Location of Repository

Parent conceptions of their role in early childhood education and care : a phenomenographic study from Queensland, Australia

By Susan Irvine

Abstract

Over past decades, the face of Australian early childhood education and care (ECEC)has changed substantially. It has been shaped by two dominant policy discourses: the discourse of market theory, and, more recently, the discourse of parent and community participation. The intertwining of these two seemingly opposing\ud \ud discourses has led to the positioning of parents both as consumers of ECEC and as participants in ECEC. Each of these perspectives promotes a particular way of fulfilling the role of parent in ECEC. Reflecting general marketing principles, the primary role of parent as consumer is seen as selecting the right service for their child and family. In contrast, while arguably more ambiguous in meaning, the role of\ud \ud parent as participant promotes a partnership approach, and, increasingly, parental\ud \ud involvement in decision making at both service and public policy levels. Each of\ud \ud these roles has been constructed for parents by governments and policymakers, with\ud \ud little reference to the views and experiences of parents using ECEC.\ud \ud \ud \ud Seeking to address this gap in the ECEC knowledge base, the present study investigated the qualitatively different ways in which parents constitute their role in Australian ECEC. The study focused on two related aspects of the role of parents: (1) the role of parents in using ECEC services; and (2) the role of parents in shaping ECEC public policy. To describe these roles, as viewed and experienced by parents, and to reveal possible variation therein, the study engaged a phenomenographic\ud \ud research approach (Bowden & Walsh, 2000; Marton & Booth, 1997).\ud \ud \ud \ud Twenty-six parents participated in the study. Data were gathered through semistructured\ud \ud interviews with individual parents and subjected to a rigorous process of phenomenographic analysis. The study results are presented in two parts. With respect to the role of parents using ECEC, the study led to the construction of five\ud \ud categories of description, denoting five distinctly different ways of seeing and\ud \ud experiencing this role. The role of parents was seen as: (1) selecting and using the\ud \ud best service for their child (the service user conception); (2) knowing what's happening for their child in the service (the informed user conception); (3) paying for a service, and, thereby, enacting certain consumer rights (the consumer conception); (4) supporting their selected service and having some say in what happens for their child at the service (the partnership conception); and (5) working as a member of the service community for the benefit of all concerned, which includes participating in\ud \ud decision making (the member of a service community conception). Taking a broader\ud \ud perspective, the study again revealed variation in how parents constituted their role in\ud \ud shaping ECEC policy, leading to the construction of four categories of description.\ud \ud The role of parents was seen as: (1) no role in shaping ECEC public policy (the no\ud \ud role conception); (2) being informed about policy that affects their child and family,\ud \ud raising any concerns and/or seeking a change to current or proposed policy (the\ud \ud raising concerns conception); (3) having some say in policy matters that affect their\ud \ud child and family (the having some say conception); and (4) participating in policy\ud \ud decision making, particularly where this is likely to affect their child and family (the\ud \ud participating in policy decision making conception).\ud \ud \ud \ud The study highlights variation in how these roles are constituted by parents, inclusive\ud \ud of the basic concepts of parent as consumer and parent as participant. In addition, the\ud \ud study offers an insider perspective on these two "dominant common-sense understandings" (Vincent & Martin, 2000, p. 2) of the role of parents, prompting questions about their future in ECEC policy. As an example of "developmental\ud \ud phenomenography" (Bowden, 2000b, p. 3), the study also identifies factors perceived\ud \ud by parents as influencing their participation at various levels, and discusses implications for both policy and practice. Finally, the study extends the general phenomenographic area of interest, from education to public policy research. Within this area, phenomenography is seen to offer a useful and pragmatic research tool, facilitating the identification and consideration of different constituent views and\ud \ud experiences, and, thereby, signifying more possible options for action

Topics: Early childhood education and care (ECEC), parents, participation, policy, Australia, phenomenography, variation, conceptions, categories of description, outcome space
Publisher: Queensland University of Technology
Year: 2005
OAI identifier: oai:eprints.qut.edu.au:16165

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1989). 1996-97, Parliament of Australia,
  2. (2004). A longitudinal study of learning for a group of Indigenous Australian university students: Dissonant conceptions and strategies.
  3. (2000). A phenomenographic interview on phenomenography.
