Location of Repository

Central London under Reconstruction Policy and Planning, 1940-1959

By Emmanuel V. Marmaras

Abstract

The thesis deals with the formation of the post-Second World War reconstruction and planning machinery in Great Britain on the one hand, and on the other, with the replanning efforts undertaken in London and especially the redevelopment programme regarding its central area in the form of the comprehensive development projects.\ud The central hypothesis is that, although the planning thought, legislation and technique realised significant evolutionary steps by introducing important innovatory instruments and bold planning concepts, the rebuilding of Central London was not a success to a comparable extent. This divergence between concept, plan and outcome was mainly due to the difficulties faced during the implementation stage as a result of financial problems and, in addition, to the way that the application of aspects of Modern Architecture in some of the new buildings were carried out.\ud The work is structured in three parts. The first one, under the title "Reconstruction and Planning Machinery", explores the administrative and statutory developments in town planning matters during the period 1940-1959. The conclusion of this analysis is that, because of the sweeping character of the new planning system which was introduced, a contradiction had emerged due to the pluralistic character of the British socio-economic system. The second part has the title “Replanning London” and deals with the plans proposed for London as a whole during the 1940s. The main finding was that the six plans which were proposed could be considered as sections of one planning endeavour. These plans have a unified and continuous character, although each one had been prepared by a different team of planners. Finally, the third part, under the title “Redeveloping Central London”, examines the proposals for the rebuilding of the City of London and for specific areas of Central London located on both sides of the Thames. The main conclusion of this analysis is that, although these projects introduced innovations concerning the control of urban dencities, and the hygiene of residence and office accommodation in the city centre, they failed to achieve one of their main\ud targets. This was the unification of both parts of Central London located at the north and south banks of the Thames

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 1992
OAI identifier: oai:lra.le.ac.uk:2381/7984

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1948). (a) ibid., (b) Anonymous, "LCC scheme for he Thames South Bank". The Architects'
  2. (a) ibid., p. 732, (b)
  3. (1945). 0., Labour in Power,
  4. (1952). 137-8, taken from:
  5. 1943b: "Notes & Topics: Propaganda gone mad". The Architects'
  6. 1956b: "South Bank Vertical Failure". The Architects'
  7. 44. of Offices from LonReview,
  8. (1942). 50-Editorial, "Uthwatt Report", The Architects'
  9. (1981). A Broken Wave: The rebuilding of England,
  10. A Broken Wave..., op. cit., p. 95. 40-London Regional Reconstruction Committee (LRRC), Greater London: Towards a Master Plan.
  11. (1942). A Master Plan for London". Architectural Review,
  12. (1966). A Study of Post-war Office Developments",
  13. A study... ", op. cit.,
  14. (1982). About the biography of Lord John Reith, see in: Addison, Paul, The Road to 1945. London: Quartet Books,
  15. (1942). After the War, 4'', The Architects'
  16. (1952). Airstop on the South Bank, signed by Evelyn Sharp,
  17. (1905). Also see: Royal Commission on London Traffic,
  18. Also, it is to be noticed that the reconsidered. See: ibid.,
  19. (1951). An Airstop on the South Bank: Memorandum by the Minister of Civil Aviation,
  20. (1959). An Outline of the Town and Country Planning Act,
  21. (1945). Art Commission, "Societies & Institutions: City Plan-. The Architects'
  22. (1987). As it comes out from a discussion with Sir Hugh Casson on 5th
  23. (1942). Asian's Plan Described'. The Architects'
  24. (1955). Barbican Stakes". The Architects'
  25. (1900). Bournville Village Trust, Deed of Foundation.
  26. (1988). Britain's first town planning act: A review of the 1909 achievement".
  27. (1945). British Society since
  28. (1914). British Society,
  29. (1968). Building in the British Economy between the Wars.
  30. (1948). Cabinet: Investment Programmes Committee,
  31. (1955). Car Parking in Central Areas'',
  32. (1959). Car Parking: The problem and some solutions",
  33. (1962). Central Area Redevelopment: A Local Authority responsibility",
  34. (1942). Chairman of the Standing Conference on London Regional Planning had been appointed
  35. (1988). Cities and Flans: The shaping of Urban Britain in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries.
