Location of Repository

Young People's Participation in Social Services Policy Making.

By Robert Gunn

Abstract

Young people are recognised as citizens with rights and competence to participate in decision making. The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child and the Children Act 1989 identifies their right to participate in social services decision making. Much of the published information on their participation has focused on involvement as individuals in case planning rather than as stakeholders in strategic policy making. This research examines how a particular organisation – social services – has responded to the participation rights of young people who are looked after. The thesis provides a critical review of current practice. It uncovers the extent of young people's participation in social services policy making and explores the perceptions of key stakeholder groups involved in the process. A national survey was used to elicit quantitative and qualitative information from a representative sample of social services departments. Semi-structured interviews with key stakeholders in the policy process provided data from three diverse case study sites. Overall, data confirmed that stakeholders did not recognise young people's right to participate. Social services were unclear about the basis of their relationship with young people in the policy process; this confusion undermined young people's ability to influence policy decisions. Findings also showed that the power of managers in departments constrained the ability of young people to shape policy. Consumerism, rather than rights, was the underlying principle which defined participation as service-led rather than user-led. In light of these findings, which emphasise the dissonance between the theory of participation and its practice, a number of recommendations are made at national and organisational level to improve the quality of young people's participation

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 2002
OAI identifier: oai:lra.le.ac.uk:2381/4374

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1990). (eds.) Constructing and Re-constructing Childhood:
  2. (2000). A „Risky‟ Business: Researching the Health Beliefs of Children and Young People.
  3. (1996). A Case of Neglect?
  4. (1993). A Challenge to Change: Practical Experiences of Building User-Led Services. London: National Institute of Social Work.
  5. (1993). A Companion to Ethics.
  6. (1969). A Ladder of Citizen Participation.
  7. (1992). A Theory of Justice.
  8. (1990). A Voice for Children in Statistical Accounting: A Plea for Children‟s Rights to be Heard.
  9. (1998). Abusers of Power.
  10. (1987). Accountabilities: Five Public Services.
  11. (1996). Achieving User Involvement in Developing Leaving Care Services. In:
  12. (1997). Acting on Principle. London: British Agencies for Adoption and Fostering.
  13. (1998). Adolescents‟ and Children‟s Knowledge About Rights: Some Evidence for How Young People View Rights in their Lives.
  14. (1996). After Social Work?
  15. (1997). Age and the Right to Vote.
  16. (1997). All Together Now: Community Participation for Children and Young People. London: Save the Children Fund.
  17. (1989). An Introduction to the Children Act
  18. (1994). Analysing Qualitative Data.
  19. (1996). Analysis of Unstructured Data.
  20. (1993). Anarchy, State and Utopia.
  21. (1982). Approaches to Gramsci. London: Writer and Readers.
  22. (1995). Approaches to the History of the Western Family 1500-1914. Cambridge:
  23. (1992). Arguing for Basic Income.
  24. (1998). Basics of Qualitative Research.
  25. (1999). British Social Attitudes: The 16 th Report: Who Shares New Labour Values.
  26. (1998). Capturing First Time Voters. In:
  27. (1997). Care, Communities and Citizens.
  28. (1998). Case Studies.
  29. (1993). Case Study Methods.
  30. (1994). Child Welfare (England 1872-1989).
  31. (1997). Child Welfare and Stigma: Principles into practice Childhood.
  32. (1965). Childcare and the Growth of Love.
  33. (1994). Childhood Matters.
  34. (2001). Children and Community Regeneration: Creating Better Neighbourhoods. London: Save the Children Fund.
  35. (1998). Children and Social Policy.
  36. (1978). Children in Care.
  37. (1994). Children Speak. Children, Trauma and Social Work.
  38. (1993). Children: Rights and Childhood.
  39. (1999). Children‟s Participation in Reviews and Planning Meetings when they are „Looked After‟
  40. (1997). Children‟s Participation: The Theory and Practice of Involving Young Citizens in Community Development and Environmental Care.
  41. (1996). Children‟s Rights and Participation in Residential Care. London: National Children‟s Bureau.
  42. (1998). Children‟s Rights.
  43. (1985). Cities and Services.
  44. (1993). Citizen Involvement, a Practical Guide for Change.
  45. (1991). Citizens, Consumers and Councils.
  46. (1997). Citizenship Feminist Perspecives.
  47. (1996). Citizenship, Children and Young People.
