Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Coloured thinking

By Jules B. Davidoff

Abstract

Charles Myers became one of the founding fathers of British psychology (see Costall, 1998) as a result of going on an expedition to the Torres Straits (off New Guinea) organised from Cambridge University. As Richards (1998) wrote, ‘for Myers the Expedition was an epochal experience, deciding him on a psychological career’. However, it is interesting to note the different outcome of that expedition for Myers (and also for Rivers, one of the founders of the BPS) compared with that for McDougall (also a founder of the BPS). McDougall, and hence perhaps his pupil Cyril Burt, saw evidence in their data for the genetic determination of cross-cultural cognitive differences. Myers, and hence perhaps his pupil Frederic Bartlett, saw the methodological impossibility of satisfactorily transferring experimental psychology from the laboratory to the field. Myers realised that their data were unreliable. As Richards wrote of the published work from the expedition, ‘the Reports thus became a virtuoso exercise in the art of writing up unsatisfactory research as positively as possible short of outright dissembling’ (p.145)

Publisher: The British Psychological Society
Year: 2004
OAI identifier: oai:eprints.gold.ac.uk:5109

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. Caramazza,A.,Berndt,R.S.& Brownell,H.H.(1982).The semantic deficit hypothesis:Perceptual parsing and object classification by aphasic patients.Brain and doi
  2. Costall A.(1998).From the ‘pure’ to the ‘applied’:C.S.Myers and
  3. Heider,E.R.& Olivier,D.C.(1972).The structure of the color space in naming and memory for two languages.Cognitive doi
  4. Kay,P.(1969).Basic color terms:Their universality and evolution.Berkeley,CA:University of California doi
  5. Richards,G.(1998).Getting a result:The Expedition’s psychological research 1898–1913.In A.Herle & S.Rouse (Eds.) Cambridge and the Torres Straits (pp.136–157).
  6. Roberson,D.,Davidoff,J.& Braisby,N.(1999).Similarity and categorisation:Neuropsychological evidence for a dissociation in explicit categorisation tasks.Cognition,71, doi
  7. (2004). Roberson,D.,Davies,I.& Davidoff,J.(2000).Colour categories are not universal:Replications and new evidence from a Stone-age culture.
  8. Roberson,D.(1999) Colour categories of a stone-age tribe.Nature,398,203–204;402,604.
  9. Roberson,D.(2004).Preserved thematic and impaired taxonomic categorisation:A case study. doi
  10. Spinnler,H.(1972). Impairment of color sorting behavior after hemispheric damage:An experimental study with the Holmgren Skein Test.Cortex,8,147–163. Goldstein,K.(1948).Language and language disturbances.Ne w York:Grune and Stratton. doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.