Location of Repository

'As you see it so it was'? Reconstructing historic built environments in the USA: the case of sites associated with George Washington

By Esther White

Abstract

This study explores the nature, function and creation of in situ, three dimensional, full-scale reconstructions from both a professional archaeological and administrative vantage point. In situ, three-dimensional reconstructions are used at heritage sites throughout the world to interpret historical archaeological remains for visitors. This type of reconstruction is the most permanent and complete of the physical treatments used to interpret buildings that are no longer standing, presenting both great risk to the archaeological resource and the historical authenticity of the place, as well as the potential for enormous reward for both interpretation and education. This thesis analyzes criteria with potential to measure the success or failure of reconstructions and provide a broader understanding of how these buildings act as replacements for their vanished originals.\ud Due to the large universe of reconstructions, data from 11 archaeologically-based reconstructions, at five sites associated with George Washington were identified to guide the discussion. The critical histories of these sites provide a textured understanding of reconstructions, and the role they play in shaping and creating a visible constructed past at tourist sites.\ud The 11 Washington case studies are analyzed within a framework of statements from international restoration policies and national stricture guiding and shaping how reconstructions are created and how standing structures are assessed within the United States. This analysis looks at the entire history of the reconstruction, from its creation, to the present function and utilization of the building, relying upon a full understanding of the entire cultural history of the building and historic site to assess the reconstruction. Through this nuanced and detailed exploration, criteria are addressed and 14 emerge that appear to provide both a gauge for assessing completed reconstructions and a valid foundation to guide the decision-making process when heritage site administrators and managers discuss reconstruction as a means of interpretation

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 2008
OAI identifier: oai:lra.le.ac.uk:2381/4812

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1988a) The Recovery ofMeaning.
  2. (2002). (2001b) Hadrian's Wall WorldHeritage Site Management Plan,
  3. (2006). 1 Am Now Very Comfortably Situated for the Winter Having a Very Nice chimney Attached to My Tent, and Everything That Tends to Make This Unhappy Life Pleasant and Agreeable. "
  4. 1) Archaeology: Science or Fantasy? Lo Scrittoio,
  5. 1) Counterpoint: Reconstruction Can Work! Archaeology Southwest 15(2). Available from http: //www. cdarc. org [accessed
  6. 1) George Washington's Mount Vernon: Or Mount Vernon and Its Associations, Historical, - Biographical, and Pictorial. New York: Gramercy Press. Originally published 1859.
  7. 1) Point: Reconstruction Doesn't Work! Archaeology Southwest, 15(2). Available from ht! R: //www. cdarc. oriz [accessed December 11,2001].
  8. 1) Preservation Comes ofAge: From Williamsburg to the National Trust,
  9. (1990). A Background Report for the Enhancement of the Greenhouse Quarters. Ms. on file, Mount Vernon Ladies'Association,
  10. (1918). A History of the Life and Death, virtues and Exploits of General George Washington.
  11. (1974). A History ofAmerican Archaeology. London: Thames and Hudson.
  12. (2002). A History ofArchitectural Conservation.
  13. (1936). A National Policy for Historic Sites and Monuments. Position paper presented to the Advisory Board on National Parks,
  14. (1994). A Perspective on the Reconstruction Quandary. In Weeks, K. Are We Losing Authenticity to Recover Appearances?
  15. (1932). A Report of the Findings of
  16. (1994). Abraham Lincoln as Authentic Reproduction: A Critique of Postmodernism.
  17. (1984). Administrative History of Valley Forge National Historical Park
  18. (2006). Administrative History,
  19. (2001). An Archaeological Assessment of George Washington's Birthplace National Monument. On file, Colonial Williamsburg Foundation, Department of Archaeological Research.
  20. (1995). An Assessment of the Condition of George Washington's Gristmill and a Proposal for its Restoration. Report submitted to the Virginia Division of Conservation and Recreation. On file, Mount Vernon Ladies' Association,
  21. (2006). Annual Report.
  22. (1975). Anthropological Perspectives in Historical Archaeology. Unpublished Ph.
