Location of Repository

The Community Safety of International Students in Melbourne: a Scoping Study

By Hurriyet Babacan, Joanne Pyke, Alexandra Bhathal, Gurjeet K Gil, Michele Grossman and Santina Bertone


This report details the findings of study undertaken to investigate the community safety of international students in Melbourne. The study arose out of increasing incidence of violence against international students and the polarised and heated debate about whether or not the violence was racially or opportunistically motivated. Key findings are drawn from the results of a media analysis, a survey of more than 1,000 students, 29 interviews with stakeholders and 35 indepth interviews with international students. The report canvasses the range of risk factors that impact on international student safety, the complexity of the factors that contribute to international student safety risks and the priorities necessary to enhance international student safety

Topics: 220000 Social Sciences, Humanities and Arts-General, 9305 Education and Training Systems, 1399 Other Education, Institute for Community, Ethnicity and Policy Alternatives (ICEPA), ResPubID17283, ResPubID20715, international students, community safety\ud
Publisher: Victoria University
Year: 2010
OAI identifier: oai:eprints.vu.edu.au:15491
Download PDF:
Sorry, we are unable to provide the full text but you may find it at the following location(s):
  • http://vuir.vu.edu.au/15491/1/... (external link)
  • http://vuir.vu.edu.au/15491/ (external link)
  • Suggested articles



    1. (2008). (2008a) “40 Students Die After Struggling with Australian Life”,
    2. (2009). (2009a) “Media release: Police and Indian group to tackle crime,
    3. (2009b) “2008-9 Crime Statistics - Police Service Area 2007-8 and 2008-9”,
    4. (2009). (2009b) “Coverage of Indian Assaults ‘Irresponsible’”,
    5. (2009). (2009d) “Indian Anger Boils Over”, The Age,
    6. (2007). 07:Global Student Mobility: An Australian Perspective Five Years On”, IDP Education Australia Limited,
    7. (2010). 121 iNsTiTUTE For coMMUNiTY, ETHNiciTY AND PoLicY ALTErNATiVEs (icEPA),
    8. (2010). 123 iNsTiTUTE For coMMUNiTY, ETHNiciTY AND PoLicY ALTErNATiVEs (icEPA),
    9. (2010). 125 iNsTiTUTE For coMMUNiTY, ETHNiciTY AND PoLicY ALTErNATiVEs (icEPA),
    10. (2010). 127 iNsTiTUTE For coMMUNiTY, ETHNiciTY AND PoLicY ALTErNATiVEs (icEPA),
    11. (2010). 2There is no overlap between these two cases and those of interviewees from this study.77 iNsTiTUTE For coMMUNiTY, ETHNiciTY AND PoLicY ALTErNATiVEs (icEPA),
    12. (1990). 3.3 Ethnicity and ‘race’ Changes in the global economy have led to different types of movements: movements of ideologies, finance, media, technology and people (Appadurai
    13. (1997). A changing vocational education and training landscape”, ANTA training update seminar,
    14. (2007). A highly-regulated ‘free market’ : Commonwealth policies on private overseas students from
    15. (2009). A volcano brewing, attacks on Indian students built up for years”, South Asia Times June, pp 8-9,
    16. (2008). Addressing Denial: The First Step in Responding to Racism’, in h.
