On determination upon divorce the final ownership and division of the value-added part of the mortgaged house purchased before marriage——Legal Analysis of Article 10 of The Third Judicial Explanation to The Marriage Law

Abstract

个人婚前按揭房在离婚时的产权认定及其增值部分的归属，历来是离婚时双方争议的焦点。在《适用婚姻法司法解释（三）》出台之前，法官根据具体案情及自我判断，做出相应判决，法官对此拥有较大的自由裁量权。因无统一法律规定，各地根据各地实际情况作出判决，导致同案不同判的现象存在。《适用婚姻法司法解释（三）》出台之后，引起了各界广泛的讨论，其在法律层面明确了个人婚前按揭房产权及其增值部分的归属，符合我国的立法精神。从法律层面来看，具有积极的意义。但婚姻法不同于其他部门法，有其独特性，其调整的是婚姻家庭关系，而组成婚姻家庭关系的除了财产外，还有与其密不可分的人与人之间的感情。如单从法律层面来考虑，势必会导致调整...The final ownership and division of the value-added part of a mortgaged house purchased before marriage has always been two key questions at issue upon divorce. Before The Third Judicial Explanation to The Marriage Law was promulgated, judges rendered their decisions basing on each specific case and their discretion. Therefore it was inevitable that decisions rendered varied even to cases simila...学位：法律硕士院系专业：法学院法律系_法律硕士(JM)学号：X200812001