Location of Repository

Museums, drama, ritual and power a theory of the museum experience.

By Jemima W. Fraser

Abstract

This thesis presents a new model of the museum visitor experience. My model analyses the dynamic interplay of visually powerful objects in authoritative institutions with the power of visitors to draw upon the knowledge, values and ideals of their own\ud life experience and use the displays as a resource to make and take ownership of\ud meaning. The model shows that the key factors affecting how people make meaning\ud of displays are transaction, ritual, identity and power.\ud I investigate the museum experience through the varied roles visitors adopt, as revealed in written comments made by visitors to my case study museum. I analyse these through a wide range of theory and through using drama as a metaphor for the visitor experience. The museum arranges the objects and spaces in a symbolic performance, leading visitors to engage in aesthetic and social rituals. Through the frames of their interpretive communities, visitors engage intellectually, emotionally and aesthetically in transactions with the objects which modify or reinforce their identities. Visitors' meaning-making is influenced, but not wholly determined, by how well the museum drama works for them. This depends largely not just on the quality of the museum but on how comfortable and familiar visitors are with museum rituals.\ud At its best, the museum drama can engage visitors' emotions and imagination and\ud enable them to experience intellectual, psychological, emotional and perhaps\ud spiritual growth. At its worst, visitors' negative experiences alienate them not just\ud from the museum but from trying such experiences again in the future.\ud In my model, authority, power and the task of creating knowledge are shared between visitors and curators. If the museum embraces this epistemological shift, and recognises the complex transactions of ritua', drama and power, it could enable\ud visitors to experience not just learning but growth, and greatly increase the educational and cultural value of museums

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 2004
OAI identifier: oai:lra.le.ac.uk:2381/4223

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1999). (eds.) Folk Psychology.
  2. (2002). (eds.) Learning Conversations in Museums.
  3. 990. 'Glasgow - a personal view of the city', in Catalyst 3(1):2-4
  4. 999. A Commonwealth - Museums in the Learning Age.
  5. (1995). A Cabinetof Curiosities.
  6. (1901). A Centuiy of Scottish History,
  7. (1995). A Constructivist Approach to Teaching'.
  8. (1997). A Guide through the Theory of Knowledge.
  9. (1994). A Theoi'y and Practice of Teaching.
  10. (2002). A Visitor Centred Hierarchy'
  11. (1993). A Yearning for Learning'.
  12. (1995). Acknowledging Consumption.
  13. (1990). Acts of Meaning.
  14. (1986). Actual Minds, Possible Worlds.
  15. After the Fact. Cambridge,Mass:
  16. (1956). An Educational Experiment 1941-1951. Glasgow: Glasgow City Council Tilley, C.1990. Reading Material Culture.
  17. (2001). Annual Meeting - The Implications of Visitor Meaning Making for Practice in Exhibition Development. Tape of the proceedings.
  18. (1985). Arranging Ethnology :A.H.L.F. Pitt Rivers and the Typological Tradition'
  19. (1934). Art as Experience.
  20. (1991). Art Museums and the Ritual of Citizenship',
  21. (1991). Assessing the National Aquarium in Baltimore's impact on Visitor's conversations, knowledge, attitudes and behaviours'
  22. (2001). Assessment in Early Childhood Settings.
  23. (1988). Audiences: A Sociological Theoty of Performance and Imagination.
  24. (2000). Available Light.
  25. (1998). Balancing Acts: Science, Enola Gay and History Wars at the Smithsonian'
  26. (1963). Behaviourin Public Places.
  27. (1985). Between Theatre andAnthropology.
  28. (1991). Beyond the Glass Case. Leicester:
  29. (1992). Border Crossings.
  30. (1993). Capturing Affective Learning',
  31. (1995). Civilising Rituals. London and
  32. (1988). Cognition in Practice. Cambridge:
  33. (1998). Communities of Practice.
  34. (1995). Constructivism in Education. New Jersey: Lawrence Eribaum Associates,
  35. (1998). Constructivism in Museums: How museums create meaningful learning environments',
  36. (1996). Contemporary' Philosphy of Social Science.
  37. Creating our Future.. .Minding Our Past.
  38. (1992). Culture, contest and cognition',
  39. (1995). Curriculum, multiculturalism and the politics of identity',
  40. (1916). Democracy and Education.
  41. (1998). Destination Culture. California:
  42. (1988). Dewey, Dilthey and Drama: An Essay in the Anthropology of Experience'
  43. (1989). Doing what comes naturally: Change, Rhetoric and the Practice of Theory' in Literary' and Legal studies.
  44. (1974). Dramas, Fields and Metaphors.