  23. (2004). Archaeological Authenticity and Reconstruction at Colonial Williamsburg
  24. (1990). Archaeological Curatorship, Leicester:
  25. (1994). Archaeological Investigations at the Mount Vernon Dung Repository (44Fx762/15): An Interim Report. Mount Vernon Archaeology Department File Report No. 5, Mount Vernon Ladies' Association,
  26. (1999). Archaeological Reconstruction and Education at the Jorvik Viking Centre and Archaeological Resource
  27. (1999). Archaeological Reconstructions and the Community in the UK.
  28. (1997). Archaeology and Interpretation at Monticello and Poplar Forest.
  29. (2006). Archaeology and the Construction of America's Jamestown.
  30. (1955). Archaeology as an Auxiliary Science to American History.
  31. (1988). Archaeology at George Washington's Mount Vernon: 1931-1987. Mount Vernon Archaeology Department,
  32. (1994). Are We Losing Authenticity to Recover Appearances?
  33. Assembly (185 8) An Act to Amend an Act Entitled An Act to Incorporate the Mount Vernon Ladies' Association of the Union, and to Authorize the Purchase of a Part of Mount Vernon,
  34. (1996). Authenticity in Canadian Conservation Practice. National Position Paper,
  35. (1983). Authenticity. File report 1165-1 (Fortress of Louisbourg, Louisbourg). Available from http: //fortress. uccb. ns. ca [accessed
  36. (2001). Available from hqp: //www. lib. virginia. edu/clemons/RMC/exhib/fiske/Conference/Chappell Wenger. html [accessed:
  37. (1935). Available from ht! p: //www.
  38. (2001). Available from http: //fortress. uccb. ns. ca/search/Proc95_5htm [accessed
  39. (2006). Available from http: //www. cr. nps. gov/logcabin/ [accessed
  40. (2002). Available from http: //www. icomos. ora/athens charter. html [accessed
  41. Available from http: //www. nps. gov/vafo [accessed February 25,2003].
  42. (2001). Available from httv: //www.
  43. (2008). Available from: hlW: //www.
  44. (1990). Beaux-Arts Ideals and Colonial Reality: The Reconstruction of Williamsburg's Capitol,
  45. (2004). Beyond the Artisfs Impression: From Photo-Realism to Integrated Reconstruction in buildings Archaeology,
  46. Birthplace (n. d. b) Home Page http: //www. nps. jzov/izewa/ [accessed February 25,2003]. George Washington's Gristmill Historic State Park (n. d. ) Brochure. On file, Mount Vernon Ladies'Association,
  47. (1988). Carter's Grove Slave Quarters Study. Memorandum to Cary Carson. On file, Mount Vernon Ladies'Association,
  48. (2004). Castell Henllys Iron Age Fort.
  49. (1953). Catalogue of the Centennial Exhibition commemorating the Founding of the Mount Vernon Ladies'
  50. (1999). Charter for the Conservation of Places of Cultural Significance, (the Burra Charter). Available from htt-p: //www.
  51. (1990). Charter for the Protection and Management of the Archaeological Heritage (Lausanne Charter). Available from h": //www. icomos. oriz/archaeoloeical charter. htmll [accessed
  52. (2005). Commerce (US) and the President's Committee on the Arts and Humanities
  53. (1996). Committees of the Americas
  54. (2006). Conclusions and Beginnings.
  55. (1992). Considering Reconstruction as an Education Tool.
  56. (2003). Constructing Quality Interpretation: The Use ofInterpretative Simulations Reconsidered. Arkell European Fellowship Report, British National Trust. Available from http: //www.
  57. (2000). Consultation on Guidelines for Reconstruction on Archaeological Sites, Draft Guidelines. Available from hilp: //www.
  58. (2004). Cultural Landscape Report for Booker T.
  59. (2004). Designing the Past at Fortress Louisbourg.
  60. (1998). Destination Culture, Tourism, Museums and Heritage.
  61. (1999). Domesticating History: The Political Origins ofAmerica's House Museums.
  62. (1996). Drawing Inferences; Visual Reconstructions in Theory and Practice,
  63. (2007). Ename Charter for the Interpretation of Cultural Heritage Sites, proposed final draft.
  64. (1992). Evoking the Past or Provoking the Gods?: Some Observations on Period Reconstructions.
