Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

The short but significant life of the International Trade Organization: lessons for our time

By Daniel Drache

Abstract

Along with the World Bank and the IMF, the International Trade Organization (ITO) formed the centrepiece of new kind of international organization in the late 40s. At the time, what was particularly novel about the Havana Charter was that it was not simply or mainly a trade organization like the WTO, its latter day descendent. At its core, the countries of the world rejected the idea that it was possible to maintain a firewall between trade, development, employment standards and domestic policy. Its most distinctive feature was the integration of an ambitious and successful program to reduce traditional trade barriers, with a wide-angled agreement that addressed investment, employment standards, development, business monopolies and the like. It pioneered the idea that trade disputes had to be settled by consultation and mediation rather than with legal clout. Further it established an institutional linkage between trade and labour standards that would effect a major advance in global governance. Finally it embedded the full employment obligation, along with "a commitment to free markets" as the cornerstone of multilateralism.\ud \ud Despite these accomplishments, the US Congress refused to ratify the Havana Charter even though it had signed it. As a direct consequence, the ITO's collapse represented a significant closure of the full employment era internationally. In the end, it's demise made possible the rapid return of the free trade canon that increasingly, would impose its authority and ideology on all international organizations and on the practice of multilateralism. As this essay concludes, its history compelling because whatever its apparent shortcomings, governments, economists and ordinary people demanded that trade, employment goals and developmental needs should reinforce each other in the world trading system

Topics: HF, JZ
Publisher: University of Warwick. Centre for the Study of Globalisation and Regionalisation
Year: 2000
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:2063

