Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Working class organisation, industrial relations and the labour unrest, 1914-1921.

By Anthony John Adams


This study assesses the impact of the years 1914 to 1921 on British labour organisation and industrial relations. By combining local studies with national sources the thesis provides a measure of corrective to the 'view from the centre' approach to twentieth-century labour history and a new perspective from which to view the period. In Section I comparative studies of Sheffield, Pontypridd and Liverpool offer explanations for regional differences in the development of labour organisation. These local studies focus upon the consolidation of labour forces and the dimensions, timing and explanation of Labour's fluctuating electoral fortunes. A second Section considers the changing power relationships between officers, activists and membership in the Co-operative Union, National Union of Railwaymen, Associated Society of Locomotive Engineers & Firemen and the South Wales Miners' Federation. A re-evaluation of the role of labour leadership contributes to a critical appraisal of 'rank and filist' interpretations of labour history. In studies of the railway and mining industries it is argued that the centralisation of industrial relations was not simply imposed upon labour by employers and the state. Trade unions played a larger and more positive role in the development of a centralised industrial relations system in these industries than is generally acknowledged. The thesis concludes with a contribution to the current debate between the 'revolutionary' or 'rank and filist' school and its critics in the following areas: the causation of labour unrest; the nature of state intervention; the character of labour leadership and the causes and timing of the rise of labour

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 1988
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. 1 District Committee - Monthly Reports; Annual Report 1919. South Wales Coalfield Joint Standing Disputes Committee Minutes.
  2. 15The numbers- of working days lost due to industrial disputes in the metal, engineering and shipbuilding industries totalled 12,248,000
  3. 1900-1920: A )rigins and Early Growth of
  4. (1975). 1919-1920 is in need of attention', doi
  5. (1971). 20Department of Employment,
  6. (1985). 370n the dockers see, N. Whiteside, 'The Dock Decasualisation Issue 1889-1924: Public Policy and Port Labour Reform',
  7. (1985). 41See, for example, Reid's description of the relationship between shop stewards and officials in the wartime shipbuilding industry; Reid
  8. (1944). A CENTURY OF CO-OPERATION, doi
  10. (1921). A REPORT OF MINERS' WELFARE WORK Recreation Union'
  12. (1986). ADJUSTING TO DEMOCRACY, doi
  13. (1918). Annual Conference,
  14. (1975). Annual Report & Delegate Meeting, 9.6. -8.8.19, passim: See
  17. (1974). British Trade Unions 1910-1921, a Study in Ph.
  18. (1917). Capital and Labour After the War', Annual of Co-operative Wholesale Societies,
  19. (1981). Capitalist Attacks Upon Co-operation',
  20. (1973). Charisma and Conciliation: A Sympathetic Look at
  21. (1980). Commonsense Thought and Working Class Conciousness: Some Aspects of the Glasgow and Liverpool Labour Movements in the Early Years of the Twentieth Century',
  22. (1916). Conference of District Councils, Proposed alteration of Rules -
  24. (1910). Control in the Railway, Industries,
  25. (1978). Cook in 1916-18',
  26. Daily Nevs (South Vales Nevs from 1919). The Times. Vestern Mail - Cardiff City Library. 4) NATIONAL OR DISTRICT TRADE UNION RECORDS. Amalgamated Society of Engineers -
  27. (1983). DEMOCRACY AND
  28. (1880). Differences Between the Wages of Skilled doi
  29. (1985). Dilution, trade unionism and the state in Britain during the First World War',
  30. (1986). Disconnecting socialist aspiration from class consciousness',
  31. (1986). Disconnecting Socialist Aspiration from Class Consciousness', essay in Review of R. Price, Labour in British Society,
  32. (1920). Discontent in Industry',
  33. Down the Pit: Work in the Great Northern and South Wales Coalfields, 1870-1914', doi
  34. (1919). Economic Fallacy in Industry',
  35. (1971). Edited by K. Middlemas, doi
  36. (1981). Editorial' 'The Labour Party and Social Democracy', doi
  37. Employers and Managers: Organisation and Strategy 1914-39',
  38. Employers Associations in the Port of Liverpool, doi
  39. (1965). For a fuller discussion of Michels work
  40. for complaints against state interference from employers in the cotton and engineering industries. On the problems arising out of the 12'% award see, Idem.,
  41. (1983). for more fulsome praise of the responsiveness of leadership from Swansea tinplate labourers.