    17. (1995). After extensive consultations in 1993-94, the Racial hatred Act (RhA) was finally passed in October
    18. (2000). All forms of racism, prejudice, and bigotry are professionally unacceptable and every effort should be made to combat these behaviours (National Police Ethnic Advisory Bureau (NPEAB)
    19. (2009). An ethical issue”,
    20. (2006). An evaluation of the impact of the
    21. (2009). Another Attack in Melbourne”, South Asia Times,
    22. (2002). Arab Australians Today: Citizenship and Belonging,
    23. (2009). Attacks on Students ‘Clearly Racist’:
    24. (2005). Audit of Antisemitic Incidents 2004: Patterns of Prejudice in Canada”, League for human Rights of B’nai Brith,
    25. (2009). Australia tops poll for student safety”, The Age, Fairfax digital,
    26. (1988). Australian Aboriginal experiences of community justice, Australian Institute of Criminology,
    27. (2003). Australian Multiculturalism: Past, Present and Future. Managing Diversity Conference,
    28. (2007). Australian university international student finances”,
    29. (2009). Australians Travel to India to Talk about Student Safety”, The Wall Street Journal,
    30. (2000). Aversive Racism and Selective Decisions: 1989-1999”,
    31. (2009). Bashings Undermine Image Blitz”, The Age,
    32. (2005). Benevolence, Belonging and the Repression of White Violence”,
    33. (1992). Bias Crimes: A Theoretical and Practical Overview”,
    34. (2007). Boundaries of “Race” and Ethnicity and Questions About Cultural Belongings’, in N. Gopalkrishnan and h. Babacan, Racisms in the New World Order Realities of Cultures, Colours and Identity, Cambridge Scholars Publishing,
    35. (2006). Building Bridges’ to Break Down harmful Discrimination, Media Release”, Victorian health Promotion Foundation,
    36. (2007). Bushspeak and the Politics of Lying: Presidential Rhetoric in the
    37. (2009). Call for Inquiry into Student Issues”, The Age,
    38. (2006). Canadian Criminology: Strategies and Perspective,
    39. (2006). Changing the Criminal Law To Combat Racially Motivated Violence”,
    40. (2010). Chart 5.2: International/domestic students by age groupLanguages49 iNsTiTUTE For coMMUNiTY, ETHNiciTY AND PoLicY ALTErNATiVEs (icEPA),
    41. (2009). China Fear Over Safety of Students”, The Age,
    42. (2010). Chinese Indian Others Total Male Female Male Female Male Female higher
    43. (2009). Commencing and All Overseas Students by State, higher Education Provider and Gender, Full Year 2008, Table 50, in Students: Selected higher Education Statistics”, Department of Education, Employment and Workplace Relations (DEEWR), Australian Government,
    44. (2002). Community participation and regional crime”, Trends and Issues in Crime and Criminal Justice, Australian Institute of Criminology,
    45. (1997). Community Policing: Elements and Effects’,
    46. (1989). Community structure and crime: Testing social-disorganization theory”,
    47. (2010). contact between the police and international students. Chinese students are particularly fearful of police and strategies are needed to open up communications.73 iNsTiTUTE For coMMUNiTY, ETHNiciTY AND PoLicY ALTErNATiVEs (icEPA),
    48. (2004). Contemporary Racism in Australia: The Experiences of Aborigines”,
    49. (2008). Contrasting the driving factors for other students,
    50. (2009). Coroner Vows Better Death Data”, The Age,
    51. (2002). Crime and Victimisation of Migrants in Australia’,
    52. (2001). Crime Victimisation and Inequality in Risk Society’,
    53. (2005). Crime victimisation in Australia: key results of the 2004 International Crime Victimisation Survey”, Series no. 64, Australian Institute of Criminology,
    54. (2002). Cross-cultural and educational adaptation of Asian students to New Zealand”,
    55. (1997). Culture of Fear. Risk-Taking and the Morality of Low Expectation,
    56. (1999). Culture, Society and Sexuality: A Reader,
    57. (2009). Darebin City Council,
    58. (2006). Defining, Conceptualizing and Characterizing Racism in health Research”,
    59. (2009). DIAC (2009a) “Student Visa Assessment Levels”, Department of Immigration and Citizenship,
    60. (2003). Discrimination, Equality and Social Inclusion”,
    61. (1990). Disjuncture and Difference in the Global Cultural Economy’, in M. Featherstone, Global Culture: Nationalism, Globalization and Modernity,
    62. (2008). Education at a Glance: OECD Indicators”, Organisation for Economic Co-ordination and Development, Paris, 113 iNsTiTUTE For coMMUNiTY, ETHNiciTY AND PoLicY ALTErNATiVEs (icEPA),
    63. (2005). Effects of Community Policing Upon Fear of Crime: Understanding the Causal Linkage”, Policing: An
    64. (2009). Effects of Worldview and Mortality Salience in Persuasion Processes”,
    65. (2009). Enhancing the Student Experience and Student Safety - A Position Paper”, Universities Australia, Canberra, ACT, Universities Australia (2009b) “Universities Australia Action Plan for Student Safety. Media Release”,
    66. (2009). Enrolments crash since visa blitz”,
    67. (1990). Epidemiology,
    68. (1975). Ethnic Identity: Cultural Continuities and Change.
    69. (1990). Ethnic Options: Choosing Identities in America,
    70. (2000). Ethnicity and Globalization,
    71. (1994). Ethnicity, Nationalism, and State-Making: Ethnic Groups and Boundaries: Past and Future’, in h. Vermeulen
    72. (2006). Evaluation of the general skilled migration categories, Dept. of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs,
    73. (2002). Exclusion from Protection of Persons of ‘Bad Character’: Is Australia Fulfilling its Treaty Based Non Refoulement Obligations?”