  48. (2001). Co-ordinated Service Planning for Vulnerable Children and Young People in England. London: Department of Health.
  49. (1996). Communitarianism and Law and Order.
  50. (1983). Community against Government: The British Community Development Project.
  51. (1990). Constructing and Reconstructing Childhood.
  52. (2000). Consulting Children.
  53. (2000). Contesting Childhood.
  54. (1989). Convention on the Rights of the Child,
  55. (1996). Data Collection and Analysis.
  56. (1974). Dilemas of Social Reform: Poverty and Community Action in the United States. Harmondsworth: Penguin
  57. (1998). Disabled People and Social Policy. Harlow:
  58. (1991). Discipline and Punish.
  59. (2000). Discovering What Children Think: Connections Between Research and Practice.
  60. (1998). Discrimination Against Young People in Care.
  61. (1981). Doing Feminist Research.
  62. (2000). Doing Qualitative Research.
  63. (1999). Education and Employment with the Qualifications and Curriculum Authority
  64. (1996). Effective Government Structures for Children. London: Calouste Gulbenkian Foundation.
  65. (1994). Empowering Practice in Social Care.
  66. (1992). Empowerment
  67. (1997). Engaging the User in Welfare Services.
  68. (1997). Engaging the User: Participation, Empowerment and the Rhetoric of Quality. In:
  69. (1975). Escape from Childhood.
  70. (1996). Ethical Issues in Practice.
  71. (1996). Ethics, Politics and Research.
  72. (1995). Evaluating Quality
  73. (1998). Family Life Threatened by Rights for Children. The Daily Telegraph.
  74. (1999). Finding their Voice. Community Care.
  75. (1998). Focus on Children in Care: Quality Protects Initiative.
  76. (1997). Friends and Neighbours.
  77. (1990). From Paternalism to Participation: Involving People in Social Services. London: Open Services Project.
  78. G.(1997) Best Value for the Public: Briefing and Discussion Papers. London: Municipal Journal Limited.
  79. (2000). Gaining Access to Looked After Children for Research Purposes: Lessons Learned.
  80. (1993). Getting Involved. London: Open Services Project/
  81. (1994). Going About Our Business? The Managerialisation of Public Services.
  82. (1981). Gramsci‟s Political Thought.
  83. (1991). Gramsci‟s Political Thought. London: Lawrence and Wishart.
  84. (2000). Guidelines provided to contracting researchers. The Children‟s Society,
  85. (2000). Having Someone Who Cares? Barriers to Change in the Public Care of Children. London: National Children‟s Bureau.
  86. Health (1998c) Statistical Bulletin 1998/33. Children Looked After in England; 1997/1998. London: Government Statistical Service.
  87. (1998). Hear Me: Consulting with Young People on Mental Health Services. London: Mental Health Foundation.
  88. (1997). Hear! Hear! Promoting Young People‟s Participation in Democratic Participation in Local Government. London: Local Government Information Unit and National Children‟s Bureau.
  89. (1982). Hegemony and Consent: A Political Strategy.
  90. Hemel Hempstead: Harvester Wheatsheaf.
  91. (1998). Home Truths and Brought to Book too Late. The Guardian [CD-ROM],
  92. (1998). How Childcare was Hijacked.
  93. (1998). How to Research.
  94. (1991). Human Rights and International Relations.
  95. (1998). In the Company of Strangers.
  96. (1998). Including Young People in Urban Regeneration: A Lot to Learn.
  97. (1981). Interviewing Women: A Contradiction
  98. (1998). Introducing Participation by Children and Young People into Public Services.
  99. (1998). Involving Children in Planning their Care. Child and Family Social Work.
  100. (1998). Involving Young People Leaving Care as Peer Researchers
  101. (1999). Involving Young Researchers.
  102. (2000). Joined-up Youth Research, Policy and Practice: A New Agenda for Change? Leicester:
  103. (1995). Know Your Rights! In:
  104. (1962). L‟Enfant et la Vie Familiale Sous L‟Ancien Regime.
  105. (1999). Let the Children Speak. Community Care.
  106. (1984). Liberalism and its Critics.
  107. (1995). Listening to Children.
  108. (2001). Listening to Looked After Young People.
  109. (1996). Local Agenda 21 as a Vehicle for Encouraging Children‟s Participation in Environmental Planning. Local Government Policy Making.
  110. (1999). Local Authorities Challenged to Transform the Lives of Children
  111. (1995). Looking After Children: Research into Practice.
