Location of Repository

The Development of British Credit Unions: 'From the Margins to the Mainstream'.

By Lydia J. Plackett

Abstract

The study investigates the reasons why British credit unions failed to achieve the levels of success enjoyed by similar organisations in other countries. Despite recent growth in membership to approximately 300,000 in 2001, a growth of 17% during the year 1999/01, credit union membership as a percentage of the total population is disappointingly low at 0.4%. Internationally credit unions have a much larger share of the financial services market.\ud Jones (1999) argues that British credit unions' lack of impact can be attributed directly to the approach taken to their development - particularly the development of community-based credit unions. Internationally credit unions are considered to be cooperative financial institutions operating as profitable businesses; where as in Britain, credit unions are assumed to be small, community projects focusing on social rather than economic goals. Jones argues that this assumption has seriously hampered their development. Jones suggests that if credit unions in Britain are to achieve the success enjoyed by credit unions internationally then it is necessary to have a new approach to development, called the 'new model', which focuses on economic rather than social goals, professional management rather than volunteerism, and economic sustainability as opposed to grant-dependency.\ud This study took place between 1998 and 2001 during the writer's employment by the\ud Association of British Credit Unions Ltd., and was largely based on the writer's\ud Implementation of the recommendations made by Jones for 'new model' credit unions, using a combination of qualitative methodologies: historical research, participant observation, and action research, based on 29 case studies. The qualitative data was triangulated using quantitative data drawn from central government and local authority statistics.\ud The research confirms Jones' findings but proposes that there is scope for British credit unions to move from the margins to the mainstream of financial services provision subject to: the implementation of more innovative organisational structures, development funding being provided directly to the credit unions, rather than through development agencies, and credit unions being managed as sustainable and economically viable businesses, by professional trained staff directed by committed elected officers, in accordance with internationally accepted co-operative principles within the wider cooperative movement

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 2003
OAI identifier: oai:lra.le.ac.uk:2381/4465

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1994c) 'The Co-operative Identity in the Twenty-first Century A Background Popcr'
  2. (1999a) 'The Dynamics of Credit Unions: Explaining Diversity in the International Credit Union Movement'
  3. (2000a) Labour and the Family. ý New directions for Co-operative Associations of Labour. Leicester:
  4. (2000b) Analysing the Business Environment: Section 3: Module 2.
  5. (1997). (I 997b) 'Management Development for Co-operatives -a Review'
  6. (2003). 1 c) 'Mixed motives hamper postal delivery' IN The Guardian. Notebook anon (2001d) PaperPresented to ABCUL Conference. Manchester: ABCUL I frntrnsfinal vers: xv I Lydia
  7. 1) 'A new era for credit unions' IN New Sector 17 [ htmsfinal vers: xv I Lydla
  8. 1) British Co-operation. Manchester: Co-operative Union Ltd.
  9. 8) 'Co-operation in China'
  10. (1997). A bond in common -people & their credit unions.
  11. (1997). A Commitment to People and Place.
  12. (1937). A History ofPolitical Theory.
  13. (1998). A man in a hurry for his divvy'
  14. (1818). A New View ofSociety.
  15. (1999). A Report into the Rapid Growth of Credit Unions in
  16. (2000). A Report into the Rapid Growth of Credit Unions In Scotland. I leriot-Watt University.
  17. (1982). A SourcebookandFieldAfanuaL London: George Allen &Unwin.
  18. (2001). a) 'Bank plan could hit credit unions - Credit Union Development Activity in Scotland' IN New Start anon (2001b) 'Banks suffer double blow over credit union movement bill'
  19. ABCUL (2000a) Achieving Financial Inclusion through a Sustainable Credit Union Afovemcnt. - Draj? Business Plan For a Central Services Organisation. Manchester: The Association of British Credit Unions Ltd.
  20. ABCUL (2000c) Proposalfor a Feasibility Study Into Sustainable Credit UnIonsfor Sunderlandfocating on the Thorney Close, Pennywell, East End and Hendon Areas of the City. Manchester The Association of British Credit Unions Ltd.
  21. ABCUL (2000d) Study Group Pack. Manchester: The Association of British Credit Unions lid.
  22. ABCUL (2001a) Credit Union Development in High Peak; Derbyshire Dales & Staffords-hire Aloorlands.
  23. ABCUL(2001b)Rhondda Cynon Taf Monitoring Report ISIV,
  24. (1997). Accountingfor Non-Accounting Students (4th Edition). London: Financial Times;
  25. (1999). Afember Sativfaction levels National Normt for Comparing Local Survey Results. Madison: Filene Research Institute.
  26. (1994). Applying Risk-Based Capital ratios to Onlit Unions. Madison: Filene Research Institute.
