Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Authority, Social Change, and Education: A Response to Dewey\u27s Critics

By James Scott Johnston


In this paper, I want to examine and challenge certain criticisms of Dewey\u27s conception of authority. These criticisms are, broadly speaking, of two species. The first set of criticisms involves what critics have labeled Dewey\u27s \u22strong\u22 authority. These critics, the so-called \u22Illinois Revisionists,\u22 argue that embedded in Dewey\u27s social and educational philosophy are assumptions about authority that lead the critics to speculate that the legitimation of authority is predicated upon an expert, professional class. This class maintains power and social control through the use of scientific, technical, and rational means. In terms of education, these critics conclude that schooling is a vehicle for the inculcation of positive values regarding science and technology and their importance in the modern world. A second set of criticisms comes from the historian John Patrick Diggins, who argues Dewey as having a \u22weak\u22 conception of authority. The argument here is that, as Dewey presupposes no metaphysical ends, and no fixed historical knowledge to draw upon, little is left over to hitch authority onto in terms of social control. What is left are individual experiences; clearly not enough to make value judgments regarding social issues. Furthermore and with respect to education, as teacher authority is said by Dewey to be minimal, and no fixed, philosophical educational \u22ends\u22 are allowable, there is little to guide authority in determining future educational direction. I intend to explore these arguments further, and then to challenge them. This will occur through a reconsideration of Dewey\u27s position on authority-both social and educational. After completing this reconsideration, I will be in a position to bring the completed results to bear on the criticisms themselves. My thesis is that, while Dewey is clearly able to refute certain of these criticisms, others continue to hold. In particular, I concur with those arguments that read Dewey as having posited no metaphysical or educational \u22ends\u22 and further positing that these ends are necessary ones if anything other than a contingent authority is to evolve. I maintain that Diggins and those who agree with him will not be satisfied by Dewey\u27s response

Publisher: Purdue University
Year: 2012
OAI identifier:
Provided by: Purdue E-Pubs

Suggested articles


  1. (1938). A Conception of Authority: An Introductory Study.
  2. (1976). Academic Freedom." In The Middle Works of
  3. (1991). Authority and Social Change." In The Later Works of
  4. (1984). Democracy and Education." In The Middle Works of
  5. (1944). Education for Freedom." In The Christian Century.
  6. (1991). Experience and Education." In The Later Works of
  7. (1988). Experience and Nature."
  8. (1991). Freedom and Culture." In The Later Works of
  9. (1988). Human Nature and Conduct." In The Middle Works of
  10. (1991). Ithaca: Cornell University Press. I would like to thank Dr. Walter Feinberg for his invaluable assistance in helping me with the drafts of this paper. James Scott Johnston is a Doctoral student at the
  11. (1973). Liberal Ideology and the Quest for Social Change." In Roots of Crisis: American Education in the Twentieth Century, edited by Clarence Karier, et al.
  12. (1990). Liberalism and Human Action."
  13. (1975). Reason and Rhetoric: The Intellectual Foundations of 20"'
  14. (1992). Schooling, Education, and the Structure of Social Reality."
  15. (1992). The Democratic Classroom: Mistake or Misnomer?" In
  16. (1965). The New Radicalism in America.
  17. (1994). The Promise of Pragmatism: Modernism and the Crisis of Knowledge and Authority. Chicago:
  18. (1989). The Public and its Problems."
  19. (1990). The Sources of a Science of Education."
  20. (1991). Theory of Valuation."

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.