Location of Repository

Cicero\u27s De Legibus: Law and Talking Justly Toward a Just Community

By Amy H Kastely

Abstract

In De Legibus, Marcus, as the principal speaker and stand-in for Cicero, describes law as right reason, as the selection of justice within a community. Most modem readers have concluded that this description is based on the belief that there is an immutable human nature and a transcendent order in the universe that dictates right reason and thus determines specific rules of law. And since this belief is said to rest on psychological and theological assumptions that are rejected in modem thought, the dialogue, Cicero\u27s principal work on the nature of law, is not considered to be of much current interest. But the text of De Legibus does not support this reading of Cicero\u27s legal views. Indeed, the standard interpretation depends upon lifting parts of the speeches made in this dialogue and in De Republica out of context and treating them as abstract statements of Cicero\u27s legal theory. Ironically, De Legibus itself, in its opening passage, anticipates and refutes this reading. The dialogue specifically denies any claim to objective truth, and its conception of law does not depend upon any notion of the essential character of human beings or a divine order in the universe. Instead, the dialogue argues for a view of law as public discourse about justice, and it presents this view as a rhetorical construct, valuable for the purpose of ethical and political action. In the following pages, I offer a reading of De Legibus that focuses on its treatment of law as a \u22discoursive\u22 practice and takes seriously its self-presentation as a rhetorical construct. My hope is that this reading will make Cicero\u27s rhetorical view of law more available to modem readers. At the end of the essay, I suggest some ways this view may contribute to current jurisprudential discussion

Topics: Arts and Humanities, History, Law
Publisher: Yale Law School Legal Scholarship Repository
Year: 2013
OAI identifier: oai:digitalcommons.law.yale.edu:yjlh-1043
Download PDF:
Sorry, we are unable to provide the full text but you may find it at the following location(s):
  • http://digitalcommons.law.yale... (external link)
  • http://digitalcommons.law.yale... (external link)
  • Suggested articles


    To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.