  45. (1991). Editors introduction. In G. Salomon (ed) Distributed Cognitives: Psychological and Educational Considerations. Cam bridge:
  46. Educational Psychology:A Cognitive View.
  47. (1996). Educators on Exhibition Teams: a New Role, a New Era',
  48. (1996). Effective Learning Activities.
  49. (1980). Encoding and Decoding'
  50. (1993). Enhancing museum learning by facilitating the visitor social agenda',
  51. (1983). Ethnography; Principles in Practice,
  52. (1995). Ethnography: Principles and Practice,
  53. (1975). Exhibiting Cultures - the Poetics and Politics of Museum Display. Washington,DC :The Smithsonian Institution:
  54. (1991). Exhibiting Intention: Some Preconditions of the Visual Display of Culturally Purposeful Objects',
  55. (1938). Experience and Education.
  56. (1986). Experience and its Expressions'
  57. (1994). Extending the Frame: Forging a new Partnership with the Public',
  58. (1970). FaIl of Public Man.
  59. (1994). Family behaviour and learning in informal science settings: A review of the research'.
  60. (1993). Fictions of Collective Life: Public Drama in Late Modem Culture.
  61. (1987). Field of Drama.
  62. (1980). Field Research: A Sourcebook and Field Manual.
  63. (1997). Finding Flow.
  64. (1946). Fmm Max Weber Essays in Sociology.
  65. Folk Songs of Great Britain, vol 8. A Soldier's Life for Me. Topic records 1961 Forgacs,
  66. (1974). Frame Analysis.
  67. (1977). Frame, Flow and Reflection'
  68. (1994). Framing the Authence for Theatre', in R.Keat, N.Whitleey and N. Abercrombie (eds). The Authoñty of the Consumer,
  69. (1997). From Knowledge to Narrative. Washington,DC: The Smithsonian Institution.
  70. (1982). From Ritual to Theatre.
  71. (1988). G.H.Mead , 'Socialism and the Progressive Agenda'
  72. (1999). Gender Trouble. London: Routledge
  73. (2000). Getty Museum and the Getty Center for Education in the Arts
  74. (2002). Globalization and its discontents New York: Penguin
  75. (1998). go's Summai'y Report
  76. (1987). Growing into Rules'
  77. (1978). Habitats, Envimnments and Human Behaviour.
  78. (1985). Hegemony and Socialist Strategy. London:Verso Press
  79. (1989). Heritage as Media: Some Implications for Research',
  80. (1996). Historical Survey of Theories of Learning'
  81. (1976). History of Sexuality: An Introduction.
  82. (1994). Human Memoiy and Cognition. New York: HarperCollins College Publishers. Audi, R.1 998. Epistemology— A Contemporary Introduction to the Theoty of Knowledge.
  83. (1936). Ideology and Utopia
  84. (1977). Image -Music-Text.
  85. (1983). Imagined Communities,
  86. (1994). Impact on the Research of the Approach to the Visiting Public at the Natural History Museum London'
  87. (1999). Intelligence Reframed.
  88. (1983). Intentionality: An Essay in the Philosophy of Mind New York :Cambndge Serrel, B.
  89. (1994). Interpreting Objects and Collections.
  90. (1993). Interpreting Qualitative Data.
  91. (1996). Into the heart of irony: ethnographic exhibitions and the politics of difference',
  92. (1995). Intrinsic motivation in museums: What makes visitors want to learn?'
  93. (1963). Invitation to Sociology.
  94. (1980). Is There a Text in This Class? The Authority of Interpretive Communities.
  95. (2000). John Dewey's Expenence and Education: Lessons for Museums' in Curator4lll: 36-49
  96. (1976). Keywords: A Vocabulaiy of Culture and Society.
  97. (1996). Knowledge as Culture. London and
  98. (2000). Learning from Museums.
  99. (1998). Learning in the Museum. London and
  100. (1971). Lenin and Philisophy and other Essays,
  101. (1983). Local Knowledge.
  102. (2002). Looking Through the Glass: Reflections of Identity',
  103. (1993). Making Meaning Together: Lessons from the Field of American History',
  104. (1999). Meaning Making Matters: Communication, Consequences and Exhibit Design',
  105. (1997). Meaningful Learning in Science. The human constructivist perspective',
  106. (1934). Mind, Self and Society.
  107. (1991). Modernity
  108. (1993). Multiple Intelligences.
  109. (1998). Museum Theatre. Portsmouth N.H.
  110. (1992). Museums and Communities',
  111. (1991). Museums and MulticuRuralism',
  112. (2000). Museums and the Interpretation of Visual Culture.