    74. (2004). Exploitation: The international students come from varied financial situations. Many come without adequate funds to support themselves and sometimes accrue debt in their country of origin (Butcher and McGrath
    75. (2003). Export education in New Zealand: Place and representations of quality”, New Zealand Geographical Society Conference,
    76. (2001). Faceless Dealers Operating Behind Steel Fortresses”,
    77. (1997). Faces of hate: hate Crime in Australia hawkins Press,
    78. (2009). Fear Appeals in Political Rhetoric about Terrorism: An Analysis of Speeches by Australian Prime Minister howard”,
    79. (2007). Feminist research in a climate of insecurity”,
    80. (2009). Foreign Students in Limbo as ‘Rotten’ College Closes”, The Age,
    81. (2009). Free Bashing in a Free Country”, Indian Voice, July, City of Melbourne (2008) “International Student Survey. Summary and Data report”, Prepared by Evaluation Solutions for the City of Melbourne,
    82. (2009). Funding to Support Overseas Students.
    83. (2010). Further to this, the EMCRx (2005) explains that official criminal justice data on the nature and extent of racist violence is limited by a number of factors, namely:35 iNsTiTUTE For coMMUNiTY, ETHNiciTY AND PoLicY ALTErNATiVEs (icEPA),
    84. (2006). Future Migration and Policing: Examining Assumptions”, Australasian Centre for Policing Research, BBC News
    85. (2005). Global migration and social protection rights: The social and economic security of cross-border students in Australia”,
    86. (2009). Government Launches Inquiry into Indian Student Attacks”, SBS News,
    87. (2009). Greens Prepare to Move for Senate Inquiry as International Student Concerns Mount Nationwide,
    88. (1994). Handbook of Social Cognition, Lawrence Erlbaum, hillsdale NJ. 2.111 iNsTiTUTE For coMMUNiTY, ETHNiciTY AND PoLicY ALTErNATiVEs (icEPA),
    89. (1999). hate Crimes in the Workplace: Worker-to-Worker Victimisation and Policy Responses”,
    90. (1993). hate Crimes: The Rising Tide of Bigotry and Bloodshed,
    91. (2008). higginbottom (2008b) “Foreign students feeling high price to study”, herald Sun,
    92. (1987). higher education : a policy discussion paper,
    93. (1991). hREOC (2004a) “Ismae - Listen: National Consultations on Eliminating Prejudice Against Arab and Muslim Australians”, human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission, Sydney, NSW, human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (hREOC)
    94. (2000). In Australia there have been various periods during which young ‘ethnic gangs’ of South-East Asian background were described as the cause of much crime (Poynting 2002). Similarly in Sydney, during 1998, police targeted youth of Arabic ethnic
    95. (2009). Indian Express (2009b) “Victoria Police to induct people from different communities”, Indian Express, August 18th 2009, Indian Express (2009c) “Don’t brand Australia racist; give time to act, say Indians”, Indian Express, Sunday May 31st 2009, Indus Age
    96. (2009). Indian fury on student bashings”, The Age,
    97. (2009). Indian Student Bashings on the Rise in Sydney: Community Leader”,
    98. (2008). Indian Student Kanan Kharbanda was Bashed
    99. (2009). Indian Students Describe Sydney Attacks”,
    100. (2009). Indian Students March in Protest Against Attacks”, The Age,
    101. (2009). Indian Students Stage Violent Protest Over Attacks in Australia”, The Telegraph,
    102. (2009). Indian students: Question Without Notice, house of Representatives Canberra.
    103. (2009). Indians have lost faith in
    104. (2009). Indians Told to Keep Low Profile”, The Age,
    105. (2008). Initiatives by other Victorian organisations After the deaths of a number of international students in fires, including three Indian students who died in
    106. (2009). Inquiry into the Welfare of International Students - Information about the Inquiry”, Commonwealth of Australia,
    107. (2009). International education - its contribution to Australia Canberra,
    108. (2007). International Education: Financial and organizational impacts in Australian Universities”,
    109. (2008). International Student Survey: Summary and data report”, City of Melbourne,
    110. (2009). International Student Workers in Australia: A New Vulnerable Workforce”,
    111. (2004). International students in New Zealand: needs and responses”,
    112. (2009). International Students’ Security and Safety Needs in Australia”, National Union of Students,
    113. (2008). International Trade in Services by Country, by State and by Detailed Services Category Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) Canberra, Australian Government.
    114. (1991). Intersexions : Gender, Class, Culture, Ethnicity North Sydney, Allen and Unwin.