  112. (2000). Lost in Care: Report on the Tribunal of Inquiry into child Abuse in North Wales. Chaired by Sir Ronald Waterhouse. London: The Stationery Office.
  113. (1978). Main Currents of Marxism. Its Origin, Growth and Dissolution. (Volume 3).
  114. (1997). Making Social Policy. Buckingham:
  115. (1994). Managing Social Policy.
  116. (1989). Max Weber on Economy and Society.
  117. (1997). Modern Political Thought.
  118. (1998). Modernising Social Services: National Priorities Guidance 1999/2000 -2001/2002. London: The Stationery Office.
  119. (1998). More Law and More Rights: Will Children Benefit? Child and Family Social Work.
  120. (1995). Moving On: Young People and Leaving Care Schemes.
  121. (1990). National Health Service and Community Care Act.
  122. (1996). New Modes of Control in the Public Service.
  123. (1993). Not Just a Name: The Views of Young People in Foster and Residential Care. London: National Consumer Council.
  124. (1992). On the Difference Between Society and Community, and Why Basic Income Cannot by Itself Confer Full Membership of Either.
  125. (1997). Participating in Transformation.
  126. (1994). Participation in Human Enquiry.
  127. (1969). Participation in Social Services Policy Making Robert
  128. (1994). Participation in Social Services Policy Making Robert Gunn
  129. (1998). Participation in Social Services Policy Making Robert Gunn 249 Appendix 8: What Helps Participation
  130. (1994). Participation in Social Services Policy Making Robert Gunn 257
  131. Participation in Social Services Policy Making Robert Gunn 258 Department of Health (1998b) Quality Protects: Objectives for Social Services for Children. Social Care Group.
  132. (1997). Participation in Social Services Policy Making Robert Gunn 259 Etzioni,
  133. (1996). Participation in Social Services Policy Making Robert Gunn 260 Fox Harding,
  134. (1980). Participation in Social Services Policy Making Robert Gunn 262
  135. (1997). Participation in Social Services Policy Making Robert Gunn 267
  136. (1998). Participation in Social Services Policy Making Robert Gunn 268
  137. (1997). Participation in Social Services Policy Making Robert Gunn 271
  138. (1998). Participation in Social Services Policy Making Robert Gunn 272
  139. (1999). Participation in Social Services Policy Making Robert Gunn 273
  140. (1997). Participation in Social Services Policy Making Robert Gunn 274 Treseder,
  141. (1994). Participation in Social Services Policy Making Robert Gunn 275
  142. (1999). Paths to Empowerment.
  143. (1997). Paul Boateng Lays out the Government‟s Plans for the Welfare and Future of Children and Young People in the UK.
  144. (1972). Pedagogy of the Oppressed.
  145. (1997). People Like Us: The Report of the Review of the Safeguards for Children Living Away From Home. London: The Stationery Office.
  146. (1997). Perspectives in Child Care Policy.
  147. (1995). Planning and Review under the Children Act: Shaping a Framework for Practice. London: National Children‟s Bureau.
  148. (1992). Planning Ethically Responsible Research.
  149. (1997). Planning to Care: Regulation,
  150. (1999). Planning With Children for Better Communities: the Challenge to Professionals.
  151. (1962). Plon. Translated by Baldick, R. as Centuries of Childhood
  152. (1998). Policy.
  153. (1992). Power and the Social System. In:
  154. (1980). Power/Knowledge. London: Harvester Wheatsheaf.
  155. (1997). Praise and Damnation: Mental Health User Groups and the Construction of Organisational Legitimacy. Public Policy and Administration.
  156. (2000). Professionals‟ Attitudes to Children‟s Participation in Decision-Making: Dichotomous Accounts and Doctrinal Contests. Child and Family Social Work.
  157. (1999). Promoting Participation for Children and Young People: Some Questions for Health and Social Welfare Organisations.
  158. (1994). Qualitative Data Analysis for Applied Policy Research. In:
  159. (2000). Quality Protects
  160. (1992). Quality, Culture and Local Government.
  161. (1992). Questionnaire Design, Interviewing and Attitude Measurement.
  162. (1996). Real World Research.
  163. (1972). Relative Depravation and Social Justice.
  164. (1998). Research Notes. What is it Like to be Looked After by a Local Authority?
  165. (2000). Researching Children‟s Perspectives: A Sociological Dimension.
  166. (1995). Researching Social Life.