  36. (1988). Cities and Plans: The shaping of urban Britain in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries.
  37. (1938). City Engineer of Leeds and President of the Town Planning Institute".
  38. (1943). City plan'' . The Architects'
  39. (1958). Civic Design and the Shopping Centre",
  40. (1942). Civic Design, manual by Thomas Sharp,
  41. (1984). Commercial towmscapes in the making".
  42. (1940). Commission on the Distribution of the Industrial Population,
  43. (1942). Committee on Land Utilisation in Rural Areas,
  44. Committee, "Official Report".
  45. (1942). Committee, "Official Report". The Architects'
  46. (1944). Committee, Preliminary Draft Proposals for Post-War Reconstruction in the City of London.
  47. (1942). Committees concerned with Reconstruction Problems,
  48. (1948). Control and the Developer,
  49. (1940). Council, Ground Plan of Britain.
  50. (1943). Country and Town: A summary of the Scott and Uthwatt Reports. Harmondsworth:
  51. (1947). Country Planning Act,
  52. County of London ... "
  53. (1951). County of London Development Plan". The Architects'
  54. (1943). County of London Flan.
  55. (1943). County of London Plan.
  56. County of London...
  57. County of London... ",
  58. (1942). Critique". The Architects"
  59. (1955). Daylight Control in Built-up Areas".
  60. (1949). Design in City Centres",
  61. (1960). Dispersal don'', The Town Planning
  62. Dispersal of Offices from London". The Town Planning Review,
  63. (1942). Doubts on the MARS Plan for London".
  64. (1947). Draft notes for Minister's speech to Local Authorities on Reconstruction under the 1944 Act; Planning Technique, signed by
  65. (1955). Editorial Notes". The Town Planning Review,
  66. Elans for the 1951 Festival". The Archi. "s - carnal,
  67. (1956). English Tradition or Beaux Arts for St. Paul's''. The Architects'
  68. (1939). Environmental Flanning, 1939-1969: Reconstruction and Land Use,
  69. (1939). Environmental Planning, 1939-1_f9: Reconstruction and Land Use Planning,
  70. (1939). Environmental Planning, 1939-1969: Reconstruction and Land Use Planning,
  71. (1980). Environmental Planning: Land Values,
  72. (1939). Environmental Planning: Reconstruction and Land Use Planning,
  73. especially for the case of StepneyPoplar, see: Stephenson, Gordon, "Town Planning: Contemporary problems of civic design",
  74. (1942). Exhibition". The Architects'
  75. (1948). Existing Use Values", The Architects'
  76. (1944). F'rofes, sor Abercrombie's Outline Plan for Greater London,
  77. Floor Space Control and the Developer", op. cit.,
  78. (1977). For a recent discussion of the development of hou-364-sing legislation see: Wohl, Anthony S., The Eternal Slum: Housing and social policy in Victorian London.
  79. (1938). For the planning system under the 1932 Act, see: Heap, Desmond, Planning Low for Town and Country. London: Sweet and Maxwell,
  80. FRO file CAB 117/20. The Committee had been constituted as follows: -The Minister without Portfolio (Chairman). -The Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs. -The Chancellor of the Exchequer.
  81. From town-country to town planning: changing priorities in the British garden city movement, 1899-1914". Planning Perspectives,
  82. From Uthwatt to DLT - The end of the road? " Barlow: Scott: Uthwatt..., op. cit.,
  83. (1974). From Working Class Tenement to Modern Flat: local authorities and multi-storey housing between the wars". Sutcliffe,
  84. (1951). Future of the South Bank site: Proposed joint announcement by the Government and the London County Council,
  85. (1944). Greater London Plan
  86. (1945). Greater London Plan: A synopsis of the planning proposals".
  87. (1942). Hall's statement included the following: Times,
  88. (1956). High density housing for the Barbican area of the City of London".
  89. (1941). Hiorns was for many years a senior member of the architectural staff of the LCC and also a member of Lord Reith's Consultative Panel, Ministry of Works and Buildings. See in: Anonymous, " Mr. Hiorns retires".
  90. Histc: rical Note, signed by
  91. Historical Note, signed by G.
  92. Historical Note, signed by George L. Pepler".
  93. Historical Note",
  94. (1986). Hofford: A study in architecture. planning and civic design.
