Location of Repository

Towards a new interpretation of school governors' roles in the 1980s.

By Angela Thody

Abstract

The powers acquired by governors during the 1880s seem to have indicated expectations that governors would control and direct schools' managers. It is suggested instead, that governors developed covert functions predisposing them towards being supportive and protective of the principals and staffs of their schools. Existing education elites\ud absorbed governors and prevented them from becoming contenders for power. Governors concurred with this.\ud \ud The first of governors' covert functions has been termed consent. This confirmed principals' rights to leadership. Consent legitimated headteachers' centrality in policy determination and confirmed the rightness of policies selected by principals. Secondly, governors protect\ud headteachers by providing a forum through which heads referred, and deferred, decisions. Governors also protected\ud heads through deflecting criticisms away from them and towards government and parents. Governors were particularly\ud protective of curricular policies, accepting the professional leadership of teachers concerning the content of education and thus, performing the function of educational protectionism.\ud \ud The belief that governors should become more powerfully involved in school management arose from a renewed emphasis upon the value of accountability. School governing bodies\ud became more representative to make this accountability a reality, but a fourth covert function of governors was to create the illusion of democracy rather than its reality.\ud \ud The explanations for the development of covert functioning are searched for within a framework of structural, political imperatives. The thesis examines the extent to which governors' covert functioning was related to their legal position, their political resources and their political will. Their legal status gave them a powerful\ud position as government but their modes of action made them more like pressure groups. To extend their influence, governors needed to have interests for which they had the\ud political will to bargain and resources critical to the survival of their schools. In the 1980s, governors had neither

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 1990
OAI identifier: oai:lra.le.ac.uk:2381/4209

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1953). (eds) Falmer Press, Lewes Form W.H. and
  2. (1986). (eds) Research in education management and administration.
  3. a curriculum innovation. Centre for Applied Research in Education, Norwich Northants L.E.A.(1986) Guidelines for governors.
  4. (1982). A high price to pay for clerking governing bodies.
  5. (1963). A little democratic anger.
  6. (1984). A question of loyalties. Training Westacott S. materials issued by the Committee of Vice Chancellors' and Principals' Administrative Training Committee.
  7. (1984). A recipe for inaction? Education,
  8. (1983). A study in school government.
  9. (1983). Accountabilit y in education: the role of elected parent and teacher governors of schools and their relationship with their constituencies.
  10. (1980). Accountability in educational organisations - Part 1. Educational Administration,
  11. (1985). Accountability v. Participation? In Hughes H. et al Manain education:the s ystem and the institution. Holt, Rinehart and Winson,
  12. (1980). Accountability, values and schooling
  13. (1926). Address to the North of England Eustace Conference. Reported in TJi.
  14. (1975). Administerin g education:international challena. Athlone Press Hughes M.G.
  15. (1974). Adult education for school government. Adult Education Vol.47 No.1,
  16. (1981). Advice notes for school governors.
  17. (1980). Ahandbook for school governors.
  18. American educational reform and government power. Paper presented at B.E.M.A.S. Annual Conference,
  19. Annual Parents' 1987/1988 - John Cleveland Colle Meetings Hinckley, Leics.; Sir Jonathan North Community College,
  20. (1988). Annual Parents' Meetings. Management in Education,
  21. (1987). Annual Reports to Parents
  22. (1961). Aspirations of power; people and agency goals. Social Work,
  23. (1989). Attracted by the company perks.
  24. (1987). British politics and the policy
  25. (1977). Bureaucracy or participation:the logic of organisation. Sage
  26. (1982). Calling education to account.
  27. (1973). Circular 7/70 and the government of schools. Educational Administration Bulletin,
  28. (1984). Cmnd. 9242 Parents Meetings(1988) Parents' Meetings. The dangers of excessive mutual support.
  29. (1977). Co-management of the school system - a case study of teacher representation on school governing and managing bodies.
  30. (1981). Communities and their schools.
  31. (1984). Community action and community schooling: the campaign to save Croxteth Comprehensive. In Wa].ford G. (ed) Schoolin g in turmoil.
  32. (1984). Community education as a movement towards real democrav.
  33. (1968). Consent. freedom and political organisation.
  34. (1980). Cororateness and education: chanin cower relationships in local government. Sheffield City Polytechnic Johnson I.
  35. (1984). Council Research Studies, MacMillan Macbeth A. et a].
  36. (1975). Courses for school governors.
