Location of Repository

A Socio -Technical Analysis of the Standards Based Apprenticeship in Ireland: a case study of the construction industry

By Leonard A. O'Connor

Abstract

Apprenticeship is one of the oldest forms of training and is one of the cornerstones on which a skills bank is built. It has been developed from a system of master and indentured apprentice, which existed in the period of the medieval guilds, to a dual system of education and training with both on-the-job and off-the-job periods of training and education.\ud A number of unsuccessful attempts were made in the last century to re-structure apprenticeship in Ireland, including three Acts of the Oireachtas (Parliament).\ud Despite this legislation, the only requirement to qualify as a craftsperson was to serve the appropriate length of time and to be a member of the craft union. There were no mandatory levels of competence to be reached by the apprentice before being recognised as a craftsperson.\ud In 1991, the social partners agreed the need for an overhaul of the apprenticeship system and set in motion the process to develop an apprenticeship system that would ensure that all apprentices in the designated trades would have to reach predetermined standards on competence before they could be awarded the National Craft Certificate.\ud The new system is modular in structure and known as the Standards Based Apprenticeship.\ud This thesis examined the effectiveness of the Standards Based Apprenticeship system in meeting the present and future needs of the construction industry and in preparing apprentices to adapt to inevitable change in the industry. It concludes that the new system is superior to the time-served system it replaced in many respects but has identified some problems. The thesis concludes by making some recommendations for change to the system, based on the analysis of the responses from the stakeholders and which, if implemented, would in the opinion of the author, ensure that the Irish crafts persons are trained to the highest international standards

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 2003
OAI identifier: oai:lra.le.ac.uk:2381/8238

