This presentation discusses studies conducted to determine the element type and size that best represents a 20-meter solar sail under ground-test load conditions, the performance of test/Analysis correlation by using Static Shape Optimization Method for Q4 sail, and system dynamic. TRIA3 elements better represent wrinkle patterns than do QUAD3 elements Baseline, ten-inch elements are small enough to accurately represent sail shape, and baseline TRIA3 mesh requires a reasonable computation time of 8 min. 21 sec. In the test/analysis correlation by using Static shape optimization method for Q4 sail, ten parameters were chosen and varied during optimization. 300 sail models were created with random parameters. A response surfaces for each targets which were created based on the varied parameters. Parameters were optimized based on response surface. Deflection shape comparison for 0 and 22.5 degrees yielded a 4.3% and 2.1% error respectively. For the system dynamic study testing was done on the booms without the sails attached. The nominal boom properties produced a good correlation to test data the frequencies were within 10%. Boom dominated analysis frequencies and modes compared well with the test results

Banik, J.

Lively, P.

Murphy, D.

Taleghani, B.

Trautt, T.

NASA Technical Reports Server

a 
https://ntrs.nasa.gov/search.jsp?R=20060005594 2019-08-29T21:31:31+00:00Z
a c 
c, 
A 
0, 
0 
0 
S 
I= 
0 
-
z 
S 
(u 
0 , c CI 
CI 
.- 8 
o> 
€ , 
S 
rc 
0 
v) 
cn 
a, 
a, c 
c, 
c, 
c, 
v) 
a, 
01 
0 
0 
S c 
0 
a, 
S 
0 
v) 
.- 
-
c, 
.- -
- 
(u 
3 
0 
3 
L 
c, 
L 
65 
v) 
' S  
0 
v) 
v) 
.- 
.- 
E 
a 
S 
0 
' 3  
U 
S 
0 
0 
.- 
c, 
a, 
0 r: 
Q) 
0 
v) 
.- 
U 
S 
(v 
L 
' S  01 S a 
0 
03 
Q 
v) 
I .- 
v) 
S 
a, 
v> 
uj 
.- 
Y 
a, 
0 , 
Q 
v) 
t .- 
E .- 
-3 
U 
a, 
0 
S 
(u > 
2 
a
a a 
7 
- 
a, > 
P 
c, x 
S 
(TJ 
.s 
CI 
Q 
0 
a, > 
a, 
U 
- E k5 
.- 6 
E 
CI E 
P 
Y- 
v) 
v) 
0 
-cI 
0 
v) 
c, 
.- 
a, x 
0 cn 
(u 
.-  
-
cn 
a, 
C 
0 
-3 
E 
U 
S 
CO 
.. 
c, 
v) 
0 
0 a, > 
0 
a, 
0 
.- 
.c-, 
3 
5 
a, 
C 
ic 
a, 
S 
a, a 
CI 
5 
0 
5 
7 
0 
S .- 
0 
3 
U 
a, 
L 
i 
U 
S 
(u 
2 
c- 
c, 
(u 
E 
P 
e 0, 
Q 
a, 
if 
E 
0 
.s 
3 
(u 
CI e- 
P m 
0 
S 
a, 
(u 
S 
a, 
d 
-L 
0 
S 
! m 
@ a ,  
.- S O  
s g  a, -c 0 cv 
a, 
0 
W 
LL 
E 
0 cv 
S 
0 
m 
N 
.- + 
% m 
S 
5 
.- 
E .- + a 
0 
a, 
Q m c cn 
0 .- 
cn 
c m 
33 cn 
a, + 
a 
cn 
% 
CA 
+ 
tn 
m 
I= 
0 
0) m 
-
.- m n 
7S 
Q) 
t 
0 
tn r 
a, 
.- 
* 
d> 
a" 
c 
E + 
C 
rn 8 
a" 
.- E 
u) 
S 
S 
0 
0 
- 
P 
s 
v) 
P 
v 
(3 
I- - w - L 