  95. (1986). Holford: A study in architecture, planning and civic design.
  96. Holford's scheme for St. Paul's".
  97. (1956). Holford's scheme for St. Paul's". The Architects'
  98. (1941). House of Lords,
  99. (1950). Housing and Planning Policies of the Principal Political Parties",
  100. Ibid. (b) "Professor Abercrombie s Chit_ine Plan... ",
  101. Inaugural Address to the RIBA'.
  102. (1960). Institute, "Central Area Development [memorandum]",
  103. (1985). Inter-war planning in Britain: The wider context".
  104. (1949). Into the Wind.
  105. Into the..., op. cit.,
  106. it emerges from: Gillies, B., "Central Commercial Zones, 29.12.1949", PRO file HLG 71/218, that ''a central commercial zone will only be defined where it is useful".
  107. It is to be noted here that, at the same time, the 1441 planning authorities of the country were reduced to 145.
  108. (1931). It was stated, with particular regard to this component, that: "Some indication of the existing state of open space 4,397,003 persons
  109. (1985). L ondon: George Allen & Unwin Ltd.,
  110. LCC scheme for the Thames...
  111. (1943). Lecture on the County of London Plan". The Architects"
  112. (1942). Lette: of Lord Portal to E.
  113. (1951). Letter of Lord Ogmor to Harold Macmillan,
  114. (1951). Letter of Max Nicholson to Evelyn Sharp,
  115. (1952). Letter sent by David Eccles to P.
  116. Letters: City of London Sketch Plan".
  117. (1942). Letters: The MARS Plan". The Architects'
  118. Local Government and Planning,
  119. (1943). Local Government and Planning, Town and Country Planning,
  120. Local Government and Planning, Town and..., op. cit.,
  121. (1942). Londcn and the Home Counties, Minute Sheet, reference :: 4542 sent by G. Pepler to Sir Geoffrey Whiskard c--.
  122. London and the Home Counties,..., sent by Pepler to Whiskard ... ",
  123. London and the Home Counties,..., sent by Pepler to Whiskard... ",
  124. (1953). London County Council: Extract from the Report of the General Purposes Committee to be submitted to -411-the Council at its meeting on
  125. (1951). London Plan: a critical report".
  126. London, c; t.,
  127. (1945). London, the Regional Plan: An analysis of Sir Patrick Abercrombie's scheme".
  128. London, the Regional Plan...
  129. London; Our Great Planning Failure", undated and unsigned.
  130. London; Our Great Planning Failure".
  131. (1950). London: Paper by the Minister of Town and Country Planning,
  132. (1950). London's Traffic Problem". The Architects'
  133. (1942). Lord Justice Scott". The Architects'
  134. (1982). Lord Leverhulme "s Unknown Venture:
  135. (1978). Lord of Windrush, Enterprise versus Bureaucracy.
  136. Machinery and Personnel, extracts from letters sent by P. Abercrombie to
  137. MARS Plan for London". The Architects'
  138. (1951). Megalopolitan Development Plan'. The Architects'
  139. Memorandum prepared for Minister (Silkin), Programme of Work".
  140. (1954). Message to The Architects'
  141. (1947). Ministry of Town and Country Planning, The Redevelopment of Central Areas.
  142. (1943). Ministry of Town and Country Planning: Summary of Address to Press Representetives by the
  143. (1941). Ministry of Works and Buildings, Expert
  144. Minutes of proceedings of Lord Reith's
  145. (1951). Modern Architecture makes good".
  146. (1969). Motorways in London.
  147. (1950). Movement from London",
  148. (1955). Moving Industry from London''. The Town Planning Review,
  149. Mr. Aslan"s Plan Described",
  150. (1942). Mr. Justice Uthwatt", The Architects'
  151. (1948). Multiple use on the South Bank''.
  152. (1954). New Barbican", The Architects'
  153. New Barbican". Op. ci t.,
  154. (1947). New City". The Architects'
  155. (1954). News: New Barbican, Decision this Week? ".
  156. (1954). News: New Barbican, Scheme Rejected, but Barbican Committee will fight".
