Location of Repository

An assessment of the impact of environmental factors on the quality of post-mortem DNA profiling.

By Dalugama Mudiyanselage Don Dimuth Nilanga Gunawardane

Abstract

DNA profiling has ignited public interest and consequently their expectations for the capabilities of forensic criminal and science investigations. The prospect of characterising the genetic makeup of individuals or trace samples from a wide variety of depositional and post-mortem circumstances raises the question of how reliable the methods are given the potential for prolonged exposure to variation in environmental factors, i.e. temperature, pH, UV irradiation and humidity, that are known to induce damage to DNA. Thus, it is crucial to verify the validity of the DNA profiling for characterising the genetic makeup of post-mortem tissues. This project aimed to assess the reliability of sequence and microsatellite based genotyping of tissues (muscle, hair and bone) sampled from carcasses over a two year post-mortem period. This assessment investigated the impact of environment induced DNA degradation in the local geographic region that is typical of the circumstances that confront forensic practitioners in southern Australia and to utilise rigorous controls by studying animals whose time of death and burial was known and for which we had pre-decay tissue samples available. A ‘body farm’ with 12 pig carcasses on the northern Adelaide plains, ~60km north of Adelaide, which has a typical southern Australian Mediterranean climate, i.e. cold wet winters and hot dry summers. Pigs (Sus scrofa) were used as an experimental analogue for human subjects because of the logistical and ethical reasons. The pig carcasses were allocated among three treatments: four were left on the surface, four were buried at 1m depth, and four were buried at 2 m depth. These ‘burial’ conditions mimic a range of conditions encountered typically in forensic and archaeological studies. Cortical bone samples were taken from each pig carcass at one week, one month, three months, six months, one year and two years post-mortem and muscle and hair over the same sampling period for as long as those tissue types were present. A set of PCR primers to amplify two (short and a long) fragments from the hypervariable part of the mitochondrial control region (HVRI) that is used in forensic and evolutionary studies of humans and many other mammal species were developed. Also a panel of four pig microsatellite loci with fluorescent labels to facilitate automated multiplex genotyping. These loci matched as closely as possible the core motifs and allele lengths typical of the commercially available microsatellite marker kits used in Australian forensic science labs so that our experiments were as good a model as possible of the human forensic DNA technology. In this study it was possible to retrieve samples from muscle tissue up to 90 days, hair up to one year and bone at two years post-mortem. The analyses showed that the long and short HVRI region PCR fragments were only amplifiable up to 30 days from muscle tissue and that these fragments were amplifiable up to one year from hair. In contrast, in cortical bone both PCR fragments were amplifiable up to two years. The long fragment disappeared in muscle tissue completely after 30 days and in hair after six months. However, the long fragment was present in cortical bone even at two years. Overall, there was a general trend of loss of concentration of both the long and short fragments over time. Comparisons of the HVRI nucleotide sequences among tissues sampled from individual animals showed substitution changes in muscles as early as 30 days (3 out of 6 individuals) and hair at six months (1 out of 6 individuals). In contrast, in cortical bone substitutions first appeared at 365 days (1 out of 6 individuals). The most common substitution observed in all tissues types was the C-T transition, with A-G transversions observed in two episodes and C-A transversion observed in one episode. Analyses of microsatellite genotypes in muscle tissues showed high allele peaks on chromatograms up to day seven samples. However, by three months PCR was not successful from muscle tissue. While, bone tissue had lower allele peak heights compared to the muscle tissues, alleles were detectable up to six months. Allele drop out occurred for one animal (at 2 meters) in muscle tissue at the dinucleotide locus and for another animal (kept on surface) also in muscle tissue at a tetranucleotide locus. Stuttering was observed for a single animal at dinucleotide locus in muscle tissue (buried sample 2 meter depth). No stuttering or allele drop outs were seen in the bone tissue. Overall the four loci completely disappeared after 30 days in muscle tissue and after 180 days in bone tissue. In summary, analyses showed that post-mortem DNA degradation was present in all the three tissue types (muscle, hair and bone). The types of damage identified were DNA fragmentation, nucleotide substitutions and DNA loss, which resulted in a diminished frequency of successful PCR for mitochondrial and nuclear markers over time and stuttering and allele drop out in microsatellite genotyping. In addition, two nucleotide substitutions were concentrated in ‘hotspots’ that correlate with sites of elevated mutation rate in vivo. Also the frequency of successful PCR of longer nuclear and mitochondrial PCR products declined markedly more quickly than for shorter products. These changes were first observed at much shorter post mortem intervals in muscle and much longer post mortem intervals in hair and bone tissue. When considering the carcass deposition treatments, tissues that were retrieved from buried carcases showed higher levels of DNA degradation compared to tissues retrieved from carcases left on the surface. Overall, muscle tissue is a good source for DNA analysis in immediate post mortem samples, whereas hair and bone tissue are good source for DNA analysis from older samples. When comparing the microsatellite genotyping and mtDNA analyses, mtDNA is a reliable source for DNA analysis from tissue recovered from bodies that had decayed for longer post-mortem durations such as months to years, whereas microsatellite genotyping gives reliable results for tissue from shorter post mortem intervals (hours to few days). Therefore it is recommended that when analysing mtDNA sequences, cloning and sequencing PCR products can help to identify the base pair substitutions especially for tissue retrieved from longer post mortem intervals. In addition, increasing the template DNA concentrations and "neutralising" co-extracted DNA inhibitors should be considered when dealing with tissue from longer post mortem intervals. Finally, the more stringent protocols used in ancient DNA studies should be considered when dealing with tissue with much longer post mortem intervals in forensic settings.Thesis (Ph.D.) -- University of Adelaide, School of Medical Sciences, 200