  42. (1983). For other attacks upon the 'rank and file-ist' school see
  44. (1969). Hartshorn: Miners' Agent and Cabinet Minister',
  45. (1981). HOMES FIT FOR HEROES: doi
  46. (1921). I Branch Minutes, 18.1.20. For (Footnote continued) Williams,
  47. (1920). Inaugural address by
  49. (1985). Industrial Structure, Employer Strategy and the Diffusion of Job Control
  50. (1917). Industrial Unrest', doi
  51. (1983). LABOUR AND SOCIALISM, doi
  52. Labour and Society in Modern Britain', doi
  54. (1918). Labour From An Employer's Point of View', Contemporary Review,
  56. (1917). Labour Organisation', Industrial Outlook,
  57. (1984). Labour Tradition in Glasgow and Liverpool', doi
  58. (1920). Labour's Councils of Action doi
  59. (1920). Labour's Councils of Action,
  60. (1980). LITTLE MOSCOWS: doi
  61. Lloyd-George and the Development of the British Government's Strikebreaking Organisation', doi
  62. LORD RIDDELL'S doi
  63. Military recruiting and the British Labour Force during the First World War', doi
  64. (1919). Mines for the Nation or Mines for the Miners: Alternative Perspectives on Industrial Democracy,
  65. (1919). More Economic Fallacies in Industry',
  66. (1961). OFFICERS: doi
  67. (1986). on Thomas's role in the unofficial rail strike, LG/F/30/2/47. And Wrigley,
  68. (1980). op. cit.,
  69. (1986). op. cit., p. 57. 44Lett ý, r from Horne to Lloyd-George on 27.1.19; 28.1.19; 29.1.19; LG/F/27/6/2-4. This involved the General Secretary of the Municipal Employees Association and the leadership of the A.
  70. (1914). Parliamentary Committee Quarterly Reports,
  73. (1919). particularly among those who had direct experience of wartime state control of industry. For example,
  74. (1968). Politcal Mobilisation', 'The impact of the labour unrest, 1910-1914, on the British labour movement',
  75. (1979). POLITICS IN doi
  76. (1979). Preparing for Power: the Sheffield labour Party 1890-1926',
  78. (1966). Railway Trade Unionism in doi
  79. Railway Trade Unionism in Britain, c 1880-1900', doi
  80. (1910). Rank and File Movements Among the Miners of South Wales,
  81. Re-casting Bourgeois Britian? The British state in the years which followed the First World War',
  82. (1918). Recent Developments in the Labour Movement',
  83. (1916). Reconstruction and Industrial Peace',
  84. (1916). Revised Ed. doi
  87. (1917). See also Executive Minutes,
  88. (1975). Socialism and Syndicalism: The Welsh Miners' Debate',
  89. (1974). Soviets in Britain, the Leeds Convention of 1917', doi
  90. Sub-committees of the Council of Action included "Supply and Transport"; "Strike Committee"; and "Publicity and Information. " doi
  91. Survey of Miners' Institutes and Welfare Hall Libraries', doi
  92. The Armed Forces and Osborne, doi
  93. (1915). The Coal Strike in South Wales', doi
  94. (1920). The Coal Strike' Round Table,
  95. (1920). THE COMING REVOLUTION, doi
  96. (1917). The Coming Revolution', Nineteenth Century Organiser,
  97. (1963). The Demand for Workers' Control in the Railway, Mining and Engineering Industries, '
  98. (1957). The Demand for Workers' Control in the Railway, Mining and Engineering Industries, 1910-22, '
  99. (1957). The Demand for Workers' Mining and Engineering Phil.
