The phase diagram of the Pb(Mg1/3Nb2/3)O3 and PbTiO3 solid solution (PMN-xPT)
indicates a rhombohedral ground state for x < 0.32. X-ray powder measurements
by Dkhil et al. show a rhombohedrally split (222) Bragg peak for PMN-10%PT at
80 K. Remarkably, neutron data taken on a single crystal of the same compound
with comparable q-resolution reveal a single resolution-limited (111) peak down
to 50 K, and thus no rhombohedral distortion. Our results suggest that the
structure of the outer layer of these relaxors differs from that of the bulk,
which is nearly cubic, as observed in PZN by Xu et al.Comment: Replaced Fig. 3 with better versio