  37. (1982). Cultural and economic reproduction in education:essavs on class. ideology and the state. Routledge and Kegan
  38. (1973). Deanhouse, Oakhill, Stokeon-Trent Greenfield T.B.
  39. (1974). Democratic theory and local governmeiit. Allen and Unwin Hinds T.
  40. (1982). Develo pment and directions in school government.
  41. (1975). Diocese of Leicester
  42. (1981). Disjointed incremental opportunism and the reconstruction of reality.
  43. (1983). Education in the eighties:the central issues. Batsford Howell D.A.
  44. (1981). Education. politics and the state.
  45. (1988). Education(No.2) Act. 1986:Section 30: L.E.A. Governors' Annual Re p ort to Parents.
  46. (1979). Educational policies in perspective an app raisal of OECD countries' educational policy reviews. OECD Paris Kogan M.(ed)
  47. (1981). Educational politics; a model for their analysis.
  48. (1976). Evaluating educational programs: problems and prospects.
  49. (1977). Evaluation research methods.
  50. (1964). Exchan ge and rower in social life.
  51. (1989). Firm's bid to change curriculum challenged.
  52. for the Advancement University of York of State Education Mill J.S. (1859)(1910) On re presentative overnmeut. Everyman Edition,
  53. (1978). Formalised parent participation in education. A caizzparative perspective.
  54. Forum Television Galton H.(1989) Curriculum p rovision in small Patrick H. schools. Ch.7 Parents, governors and the local authority. Routledge and Kegan
  55. (1968). Function of a bureaucratic ideology: citizen participation.
  56. (1989). Getting to the bottom of things: a headmaster's view of his changing role.
  57. (1977). Governing schools - has Taylor got and
  58. (1977). Governing schools. Has the Taylor Report got the balance right? educational Administration,
  59. (1989). Governor trainin g ro.ject -ettin started Audio-cassette study pack.
  60. (1983). Governor training. Adult Education June, Vol.56, No.1 pp.44-49 (1984a) Can we learn from the Samaritans? Education,
  61. (1979). Governor's guide. Home and
  62. (1988). Governors' re ports and Annual Parents' Meetins:the
  63. (1989). Governors' visits to schools.
  64. (1962). Handbook of evaluation research.
  65. (1970). Handbook of Organisations. Rand Mcnally,
  66. (1973). Headmasters and schools: some preliminary findings. Sociological Review,
  67. (1984). I have a solution..." -Administrative power in a school meeting. Educational Administration Quarterly ,
  68. (1971). Imlementin oranisational innovation: Giaquinta J.B. a socioloioal anal ysis of planned Bernstein H. educational change.
  69. (1964). In defence of politics.
  70. (1984). Inside information - evaluating
  71. (1978). Insider groups. outsider groups and interest rou strate g ies in Britain.
  72. (1985). Institution - client relationships International Encyclopaedia of Education, pp.2530-2534, Pergmon,
  73. (1975). Institutional autonomy and public et al accountability.
  74. (1974). Institutionalising conflict response: the case of the school boards. Social Science Quarterly,
  75. (1981). Integrated organisational participation in government.
  76. (1989). Is corporate planning on the agenda?
  77. (1981). Issues in education and
  78. (1969). Issues in participant observation. Simmons J.L.
  79. Jefferies 0. and(1989b) The weight of office.
  80. (1982). Jjgndbook for Labour governors.
  81. (1987). Judgenient. p lanning arid educatiQnaU.Chaflge. Harper and Row Hostrop R.
  82. (1988). Keeping governors in the family.
  83. (1984). Learning from experience -Lavelle M. problems and princip les of develoin an INSET course. Sheffield Papers in Education Management, Sheffield Polytechnic Crick B.
  84. (1989). Learning to trust. T.E.S,
  85. Leicesterhire (1988a) Training for governors.
  86. (1985). Local Government Policy Studies, May/June,
  87. (1980). Management develo pment and management performance. Sheffield Papers in Education Management.
  88. (1982). Management development for the education profession. Harrap Glatter R.
  89. (1975). Management education: a conceptual framework. In
  90. (1984). Management in comprehensive schools - what can be learned from industry?
  91. (1975). Management in education. Reader L The management of organisations and individuals. Ward Lock
  92. (1989). Managing for quality and accountability in Western Australian education.
  93. (1989). Managing quality education. Paper B.E.M.A.S. Annual Leicester, Sept. in 're-formed' presented at Conference,
  94. (1987). McKechin W.J.
