daily Telegraph.
  140. (1992). Orientalism and the Exhibitionary Order‟.
  141. (1998). Paddy‟s Chinatown: A Short (Hi)story of a Liverpool Hybridity.‟ In interventions.
  142. (1998). Paint it Red.
  143. (1994). Painters and Politics in the People’s Republic of China,
  144. (2008). Painting over Mao: notes on the inauguration of the Beijing Olympic Games‟. The China Beat.
  145. (2006). Para-)humanity, Yellow Peril and the postcolonial (arche-)type‟.
  146. (1973). Peking into the past.‟
  147. (1976). Poker vigil‟ of Mao‟s widow‟.
  148. (1983). Popular Books on China: The New Journalistic Wave.‟
  149. (1986). Popular Culture and Social Relations. Milton Keynes:
  150. (1980). Popular Culture and the State‟.
  151. (2005). Popular‟. In Bennett, Tony, Lawrence Grossberg and Meaghan Morris (eds). New Keywords: A Revised Vocabulary of Culture and Society.
  152. (2005). Portrait of a Monster‟. In The New York Review of Books.
  153. (2006). Power to the people.‟
  154. (1976). Power vacuum after Mao‟s death‟.
  155. (1935). Preface‟. In Executive Committee. Catalogue of the International Exhibition of Chinese Art 1935-6. London: Royal Academy of Arts.
  156. (2008). Propaganda Posters and Art during the Cultural Revolution.‟
  157. (2007). Proteste gegen Tibet-Ausstellung‟.
  158. (2005). Qualitative Case Studies‟. In
  159. (1966). Rebels in Shanghai: from our Shanghai correspondent.‟
  160. (1976). Record of Achievement.‟
  161. (2002). Red and Expert: China‟s “Foreign Friends” in the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution,
  162. (1996). Red Azalea: Life and Love in China,
  163. (1996). Red China Blues: My Long March from Mao to Now. London:
  164. (1967). Red Guard Attack as Ultimatum Expires.‟ In The Times.
  165. (1939). Red Star Over China‟. In Left News.
  166. (1981). revised edition, translated in 1977, originally published in French,
  167. (2001). Revolution‟. The Beatles (The White Album). Apple Records.
  168. (2007). Revolutionary Chinese Posters and Their Impact Abroad‟.
  169. (1976). Revolutionary leader who inspired the regeneration of China‟.
  170. (1996). Season of High Adventure: Edgar Snow in China.
  171. (1977). Secretary-General‟s Report.‟ In Value For Money: Thirty-second annual report and accounts, year ended 31
  172. (2006). Seize the Hour: When Nixon Met
  173. (2006). Select Committee on Foreign Affairs.
  174. (2006). Sensuous (Re)Collections: The Sight and Taste of Socialism at Grūtas Statue Park, Lithuania‟.
  175. (1996). Shades of Mao: The Posthumous Cult of the Great Leader.
  176. (2001). Should Beijing get the games?‟
  177. (1972). Sir Alec confirms new era of warmer relations with China‟.
  178. (2005). Sixties Britain:
  179. (2007). Society.
  180. (1966). Something has happened in China‟.
  181. (2009). Soviet Bunker - the strangest tourist trap in Europe‟.
  182. (2010). Star City: The Futurological Congress, 12 February,
  183. (2005). Storm rages over bestselling book on monster Mao‟.
  184. (1984). Studies in Chinese Ceramics. Hong Kong:
  185. (1974). Style in the Arts of China.
  186. (2004). Supping with the Devil?
  187. (1999). Swan and Spider Eater in Problematic Memoirs of Cultural Revolution‟. In positions.
  188. (1966). Teaching the Senators Wisdom‟.
  189. (1990). Tebbit leads new revolt over Hong Kong passports.‟
  190. (1998). The Archive State and the Fear of Pollution: from the Opium Wars to Fu-Manchu‟.
  191. (2002). The Art of Calligraphy in Modern China.
  192. (2008). The Art of Mao‟s Revolution.‟
  193. (2008). The Battle for China’s Past: Mao and the Cultural Revolution.
  194. (1991). The Cambridge History of China. Volume 15, The People’s Republic, Part 2: Revolutions within the Chinese Revolution 1966-1982. Cambridge:
  195. (1974). The Changing Face of Chinese Art‟.
  196. (1967). The children of Mao‟.
  197. (1973). The China boom.‟
  198. (1935). The Chinese Art Exhibition: popularity of official lectures‟. In The Times.