  100. The Division of Labour and Politics in Britain, 1880-1920',
  101. (1977). The Dock Decasualisation Issue 1889-1924: Public Policy and Port Labour Reform',
  102. (1986). THE DOCKER'S UNION:
  103. (1983). The Effects of the First World War on Aspects of (Footnote continued) the Class Structure of English Society',
  104. (1910). The effects of World War I on class and status in
  105. (1910). The effects of World War I on class and status in England,
  106. (1919). The Failure of consensus in Britain: doi
  107. (1919). The Failure of Consensus in Britain: the National Industrial Conference, doi
  108. (1976). The Franchise Factor in the Rise of the Labour McKibbin, doi
  109. (1976). The Franchise Factor in the rise of the Labour Party', doi
  110. (1984). The Impact of Unofficial Trades Union Movements and Industrial politics,
  111. (1915). The Industrial Situation', Round Table, doi
  112. (1919). The Industrial Unrest: A New Policy Required', Contemporary Review,
  113. (1974). The Interaction Between Race and Colonialism: A Cohen, R. Case Study of the Liverpool Race Riots of 1919', doi
  114. (1971). The Labour Movement in Clydeside Politics 1914-1922',
  115. (1983). The Labour Process and Labour History', doi
  116. (1982). The Liberals the War and the Franchise', doi
  117. (1950). THE LIGHTED FLAME.
  118. (1969). The Liverpool Labour
  119. The Liverpool Labour Party and the Liverpool Working Class, 1900-39', doi
  120. The Liverpool Trades Council 1880-1914',
  121. (1959). The Liverpool Trades Council and Politics
  122. (1978). The Making of A. doi
  123. The Membership of the Independent Labour Party 1904-1910. A Spatial and Occupational Analysis', doi
  124. (1974). The Myth of the "Servile State"',
  125. (1910). The National Transport -Workers' Federation,
  126. The National Union of Police and Prison Officers', doi
  127. The Parliamentary Electoral System, the 'Fourth' Reform Act and the rise of Labour in England and Wales', doi
  128. The Port of Liverpool: Employers and industrial relations, 1919-39',
  129. (1927). The position of the skilled and less skilled workmen in the engineering and building trades, 1914-25',
  130. The Railway Companies and the Growth of Trade Unionism in the Late Nineteenth and Early Twentieth Centuries', doi
  131. (1918). The Railwaymen: A Study of Worker Demands and Strike Agitation,
  132. (1915). The Sequel of the South Wales Coal Strike and its Significance', doi
  133. (1919). THE SOLDIERS' doi
  134. The South Wales Race Riots of 1919',
  135. The Stockholm Conference of 1917', doi
  136. The strike breaking organisation of the British government and Black Friday',
  137. (1917). The Swansea Conference of the British Council of Soldiers and Workers Delegates',
  138. (1916). The Triple Industrial Alliance', doi
  139. (1978). The Unofficial Reform Committee and the Miners' Next Step',
  140. (1971). THE WORKERS
  141. (1980). THE-FED:
  142. (1964). THOMAS: A LIFE FOR UNITY,
  143. (1981). Towards a New View of Co-operatives and Co-operation',
  144. (1987). Trade Union History or the History of Industrial Relations? ' Essay in Review, doi
  145. (1986). Trade union history or the history of industrial relations? ',
  147. (1919). TRADE UNIONISM: doi
  148. (1983). Trade Unions and Job Control: A Critique of 'Rank and Filism ",
  149. Trades Councils During the First World War', doi
  150. Union Democracy: An Explanatory Framework', doi
  151. (1964). Unofficial Reform THE MINERS' NEXT STEP,
  152. (1910). vi) Negotiating machinery South Wales Miners' Federation - South Wales Coalfield Archive,
  153. Wage Bargaining Under Conciliation Agreements, 1860-1914', doi
  154. Wages and Welfare: Trade union Benefits and Industrial Bargaining before the First World War',
  155. (1987). War and Labour Unrest',
  156. (1973). Working Class Leadership in South Wales 1900-201,
  157. (1983). Working Class Politics Regional Study in the the Labour Party, ' Polytechnic,
  159. World War I and State Intervention in Industrial Relations',

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.