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1990). 36 Definition of Apprenticeship ............................................................ 36 Institution of Apprenticeship ............................................................
  2. (1998). A blueprint for change: construction skills training in Britain,
  3. (1983). A treatise of social theory.
  4. (1988). Adult Training Policy and Local Labour Markets,
  5. (2002). An Evaluation of the Sole Use of Short Answer Tests In Apprenticeship Examinations,
  6. (2002). An Evaluation of the Use of Short Answer Tests In Apprenticeship Examinations. Report for the Department of Education and Science.
  7. (1994). An Introduction to Classroom Obsenation.
  8. (1994). An Introduction to Classroom Observation.
  9. (1985). Applied Qualitative Research,
  10. (1977). Apprentice Attitudes in Dublin, Dublin, An Comhairle Oiliun& Huddleston,
  11. (1999). Apprenticeship a la mode ? Some Reflections on learning as Cultural Labour,
  12. (1993). Apprenticeship and RPL: Re-cognizing the Learning of a Trade,
  13. (1993). Apprenticeship and RPL: Recognising the Learning of a Trade,
  14. (1993). Apprenticeship and RPL: Recognizing the Learning of a Trade,
  15. (1998). Apprenticeship as a Conceptual Basis for a Social theory of Learning,
  16. (1996). Apprenticeship in England 1600-1914,
  17. (1993). Apprenticeship in Ireland: A Historical Analysis.
  18. (1993). Apprenticeship in Ireland: A Historical Analysis. Unpublished PhD.
  19. (1974). Apprenticeship in Ireland: Towards a Structured System, Unpublished M. Ed Thesis,
  20. (1977). Apprenticeship in Ireland: Towards a Structured System. Unpublished
  21. (2000). Apprenticeship Training and Education: A Review for the National Apprenticeship Advisory Committee,
  22. (2001). Apprenticeship Training in Ireland: from timcserved to standards based: potential and limitations for the construction industry,
  23. (2001). Apprenticeship Training in Ireland: from timeserved to standards based: potential and limitations for the construction industry,
  24. (1989). Apprenticeship, A New Approach: a Discussion Document.
  25. (1989). Apprenticeship, A NewApproach: a Discussion Document.
  26. (1994). Apprenticeship: A New Dawning,
  27. (1977). Attitudes in Dublin, Dublin, An Comhairle Oiliuna.
  28. (1996). Basics of Qualitative Research - Techniques and Procedures for developing Grounded Theory
  29. (1996). Basics of Qualitative Research - Techniques and Procedures for developing Grounded Theory,
  30. (2000). Beyond Competence,
  31. (1999). Beyond the Institution of Apprenticeship: Towards a Social Theory of Learning as the Production of Knowledge,
  32. (2002). Building Theories From Case Studies Research in The Qualitative Researcher's Companion,
  33. (1989). Can competence and knowledge mix?
  34. (1989). Can competence and knowledge mix? in Competency Based Education and Training,
  35. (1998). Case studies in modem apprenticeship: new wine in old bottles?
  36. (1998). Case studies in modern apprenticeship: nerv wine in old bottles?
  37. (1994). Case Study Research - Design and Methods,
  38. (1994). Case Study Research -Design and Methods,
  39. (1994). Changing the Training Culture: lessons from AngloGerman comparisons of vocational education and training,
  40. (1989). Competence and Standards,
  41. (1989). Competence based education and training: background and origins,
  42. (2002). Competence-Based Approaches: a discussion of issues for professional groups,
  43. (2001). Consider a research project you have undertaken, or propose to undertake and discuss the relevance and appropriateness to it of both the positivist and interpretive paradigm,
  44. (2002). Construction Industry Review
  45. (1995). Construction Industry training Board
  46. (1999). Construction IndustryReview
  47. (1998). Constuctivist, Interpretivist Approaches to Human Inquiry',
  48. (1998). Contemporary Apprenticeship: perspectives on learning, teaching, policy and design,
  49. (1998). Contemporary Apprenticeship: perspectives on learning. teaching, policy and design,
  50. (1999). Conversation and Instruction within Apprenticeship: Affordances for Learning,
  51. (1979). Craft Apprenticeship in Europe,
  52. (1982). Craft Level Education and Training in the Construction Industry, Coome Lodge Staff Structure of the Construction Industry and Future Training Needs.
  53. (1982). Craft Level Education and Training in the Construction Industry, in Staff Structure of the Construction Industry and Future Training Needs.
  54. (1982). Craft level education and training in the Construction Industry.
  55. (1979). Craft Skills for Industry, Craft Education and Training,
  56. (1979). Craft Skills forIndustry, Craft Education and Training,
  57. (1989). Data Analysis for Research Designs: Analfsis of Variance and Multiple Regression/Correlation Approaches,
  58. (1989). Data Analysis for Research Designs: Analysis of Variance and Multiple Regression/Correlation Approaches,
  59. (1982). Daybreak : Thoughts on the prejudices of morality.
  60. (1982). Daybreak: Thoughts on the prejudices of morality,
  61. (1993). Doing Naturalistic Inquiry: A Guide to Methods,
  62. (1993). Doing Naturalistic Inquiry. A Guide to Methods,
  63. (2001). Education and Skills.
  64. (1996). Education and Training and the Flexible Labour Market,
  65. (1978). Educational Research; the Art and Science of Investigation.
  66. (1978). Educational Research; the Art and Science oflnviestigation,
  67. (1997). Effective Supervisory Management in Ireland,
  68. (1998). Ethnic Modelling in Qualitative Research
  69. (1998). Ethnic Modelling in Qualitative Research,
  70. (2002). Ethnography and Realism,
  71. (1999). European Social Fund Evaluation Unit
  72. (1995). European Social Fund Evaluation Unit,
  73. (2001). Expert Group on Future Skills Needs
  74. (2003). General training by firms, apprentice contracts, and public policy,
  75. (2002). Increasing the Generalizability of Qualitative Research,
  76. (1989). Initial teacher training and the NCVQ model,
  77. (1989). Initial teacher training and the NVQ model,
  78. (1991). Institutional Structures and the Provision of Intermediate Level skills: Lessons from Canada and Hong Kong,
  79. (1996). Interviews: an Introduction to Qualitative Research Interviewing.