  95. (1960). McNay I. and
  96. (1962). Micropolitics of educational organ isat ions.
  97. (1975). Models of participation in the school system of the German Federal Republic.
  98. (1978). Much to do about education.
  99. (1986). Northants L.E.A.(1987a) School governor trpining:pilot scheme evaluation.
  100. (1966). Obligation and consent -
  101. (1960). Obligation and the bod y politic.
  102. (1970). olitics. power and olicv: the overnin of local school districts.
  103. (1977). Oranisational participation in government.
  104. (1973). Organisation theory: some themes and distinctions. In Salaman G. and Thompson K.(eds), Peop le and oranisations. Longmans/
  105. (1977). Organising educational insitutions as anarchies.
  106. (1970). ountabilitv in the English educational system. Hodder and
  107. (1989). Outsiders come inside.
  108. (1983). Parental involvement in school policy making. Educational Management and Administration, Vol.11, No.2,
  109. (1987). Parents vote for teacher power.
  110. (1986). Participation and popular control on school governing bodies: the case of the Taylor Report and its aftermath.
  111. (1983). Participation councils in Italy. Paper presented at Conference on the school and the family in the European Community.
  112. (1982). Participation in school organisation.
  113. (1983). Participation: accountability's neglected dimension? Educational Management and Administration, Vol.11, No.1,
  114. (1974). Participation. accountabilit y and Parkes D. (eds) decision making at institution level.
  115. (1981). Patterns of authority and autonomy in three junior schools.
  116. (1971). Patterns of Power and Authority in En glish Education. Methuen (undated) A trainin g package. N.A.G.M.
  117. (1988). Pergamon Devon County
  118. (1975). Permuting the relating game of governors and governed Education,
  119. (1967). Persectives on curriculum et al evaluation.
  120. (1974). Pitfalls of management development
  121. (1982). Policies for educational Eraut M. and accountability.
  122. (1976). Policy issues in education. and
  123. (1979). Political obligation and conceptual analysis.
  124. (1981). Politics and educational change.
  125. (1985). Politics in Eng land. 4th edition Faber
  126. (1883). Power in and around oranisations Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J. Miskel C.B.
  127. (1985). Press Governing schools: powers. issues and practice. Macmillan Governors, accountability and parents. W.E.A., Leicestershire
  128. (1983). pressure group arena. Local Government Policy Studies,
  129. (1981). Problems of school government.
  130. (1979). Procedural democracy.
  131. (1984). Questions governors
  132. (1988). Re port on school governor training prolects in ten L.E.As suorted by Education Suort Grants.
  133. (1986). Reassessing the roles of teachers parents and governors.
  134. (1978). Reforming school politics Harvard Educational Review Vol.48 No.4,
  135. (1977). Reoranisin education:manaement and participation for change.
  136. (1989). Report on a survey conducted in June and
  137. (1988). Representative democracy and its limits.
  138. (1977). Reproduction in education. society and Passeron
  139. (1970). Research Group, Exeter Society for Curriculum Studies, Fair Way Publications Goldstein H. and(1988) A note on national assessment and Cuttance P. school comparisons.
  140. (1981). Research in education management
  141. (1983). Rethinking educational policy and management.
  142. (1988). ridin the rules. Lawrence and Wishart
  143. (1974). Royal Commision on Local Government, Research Studies 6, H.M.S.O.
  144. (1985). School effects in Scottish secondary Cuttance P. schools.
  145. School governing bodies and lay participation.
  146. (1988). School governing bodies and the
  147. (1986). School governor trainin g 1986 -a survey of current L.E.A.
  148. (1987). School governor training p ilot scheme evaluatin.
  149. (1987). School governors and L.E.As:two disputes in the context of leg islative chan ge.
  150. (1988). School governors and parent power.
  151. (1981). School governors. Councils
  152. (1968). School management and government.
  153. (1977). School Managers and Governors: Taylor and After. Ward Lock Sallis J
  154. (1983). School overnin bodies proiect 1980-1983. Final Re port to the D.E.S.. Educational Studies Unit,
  155. (1981). School Self-evaluation:accountabilitv with a human face. Schools Council
  156. (1976). School systems and their clients, school governors in Sheffield. Trends
  157. (1988). Schools. parents and governors.
  158. (1980). Sharing it out: the role of the head in participatory government. In
  159. (1989). Shining examples. T.E.S.,No..3805, 2nd June, p.B2B (1989b) The spice of life.
