Bis(phenoxyimine)Ti catalysts with ortho-F-substituted phenyl rings on the N can be
“living” propene polymerization catalysts. On the basis of DFT calculations, it has been
proposed that the “living” behavior originates from an unprecedented attractive interaction
between the said ortho-F atoms and a β-H of the growing polymer chain, which would render
the latter less prone to be transferred to the metal (or to the monomer). In this paper, we
report on a thorough full-QM and combined QM/MM investigation of representative model
catalysts, demonstrating that the key factor is instead the repulsive nonbonded contact of
the F-substituted rings with the growing polymer chain and an incoming propene molecule,
which destabilizes the sterically demanding six-center transition structure for chain transfer
to the monomer. A conceptually similar substituent effect has been reported before for several
metallocene and non-metallocene catalysts; in the present case, though, this is partly
alleviated by a weak attractive interaction between the ortho-F and a close-in-space α-H of
the growing chain