  113. (1994). Museums and their Visitors. London: Routledge Hooper-Greenhill,
  114. (2003). Museums, Libraries and Archives formerly Re-source,
  115. (2003). Museums, national, postnational and transcultural identities'
  116. (2002). Museums, Society, Inequality. London and New York: Routledge Saussure, F.de.
  117. Noodling Around',
  118. (1987). Object de religion, objets de musee, Museologie et Ethnologie. Notes et Documents des Musees de France 16. Paris: Reunion des Musees Nationaux.
  119. (1988). of the Self', in
  120. (1990). Of us and other 'things': the content and functions of talk by adult visitor pairs in an art and history museum. Unpublished dissertation,
  121. (1989). Oh, Yes, They Do: How Museum Visitors Read Labels and Interact with Exhibit Texts',in Curator 32/3:
  122. (2000). On Identity. Tr. By Barbara
  123. On the Principles of Classification adopted in the Arrangement of his Anthropological Collections, now exhibited in the Bethnal Green Museum',
  124. (1977). Outline of a Theotyof Practice, Cambridge: Cambndge University Press. First published
  125. (1990). Outside Literature.
  126. (1999). Paying Attention: Visitors and Museum Exhibits.
  127. (1985). Performance Contexts in Historical Perspective',
  128. (1988). Performing Ethnography' in Turner,V.(ed) The Anthropology of Perfoirnance. Baltimore,USA:The John Hopkins
  129. (1934). Play, the Game and the Generalised Other',
  130. (1992). Post Industnal Lives. London:Sage Publications.
  131. (2002). Poststructuralism Oxford:
  132. (1986). Pragmatism and Social Interactionism',
  133. (1993). Preface to The St Mungo Museum of Religious Life and Art.
  134. (1972). Psychology and Epistemology.
  135. Qualitative Data Analysis.
  136. (1996). Qualitative Researching.
  137. (1997). Questioning the Museum Narrative',
  138. (1996). Questions of Cultural Identity.
  139. (1991). Reflections on the Origins and Spread of Nationalism,
  140. (2000). Religion in Modem Europe. Oxfo d:
  141. (1932). Remembering: A Study in Experimental and Social Psychology. Cambridge:
  142. (1997). Representation :Cultural Representation and Signifying Practices,.
  143. (1985). Reverence, association and education: Testing a typology of museum goer needs. Un pubhshed MS
  144. Role: Personality and Social Structure',
  145. (1995). Sense making in Organisations.
  146. (1994). Serious Earth'
  147. (1991). Situated Learning: Legitimate Peripheral Participation. Cambridge:
  148. (1998). Situated motivation and informal learning',
  149. (1992). Smart Schools, Better Thinking and Learning for Every Child.
  150. (1993). Smithsonian Institution Press:1-19 Katriel,T.
  151. (2000). Social and Cultural Anthropology.
  152. (1995). Social Construction and the Educational Process'
  153. (1954). Sociocultural Knowledge in Conversational Inference',
  154. (2003). Speech delivered at the Royal Scottish Academy of Music and Drama
  155. Steps to an Ecology of Mind.
  156. (1970). Strategic Interaction.
  157. (1973). Structuralism. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul. First published
  158. (2002). Taking a Wider View of Museum Outcomes and Experiences: Theory, Research and Magic'.
  159. (1985). Technologies of the Self: a seminar with Miche!
  160. (1978). The Act of Reading :A Theory of Aesthetic Response Baltimore:John Hopkins
  161. (1977). The Age of Capital,
  162. (1948). The Andaman Islanders,
  163. (1998). The Anti-Aesthetic —Essays on PostModem Culture.
  164. (1998). The Birth of a Museum. London: Routledge Bentley,
  165. (1958). The Blue and Bmwn Books.
  166. (1992). The Communicative Circle: Museums as Communities',
  167. (1989). The Condition of Postmodemity.
  168. (1974). The Construction of Reality in the Child.
  169. (1996). The Culture of Education. Cambridge:
  170. (1979). The Culture of Namissism: American life in an Age of Diminishing Expectations.
  171. (1967). The Discovery of Grounded Theory,
  172. (1993). The Field of Cultural Production,
  173. (1994). The German Art Museum and the History of the Nation'
  174. (2002). The Good Enough Visitor'
  175. (2000). The Image of Christ, London: National Gallery Company Limited distributed by Yale
  176. (1994). The impact of informal education on visitors to museums',
  177. (1992). The Influence of Culture on Learning and Behaviour',
  178. (1973). The Interpretation of Cultures. London:
  179. (1983). The Invention of Tradition, Cambridge:
  180. (1981). The Meaning of Things: Domestic Symbols and the Self. Cambridge:
  181. (2001). The Meaning of Things.