  65. (2006). Excavated Foundations and Total Reconstruction
  66. (2000). Exit Interview with
  67. (1983). Expansion of the National Park Service in the 1930s: Administrative History.
  68. Experiment andDesign: Archaeological Studies in Honour ofJohn Coles. Oxford: Oxbow. Available from hqp:
  69. (2003). Exploring the Boundary: Archeological Authenticity vs. Pragmatic Accuracy at Mount Vernon. Forum Journal, National Trust for Historic Preservation,
  70. (2000). Fables of the Reconstruction: Morley Jeffers Williams and the Excavation of Tryon Palace,
  71. (1995). Fiske Kimball and Colonial Williamsburg. In Colonial Williamsburg Research Review,
  72. (1995). Fiske Kimball, the Robert E. Lee Memorial Foundation, and the "Museurnification" of Stratford Hall. Paper presented at Fiske Kimball: Creator ofan American Architecture, symposium held at the School of Architecture,
  73. (2004). Foreward.
  74. (1993). Fort George. In Canadian Parks Service Proceedings of the Canadian Parks Service Reconstruction Workshop. Ottawa: National Historic Sites,
  75. (1932). Fort Necessity c.
  76. (1954). Fort Necessity National Battlefield Site
  77. Foundation (n. d. ) Homepage Available from httn: //www. histoKy. org [accessed October 23,2007]. Council for British Archaeology (n. d. ) Sites with Reconstructed Buildings.
  78. (2008). Foundation (n. d. ) Homepage. Available from htip: //www. monroefoundation. org [accessed
  79. (1997). Founding Father: Rediscovering George Washington.
  80. (1999). From the Ground Up: The Reconstruction of Japanese Historic Buildings from Excavated Archaeological Data.
  81. (1988). George Washington Slept Here: Colonial Revivals and American Culture 1876-1986.
  82. (1992). George Washington: Pioneer Farmer inAnnual Report
  83. (2005). George Washington's Birthplace and the Curious Case of 'Building X, 'Northem
  84. (2005). George Washington's Gristmill.
  85. Government Printing Office.
  86. (2003). Hadrian's Wall World 'Heritage Site, English Heritage: A Case Study. Los Angeles: The Getty Conservation Institute. Available from www. getty. edii/conservation/publications/pdf publications/hadrians-wall. p df [accessed
  87. (1989). Heritage Trust
  88. (2008). Historic Londontown (n. d. ) Homepage. Available from http: //www. historiclondontown. com [accessed
  89. (1996). Historic Preservation Treatments: Toward a Common Language. CRMBulletin,
  90. (1990). Historic Preservation: Curatorial Management of the Built World, 2nd edition.
  91. (2008). Historic Sites (n. d. ) Homepage. Available from hgp: //www. nchistoricsites. oriz [accessed
  92. (1969). Historical Archaeology.
  93. (1989). Historical Archeology: The Fort Union Reconstruction
  94. (1987). Historical Authenticity and the Use of Evidence in Reconstructing and Maintaining the Fortress of Louisbourg (Draft).
  95. (2001). Historical Memory, Sectional Strife, and the American
  96. (2008). Historical Trust, Annapolis, MD. Port Tobacco (n. d. ) Port Tobacco Blogspot. Available from http: //porttobacco. blogspot. com [accessed
  97. (2008). Homepage. Available from hLtp: //www. nps. ijov/fova/index. htm [accessed
  98. (1969). Ice House and Blacksmith Shop: A Summation. Ms. on file, Mount Vernon Ladies'Association,
  99. (2006). Illinois Historic Preservation Agency
  100. (1999). Imag(in)ing the Past; the Politics and Practicalities of Reconstructions in the Museum Gallery.
  101. (1993). in association with Arts and Entertainment Network Diggingfor Slaves: The Excavation of Slave Sites.
  102. (1999). International Cultural Tourism Charter: Managing Tourism at Places of Heritage Significance.
  103. (1994). Interpretive, Rather Than Structural, Solutions, in Weeks, K. Are We Losing Authenticity to Recover Appearances?
  104. (1988). Introduction, Issues in Historical Archaeology.
  105. (2004). Introduction: Archaeology and Reconstructions.
  106. (1999). Introduction: Contexts for Collaboration and Conflict.