  4. (1994). A phenomenographical investigation of policing by consent. In
  5. (2000). Achieving empathy and engagement: A practical approach to the design, conduct and reporting of phenomenographic research.
  6. Act 1991, Queensland Legislative Assembly.
  7. Act 2002, Queensland Legislative Assembly.
  8. (1993). Advancing phenomenography:Questions of method. In
  9. (1985). An approach to describing learning as change between qualitatively different conceptions. In
  10. (1997). An ecology of centre-based child care.
  11. (1994). Applying the phenomenographic method to children's experience of learning in the context of an 'alternative school'.
  12. (1997). Are phenomenographic results reliable?
  13. (1993). Australia: Social Science Press.
  14. (2003). Australian Government Report on the April
  15. (2003). Beyond "lesson study": Comparing two ways of facilitating the grasp of some economic concepts.
  16. (2000). Bowling alone: The collapse and revival of American community.
  17. (1995). Care Working Group.
  18. (2000). Child Care and Family Support Hub Strategy (Discussion Paper).
  19. (1991). Child care quality, family background, and children's development.
  20. (1996). Childhood matters: The report on the inquiry into early childhood education.
  21. (1999). Childhood: the apocalyptic vision? In
  22. (1999). Children and Australian social policy. In
  23. (1997). Children, families and communities: Contexts and consequences
  24. (1995). Choice and control in American education: The theory of choice and control in American education.
  25. (2004). Choice and provision in local pre-school childcare markets: Final report (unpublished).
  26. Citizens as partners: OECD handbook on information, consultation and public participation in policymaking.
  27. (1993). Community participation? The establishment of City's Parents'
  28. (2001). Community renewal information paper. Brisbane, Australia: Department of Housing.
  29. (2000). Community Services.
  30. (2004). Competing paradigms in qualitative research: Theories and issues. In S. Nagy Hesse-Biber & P. Leavey (Eds.), Approaches to qualitative research: A reader on theory and practice
  31. (1997). Competition and contestability in Australian higher education.
  32. (1993). Conceptions of learning.
  33. (1983). Conceptions of political power,
  34. (1979). Conceptions of research in student learning.
  35. (2001). Consumerism and gender in an era of school choice: A look at U.S. charter schools.
  36. (1995). Council of Australian Governments Child Care Working Group.
  37. (1994). Customer focussed child care.
  38. (1990). Defining quality in the evaluation of early childhood programs.
  39. (1988). Describing and improving learning. In
  40. (1995). Discourses of participation. In
  41. (1992). Displacement, velocity, and frames of reference: Phenomenographic studies of students' understanding and some implications for teaching and assessment.
  42. (2002). Early childhood services in Australia: Recent Commonwealth and State Initiatives. In
  43. (1996). Economic Planning Advisory Commission.
  44. (1997). Educating Australia: Government, economy and citizen since
  45. (1996). Education and Training Reference Committee.
  46. (1994). Education reform: A critical and post-structural approach.
  47. (1993). Educational consumerism: Family values or the meanest of motives? In
  48. (2001). Effective early childhood education and care services: A proposal for identifying parent expectations and perceptions using phenomenographic research. In
  49. (1997). Empowering the powerful: A discussion of the interrelation of government policies and consumerism.
  50. (1970). Exit, voice and loyalty: Responses to decline in firms, organisations and states.
  51. (2000). Experience of phenomenographic research: A personal account.
  52. (1977). Experimental phenomenology.
  53. (2000). Exploring conceptions: Phenomenography and the object of study.
  54. (2003). Families and QIAS: How much do they know?
  55. (2004). Families as a context for children.
  56. (2002). Families.
  57. (2004). For all our children: National preschool education inquiry report.
  58. (1999). From home to the world beyond: The interconnections among family, care and educational contexts.
  59. (2002). from http://www.families.qld.gov.au/childcare/hub/strategy.html Department of Families.
  60. (1995). From involvement to participation: Six levels of schoolcommunity interaction. In
  61. (2001). from www.abs.gov.au Australian Government.
  62. (1996). Future child care provision in Australia.
  63. (2003). Getting beyond childcare: Reflections on recent policy and future possibilities. In
  64. (1994). Half full or half empty? Child care policy and the missing bits. In
  65. (2002). Help for parents.
  66. (2000). Home, school and community relations: A guide to working with families (4th ed.).