  80. (1998). Is Apprenticeship Better? A Review of the Economic Evidence,
  81. (1970). Is Apprenticeship Outdated? London, Institute of Personnel Management.
  82. (1999). Making Meaning: Language for Learning,
  83. (1999). Making Meaning: Language for Learning, in Towards a New Paradigm of Learning, Eds.
  84. (1998). Mixed Methodology.
  85. (1998). Mixed Methodology. Califomia: Sage.
  86. (1999). Modem Apprentices in College. So What's New?
  87. (1999). Modem Apprentices in College. So What's New? Towards a New Paradigm of Learning,
  88. (1998). Modem Apprenticeship in College: `something old, something new',
  89. (1998). Modern Apprenticeship in College: `something old, something new',
  90. (2002). Narrative Analysis,
  91. (1999). Nietzsche, Marx and Mastery. The Learning unto Death,
  92. (1999). Nietzsche, Marx and Mastery. The Learning unto Death, in Apprenticeship: - Towards a New Paradigm of Learning,
  93. (1998). Observational Techniques',
  94. (1990). On `Competence,
  95. (1990). On `Competence',
  96. (1990). On 'Competence,
  97. (1970). On the Nature of Skill,
  98. (1991). Outcomes: NVQs and the Emerging Model of Education and Training,
  99. (1991). Outcomes: NVQs and the EmergingModel of Education and Training,
  100. (1958). Personal Knowledge; towards a post-critical philosophy,
  101. (1979). Policies on Apprenticeship.
  102. (1994). Politics and Ethics in Qualitative Research,
  103. (1994). Qualitative Data Analysis,
  104. (1986). Qualitative methods in research on
  105. (2002). Real Men Don't Collect Soft Data,
  106. (2002). Real Men Don't Collect Soft Data, in Nuberman.
  107. (1993). Real World Research -A Resource for Social Scientists and Practitioner Researchers,
  108. (1993). Real World Research -A Resource for Social Scientists and Practitioner-Researchers,
  109. (1998). Reconceptualising Apprenticeship: exploring the relationship between work and learning,
  110. (2001). Recreating Apprenticeship: lessons from the Irish standards-based model,
  111. (1998). Research Methods for Generalist Social Work,
  112. (1990). Research Methods.
  113. (1998). Rethinking Critical Theory
  114. Royal Commission on Technical Instruction,
  115. (1980). Skill and the English Working Class, 1870-1914, London, Croom Helm social history series.
  116. (1980). Skill and the English Working Class, 1870-1914, London, Croom Helm, social history series.
  117. (1997). Social Research, issues, methods and process.
  118. (1998). Strategies of Qualitative Inquiry,
  119. (1999). Teaching for Quality Learning at
  120. (1999). The Apprentice in History,
  121. (1999). The Apprentice in History, in Apprenticeship: Towards a New Paradigm of Learning,
  122. (1996). The Apprenticeship System in British History: The Fragmentation of a Cultural institution,
  123. (1996). The Apprenticeship System in British History. The Fragmentation of a Cultural institution,
  124. (1991). The Competence Approach,
  125. (1995). The Competence Movement and the National Vocational Qualification Framework the Widening Parameters of Research',
  126. (1982). The Competent Manager: a model for effective performance.
  127. (1996). The Compleat Observer? A field guide to observation.
  128. (1994). The Decline of Apprenticeship Training
  129. (1995). The decline of apprenticeship training in Britain,
  130. (1990). The Definition of Standards and their Assessment,
  131. (1999). The Embedding of Apprenticeship
  132. (1999). The Embedding of Apprenticeship in Industrial Relations: British Engineering, 1925-65 in Apprenticeship: - Towards a New Paradigm of Learning.
  133. (1989). The Employment Department/Training Agency Standards Programme and NVQ's: implications for education,
  134. (1989). The Employment Departmentfrraining Agency Standards Programme and NVQ's: implications for education,
  135. (1998). The Fifth Moment,
  136. (1998). The Landscape of Qualitative Research,
  137. (1999). The Nomad's Apprentice: Different Kinds of `Apprenticeship' among Kyrgyz Nomads in Central Asia,
  138. (1998). The Practice of Social Research (8`h ed),
  139. (1992). The Psychology of Apprenticeship, in Skill and Education: Reflection and Experience,
  140. (1994). The Qualitative Researcher's Companion,
  141. (2000). The Question of Competence: the origins, strengths, and inadequacies of a leadership training paradigm,
  142. (2001). The Relative Contributions of Institutional and Workplace Learning Environments: an analysis of apprenticeship training,
  143. (1997). The Role of Apprenticeship in Enhancing Employability and Job Creation: Final Report. Rotterdam: Netherlands Economic Institute for the European Commission, DG XXII.
  144. (1999). The Skill Development Process of Apprenticeship,
  145. (2000). The Standards Based System of Apprentice Education and Training: Its potential and Limitations for the Construction Industry. Unpublished Thesis,
  146. (2000). The Standards Based System ofApprentice Education and Training: Its Potential and Limitations for the Construction Industry. Unpublished Thesis,
  147. (2001). Third Annual Report,
  148. (1984). Towards a Competence-Based System.
  149. (2002). Understanding and Validity in Qualitative Research,
  150. (2000). Understanding the Irish VET System: beyond neoclassicism,
  151. (1995). Using Semi-Structured Interviews in Small-Scale Research,
  152. (1997). Vocational ? raining in the Dual System in Germany. Bonn, The Federal Ministry of Education,
  153. (1999). What is Evidence-Based Education? in
  154. (2000). What is Wrong with Competence?
  155. (2000). What is Wrong with Competence? in
  156. (1986). White Paper on Manpower Policy.
  157. (1999). Work Experience as an Education and Training Strategy to Combat Social Exclusion: Two Case Studies
  158. (2002). Work-based Learning, Action Learning and the Virtual Paradigm,
  159. (1999). Working to Learn: An Holistic Approach to Young People's Education and Training,
  160. (1999). Workplace Learning: learning culture and performance improvement, Report for the Institute of Personnel and Development,
  161. (2001). Young People's Perspectim on Education, Training and Employment,
  162. (2001). Young People's Perspectives on Education, Training and Employment,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.