  199. (1977). The Chinese Exhibition at the Warehouse Gallery.‟
  200. (1991). The Chinese state in crisis‟.
  201. (2003). The Cold War: A Very Short Introduction.
  202. (1988). The Collected Essays and Criticism: Perceptions and Judgments 1939-1944. Chicago:
  203. (2008). The creation of coevalness and the danger of homochronism‟.
  204. (2008). The East is Red.‟ In The London Traveller. URL: http://www.thelondontraveler.com/the-east-is-red/ (15/04/2008) I owe Prof. Simon Knell for this observation.
  205. (1997). The Empire of Things: the engagement with the Orient.
  206. (1998). The Foundations of Social Research: meaning and perspective in the research process. London and Thousand Oaks,
  207. (1999). The future of collecting: lessons from the past‟.
  208. (1973). The Genius of China: An exhibition of archaeological finds of the People’s Republic of China.
  209. (1966). The Golden Bridge‟. In Far Eastern Economic Review.
  210. (1992). The Good Old Cause:
  211. (2007). The iconic Mao‟. In Peking Duck.
  212. (1989). The Meeting of Eastern and
  213. (1971). The missing Lin Piao men complicate the Chinese puzzle‟.
  214. (1949). The New China.‟ In The Times,
  215. (1987). The New Chinese Painting,
  216. (2007). The Nightmares of the Cultural Revolution genre has had its day.‟ In
  217. The People’s Republic, Part 2: Revolutions within the Chinese Revolution 1966-1982. Cambridge:
  218. (2004). The Political Body in Chinese Art: Posters, Politics and Performances.‟
  219. (2006). The Portrayal of Opportunism, Betrayal, and Manipulation in Mao‟s Rise to Power‟.
  220. (1966). The Poster Purgative.‟ In Far Eastern Economic Review.
  221. (2005). The Rebel Sell: How the counterculture became consumer culture.
  222. (2008). The Right to Party, en masse.‟
  223. (2000). The Shock of the New: Collecting Post-1949 Chinese Ceramics at the V&A.‟
  224. (1997). The Sixties on both sides of the Channel‟. In Mellor, David Alan and Laurent Gervereau.
  225. (1997). The Sixties: Britain and France, 1962-1973, The Utopian Years.
  226. (1998). The Sixties: Cultural Revolution
  227. (1999). The Social Construction of What?
  228. (1966). The struggle to be holier than Mao‟.
  229. (1991). The succession to Mao and the end of Maoism‟.
  230. (1968). The thoughtful stripper‟.
  231. (2009). The torch passes‟. The Guardian.
  232. (1992). The Tsui Gallery of Chinese Art: A Visitor Survey.
  233. (1984). The Unbearable Lightness of Being.
  234. (1998). The Winking Owl: Art in the People's Republic of China.
  235. (1988). The Winking Owl: Art in the People’s Republic of China.
  236. (2005). There was nothing else to see‟. The Guardian. Friday 4th
  237. (1999). Tokens of Exchange: The Problem of Translation in Global Circulations. Durham & London:
  238. (2000). Twentieth-century Chinese prints at the British Museum: the formation and development of the collection.‟
  239. (1999). Under the Red Flag: A History
  240. (2002). Unraveling the Threads of History: Soviet-Era Monuments and Post-Soviet National Identity‟.
  241. (1999). Views of Difference: Different Views of Art. New Haven and London:
  242. (1968). Violent protest‟.
  243. (2009). Was There a Master Plan to use the Olympics Games to Promote a Positive Image of China to the World?‟ The China Beat.
  244. (1972). Ways of Seeing. London: British Broadcasting Corporation and Penguin.
  245. (1993). Western Images of China (review article)‟.
  246. (1999). What about Chinese art?‟
  247. (1967). What‟s Going On In China?‟.
  248. (2004). When We Look: Reflections on personal memory and posters as historical artefacts.‟
  249. (1966). Who Are the Red Guards?‟
  250. (1939). With China‟s Red Army.‟
  251. (1977). With you in charge, I am at ease‟, Anon.
  252. (1993). Writing Diaspora: Tactics of Intervention in Contemporary Cultural Studies. Bloomington and Indianapolis:
  253. (1975). You Can Get There From Here.
  254. (2007). Your Mao T-Shirt Won‟t Get You Into Heaven‟. In Geek Buffet.
  255. (1927). Zedong [Mao Tse-tung]: Report on an Investigation of the Peasant Movement in Hunan,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.