  157. (1955). News: St. Paul's Architect for Precinct''. The Architects'
  158. (1942). Note of an informal meeting with representatives of the six Home Counties at Lambeth Bridge House,
  159. (1942). Note of an informal meeting,...,
  160. (1942). Notes & Topics: ... and Lord Scott's views"
  161. Notes & Topics: Academy Plan".
  162. (1942). Notes & Topics: Academy Plan". The Architects'
  163. Notes & Topics: Black magic".
  164. (1944). Notes & Topics: City of London Plan".
  165. (1946). Notes & Topics: City Plan". The Architects'
  166. (1948). Notes & Topics: Development Charges", The Architects'
  167. (1941). Notes & Topics: New Architect to the LCC".
  168. (1941). Notes & Topics: New Architect to the LCC". The Architects"
  169. (1951). Notes & Topics: New hope for the South Bank". The Architects'
  170. Notes & Topics: St. Paul's Precinct".
  171. Notes & Topics: St. Paul's Precinct". The Architects'
  172. (1938). Notes & Topics: Underground car parks", The Architects'
  173. (1956). Notes: Personal-Birthday Honours",
  174. (1955). Notes: Personal".
  175. (1943). ounty of London Plan". The Architects'
  176. (1941). overture to Planning.
  177. (1934). Particulars of Slum Clearance Programmes furnished by Local Authorities, Cmd.
  178. (1950). Parties and Planning", The Architects'
  179. (1943). Pepler to S.
  180. Plan for London".
  181. (1942). Plan for London". The Architects'
  182. (1948). Planning and Construction.
  183. (1949). Planning for Daylight: A new method of developing building sites", reprinted from The Builder,
  184. (1949). Planning for Daylight: A new method of developing building sites". The Builder,
  185. Planning will end private property The Architects'
  186. (1943). Planning will end private property'',
  187. Plans A&B contrasted", op. cit.,
  188. (1942). Plans A&B contrasted".
  189. (1953). Presidential Address: Sir William Holford, FRIBA, FILA".
  190. (1944). PRO file CAB 87/35. The situation of Greater London Planning in
  191. Professor Abercrombie's Outline Plan... ", op. cit.,
  192. (1953). Proposed scheme for the South Bank redevelopment".
  193. Rebuilding Cities,
  194. Rebuilding Cities, op, cit.,
  195. Rebuilding Cities, op. cit.,
  196. (1966). Rebuilding Cities.
  197. (1960). Rebuilding City Centres: Report of a Conference",
  198. (1947). Reconstruction in the City of London".
  199. (1943). Regional Plan for London".
  200. (1980). Remaking Cities: Contradictions of the recent urban environment.
  201. (1959). Reviews of Books: The Town and Country Planning Act,
  202. (1942). Secretary of MARS".
  203. (1951). See photographs of the buildings in: Anonymous, "Festival of Britain: South Bank Exhibition nears completion".
  204. (1960). See the following articles: (a)
  205. (1945). sent by K.
  206. (1980). Shaping an Urban World: Flanning in the Twentieth Century.
  207. (1942). Sir Geoffrey Whiskard".
  208. (1959). Sir George Pepler".
  209. (1937). Sir, Problems of Town and Country Planning.
  210. Societies & Institutions: The
  211. (1963). Some Aspects of Central Area Redevelopment: A case study of Hanley, Staffordshire",
  212. (1943). Some Notes on the Post-War Problem of the War Damage Commission,
  213. (1942). Some of the comments of the Observer and The Sunday Times were republished in The Architects'
  214. (1951). South Bank Site - Interim eve: -pr: ent:
  215. (1956). South Bank's Vertical Failure". The Architects'
  216. (1943). Speech at a press conference on the County of London Plan".
  217. (1956). St. Paul's: Report on the surroundings of St. Paul's Cathedral in the City of London". The Town Planning Review,
  218. (1945). Standards of Redevelopment in Central Areas, signed by William Holford
  219. (1942). Statement of Policy on the Uthwatt Report,
  220. (1951). Strong and Free: A statement of Conservative and Unionist Policy,
  221. (1943). TCPA versus LCC".