  182. (1974). The Measurement and Facilitation of Learning in the Museum Environment: An Experimental Analysis.
  183. (1992). The Medium is the Museum: on Objects and Logic in Time and Space,'
  184. (1949). The Museum - Its History and Its Tasks in Education. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul Ltd.
  185. (1967). The Museum Age: trans. J. van Nuis Cahill,
  186. (1994). The Museum as Metaphor in 1 9C France'
  187. (1992). The Museum Experience. Washington DC:
  188. (1997). The Museums and the Public. Unpublished lecture,
  189. (1999). The New Fontana Dictionary of Modem Thought.London:HarperCollinsPublishers.
  190. (1970). The Order of Things.
  191. The Origin of the Species by Means of Natural Selection.
  192. (1938). The Philosophy of the Act. Chicago:
  193. (1997). The Poetics and Politics of Exhibiting Other Cultures',
  194. (1994). The politics of identity in late modern society'
  195. (2003). The Positive Philosophy of Auguste Comte. New York: Kessinger Publishing. First published 1855
  196. (1984). The precession of simulacra,
  197. (1988). The Predicament of Culture,
  198. (1959). The Presentation of Se/fin Everyday Life.
  199. (1960). The Process of Education.
  200. (1976). The Rise of Hermeneutics',
  201. (1960). The Rites of Passage. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. First published
  202. (1938). The Rules of Sociological Method. Translated by F.Alcan.
  203. (1907). The School and Society': being three lectures by John Dewey supplemented by a statement of the University Elementary School. Chicago:
  204. (1954). The Science of Learning and the Art of Teaching'
  205. The Scotsman newspaper (1866,
  206. (1999). The Social Constrcution of What? Cambridge,
  207. (1966). The Social Construction of Reality.
  208. (1992). The social construction of scientific concepts, the concept map as conscription device and tools for social thinking in high school science',
  209. (1992). The Social Mind: Language, Ideology and Social Practice.
  210. (1981). The Sociology of Culture.
  211. (1999). The Stories We Tell About Meaning Making',
  212. (1989). The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere, Cambridge,
  213. (1982). The Subject and Power'
  214. (1985). The Symbolic Construction of Community. London and
  215. (1992). The Time Being.
  216. (1991). The Unschooled Mind: How Children Think and How Schools Should Teach.
  217. (1997). The Work of Representation'
  218. The World of Wrestling'
  219. (1994). TheAnthropologyof the Self.
  220. (1992). Think Practically and Act LocallyLanguage and Gender as Community Based Practice'
  221. (1930). Thought andLanguage.
  222. (1996). Thought Styles.
  223. (1982). Toward Transformation in Social Knowledge.
  224. (2004). Towards a Sociology of Learning in Primary Schools',
  225. (1954). Towards a Strategy of Presentation in Museums. Vol.7 No.1:4 Ricouer, P. 'The Narrative Function',
  226. (1991). Transformative Dimensions of Adult Learning. San Francisco:Jossey —Bass Michel,
  227. (2000). Transforming Practice' Selections from the
  228. (1977). Transnationa! Religion and Fading States.
  229. (1975). Truth and Method. New York: Sheed and Ward. First published
  230. (1993). Unholy row over G(asow Museum of Recic i Mueums Journal,
  231. (2002). Unpublished paper given at
  232. (1993). Using visitor behaviour to define the effectiveness of exhibitions,
  233. (1991). Validating a measure of aesthetic development for museums and schools',
  234. (1986). Varieties of Realism: A Rationale for the Natural Sciences.
  235. (2001). Visitor's Interpretive Strategies at Wolverhampton Art Gallery. Leicester: Research Centre for Museums and Galleries.
  236. (1972). Ways of Seeing. The British Broadcasting Corporation and
  237. (2004). What is Cultural Studies Anyway?',
  238. (1979). What's in a Frame? Surface Evidence for Underlying Expectations',
  239. (1999). What's the Object of the Exercise? A Meandering Exploration of the Many Meanings of Objects in Museums',
  240. (2002). When I Grow Up I'd Like To Work In A Place Like This: Museum Professionals Narratives of Early Interest in Museums',
  241. (1992). Why Humans have Cultures.
  242. (2001). Why is Shiva Squashing the Baby? Young Children Visit an Art Galle,y.' Paper presented at the Museums Australia Sixth Annual Conference,
  243. (1997). Young children and museums: The role of cultural content in eatly development of attitudes, beliefs and behaviours'. Visual Arts Research.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.