  160. (1984). Snapshots of the relationship between a school and its governing body. In Goulding S. et al (eds) Case studies in education management
  161. (1979). Social Orig ins of Educational Systems.
  162. (1954). Social stratification in voluntary organisations.
  163. (1986). Standards and the L.E.A. :the accountability f schools.
  164. (1988). Starting from scratch.
  165. (1981). Studies of organisation and their implications for accountability in education:
  166. (1987). Surve y of governors' Annual L.E.A. Reports to Parents and Annual Parents' Meetin gs.
  167. (1985). Sustaining vigorous educational institutions in a period of retrenchment. In Hughes H. et al, Manain education:the s ystem and the institution.
  168. (1976). Tacit consent and political obligation.
  169. (1984). Taken for granted? Lookin g at schools as organisations. Longman Handy C.B.
  170. (1983). Talk as the work: the accomplishment of school administration.
  171. (1987). Teacher governors. M.Ed thesis, unpublished. University of Le icester Peschek D. and (1966) Policies and politics j secondary Brand J.A. education. Greater London Papers,
  172. (1984). That uncertain something.
  173. (1980). the balance right? Educational Administration Vol.6, No.1,
  174. The dangers of excessive mutual support.
  175. (1969). The definition of organisational goals.
  176. (1962). The effects of supervisors' training courses in changing supervisors' perceptions and expectations of the role of management.
  177. (1989). The exercise of power.
  178. (1971). The governmental p rocess, 2nd Ed.
  179. (1965). The grouP basis of politics.
  180. (1980). The local government of middle schools: governing bodies and the problems of middle school identity.
  181. (1989). The lone rangers. Education,
  182. (1982). The management of educational institutions - theory . research and consultancv. Falmer Press,
  183. (1981). The managerial behaviour of high Willower D.J. school principals.
  184. (1982). The micropolitical dimension in school evaluation and accountabilty in England and Wales. Com pare,
  185. (1985). The new educational consensus.
  186. (1988). The new governing class.Education 17th Feb.,
  187. (1974). The new governor's guide.
  188. (1987). The new governors.
  189. (1989). The new post -88 thinking takes shape Education,
  190. (1977). The political context of urban education. Open University/Ward Lock
  191. (1976). The politics of administrative representation.
  192. The politics of education.
  193. (1986). The politics of school management. Hodder and Stoughton Hoyle E.
  194. (1969). The power and functions of boards of directors: a theoretical synthesis.
  195. (1980). The pp licv-mpking process Prentice-Hall, Englewood-Cliffs,
  196. (1989). The Qualit y of school governor training INS/12/357
  197. (1988). The relationshi p between Church of Eng land schools and their parish churches.
  198. (1984). The role and power of pressure groups.
  199. (1983). The role of secondar y school gvernors from St. Au gustine to Taylor.
  200. (1976). The role of the head. Routledge and Kegan Paul
  201. (1978). The school governor's and manager's handbook and trainin g guide. N.A.G.M. Kogan Page
  202. (1981). The school in an oranisational Wallin E. perspective.
  203. (1980). The school in its setting:a et al guide to the education service for school governors and
  204. (1983). The sociolov of school oranisation.
  205. (1980). The structuring of organisational structures.
  206. (1973). The study of schools as organisations.
  207. (1976). The theory of p luralist democracy.
  208. (1983). The utilization of evaluation.
  209. (1989). The weight of office.
  210. (1986). Theories of education management. Harper and Row Carspecken P.
  211. (1986). Theory about organisations: a new perspective and its implications for schools. In
  212. Those annual parents' meetings.
  213. (1989). Towards a charter for public education. Paper presented at B.E.M.A.S.
  214. (1987). Training courses for school governors - towards a vocational curriculum. Curriculum,
  215. (1987). Training school governors.
  216. (1980). unpublished consultation paper (1980a) Scottish School Cpuncils:policy making . p articipation or irrelevance? HHSO,
  217. (1975). Very hostile takeovers.
  218. Vol 32, No.6, pp.207-212 Forum Television(1988) Sendin power. Video and Booklet - resource pack.
  219. (1985). Where are the parents coining from? Forum,
  220. (1982). Who are the governors now?
  221. (1976). Who controls the schools? In Ormstein
  222. (1983). Why teachers are justifying their seat on the board.
  223. (1976). William Tvndale. Allen and Unwin
  224. (1978). Work Organisations:Resistance Control. Longman Salancik G.R.
  225. (1982). Working together:training exercises for governors, heads and teachers in rimarv and secondary
  226. (1988). You are a governor.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.