  222. (1954). Technical Section: Legislation", The Architects"
  223. (1940). The
  224. (1967). The - _nce of Wales, ''My Vision of Britain" . The Sun c'=: Times Magazine, September 3,1989, p. "C. 38 . Marr _ Oliver, The Property Boom. Lond _, r; : Ha In i_; tý
  225. (1943). The ::; lowing observations were taken from:
  226. (1949). The Annual Report of the Central Board", The Architects'
  227. (1948). The Application of Floor Space Indices,
  228. (1948). The Architect and the Planning Act", The Architects'
  229. (1942). The Architects'
  230. (1973). The Barbican Development, City London". The Architectural Review,
  231. The Barbican Development...
  232. The Barbican Development... ".
  233. (1950). The Central Land Board's Report",
  234. (1949). The Chartered Auctioneers' and Estate Agents'
  235. (1951). The City of London: A record of destruction and survival.
  236. (1951). The City of London: A record of destruction and survival. London: The -400-Architectural Press,
  237. The City of London: A record..., op. cit.,
  238. (1946). The City of London: Basic proposals for reconstruction and repla-arining submittn-d tc, the- (::
  239. The City of London: Basic...
  240. (1945). The City Plan". The Architects'
  241. (1944). The City Plan". The Architects"
  242. (1972). The Conservative Party from Feel to Churchill.
  243. (1972). The Conservative Party from Peel to Churchill.
  244. (1944). The control of land use, Memorandum by the Minister of Reconstruction,
  245. The data were adapted from ibid.,
  246. The Decentralisation of Industry from Central London, paper written by
  247. (1989). The destruction of a wonder of the world"
  248. (1974). The Evolution of British Town Flanning: A history of town planning in United Kingdom during the 20th century and of the Royal Town Flanning Institute, 1914-74. Leighton Buzzard:
  249. (1974). The Evolution of British Town Plann: n_ :A history of town plgnning
  250. (1974). The Evolution of British Town Planning: A history of town planning in the United Kingdom during the 20th century and of the Royal Town Planning Institute,
  251. (1974). The Evolution of British Town Planning: A history of town planning in the United Kingdom during the 20th century and of the Royal Town Planning Institute, 1914-1974. Leighton Buzzard:
  252. (1974). The Evolution of British Town Planning: A history of town planning in the United Kingdom during the 20th century and of the Royal Town Planning Institute, 1914-74. Leighton Buzzard:
  253. The Evolution..., op. cit.,
  254. The Famous Scott Report -A text for all time? " Barlow: Scott: Uthwatt..., op. cit.,
  255. (1949). The Federation of
  256. (1959). the Financial Secretary to the Treasury told the House of Commons that 27,000 civil servants were working outside London. See in:
  257. (1965). The Genesis of Modern British Town Flanning': A study in economic and social his-366-Cory of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul Ltd.,
  258. (1972). The Genesis of Modern British Town Planning: A study in economic and social history of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul Ltd.,
  259. (1965). The Genesis of Modern British Town Planning: A study in economic and social history of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. London: Routledge & Regan Paul Ltd,
  260. The Genesis..., op. cit.,
  261. (1930). The Genesis..., op. cit., p. 115; (b) Royal Commission in Transport, Final Report.
  262. (1943). The LCC Plan". The Architects'
  263. (1949). The LCC's Draft Development Plan". The Architects'
  264. (1956). The Lijnbaan at Rotterdam", The Town Planning Review,
  265. The list of the recommended total use zones for
  266. The London and Home Counties Traffic Advisory Committee, London Traffic Congestion.
  267. The London Boroughs and the London Plan".
  268. (1944). The Machinery of Town and Country Planning. Oxford: Catholic Social Guild,
  269. (1955). The Minister Approves the County of London Development Plan".
  270. (1943). The Minister of Local Government and Planning, Town and Country Planning,
  271. The Minister of Local Government and Planning, Town and Country Planning..., op, cit.,
  272. The Minister... ", op. cit.,
  273. The Ministry of Town and Country Planning,
  274. (1947). The Ministry of Town and Country Planning, The Redevelopment of Central Areas.
  275. The Ministry of Town and Country Planning, The Redevelopment..., op. cit.,
  276. The most heavily blitzed areas of the City were estimated in 231 acres, according to the following evident: "City of London Reconstruction F'rt:,, jects".