    115. (2002). Introduction to Social Pscyhology, Prentice hall,
    116. (2009). It’s racism’: Indian Media Seizes on Student Scam Report,
    117. (2000). Kebabs, kids, cops and crime : youth ethnicity and crime,
    118. (2000). Kebabs, Kids, Cops and Crime: Youth, Ethnicity and Crime, Pluto Press,
    119. (2009). Legal Advice Clinic was established at the Western Suburbs Legal Service, to offer legal advice and assistance to international students across Melbourne. The Clinic is staffed by volunteers who speak hindi, Urdu, Punjabi and Tamil (Indus Age
    120. (2004). Living with Racism. The Experience and Reporting by Arab and Muslim Australians of Discrimination, Abuse and Violence Since
    121. (2006). Locating Identity: Sense of Space,
    122. (2006). Measuring Wellbeing: Developing Community Indicators for Victoria”,
    123. (2009). Melbourne unsafe and unfriendly “, The Age, Fairfax digital,
    124. (2009). More private colleges put on inquiry hit list”, The Australian,
    125. (2007). More Than Tolerance: Embracing Diversity for health: Discrimination Affecting Migrants and Refugee Communities in Victoria, Its health Consequences, Community Attitudes and Solutions, A Summary Report”, Victorian health Promotion Foundation,
    126. (2000). Multicultural perspectives of crime and safety Victorian Multicultural Commission,
    127. (2007). National Code of Practice for Registration Authorities and Providers of Education and Training for Overseas Students
    128. (1991). National Inquiry into Racist Violence (NIRV) recommended amendments to the RDA and the Commonwealth Crimes Act to cover racist violence and harassment, and incitement to racist violence and racial hatred.
    129. (1997). National Survey of Police and Ethnic Issues Report”, National Police Advisory Bureau & Australian Institute of Jewish Affairs,
    130. (1985). Neighborhood and Crime: The Structural Determinants of Personal Victimization”,
    131. (1997). Neighborhood and Violent Crime:
    132. (1993). Neighborhoods and Crime: The Dimensions of Effective Community Control,
    133. (2007). Neo-Liberalism and Infeartainment: What Does a State Do’, in h.
    134. (2009). New Sentencing “, Victorian Government Web-Site, The Premier of Victoria,
    135. (2008). Overseas Students Victims of a New ‘Slave Trade’”, The Age,
    136. (2009). Parents of ‘Suicide’ Victims Want Justice”, The Australian,
    137. (2001). Perceptions, information and choice: Understanding how Chinese students select a country for overseas study”, Australian Education International,
    138. (2002). Perpetual War for Perpetual Peace, Nation Books,
    139. (2005). Picking Winners”: The Recent Transformation of Australia’s Skilled Migration Policy”,
    140. (2010). places of worship and schools were vandalized and 33 iNsTiTUTE For coMMUNiTY, ETHNiciTY AND PoLicY ALTErNATiVEs (icEPA),
    141. (2001). Police chief hits out at ethnic gang violence”,
    142. (2009). Police Move Indian Station ‘Guards’”, The Age,
    143. (2005). Police Reform and the Problem of Trust”,
    144. (2000). Police-citizen contact and police performance: Attitudinal differences between hispanics and nonhispanics”,
    145. (2005). Politics of Fear Continuum,
    146. (2002). Politics of Social Exclusion: Refugees on Temporary Protection Visa in Victoria”,
    147. (2009). Postcode Link to City Violence”, The Age,
    148. (2003). Psychology of Fear. Perth Day of Ideas,
    149. (2005). Public Safety and the Management of Fear”,
    150. (1999). Punishing hate: Bias Crimes Under American Law, harvard University Press,
    151. (2005). Racially Biased Policing: Determinants of Citizen Perceptions”,
    152. (2008). Racism and Asylum Seeker Policies’,
    153. (2002). Racism and Community Safety”,
    154. (2003). Racism and health”,
    155. (2005). Racism and the Conspiracy of Silence”,
    156. (2001). Racism, Ethnicity and hate Crime “,
    157. (2005). Racist Violence in 15 EU Member States: A Comparative Overview of Findings from the Racism and xenophobia Network National Focus Point Reports 2001-2002”,
    158. (2006). Recommendations on Policing in Multi-Ethnic Societies”, Office of the high Commissioner on National Minorities, The
    159. (2002). Regulating Racism: Racial Vilification in Australia”, M, Institute of Criminology
    160. (2006). Responses can be inner or outer directed (harrell 2000). Drawing from a wide range of literature Paradies
    161. (2004). Retreat From Injustice: human Rights Law in Australia,
    162. (2009). Review of the ESOS Act
    163. (2009). Rudd Forms Indian Violence Taskforce”,
    164. (2009). Sentencing Amendment Bill 2009. Introduction Print. Explanatory Memorandum. , Victorian Legislation and Parliamentary Documents.