  167. (1997). Researching Social Work and Social Care Practices.
  168. (1992). Rethinking Citizenship.
  169. (1991). Rights.
  170. (1997). Seen and Heard.
  171. (1996). Selections from the Prison Notebooks. London: Lawrence and Wishart.
  172. (1975). Separation, Anxiety and Anger.
  173. (1995). Service User Involvement.
  174. (1999). Services‟ Development for Older People in Shrewsbury.
  175. (1998). Seven Years for Priest who Abused Orphans. The Daily Telegraph.
  176. (1996). Social Policy in Britain.
  177. (1992). Social Policy Review 4. Canterbury: Social Policy Association.
  178. (1975). Social Policy.
  179. (1989). Social Policy. Cambridge:
  180. (1995). Social Research and Policy Making.
  181. (1980). Social Research and Royal Commissions. London: George Allen and Unwin.
  182. (1997). Social Research. Buckingham:
  183. (1995). Social Work and Assessment with Adolescents. London: National Children‟s Bureau.
  184. (1998). Social Work and Organisations.
  185. (1999). Social Work. Regulation and Managerialism.
  186. (1992). Somewhere Over the Rainbow: Universality and Diversity in Social Policy.
  187. (1999). State Child Care … Looking After Children?
  188. (1998). Stepping Forward.
  189. (1980). Street Level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Services.
  190. (1995). Taking Part. Children‟s Participation in Decision Making.
  191. (1994). The Changing Organisation and Management of Local Government.
  192. (1981). The Child‟s Generation.
  193. (2000). The Children Act Report
  194. (1967). The Discovery of Grounded Theory.
  195. (1998). the Environment, Transport and the Regions
  196. (1984). The Foulcault Reader.
  197. (1994). The Foundations of Citizenship. London: Harvester Wheatsheaf.
  198. (1994). The Frontiers of Excellence (Learning from Companies That Put People First).
  199. (1995). The Handbook of Children‟s Rights.
  200. (1997). The Participation Rights of the Child.
  201. (1999). The Personal Social Services Performance Assessment Framework. London: The Stationery Office.
  202. (1991). The Pindown Experience and the Protection of Children. Staffordshire: Staffordshire County Council.
  203. (1989). The Politics of Child Welfare. Hemel Hempstead: Harvester Wheatsheaf.
  204. (1990). The Politics of Disablement.
  205. (1992). The Politics of Participation.
  206. (1997). The Right to Say: The Development of Youth Councils/Forums within the UK. Unpublished Working Paper.
  207. (1983). The Rights and Wrongs of Children.
  208. (1986). The Rights of Children.
  209. (1944). The Road to Serfdom. UK: Ark Paperbacks.
  210. (1993). The Spirit of Community.
  211. (1972). The Theory of Social and Economic Organisation.
  212. (1965). The Trial of Stephen Ward.
  213. (1995). The View from the Front. The User View of Child-Care in Norfolk. Norwich: Norfolk County Council Social Services Department.
  214. (1996). The Voice of the Child in Decision Making. London: Institute for Public Policy Research.
  215. (1998). Theorising Welfare: Enlightenment and Modern Society.
  216. (1998). Theorizing Childhood.
  217. (1994). To Tell The Truth.
  218. (1999). Users as Citizens. Social Policy and Administration.
  219. (1987). Webarian Sociological Theory. Cambridge:
  220. (1994). Weber – Political Writings. Cambridge:
  221. (1997). What Children and Young People Say they want from Social Services. Research Policy and Planning.
  222. (1998). When Children‟s Wishes Clash with Their „Best Interests‟.
  223. (1998). Which Champions, Which People? Social Policy and Administration.
  224. (2001). Who Knows What to Do About Children‟s Services? A Review of Current Issues and Lessons Learned from the Past. Management Issues in Social Care.
  225. (1998). Why Should We Care? Young People, Citizenship and Questions of Social Responsibility.
  226. (1996). Young People and Local Authorities: What can we do to make them more Interested - Should we Bother? Local Government Policy Making.
  227. (1999). Young People and Political Apathy.
  228. (1998). Young People in the City.
  229. (1998). Young People Leaving Care: Life After the Children Act
  230. (1999). Young People‟s Participation and Representation in Society.
  231. (1996). Youth and Citizenship in the 1990s.
  232. (1995). Youth and Social Policy.
  233. (1992). Youth, Family and Citizenship.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.