  107. (1993). Introduction. In Canadian Parks Service,
  108. (1938). Jamestown and St. Mary's: Buried Cities of Romance. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins Press.
  109. jsp? no=9436&mode=l-ileI [accessed September 27,2007] State Commission on Conservation and Development (n. d. ) Application for a Loan From the Reconstruction Finance Corporation. On file, Mount Vernon Ladies'Association,
  110. (2006). Keeping Time: The History and Theory ofPreservation in America, Yd Edition.
  111. (2004). Lessons Learned at Bent's Old Fort and Fort Union Trading Post.
  112. (1941). Letter to
  113. (1990). Letter to Editor.
  114. (1952). Letter to Mary Scott. February 26. On file, Mount Vernon Ladies'Association,
  115. (1896). Letter to Miss Mary Pendleton, Vice-Regent for
  116. (1941). Letter to Mrs.
  117. (1915). Letter to Mrs. Comegys. February 23. On file, Mount Vernon Ladies'Association,
  118. (1998). Levels ofArchaeological Evidence IllustratedIn ThreeDimensional Computer Models.
  119. (1979). Martin's Hundred.
  120. (2000). Master Plan. On file,
  121. (1966). Memorandum to the Regent. March 10. On file, Mount Vernon Ladies'Association,
  122. (1935). Minutes of the Council.
  123. (1950). Minutes of the Council. Mount Vernon, VA: Mount Vemon Ladies'Association.
  124. (1937). Minutes ofthe Council.
  125. (2004). Modeling Amarna: -Computer Reconstructions of an Egyptian Palace.
  126. (2000). Mont Orgueil Castle, Jersey: A Review.
  127. (2002). Montpelier, An American Country House. Ms. on file,
  128. (2001). Mount Vernon Historic Structure s Report: Coach House. On file, Mount Vernon Ladies'Association,
  129. (1992). My Life is in Ruins: The Limitations of Stabilization as a Presentation Technique.
  130. (1991). Mystic Chords ofMemory: The Transformation of Tradition in American Culture.
  131. (1994). Nara Document on Authenticity. Available from htip: //www. intemational. icomos. ortz/naradoc eng. htm [accessed
  132. (2004). National Park Service Reconstruction Policy and Practice.
  133. (2003). New Light on Washington's Fort Necessity,
  134. (2007). October Monthly Letter. November 16. On file, Mount Vernon Ladies'Association,
  135. (1985). Of and Around Standing Structures: Archaeology and Restoration. The Ligature, NC Division of Archives and History.
  136. (1964). of Architects and Technicians of Historic Monuments
  137. (2000). on Authenticity and Historical Reconstruction in Relationship to Cultural Heritage
  138. (1995). Open Air-Museums: Enhancing Viability Without Compromising Integrity. Louisbourg: Louisbourg Heritage Society.
  139. (2005). Operational Guidelinesfor the Implementation of the World HeritageConvention. World Heritage Committee and World Heritage Centre. Available from hqp:
  140. (1994). Parks Canada Guiding Principles and Operational Policies.
  141. (1999). Pembrokeshire's Pasts. Natives, Invaders and Welsh Archaeology: The Castell Henllys Experience. In
  142. (1989). Pious Frauds: Federal Reconstruction Efforts During the 1930s. Paper presented at the Organization of American Historians annual meeting,
  143. (1979). Pope! y Creek Plantation: Birthplace of George Washington. Wakefield National Memorial Association.
  144. (1999). Preface and Introduction.
  145. (1965). Presence of the Past: A History of the Preservation Movement in the United States Before Willhamsburg.
  146. (2007). Presenting Archaeological Heritage to the Public: Ruins Versus Reconstructions.
  147. (1997). Presenting Archaeology to the Public: Diggingfor Truths.
  148. (1995). Preserving Historic New England: Preservation, Progressivism, and the Remaking otMemory,
  149. (1993). Preserving the OldDominion: Historic Preservation and Virginia Traditionalism,
  150. (1993). Proceedings of the Canadian Parks Service Reconstruction Workshop, Ottawa: National Historic Sites,
  151. (1997). Public Archaeology at Cahokia.
  152. (1992). Raising the Dead: Reconstruction Within the Canadian Parks Service.