    165. (1981). Situational Ethnicity”,
    166. (2003). Skin Deep: Proof and Inferences of Racial Discrimination in Employment”,
    167. (2001). Social Participation and Support: Research shows that international students prefer close friendship with co-nationals (Ward
    168. (2008). Stop the Violence, Demand Indians”, The Age,
    169. (2007). Stressing the importance of ‘power’ relations, Anthias
    170. (1990). Structural Covariates of homicides Rates: Are there any Invariances Across Time and Space”,
    171. (2009). Student Danger Zones”, The Australian,
    172. (2009). Submission, Senate Inquiry into the Welfare of International Students”, Tenants Union of Victoria, Australian Government
    173. (2004). Suspect Disrespect towards the Police”,
    174. (2005). Targeted’ E.xperiences of Racism in New South Wales after
    175. (2009). Taskforce and national International Student Strategy The Taskforce, comprised of officials from DFAT, DEEWR and DIAC, was established by Prime Minister Rudd in early June to oversee Australia’s responses to attacks on Indian students (Banham
    176. (2008). Taskforce Report, Overseas Student Education Experience Taskforce (Victoria)”, Victorian Government, Department of Innovation, Industry and Regional Development,
    177. (2009). The Age (2009) “Bollywood Eyes Racist Attacks”, The Age,
    178. (1992). the ALP introduced the RDA Amendment Bill that proposed to make racist violence a criminal offence and racial vilification unlawful. This Bill lapsed with the calling of the March
    179. (2009). The Australian education sector and the economic contribution of international students”, Australian Council for Private Education and Training,
    180. (2006). The City of Melbourne (COM) has conducted a bi-annual survey, including questions on safety and wellbeing, of international students living and studying within its LGA since
    181. (2000). The Colour of Democracy: Racism
    182. (2002). The Effect of Police Presence on Public Fear Reduction and Satisfaction: A Review of the Literature”, The Justice Professional,
    183. (2003). The Global hierarchy of Race”, The Guardian,
    184. (2009). the housing market in Australia is stretched and the availability of affordable and quality housing is limited
    185. (2001). The impact of international students on domestic students and host institutions: a literature review”, Ministry of Education,
    186. (2007). The Landmark of Cronulla’,
    187. (1998). The Local Governance of Crime: Appeals to Community and Partnerships,
    188. (2007). The lure of permanent residency and the aspirations and expectations of international students studying accounting in Australia”,
    189. (2006). The Neo-Liberal Assault on Australian Universities and the Future of Democracy”,
    190. (2004). The New Liberalism’,
    191. (2003). The Role of Procedural Justice and Legitimacy in Shaping Public Support for Policing”,
    192. (1995). The Scientific Credibility of Folk Psychology, Lawrence Erlbaum,
    193. (2009). The Victorian Government announced on 24
    194. (2000). Theories of Race and Racism : A Reader,
    195. (1995). These stories can be seen manifest in the rise of hansonism in Australia and the rise of extreme nationalist movements in other parts of the world (Waymer 2009). Wieviorka
    196. (2001). This was demonstrated in a study of Chinese students, which concluded that a safe environment was the most significant predictor of intentions to choose Australia over competitor nations (Mazzarol, Soutar et al.
    197. (2005). Trading places: The impact and outcomes of market reform in vocational education and training”, Adelaide,
    198. (2009). Transnational and temporary: students, community and place making in central Melbourne”,
    199. (2005). Universities: the governance trap and what to do about it.” Wednesday night at the New International Bookshop: Australian Fabian Society,
    200. (2005). Using narrative in social research: qualitative and quantitative approaches, SAGE, London ; Thousand Oaks.
    201. (2009). Walking in Fear: An Autoethnographic Account of Media Framing of Inner-City Crime”,
    202. (2006). What caused the Cronulla riot?
    203. (2000). What is Globalization?,
    204. (2010). when all the bullshit has happened, so at that moment I was absent from the class. Many other students also did not attend.
    205. (2009). which will sit alongside the ESOS legislative framework, aims to ‘promote a broader vision of international education’, emphasising its benefits to Australia and students’ countries of origin (COAG
    206. (1989). While Australia has not experienced racist violence to the degree of the USA or UK, there is evidence to indicate that racialised violence is taking place. In
    207. (2010). year … I got on the tram. …There was a guy, get out from the car, and get on the tram, and then bash, you know, in that tram [a group of young African male passengers who had yelled at
    208. (2003). Youth, Community Safety and the Paradox of Inclusion”,

    To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.