  27. (2000). Bank Competition and Concentration: Do CrcdiI Unions Matter? Federal Reserve Bank of St.
  28. (2000). Banks veto plan to save post offices' IN The Guanham Treanor,
  29. (1993). Birmingham Heartlands: A Community Audit Report. Docklands Consultative Committee Support Unit.
  30. (1996). Board - CEO Relationships: Successes. Failures. and Remedies. Madison: Filene Research Institute.
  31. (1993). Building High LoanlShare Ratios Challenges anti Strategies. Madison: Filene Research Institute.
  32. (1996). Building Societies: Stakeholding
  33. (1999). Canadian Credit Unions take on the Future'
  34. (1941). Ceylon
  35. (2000). Changing the shape ofcredit unions.
  36. (1995). Chicanos Por La Causa Inc.
  37. (1910). Co-op Credit Associatioav in the Province ofQucbec. The
  38. (1934). Co-operation and the State, Year Book ofAgricultural Co-operation.
  39. (1974). Co-operative Development Agency'
  40. (1995). Co-operative Identity and Co-operative Afanagement. International Co-opcrative ,
  41. (1998). Co-operative Management a Philosophyfor Business. Cheltenham: New I
  42. (1996). Co-operative Principles for the 21st Century, International C-operative
  43. (1983). Community against Government The British Community Development Project, J968-78- a Study of Government Incompetence.
  44. (1998). Community Development Credit Unions in the United States'
  45. (1996). Concentration & Stability in the Mutual Building Society Industry'
  46. (1977). Conditionsfor Efficiency of the Co-operative Sector.
  47. (1993). Consumer Relations uith Financial Institutions. Madison: Filene Research Institute.
  48. (1923). Cooperative Banking a Credit Union Book.
  49. (2000). CP77 The Regulation of Credit Unions. London: The Financial Services Authority.
  50. (1999). Credit Union Development In
  51. (1998). Credit Union Restructuring: A Response to the Developments In the International Finance Industry. World Council of Credit Unions. Research Monograph Series.
  52. (1994). Credit Union Service Oriented Peer Groups. Madison: Filene Research Institute.
  53. (2000). Credit Unions Act
  54. (2001). Credit Unions and Capacity Building in Cornwall: ExeculiwSummaiyofan Action Researchfor PROSPER. Cornwall Rural Conununity Council.
  55. (1998). Credit Unions and the New Mutualism'
  56. (1999). Credit Unions Deserve a Better Deal. Parliamcntary Bricf 5.
  57. (1996). Credit Unions in Great Britain: A Review of the Years 1979-1995. London: Registry of Friendly Societies.
  58. (1993). Credit Unions Retooled- A Road Hapfor Financial Stabilization, Experiencesfrom the Guatemala Cooperative-strengthening project. Madison: World Council Infonnation Centre.
  59. (1993). Credit Unions Retooled: A RoadAlapforRnanclal Stabilization. World Council of Credit Unions, Research Monograph Series.
  60. (2000). Credit Use and Ethnic Minorities. London: Policy Studies Institute.
  61. (2000). Debt and Credit in Rural, 4reas, 4n assessment of issues around rural Dorset and Somerset. Hasto Housing Association.
  62. (2000). Decemb& 2.2003 Pago: Ix The Development of British Credit Unions: From the Margins to the MaInstresm 0 Lydia J Plackett December 2,2003 POgO:
  63. (1969). Democracy & Competition in Consumer Co-operatives'
  64. (1996). Deprivation and 'the Rural': an Investigation into Contradictory Discourses'
  65. (1999). Development International Desjardins: Finance Serving the Community'
  66. (1998). Directory and Statistics of Agricultural CO-operatives and other FarmerControlled Businesses in the UK. The Plunckett Foundation.
  67. (1988). Educational Research Methodology andMeasurment.
  68. (1996). Empowerment: Community Economic Development from the inside out'
  69. (1998). European Regional Development Fund. Mountain Ash, CardifP Welsh Offlice.
  70. (1993). Evaluating the Performance of Credit Unions. Madison: Filene Research Institute.
  71. (2000). Exclusion what is to be done? '
  72. (2000). Extortionate credit in the UK - summary & recommendations. Department of Trade and Industry -
  73. (1998). F. WRaiffeisen 1818-1888.
  74. (1996). Facts & Figuresfor Gennan Co-op Banks etc. Raiffeisen Federation.
  75. (2000). Financial Exclusion. Newcastle University Website (Internet) Burger,
  76. (1989). Financial Management for Credit Union Managers and Directom
  77. (1986). Financial Planning and Control.
