It has been claimed recently that the black hole information-loss paradox has
been resolved: the evolution of quantum states in the presence of a black hole
is unitary and information preserving. We point out that, contrary to some
claims in literature, information-preserving black holes still violate baryon
number and any other quantum number which follows from an effective (and thus
approximate) or anomalous symmetry.Comment: Honorable Mention on Gravity Essay Competition 2005; Published in the
special Essay issue of Int.J.Mod.Phy