  153. (1994). Reanalysis of Features and Artifacts Excavated at George Washington! s Birthplace,
  154. (2003). Reconstructing Fort Necessity. Available from httD: //www. nps. jzov/archive/fone/fortreconst. htm [accessed
  155. (2005). Reconstruction and its Interpreation in Russia - 2. Paper presented at the ICOMOS 150' General Assembly and Scientific Symposium,
  156. (1999). Reconstruction as Ideology: the Open Air Museum at Oerlinghausen,
  157. (2004). Reconstruction Dilemmas at George Washington's Blacksmith Shop.
  158. (1992). Reconstruction of Fort Union:
  159. (1999). Reconstruction Sites and Education in Japan: A Case Study from the Kansai Region. In
  160. (1999). Reconstruction Versus Preservation-inPlace
  161. (2004). Reconstruction, Interpretation, and Education at Fort Loudoun.
  162. (2006). Reconstruction: Changing Attitudes in Britain
  163. (1979). Reconstructions--Expensive, Life-Size Toys?
  164. (2004). Reflections on a Reconstruction of the Ancient Qasrin Synagogue and Village.
  165. (1991). Reflections on the Social and Economic Impact of the Fortress of Louisbourg.
  166. (1990). Remarks on the Slave Quarters Furnishing Panel at Recreating the World of the Virginia Plantation,
  167. (1949). Report of Physical Research Findings and Recommendadons for the Restoration of Greenhouse Built by George Washington at Mount Vernon. Ms. on file, Mount Vernon Ladies' Association,
  168. (2001). Reports on Field Trips to Slave Quarter Reconstructions at Regional Museums, Phase IB, Mulberry Row Project Research Plan.
  169. (1990). Response to David Jacques.
  170. (1955). Restoration -A Survey, Prepared at the Request of the Chairman of the Buildings Committee. Ms. on file, Mount Vernon Ladies' Association,
  171. (1969). Restoration and Archaeology.
  172. (1999). Results of Phase I and Phase 11 Archaeological Investigations at Washington's Mill Historical State Park (44FX2262). Mount Vernon Archaeology file report no. 6. Mount Vernon Ladies'Association,
  173. (1999). Resurrection and Deification at Colonial
  174. (1966). Ruskin, Morris, and the "Anti-Scrape" Philosophy, in Historic Preservation Today: Essays Presented to the Seminar on Preservation andRestoration,
  175. (1928). Scrapbooks, three volumes. Accession 30463, Personal Papers Collection, Virginia State Library and Archives,
  176. Service (2008a) List of Classified Structures. Query run
  177. Service (2008b) National Register Information System, National Park Service Owned Reconstructed Properties, Criteria Consideration E. Query run
  178. Service (2008c) National Register Information System, Reconstructed Properties, Criteria Consideration E. Query run May 15. National Park Service
  179. (1999). Shakespeare's Globe: 'As faithful a copy as scholarship ... could get; 'A bit of a bastard'.
  180. (1959). Special Report on the Quarters, Mount Vernon Ladies' Association,
  181. (2003). Standards and Guidelines for the Conservation of Ifistoric Places in Canada. Available from hgp: //www. pc. gc. ca/docs/Dc/zuide/nldclpc-sRchl2c/nldclpc s%zchPc e. 12d [accessed
  182. (1982). Structural Reconstruction 4pproaches to the Interpretation ofthe Excavated Remains ofBuildings.
  183. (1999). The Ancient technology Centre, Cranborne, UK: A Reconstruction Site Built for Education. In
  184. (2001). The Birthplace of a Chief. Archaeology and Meaning at George Washington Birthplace National Monument.
  185. (1992). The Case Against Reconstruction.
  186. (1993). The Conservation of Immovable Cultural Property: Ethical and Practical Dilemmas.
  187. (1999). The Cultural Biography of Objects.
  188. (2002). The Diet of Washington's Soldiers at Valley Forge during the Winter of 1777-78.
  189. (1993). The Fort Anne Officers' Quarters; A Reconstruction Case Study.
  190. (1996). The Heritage of Memory.