  78. (2003). fmtmsfinal vers: xv I Lydia
  79. (1988). Focus Groups as Qualitative Research.
  80. (1947). France. YearBookofAgricultural Co-operation 194711effcr&Som Ltd
  81. (1951). French Union Equatorial Affica'
  82. FSA (2000a) CPXY The Regulation of Credit Unions Dra . ft. London: Financial Scrviccs Authority.
  83. FSA (2000b) Credit Union Consultation Panel. London: Financial Services Authority.
  84. (1994). Fulfilling the Co-operative Dream A Declaration for the Twcnty First Ccntury'
  85. (1999). Global Co-operation in a New Century'
  86. (1983). Government and Urban Policy,
  87. (2003). htmsfinal vers: xv I Lydia J Plackett December 2,2003 Pago: Iv The Development of British Credit Unions: From the Margins to the Mainstream 0
  88. (2003). I htmsfinal vers: xv I Lydia J Plackelt D(Kombor 2.2003 Pago-. VI The Development of British Credit Unions: From the Margins to the Mainstream
  89. (1994). I htmsfinal vers: xv I Lydia J Plackett Doc4)mb6r 2,2003 Pago:
  90. (2003). I htmsfinal vers: xv I Lydla J Plackett Decenbor 2.2003 Pago: The Development of British Credit Unions: From the Margins to the Mainstream 0
  91. (1939). I htmsfinal vers: xv J LYdia J Plackett December 2.2003 Pago: x1l The Development of British Credit Unions: From the Margins to the Mainstream Q Lydia J Plackett December 2,2003 Pago: All
  92. (1998). I'd like to shop at the Co-op'
  93. (1999). ICA Congress and General Assembly 1999. Intemational Co-opcrative Alliance.
  94. (1997). Inclusive Partnership: Key to Business Success'
  95. (1999). Information Technology and Management Structure 11: Insights for Credit Unions. b-ladison: Filcric Research Institute.
  96. (1993). International Laws Governing Credit Unions.
  97. (1999). Involvement of the Community in SRB schemes. London: Department of die Environment Transport and the Regions.
  98. (1997). Les Mouvement des caisses
  99. (1993). Local Authorities and Community Development. The Association of Metropolitan Authorities.
  100. (1998). Local Development and co-operatives: None, only one, more than one in the same village
  101. (1994). Local Government and the Expansion of Crcdit Unions 1991-93' IN LocalEconomy.
  102. (1963). Management of Co-operative Societies.
  103. (2003). Managing the Co-operative Diffiermcc. Geneva. Switzerland: International Labour Office, Co-operative Branch;
  104. (1998). Marketing Co-operation in the Global Economy'
  105. (1995). Marketing Credit Union Services: The Role of Perceived ;
  106. (1996). Marketing.
  107. (2000). Membership participation INCUME email discussion group (Intcmct) Goulet,
  108. (2001). Membrship Relationship Maanagement in Credit Co-operatives'
  109. (2001). Memher Acceptance of Electronic Systems: Innovators Versus Laggards. Madison: Filene Research Institute.
  110. (2000). Mission Values and Leadership Styles In Credit Unions. hfadison: Filene Research Institute.
  111. Model Lawfor Credit Unions developed and recommended by the Morld Council of Credit Unions, Inc. Guidelinesfor legislation to protect the safety and soundness ofcredit unions.
  112. (1994). Models ofManagement.
  113. (1999). Mutualism speaks to the capacity of conununities to change their own lives'
  114. (1998). nall is Bankable Community Reinvestment in the UK. New Economics Foundation.
  115. (1998). Network of support & sponsorship from organisations within each I credit union's common bond A13CUL
  116. (1998). New Mutualism. Manchester: The Co-operative Party.
  117. (1998). One National Body or Two? ' IN Credit Union Nevis.
  118. (1995). Organising Credit Unions A AfanuaL
  119. (1997). Organizing a Civil Society TForking Paper No 2. The Foundation for Civil Society.
  120. (2000). Over 14,000 members and still rising. Glasgow. Scotwest Crcdit Union.
  121. (2000). Paying the dues'
  122. (2000). PEARLSTMMonitoring System. Madison: World Council of Crcdit Unions.
  123. (2001). People, Communities and Credit Unions. Binningham City Council.
  124. (1993). Politics: Decolonializing Applied Social Science'
  125. (2001). Post Office seeks L130m a year to run bank for poor'
  126. (2000). Poverty Alleviation and the Role of Credit Unions. Now Delhi: International Cooperative Alliance (ROAP) Twelvetrees,
  127. (2000). Profit to help the poorest'
  128. (1973). Projecting Co-operative Principles' IN The Socletyfor Co-operative Studies.
