Inside the black box: The role and composition of compensation peer groups

Abstract

This paper documents the features of the newly disclosed compensation peer groups and demonstrates their significant role in explaining variations in CEO compensation beyond that of other benchmarks such as the industry-size peers. After controlling for industry, size, visibility, CEO responsibility and talent flows, we find that firms appear to select highly paid peers to justify their CEO compensation and this effect is stronger in firms where the compensation peer group is smaller, where the CEO is the Chairman of the Board of Directors, where the CEO has longer tenure, and where directors are busier serving on multiple boards