212 research outputs found
Two Models Relevant to the Interaction of a Point Charge and a Magnetic Moment
An understanding of the interaction of a point charge and a magnetic moment
is crucial for understanding the experiments involving electromagnetic momentum
carried by permeable materials as well as the experimentally-observed
Aharonov-Bohm and Aharonov-Casher phase shifts. Here we present two simple
models for a magnetic moment which have vastly different interactions with a
distant point charge. It is suggested that a satisfactory theoretical
understanding of the interaction is still lacking and that the "hidden
momentum" interpretation has been introduced into the textbook literature
prematurely.Comment: 10 page
Is Planck's Constant h a "Quantum" Constant? An Alternative Classical Interpretation
Although Planck's constant h is currently regarded as the elementary quantum
of action appearing in quantum theory, it can also be interpreted as the
multiplicative scale factor setting the scale of classical zero-point radiation
appearing in classical electromagnetic theory. Relativistic classical electron
theory with classical electromagnetic zero-point radiation gives many results
in agreement with quantum theory. The areas of agreement between this classical
theory and Nature seem worth further investigation.Comment: 10 page
Interaction of a Point Charge and a Magnet: Comments on "Hidden Mechanical Momentum Due to Hidden Nonelectromagnetic Forces"
The interaction of a point charge and a magnetic moment (and by extension a
point charge and a solenoid) is explored within well-defined point-charge
magnetic-moment models where full calculations are possible. It is shown
explicitly how the "hidden mechanical momentum" is introduced by the "hidden"
external forces of constraint, requiring a prescribed response (through order
1/c^2) of the system to electromagnetic forces. These external forces often go
unmentioned in the textbook and research literature. The dependence of "hidden
mechanical momentum" upon detailed external (nonelectromagnetic) forces may
undermine the idea's usefulness in describing nature. Some statements of
dubious validity in the textbook literature are noted.Comment: 36 page
Connecting blackbody radiation and zero-point radiation within classical physics: A new minimum principle and a status review
A new thermodynamic analysis is presented for the intimate connections
between blackbody radiation and zero-point radiation within classical physics.
First, using the thermodynamic behavior of an oscillator under an adiabatic
change of frequency, we show that the thermodynamic functions can all be
derived from a single function of w/T, analogous to Wien's displacement
theorem. The high- and low-frequency limits allow asymptotic energy forms
involving T alone or w alone, corresponding to energy equipartition and
zero-point energy. It is then suggested that the actual thermodynamic behavior
for a harmonic oscillator is given by the function satisfying the Wien
displacement result which provides the smoothest possible interpolation between
scale-decoupled energy equipartition at low frequency and scale-invariant
zero-point energy at high frequency. This leads to the Planck spectrum. Second,
we turn to radiation in a box with conducting walls and a conducting partition
so that the discrete normal mode structure of the box becomes important. The
contrasting Casimir energies are explored for the Rayleigh-Jeans and zero-point
spectra. The Rayleigh-Jeans spectrum involves no change of energy with
partition position, and the zero-point spectrum involves no change of entropy.
It is suggested that the Planck spectrum with zero-point radiation satisfies a
natural minimum principle which corresponds to greatest independence of the
system energy from the position of the partition for a fixed temperature.
Numerical calculation is used for confirmation. Third, we review the previous
derivations of the Planck radiation spectrum in classical physics, all of which
involve zero-point radiation.Comment: 22 page
Concerning Hidden Momentum
The fact that the author of an excellent textbook on electromagnetism could
be duped by "hidden momentum" vividly illustrates the problematic nature of its
use.Comment: 4 page
Blackbody Radiation in Classical Physics: A Historical Perspective
We point out that current textbooks of modern physics are a century
out-of-date in their treatment of blackbody radiation within classical physics.