  129. (1986). Promoting Economic Development Amongst Rural Communities'
  130. (1999). Promoting the Co-operative Agenda - New Mutualism and the "Third Way..
  131. (2000). Promotion of Co-operatives. International Labour Office V (1) IRU (1991)IRUCo-operative Guidelines. International Raiffeisen Union.
  132. (1970). Raiffeisen The Credit Unions. Neuwied on the Rhine German)r. The Raiffeisen Printing and
  133. (1998). Ready for New Competition'
  134. (1993). Real Morld Research, A Resource for Social Scientiviv and Practitioner Researchers.
  135. (1998). Rediscovering Mutuality'
  136. (2000). Report for Reasserting the Co-operafive Advantage A Research Report based on the Questionnaire Survey Returns of 16 British Consumer Co-operative Societies. Leiccster:
  137. (1999). Report ofthe ChlefRegistrar 1998-99. London: IIMSO & Registry of Friendly Societies.
  138. (2000). Reprieve for Local Post Offices'
  139. (1974). Role of Government in Agricultural Co-operation'
  140. (1999). Roles and Responsibilities of Directors.
  141. (1999). Rural report. Rural Credit Unions; pointing the way to successful sustainable development. National Council for Voluntary Organisations.
  142. (1990). Skills in Neighbourhood Work London: UnAin I lyinan.
  143. (1997). Social & Economic Regeneration in Wales.
  144. (2000). Social Erclusion in the Counto-side: A briering note by the Countryside Agency.
  145. (1995). Strategic Opportunities in Serving Low to Moderate Income Members. Madison: Filene Research Institute.
  146. (1995). Taking Power: an agenda for community economic reneuv/. a paperfor the economic neighbourhood think thank. New Econoniics Foundation.
  147. (1997). Technology Strategies of Best Practice Cre(lit Unions: Today, The Near Future, and the ForFuture. Madison: Filene Research Institute.
  148. (1968). The Active
  149. (2001). The backbone that could allow credit unions to stand tall. Parliamentary Brief (ABCUL).
  150. (2000). The Contribution of the Co-operative and Mutual Sector to the Promotion of&w1al Inclusion and Community Involvement in Males. Short Debate in the Welsh Assembly.
  151. (1914). The Cooperative People's Bank La CaissePopulaire.
  152. (1994). The Coopers Lane Project: Craft & Cooperage'
  153. (1961). The Death andLife of GreatAmerican Cities.
  154. (2003). The Digital Revolution: Delivering Financial Services in the Future. Madison: Filene Research Institute.
  155. (1999). The enterprise that people trust'
  156. (1990). The Measurement and Analysis of Rural Deprivation. Report Preparedfor the Convention ofScottish Local Authorities.
  157. (2000). The Operating Environment' IN Strategic Managementý An Introduction to Business and Corporate Strategy. LA)ndon: Financial Times Prentice I fall.
  158. (1977). The Problems of Thrift & Credit. International Conference: Co-operative Thrift Credit, Rio de Janeiro LGA
  159. (1986). The Rhetoric and the Reality of Rural Deprivation'.
  160. (1997). The role of Co-operatives and Sej(-help Organisations in Financial Sen-Ices.
  161. (1997). The Strategic Development of Credit Unions.
  162. (1997). The Town that came back from the dead'
  163. (1973). To-operative Development Agency'
  164. (1989). Total Quality Management
  165. (1998). Towards sustainable credit union development; A Research Project.
  166. (1999). Treasury
  167. Treasury (2000a) Credit Unions ofthe Future.
  168. Treasury (2000b) Meeting the Productivity Challenge. London:
  169. (1999). TVhy Many Small Credit Unions are Thriving.
  170. (2000). Unorthodox Micro finance: The Seven Doctrines of Success'
  171. (2003). vers: xv I Lydia J Plackett 06cambor 2,2003 Pago: vill The Development of British Credit Unions: From the Margins to the Mainstream 0
  172. (1996). vers: xv I LYdia J Plackett December 2,2003 Pago: vil The Development of British Credit Unions: From the Margins to the Mainstream 0
  173. (2003). vers: xv I Lydla J Plackett December 2,2003 Pago: x The Development of British Credit Unions: From the Margins to the Mainstream 0
  174. (1998). Why Consumer Co-operative Societies Fail'
  175. WOCCU (2000a) New Program shows how credit unions are different.
  176. (1998). Yhe Co-operative Movement in Cyprus. The Plunckett Foundation. Parnell, Edgar (I 999a) Reinventing Co-operation; the challenge offhe 21st century.
  177. (1999). Yunerable Consumers andFinancial Services. IIMSO& Office of Fair Trading.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.