  67. (1962). Ideas: General introduction to pure phenomenology
  68. (2000). Including parents? Education, citizenship and parental agency.
  69. (1998). Influences on young children's knowledge: The case of road safety education.
  70. (2002). Information literacy needs of local staff in crosscultural development projects.
  71. (1996). Information literacy: a phenomenography. Unpublished PhD,
  72. (1977). Inlarning och omvarldsuppfattning (Learning and conception of the world around). Stockholm: Almquist and Wiksell.
  73. (2004). Interview 24) The role of parents shaping ECEC public policy Group Discussion Friday,
  74. (1993). Issues in parent participation.
  75. (1989). Issues of validity in qualitative research. Lund: Studentlitteratur Chartwell-Bratt.
  76. (1997). Learning and Awareness.
  77. (1988). Learning in educational settings: Methods of inquiry. In
  78. (1979). Learning in the learner's perspective (No.
  79. (2001). Learnings from Alberta? Choice, equity, difference and diversity in public education.
  80. (2004). Lenses and lessons in phenomenographic research for public policy in early childhood education and care. In
  81. (2004). Making links: A collaborative approach to planning and practice in early childhood services.
  82. (1994). Managing intricacy in phenomenographic inquiry. In
  83. (1993). Marketing education in the 1990s: an introductory essay.
  84. (1995). Markets, choice and equity in education.
  85. (2004). May). Phenomenographic analysis: Postgraduate student seminar.
  86. (1994). Minding action: Conceiving of the action versus participating in cultural practices.
  87. (1991). National child care survey
  88. (1985). Naturalistic inquiry.
  89. (2000). OECD thematic review of early childhood education and care policy: Australian background report.
  90. (1992). On Foucault's concept of discourse. In
  91. (1996). On the philosophical foundations of phenomenography.
  92. (2003). Opening dimensions of variation: Am empirical study of learning in a web-based discussion.
  93. (2002). Parent conceptions of their role in early childhood education and care public policy and service development.
  94. (1985). Parent-professional partnership in preschool services: Issues and implications.
  95. (1990). Parent/teacher relationships.
  96. (2001). Parental influences on school policy: Some evidence from research (pp. 1-9): Education-line,
  97. (1994). Parental perceptions of early childhood services for pre-primary children in Australia. Early Child Development and Care,
  98. (2000). Parental reflections on the use of centre-based child care.
  99. (2000). Parents and schools: Partners or protagonists? Stoke on Trent,
  100. (1996). Parents and teachers: Power and participation.
  101. (1986). Parents as consumers of child care.
  102. (2000). Parents exist, ok? Issues and visions for parent-school relationships.
  103. (1994). Participant perceptions of quality child care.
  104. (1995). Participating parents. In
  105. (2002). Peripheral voices: Parental involvement, social class and educational disadvantage.
  106. (2000). Phenomenographic analysis of interview transcripts.
  107. (1997). Phenomenography - a "good-for-nothing brother" of phenomenology?
  108. (1995). Phenomenography and Practice.
  109. (1991). Phenomenography as a qualitative research approach in social pharmacy research.
  110. (1986). Phenomenography: A research approach to investigating different understandings of reality.
  111. (1981). Phenomenography: Describing conceptions of the world around us.
  112. (1988). Phenomenography: Exploring different conceptions of reality. In
  113. (1992). Phenomenological features of phenomenography (No.
  114. (2000). Policy development and change on the Australian landscape: A historical perspective. In
  115. (2001). Policy research. In
  116. (1990). Politics and policy making in education: Explorations in policy sociology.
  117. (2002). Preparing early childhood professionals to work with parents: The challenges of diversity and dissensus.
  118. (1994). Principals' conceptions of competent beginning teachers. In
  119. (2002). Principles and practice in phenomenographic research.
  120. (2003). Public government and management.
  121. (1995). Qualitative research: Phenomenography: Theory and applications [video-recording].
  122. (1999). Queensland Child Care Strategic Plan 2000-2005.
  123. (2002). Queensland the Smart State: Education and Training Reforms for the Future.
  124. (2003). Reflection and phenomenography: Towards theoretical and educational development possibilities.
  125. (1996). Reflections on phenomenography : Toward a methodology? Goteborg, Sweden: Acta Universitatis Gothoburgensis.
  126. (2000). Reflections on some faces of phenomenography.