  191. (1999). The Historical--Archaeological Experimental Centre at Lejre, Denmark: 30 Years of Experimenting with the Past. In
  192. (1995). The Image Recapitulated. On The, 4potheosis of George Washington: Brumidi's Fresco & Beyond. Available from httv: //xroads.
  193. (1992). The Impact of Enhanced Values in the Care of Historic Structures.
  194. (2003). the Interior
  195. (1968). the Interior (US)
  196. (1983). the Interior, National Park Service (Revision to
  197. (2004). The Ironbridge Gorge: Preservation, Reconstruction, and Presentation of Industrial Heritage.
  198. (1963). The Lamp of Memory. In
  199. (2005). The Man U%o Found Thoreau: Roland W. Robbins and the Rise offfistorical Archaeology in America. Lebanon, NH:
  200. (2000). The Management qfA rchaeological Resources in Mexico: Oaxaca as a Case Study. Translated by
  201. (1966). The Mount Vernon Blacksmith Shop. Ms. on file, Mount Vernon Ladies'Association,
  202. (1999). The Nature of Experiment in Archaeology. In
  203. (1997). The New History in an Old Museum.
  204. (1999). The Origin and Role of the Irish National Heritage Park. In
  205. (1995). The Other Hay". - Making African-American History at Colonial Williamsburg. Unpublished Ph.
  206. (1999). The Papers of George Washington, Retirement Series,
  207. (1992). The Past in Contemporary Society: Then,
  208. (1985). The Past is a Foreign Country, Cambridge:
  209. (1998). The Presence of the Past: Popular Uses offfistory in American Life.
  210. (1953). The Rebuilding of the Greenhouse-Quarters. Annual Report
  211. (1996). The Road to Ruins and Restoration'ý- Roland W. Robbins and the Professionalization offfistorical Archaeology. Unpublished Ph.
  212. (1991). The Role of Archeology in Restoration and Demolition.
  213. (1998). The Roles of Archaeology and Ideology in the Reconstruction of an Eighteenth Century North Carolina Moravian Dwelling.
  214. (2000). The Spirit of Place: The Physical Memory of Canada.
  215. (1997). The Unreal, 4merica: 4rchitecture andIllusion,
  216. (1982). The Validity of Inference From Archaeological Evidence
  217. (1993). The Value of Reconstruction, in Canadian Parks Service.
  218. (2004). The Value of Reconstructions: An Archaeological Perspective.
  219. (2007). The Whole Site is the Artifact: Interpreting the St.
  220. (2004). Thomas Jefferson Memorial Foundation,
  221. (1990). To Reconstruct or Not to Reconstruct: An Overview
  222. (1987). Toward a Critical Archaeology.
  223. (1986). Travels in Hyperreality,
  224. (1985). Two CRM Data Bases: Resources for Management.
  225. (1936). Two Infamous Lies Nailed. December,
  226. (1995). Valley Forge: Making and Remaking a National Symbol,
  227. (1984). Value and Meaning in Cultural Resources.
  228. (1993). Value of Reconstructions to Fort George.
  229. Vernon Ladies'Association) (1894) Minutes of the Council. Mount Vernon, VA: Mount Vemon Ladies'Association. MVLA (Mount Vernon Ladies'Association) (n. d. ) George Washington'sMount Vernon Official Guidebook. Mount Vemon, VA: Mount Vemon Ladies'
  230. (1966). Viollet-le-Duc and Restoration in France. In Historic Preservation Today: Essays Presented to the Seminar on Preservation and Restoration,
  231. (2004). Walden Pond and Beyond: The Restoration Archaeology of Roland Wells Robbins.
  232. (1969). Washington, The Indispensable Man.
  233. (2001). What Does the Public Really Know About Archeology? Common Ground, summer fall,
  234. (1993). What to do with our Ageing Reconstructions: Authenticity and the Meeting of Challenges. Report number 97296-08. Paper presented at the Association for Preservation Technology meeting,
  235. (2007). When the Digging is Over: Some Observations on Methods of Interpreting Archaeological Sites for the Public.
  236. (2000). White Women and the Politics of Historical Memory in the New South, 1880-1920,
  237. (2007). Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, November 1. Available from http: //en.
  238. (2006). Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, October 8. Available from hn: //en. wikipedia. orgLwiki/Cateizo! y: French and Indian War forts [accessed

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.