Topics: DNA; DNA profiling; DNA degradation; DNA decay; environmental effects, DNA fingerprinting -- Australia., Forensic anthropology -- Australia., Forensic genetics -- Technique., DNA -- Analysis.
Year: 2009
OAI identifier: oai:digital.library.adelaide.edu.au:2440/51067

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1989). A computer program for choosing optimal oligonucleotides for filter hybridization, sequencing and in vitro amplification of DNA." doi
  2. (1997). A preliminary investigation of DNA stability in bone during artificial diagenesis."
  3. (1998). A procedure for cloning genomic DNA fragments with increasing thermoresistance." doi
  4. (1999). A time course study on STR profiles derived from human bone, muscle and bone marrow."
  5. (1995). Abundance and characterisation of simple-sequence repeats (SSRs) isolated from a size fractionated genomic library of Brassica napus L. (rapeseed)." doi
  6. (1986). Analysis of restriction fragment length polymorphisms in deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) recovered from dried blood stains."
  7. (2002). Ancent DNA in Anthropology: Methods, Applications, and Ethics."
  8. (1989). Ancient DNA : extraction, characterisation, molecular cloning and enzymatic amplification." doi
  9. (2000). Ancient DNA analysis of human populations." doi
  10. (2000). Ancient DNA: Do it right or not at all." doi
  11. (1994). Ancient DNA: methodological challenges." doi
  12. (2005). Ancient DNA." doi
  13. (1986). Application of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) polymorphisms to the analysis of DNA recovered from sperm."
  14. (2004). Assigning African elephant DNA to geographic region of origin: Application to the ivory trade." doi
  15. (2003). Characterization of genetic miscoding lesions caused by postmortem damage." doi
  16. (1993). Characterization of porcine polymorphic microsatellite loci." doi
  17. (2007). Climate Services.
  18. (2003). Distribution patterns of post-mortem damage in human mitochondrial DNA."
  19. (2003). DNA analysis of neonatal human remains wrapped and kept in a vinyl bag for 15 years." doi
  20. (1996). DNA damage and DNA sequence retrieval from ancient tissues." doi
  21. (1990). DNA damage promotes jumging between templates during enzymatic amplification."
  22. (2002). DNA decay rate in papyri and human remains from Egyptian archaeological sites." doi
  23. (2006). DNA degradation in avian faecal samples and feasibility of non-invasive genetic studies of threatened capercaillie populations." doi
  24. (1992). DNA fingerprinting -An introduction.
  25. (1997). DNA fingerprints from fingerprints."
  26. (1999). DNA preservation: a microsatellite-DNA study on ancient skeletal remains." doi
  27. (2007). DNA rewiews: the national DNA database of the United Kingdom." Forensic Sci. doi
  28. (2001). DNA sequences from multiple amplifications reveal artifacts induced by cytosine deamination in ancient DNA." doi
  29. (1993). DNA typing with fluorescently tagged short tandom repeat."
  30. (1994). Dried samples: Body fluids. Ancient
  31. (2008). Dryland cropping soils of South Australia.
  32. (1985). Enzymatic amplification of beta-globin genomic sequences and restriction site analysis for diagnosis of sickle cell anemia." doi
  33. (1995). Experiments in Taphonomy." doi
  34. (1992). Ferric-iron-photosensitized damage to DNA by hydroxyl and non-hydroxyl radical mechanisms." doi
  35. (2005). Forensic DNA Typing. London, doi
  36. (1996). Forensic Pathology. doi
  37. (1997). Genetic individualization of domastic cats using feline STR loci for forensic applications."
  38. (2004). Genetic variation in an endermic salamander, Salamandra atra, using amplified fragment length polymorphism." Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution doi
  39. (2000). Genetics: From Genes to Genomes. Boston, The McGraw-Hill Companies,
  40. (1998). Genetics: principles and analysis.
  41. (2002). Genomic microsatelittes as evolutionary chronometers: A test in wild cats." doi
  42. (1996). Heteroplasmic point mutations in the human mtDNA Control Region."
  43. (2006). Histological correlates of post mortem mitochondrial DNA damage in degraded hair." Forensic Sci. doi
  44. (1986). Human blood stain identification and sex determination in dried blood stains using recombinant DNA techniques." doi
  45. (2003). Human molecular biology: an introduction to the molecular basis of health and disease. Cambridge, doi