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. 1,300 bilateral investment treaties have been signed but there is still no comprehensive agreement -- the goal that eludes the OECD for more than a quarter of a century.
  2. (1920). 1913. As well Conferences were held throughout the twenties in
  3. 24 of the Andean Pact imposes stringent controls and screening procedures on FDI and the transfer of technology including a provision requiring the disinvestment of foreign firms after a number of years.
  4. (1972). A helpful retrospective analysis of the Bretton Woods era by participants is found in Keith Acheson,
  5. Act of the European Energy Charter Treaty proposes new investment rights and protection for private investors.
  6. addresses the ILO December Washington meeting and promises the ILO delegates that their Organization will play an essential part in building up a stable international system of social justice for all peoples everywhere.
  7. An extensive UN Code on the conduct of TNCs is proposed but the instrument is never adopted despite agreement on many of its provisions.
  8. (1994). and a second by Diebold, From the ITO to GATT -- And Back? The Bretton WoodsGATT System Retrospect and Prospect After Fifty Years.
  9. APEC’s Non-Binding Investment Principles adopted supporting foreign direct investment and new protection for investors.
  10. Australia elects a labour government under Chifley, a strong advocate of the tariff for national development and ITO, World Bank and full employment goal internationally
  11. Beveridge’s report on Social Security in a postwar world published incorporating the principles of the Atlantic Charter and signalling the new role for labour in public policy making
  12. Bills: full employment commitment watered down. Congress refuses to follow the UK example
  13. (1972). Bretton Woods Revisited. Toronto: U of T. Alcock, doi
  14. Britain negotiates a $5 billion loan from Washington and US officials insist on committing UK on joint proposals for establishing the ITO
  15. Brynes replaces Hull as Secretary of State; free trader Clayton nominated UnderSecretary of State for Economic Affairs
  16. Chifley’s ‘Light on the Hill’ address recommits Australia to full employment
  17. Codes of Liberalization of Capital Movements and of Current Invisible Operations establishes binding rules and provides effective machinery for their gradual expansion and implementation by OECD countries.
  18. (1948). Conference on Trade and Employment, Final Act and Related Documents,
  19. Congressional elections return a Republican US doi
  20. Convention on full employment policies
  21. Council of Ministers reviews the OECD instruments on TNCs and agrees on a number of changes to strengthen them.
  22. Countries amend their previous instrument on foreign investment and replace it with a liberal set of regulations – a major reversal of policy. They now relax rules regarding foreign investment in host country.
  23. developed countries negotiate a Draft Convention on the Protection of Foreign Private Property and is approved by the Organization’s Council but is never opened for signature.
  24. (1944). Export Policy and Full Employment. London: Fabian
  25. final text is signed by 53 countries on March 24. Includes major chapters on trade policy, cartels, commodity agreements, employment, economic development and international investment and the constitution of a new UN institution in international trade
  26. (1989). For a discussion of the reasons for the weak dispute settlement in GATT, see
  27. For a particularly influential work on the full employment imperative internationally, see Schumacher 1944. Much later his influential work Small is Beautiful established his international reputation as a practical utopian.
  28. France establishes national planning under
  29. (1995). Havana was broadly representative of the countries of the world at the time. Half came from Latin America and Asia and ten from the Middle East or Africa, with the remaining signatories from First World countries.
  30. In terms of political theory, the defining element for government was interpreted to mean "…how much responsibility will be left to private enterprise and how much will be assumed by public authority.”.
  31. India becomes the world’s largest democracy and independent from doi
  32. inter-agency committees meet continuously in Washington from the spring of 1943 to summer of 1945 chaired successively by Acheson and Clayton; also talks with Canadian officials
  33. ITO meetings at Geneva; successful tariff negotiations make possible non-tariff measures to be included in Havana Charter
  34. key economic advisor to the President, publishes influential volume, America’s Role in the World
  35. Keynes to Treasury where his ideas on full employment begin gain influence and acceptance and he takes part in discussions on the postwar order in
  36. leading US trade authority, declares support for the ITO in Foreign Affairs, a leading US forum of opinion and expert advice
  37. Lend-Lease commits US and UK to begin to search for new principles for rebuilding the world’s trading system
  38. New Dealers’ in Department of State begin to prepare the draft treaty proposing the ITO; eventually they loose control of the agenda
  39. on Trade and Employment is opened in Havana, November 18; 56 nations send delegations. A great deal of criticism of Geneva text that it was onesided and served the interests of the major industrial powers and not the developing countries.
  40. Paper on Full Employment/followed by Canadian and Australia White Papers on Employment
  41. pioneers a code of International Code of Marketing of Breast Milk Substitutes in the area of consumer protection. This is one of several initiatives taken to protect consumers from TNCs and set new standards for corporate behaviour.
  42. Plan to support European reconstruction and a rival agenda to the ITO
  43. postwar planning negotiation related to Article VII
  44. (1994). Reflections on the International Trade Organization.” Northern Illinois University Law Review 14:2(Spring):
  45. Report on National and International Measures To Achieve Full Employment published by the UN’s Economic and Social Council Group of Experts among them Kaldor.
  46. Schumacher publishes a major statement on trade and employment as Fabian pamphlet; Hayek’s book Road to Serfdom appears
  47. so hostile that President Truman signs GATT as an executive order; not submitted to Congress Fifty Years of Regulating Foreign Investment
  48. (1952). The Changing Workplace: The Changing Workplace Toronto: doi
  49. The contentious subject of investment rights did not die with the end of the ITO.
  50. The Economist Restructuring the World Trading System, a series of six articles on trade, employment and the design of the commercial order
  51. the ITO. A coalition of protectionists and perfectionists, critics of the Charter, convinces Truman to withdraw the draft treaty from Congress.
  52. (1947). The list is adapted from Viner,
  53. (1997). The three aims of the Geneva meeting were: “continuing the preparation of the charter; negotiation of a multilateral agreement of tariff reduction; drafting “general clauses of obligations related to tariff negotiation.” (Ostry,
  54. (1981). The Two Postwar Eras and Conditions for Stability in Twentieth Century Western Europe.” American Historical Review 86(April): 327-352; doi
  55. (1945). The United States in a Multi-National Economy. New York: Council on Foreign Relations.
  56. The US sponsors the creation of the Organization for European Economic Cooperation (OEEC) to promote trade liberalization and the further reduction of barriers.
  57. The World Bank prepares and proposes the non-binding Guidelines on the Treatment of Foreign Direct Investment that will be a benchmark in augmenting protection for foreign direct investment rights.
  58. (1900). There had been international meetings and congresses to promote customs co-ordination in
  59. Treaty is submitted to Congress,
  60. Tripartite Declaration of Principles concerning MNEs and Social Policy is adopted even if only voluntary. doi
  61. (1950). VII for the pros and cons of this debate which has never had any closure.
  62. (1976). Voluntary codes are a poor second best choice by any standard to address this issue. Two such efforts are:
  63. (1989). was not an ‘organization at the time’, its status was that of a negotiating forum of the ITO. GATT membership and a full secretariat came much later.
  64. writes a Proposal for an International Commercial Union calling for ‘far-reaching and imaginative proposals for the reduction of restrictions to international commerce’; top civil servants preoccupied with working on the proposal

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.