  277. (1954). The New Town and Country Planning Act -
  278. The New... ", op. cit.,
  279. (1985). The People - Where will they go? '' Barlow: Scott: Uthwatt., Three
  280. The People - Where will they go? "
  281. (1954). The Permanent Development of the South Bank".
  282. The Permanent Development...
  283. The Planning of London,
  284. (1943). The Planning of London, letter sent by S.
  285. (1943). The Planning of London, paper sent by S.
  286. (1948). The Planning Team", The Architects'
  287. (1982). The Politics of Town Planning.
  288. (1956). The Precincts of St. Paul's: A review of Sir William Holford's proposals".
  289. The Precincts of St. Paul's: A review...
  290. (1989). The Prince of Wales, "Frankenstein Britain". The Sunday Times,
  291. The Property..., op. cit.,
  292. (1956). The Proposed Precinct of St. Paul's in the City of London: A note on some of the underlying ideas''.
  293. (1952). The quoted text is taken from:
  294. (1956). The Redevelopment of Central Areas",
  295. The Redevelopment...
  296. The Redevelopment... ", op. cit.,
  297. (1953). The Redevelopment... ", op. cit., p. 14. 21-Anonymous, "Presidential Address: Professor Sir William Holford, FRIBA FILA",
  298. (1947). The Road ..., op. cit.,
  299. (1982). The Road to 1945. London: Quartet Books Ltd.,
  300. (1982). The Road to 1954. London: Quartet Books,
  301. (1956). The Road Traffic Problem in Britain'' . The Town Planning Review,
  302. The Road Traffic...
  303. The Road..., op. cit.,
  304. (1942). The Scott Report". The Architects'
  305. (1952). the South Bank: Memorandum by the Minister of Housing and Local Government,
  306. (1942). The Technical Committee had the following composition: Harry Stewart (Ministry of Works
  307. (1958). The Town and Country Planning Bill
  308. The Town Centre: tevenagN , The Town Planning Review,
  309. (1955). The Town Centre",
  310. The Town Centre", op. cit.,
  311. The used information has been adapted from ibid.,
  312. The Uthwatt Report", op. cit.,
  313. (1942). The Uthwatt Report", The Architects'
  314. (1961). The, Design of Sty )pi i:, g Centres',
  315. These aspects belong to Ralph Miliband and
  316. (1961). This sentence has been quoted from the sub-title of the following book: The Institute of Bankers, The City of London, as a Centre of International Trade and Finance. Kent: Stapples Printers Ltd.,
  317. (1943). This view was that of Henry Strauss stated on 6
  318. (1955). Three proposals for the Barbican site, City of London''. The Architects"
  319. Three proposals for the Barbican... "
  320. (1981). Towards the Planned City: Germany, Britain, the United States and France,
  321. (1947). Town and Country Planning Act,
  322. (1944). Town and Country Planning Bill -Memorandum by the Minister of Economic Warfare,
  323. (1944). Town and Country Planning Bill, Clauses 45 and 46 - Memorandum by the Minister of Town and Country Planning,
  324. (1944). Town and Country Planning Bill, Memorandum by the Minister of Economic Warfare,
  325. (1944). Town and Country Planning: The control of land use - Memorandum by the Minister of Reconstruction,
  326. (1943). Town and Country Planning. London:
  327. (1943). Town and Country Planning. London: Oxford University Press (first published in 1933). -1945a: Greater London Plan 1944. London: HMSO. -1945b: The Plan for Kingston-upon-Hull.
  328. (1951). Town Planning and Road Traffic.
  329. (1942). Town Planning and Road Traffie.
  330. Town Planning Committee, Preliminary Draft Proposals...,
  331. (1941). Trust, When We Build Again.
  332. (1972). Twentieth-Century Coventry.
  333. (1944). Uthwatt Report", The Architects'
  334. (1945). Wartime Bill of Fare'',
  335. (1948). What has happened to the London -398-Plans? ".
  336. (1951). Working Party on the Winding up of the South Bank Exhi5ition: Interim Report to the Lord Privy Seal,
  337. (1951). Working Party on the Winding-up of the South Bank Exhibition: Report to the Minister of Works,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.