  127. (1994). Reflections on the experience of the phenomenographic interview. In
  128. (1990). Reflections: A country mother's view on experiences for her preschool children.
  129. (2004). Report of Government Services
  130. (1992). Research students' conceptions of a literature review. Unpublished M.Ed.,
  131. (1995). Restructuring Australian schooling: Changing conceptions of top-down and bottom-up reforms. In
  132. (1999). Reversing the real brain drain. Early Years Study. Final Report.
  133. (1998). Reweaving parents into early chldhood education programs.
  134. (1997). Rural parents' perceptions and values and how they may contribute to a more contextually based early childhood program.
  135. (1995). School and community relations: Participation, policy and practice.
  136. (1991). School programs and teacher practices of parent involvement in inner-city elementary and middle schools.
  137. (2000). School-based parents' groups: A politics of voice and representation?
  138. (1997). School, family, and community partnerships : Your handbook for action. Thousand Oaks,
  139. Second reading of the Child Care Bill (No. 79), Queensland Legislative Assembly(1991).
  140. Second Reading Speech on introduction into the Australian Parliament of the
  141. (2001). Secondary teachers' conceptions of teaching and learning.
  142. (2003). Sharing care and education: Parents' perspectives.
  143. (1987). Silent partners: Parents of children in three types of day care.
  144. (1990). Social and family connections: Theory, research and implications for integrating sociologies of education and family. In
  145. (2001). Social class and parental agency.
  146. Starting strong: Early childhood education and care.
  147. (1991). State control and parent participation: Analysis of recent reports.
  148. (2004). Stronger Families and Communities Strategy.
  149. (1997). Talk as data and practice: A critical look at phenomenographic inquiry and the apeal to experience.
  150. (1999). Teaching as constituting a space of variation.
  151. (2001). The challenge to lead and the opportunity to learn through community renewal
  152. (1987). The concept of public management and the Australian state in the 1980s.
  153. (1999). The concepts and methods of phenomenographic research.
  154. (1989). The conceptualization of cases of physical motion.
  155. (1988). The construction and deconstruction of educational policy documents. In
  156. (1994). The creation of market competence for education in New Zealand: First report to the Ministry of Education.
  157. (1999). The demise of community-owned long day care centres and the rise of the mythical consumer.
  158. (1967). The discovery of grounded theory.
  159. (2001). The ethical climate of public schooling under new public management.
  160. (1984). The Experience of learning.
  161. (1964). The field of consciousness. Pittsburgh:
  162. (2000). The nature of phenomenographic research.
  163. (1996). The New Public Management in action.
  164. (1988). The phenomenography of the 'mole concept' in chemistry.
  165. (1998). The politics of Australian child care: Philanthropy to feminism and beyond.
  166. (1998). The purposes of nursery education in the UK: Parent and child perspectives.
  167. (2000). The Queensland ACCESS Project: Enhanced well-being and community capacity through integration of early childhood and family services.
  168. (1997). The seven faces of information literacy.
  169. (2004). The space of learning. In
  170. (2000). The structure of awareness.
  171. (1990). The theory of choice applied to education.
  172. (1996). The uncertain progress of educational reform 1983-1994. In
  173. (1998). The university of learning.
  174. (2001). The voices of parents: Rethinking the intersection of family and school.
  175. (1997). Theoretical foundations of phenomenography.
  176. (1999). They're going to tear the doors off this place": Upper-middle-class parent school involvement and the educational opportunities of other people's children.
  177. (1995). Towards integration and quality assurance in children's services.
  178. (2003). Towards the development of a national agenda for early childhood (Consultation paper). Canberra: Australian Government.
  179. (1999). Two faces of variation.
  180. (1996). Understanding and empowering the child as a learner.
  181. (2001). Understanding the discourses of partnership: An examination of one school's attempts at parent involvement.
  182. (1993). Use and Choice of Child Care.
  183. (2002). Use and integration of early childhood services: Insights from an inner city community.
  184. (2000). Using phenomenographic research methodology in the context of research in teaching and learning.
  185. (1988). Validity and reliability from a phenomenological perspective. In
  186. (1994). What is policy? Texts, trajectories and toolboxes.
  187. (1998). What is the 'world' of phenomenography?
  188. (1996). Young children, parents and professionals: Enhancing the links in early childhood.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.