We present an up-to-date critique of the physical basis for the spectral
ageing method. We find that the number of cases where this method may be
meaningfully applied to deduce the ages of classical double radio sources is
small indeed. This critique is much more than merely a re-expression of
anxieties about the calibration of spectral ageing (which have been articulated
by others in the past).Comment: 9 pages, 3 figures, published in `Particles & Fields in Radio
Galaxies', PASP, eds RA Laing & KM Blundel