Relativistic classical electrodynamics including classical electromagnetic
zero-point radiation gives the Planck spectrum with zero-point radiation as the
blackbody radiation spectrum. In contrast, nonrelativistic mechanics cannot
support the idea of zero-point energy; therefore if nonrelativistic classical
statistical mechanics or nonrelativistic mechanical scatterers are invoked for
radiation equilibrium, one arrives at only the low-frequency Rayleigh-Jeans
part of the spectrum which involves no zero-point energy, and does not include
the high-frequency part of the spectrum involving relativistically-invariant
classical zero-point radiation. Here we first discuss the correct understanding
of blackbody radiation within relativistic classical physics, and then we
review the historical treatment. Finally, we point out how the presence of
Lorentz-invariant classical zero-point radiation and the use of relativistic
particle interactions transform the previous historical arguments so as now to
give the Planck spectrum including classical zero-point radiation. Within
relativistic classical electromagnetic theory, Planck's constant h appears as
the scale of source-free zero-point radiation.Comment: 40 page
Connecting Blackbody Radiation, Relativity, and Discrete Charge in Classical Electrodynamics
It is suggested that an understanding of blackbody radiation within classical
physics requires the presence of classical electromagnetic zero-point
radiation, the restriction to relativistic (Coulomb) scattering systems, and
the use of discrete charge. The contrasting scaling properties of
nonrelativistic classical mechanics and classical electrodynamics are noted,
and it is emphasized that the solutions of classical electrodynamics found in
nature involve constants which connect together the scales of length, time, and
energy. Indeed, there are analogies between the electrostatic forces for groups
of particles of discrete charge and the van der Waals forces in equilibrium
thermal radiation. The differing Lorentz- or Galilean-transformation properties
of the zero-point radiation spectrum and the Rayleigh-Jeans spectrum are noted
in connection with their scaling properties. Also, the thermal effects of
acceleration within classical electromagnetism are related to the existence of
thermal equilibrium within a gravitational field. The unique scaling and
phase-space properties of a discrete charge in the Coulomb potential suggest
the possibility of an equilibrium between the zero-point radiation spectrum and
matter which is universal (independent of the particle mass), and an
equilibrium between a universal thermal radiation spectrum and matter where the
matter phase space depends only upon the ratio mc^2/kT. The observations and
qualitative suggestions made here run counter to the ideas of currently
accepted quantum physics.Comment: 31 page
Interaction of a Magnet and a Point Charge: Unrecognized Internal Electromagnetic Momentum Eliminates the Myth of Hidden Mechanical Momentum
A model calculation using the Darwin Lagrangian is carried out for a magnet
consisting of two current-carrying charges constrained by centripetal forces to
move in a circular path in the presence of the electric field from a distant
external point charge. In the limit that the magnet's two charges are
non-interacting, the calculation recovers the only valid calculation for hidden
mechanical momentum. However, if the magnet's charges are mutually interacting,
then there is internal electromagnetic linear momentum associated with the
perturbed magnet's electrostatic charge distribution and the motion of the
magnet's charges. This internal electromagnetic momentum does not seem to be
recognized as distinct from the familiar external electromagnetic momentum
associated with the electric field of the external charge and the magnetic
field of the unperturbed magnet. In the multiparticle limit, the hidden
mechanical momentum becomes negligible while the internal electromagnetic
momentum provides the compensating linear momentum required by the relativistic
conservation law connecting the total linear momentum to motion of the center
of energy. Whereas the changes in the external electromagnetic momentum are
often associated with magnetic forces of order changes in the
internal electromagnetic momentum are associated with the electrical forces of
order . These electrical forces are relevant to the Shockley-James
paradox and to the experimentally observed Aharonov-Bohm and Aharonov-Casher
phase shifts.Comment: 19 page
Semiclassical Explanation of the Matteucci-Pozzi and Aharonov-Bohm Phase Shifts
Classical electromagnetic forces can account for the experimentally observed
phase shifts seen in an electron interference pattern when a line of electric
dipoles or a line of magnetic dipoles (a solenoid) is placed between the
electron beams forming the interference pattern.Comment: 8 page
The Contrasting Roles of Planck's Constant in Classical and Quantum Theories
We trace the historical appearance of Planck's constant in physics, and we
note that initially the constant did not appear in connection with quanta.
Furthermore, we emphasize that Planck's constant can appear in both classical
and quantum theories. In both theories, Planck's constant sets the scale of
atomic phenomena. However, the roles played in the foundations of the theories
are sharply different. In quantum theory, Planck's constant is crucial to the
structure of the theory. On the other hand, in classical electrodynamics,
Planck's constant is optional, since it appears only as the scale factor for
the (homogeneous) source-free contribution to the general solution of Maxwell's
equations. Since classical electrodynamics can be solved while taking the
homogenous source-free contribution in the solution as zero or non-zero, there
are naturally two different theories of classical electrodynamics, one in which
Planck's constant is taken as zero and one where it is taken as non-zero. The
textbooks of classical electromagnetism present only the version in which
Planck's constant is taken to vanish.Comment: 9 page
- …