This document is the author deposited version. You are advised to consult the publisher&apos;s version if you wish to cite from it

Harfield, Steve

English

Variously used to describe a branch of knowledge, a system of rules of conduct or a method of practice, or a character trait associated with rigorous and controlled behaviour, the term a??disciplinea?? is both widespread in its application and yet considerably under-examined in regard to its expectations and consequences. While the general field of design, or each of the various sub-fields thereof, is colloquially referred to as being a discipline a?? and unreflectively accepted as such a?? quite what constitutes and informs this disciplinarity remains unclear. Arguing that design problems are, to a significant extent, personally determined rather than neutrally provided; that, while highly informed in regard to their disciplinary practice(s), design agents are inescapably influenced, driven, and, to large measure, controlled by their specific theory choices and ideological commitments; that, rather than being a knowledge-generating discipline, the field of design generally constitutes a practice-based knowledge-utilization discipline, aimed at providing service to an external world; and thus that design is essentially normative rather than explanatory-descriptive; this paper explores the nature of designa??s disciplinarity, and avers that the above factors not only actively contribute to, but promote and prolong designa??s undisciplinarity. Designa??s very characteristics are thus the roots of its undiscipline, roots that go deep into designa??s psyche, and that support and feed an enterprise that is in need of serious self-examination

Harfield, S

OPUS - University of Technology Sydney

On the Roots of Undiscipline

Sheffield Hallam University Research Archive

Ideology. In

On design ‘problematization’: Theorising differences in designed outcomes.

On the self-construction of design problems.

Quoted in The Weekend Australian,

The Oxford Dictionary of Philosophy.

Theory and Reality.

https://opus.lib.uts.edu.au/bitstream/10453/11317/1/2008000678OK.pdf

On the Roots of Undiscipline

Abstract

Similar works

Full text

Available Versions

OPUS - University of Technology Sydney

Sheffield Hallam University Research Archive