  46. (1985). Hypervariable 'minisatellite" regions in human DNA." doi
  47. (1995). Identification of bodies from the scene of a mass disaster using DNA amplification of short tandem repeat (STR) loci." doi
  48. (1994). Identification of the remains of the Romanov family by DNA analysis." doi
  49. (1992). Identification of the skeletal remains of Josef Mengele by DNA analysis." doi
  50. (1985). Individual specific finger prints of human DNA."
  51. (1993). Instability and decay of the primary structure of DNA." doi
  52. (2001). Microsatellite stability in human post-mortem tissues." doi
  53. (1999). Microsatellites identify introduced New Zealand tammar wallabies (Macropus eugenii) as an 'extinct' taxon." doi
  54. (2002). Microsatellites: genomic distribution, putative functions and mutational mechanisms: a review." doi
  55. (2000). Minisatellites: mutability and genome architecture." doi
  56. (2003). Molecular analyses of the pharaos: feasibility of molecular studies in ancient Egyptian material." doi
  57. (1997). Multiplex PCR: Critical parameters and stepby-step protocol."
  58. (2001). Mutations induced by 5-formyl-2'-deoxyuridine in Escherichia coli include base substitutions that can arise from mispairs of 5-formyluracil with guanine, cytosine and thymine." doi
  59. (2007). Novel high-resolution characterization of ancient DNA reveals C> U-type base modifications events as the sole cause of post mortem miscoding lesions." doi
  60. (1992). Oxidative damage to DNA in mammalian chromatin." doi
  61. (1998). Population data for 1001 Austrian Caucasian mitochondrial DNA d-loop sequences: application of mtDNA sequence analysis to a forensic case." doi
  62. (2005). Post-mortem DNA damage hotspots in Bison (Bison bison) provide evidence for both damage and mutational hotspots in human mitochondrial DNA." doi
  63. (1988). Postmortem stability of DNA." doi
  64. (1998). Pretreatment with restriction enzyme or bovine serum albumin for effective PCR amplification of Epstein-Barr virus DNA in DNA extracted from paraffin-embedded gastric carcinoma tissue."
  65. (1999). Removal of a PCR inhibitor and resolution of DNA STR types in mixed human-canine stains from a five year old case."
  66. (2006). Resistance of degraded hair shafts to contaminant DNA." Forensic Sci. doi
  67. (1995). Short tandem repeats typing of bodies from a mass disaster: high success and characteristicn amplification patterns in highly degraded samples."
  68. (2005). Short tandom repeat (STR) genotyping of keratinised hair Part 2. An optimised genomic DNA extraction procedure reveals donor dependence of STR profiles." Forensic Sci. doi
  69. (1998). Species identification using genetic tools: the value of nuclear and mitochondrial gene sequences in whale conservation." doi
  70. (2001). Statistical evidence for miscoding lesions in ancient DNA templates." doi
  71. (1997). Sunlight and skin cancer: Another link revealed." doi
  72. (1988). The autodegradation of Deoxyribonucleic Acids (DNA) in human rib bone and its relationship to the time interval since death."
  73. (2003). The development of reduced size STR amplifications as tool for analysis of degraded DNA."
  74. (1998). The mutations induced by oxidatively damaged nucleotides, 5-formyl-dUTP and 5-hydroxy-dCTP, in Escherichia coli." doi
  75. (2000). The personal identification of many samples recovered from under the sea." Forensic Sci. doi
  76. (1996). The retrieval of ancient human DNA sequences."
  77. (2005). The sociogenetic structure of a controlled feral pig population." doi
  78. (1994). The validation of short tandem repeat (STR) loci for use in forensic casework." doi
  79. (2007). Typeability of AmpFISTR SGM Plus loci in brain and thyroid gland tissue samples incubated in different environments." doi
  80. (1991). Typing of Deoxyribonucleic Acid (DNA) extracted from compact bone from human remains."
  81. (1994). Ultraviolet-light-induced free radical formation in skin: an electron paramagnetic resonance study." doi
  82. (1996). Using multiplex PCR amplification and typing kits for the analysis of DNA evidence in a serial killer case."
  83. (1987). Variable number of tandem repeat (VNTR) markers for human gene mapping." doi
  84. (2003). Violent crime index, FBI.
  85. (2000). Weeater's Functional histology.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.