Q) m C 
T a z Q) 
0 
L 
* a 
2 
G- 
I 
Q) 
C 
Y 
0 
zl 
2 
>- 
A 
... 
v) m 
3 
U .- 
s: 
6 tn 
to .c, 
E" 
L 
3 
0 
b 
L 
c. 3 
0 
3 
v) 
L c,
a, 
5 
0 c. 
Q) 
W 
- U t m CLI -
.- E" 
a 
+ 
3 
d 
Q) 
S 
LL 
* 
I- 
I- Ai- a 
E" 
u, 
L 0 
CI 3 
0 
b U 
Q) > 
a, 
E" 
L 
E" m 
v) 
a, x 
a, 
v) 
3 
c, 
v) 
0 
U 
S 
0 
S 
-
.I 
v) .- 
Q, m 
0 
L - 3 
0 
v) 
4 
2 
c, 
v) 
m 
v) 
- ._. L m 
0 m 
-
L 
3 
0 
4- 
8 
A 
v) 
0 
0 
(Y 
- a 
W 
8 
c, 
S 
E 
a, w 
a 
S 
L L  
a cn 
c, 
.I 
.I 
- .I 
a 
ir 
m 
ZI 
U a 
=I 
W 
w 
$! 
i5 
E 
0 
.I-r 
E w .- 
3' 
r m 
E 
0 
m a 
fl 
.- 
A A  
0 
.c, 
U 
a, 
0 
a, 
t 
S 
CI 
8 
cn 
a, cn 
# 
E" 
.c, 
t 
0 
Q. 
.- 
2 
P 
m 
# 
a, 
c, 
c 
A 
13) 
S 
U 
S 
a, a 
.- 
a, > m c 
\c 
0 
A 
rn 
Q) 
U 
0 z 
- .- 
m 
CO 
0 
Lo 
c\I 
7 
h 
3 
5 
Q) 
Q 
Y- 
O 
I 
E 
0 
0 
ccl 
3 
W 
LL 
.- as cn 
0 
v> 
L 
a, 
a, 
.c.r 
€ 
0 
N 
a, 
Q 
0 
+ + +  
m 
fr' 
'$3 cn 
a, a. m r cn 
0 
cn 
0 
+ + +  
I 
5 L 
3 
U a 
0 
0 
& 
a 
F 
a z 
I- . 
fi .- 
0 
7 
il 
a 
E 
.- fi 
I- . 
LD 
7 
a 
E 
I- 
C .- 
0 cv 
c .- 
0 
r 
r' .- 
0 cv 
r' .- 
0 m 
f 
, I I I=I 
P 
Q 
3 
A 
A 
A ._ 
P 
i .- 
1 
3 
E 
&! 
r %  
v ) -  
P 
E 
1 
rl * 
3 a 
n a 
a 
S 
a 
v) as 
.-  
m 
c 
v) 
E A 
P 
ic) 
3 
i .- 
0 m 
A A 
1 
, .  . 
r 
0 
J 
a, 
SI 
S 
a, 
a, 
a, 
II 
a, 
0 
S 
a, 
U 
c1 
3 * 
E? 
s 
0 
L c .- v 
0 
u) 
P 
5 * 
S 
a, 
0 
a, 
II cu 
S 
0 cn a 
a, 
a 
cn 
a, 
3 
m 
a, 
-
L 
I .- 
I 
Y- 
O 
0 
0 
1 
9 
2 
W 
L L  
cn 
cn s 
0 
m 
.- + 
G 
8 
0 
a, 
Q 
- m 
S m 
'33 cn 
a, 
.clr 
cn 
0 .- 
E m c > 
Q 
E 
a, 
cn 
>s 
cf) 
.c.r 
Y) 
0 
U 
S m d a, a m c 
v) 
B 
9 
E I 
4 
d 
-c.r 
v) 
a, - cn 
a, m m 
a, 
C 
T3 
S m 
G 
.- 
.- E 
CI 
t 
3 
m 
a, 
0 
S 
U 
L 
2 
a, 
u) 
S 
E! 
a 
5: 
CI S rn 
a, - t 0 E 0 t 
v) 
0 
t x 
S 
3 
5 
v 
L 
c, 
c 
.I 
cn 
S 
0 
> 
a, 
S 
0 
U 
a, cn m a 
U 
a, 
m 
S 
.- 
k 
-c.r 
.- 
F 
Ca 
0 
m 
cn 
.- 
CI 
c, a, 
v) 
3 cn 
3 c 
CI 
v) 
P 
a, 
U cn Q 
cn 
s! 
CI 
E 
a, 
CI 
E m 
a 
Q 
L 
a, 
m 
U 
t m 
L G 
s! 
+-r 
E 
m 
Q 
(ZI 
0 
>r 
S 
Y- 
c, 
.- 
2 
a, 
0 
S 
3 
O 
a, 
a, 
0, 
a, 
73 
Y- 
L 
ts 
c, 
S U a, 
v) m 
d 
rn L a, > m c 
U m 
3 
n 
v) 
5 
5 n 
CI 
E m 
u) 
t 
3 a 
S 
0 
0 
S 
0 
S 
.- 
+-r 
.- 
L 
-I--I 
I 
S 
a, cn 
0 
5: 
0 
t 
a, 
.-  
CI 
S a, z 0 m cn s! U 0 v) -cn c 
3 
O 
L 
Y- 
a, 
U 
Eo 
rr- 
-c.r 
0 
S 
3 
E a 
5 
U 
2 
a, 
c, 
E 
m 
a 
F 
E a 
a, 
-c.r 
a, 
IJ) 
S 
cn 
-
.- 
IC 
0 
.- m I. 0 a, 5: 
CI 
U 
a, 
0 
a, 
a, cn 
- 
-
tij 
E 
d 
3 c 
C 
0 
m 
S 
.- 
c, 
m L c 
0 
m 
S 
m x 
W 
I- + 
.- 
E 
.. 
0 m n. 
>r 
S 
m a, 
g 0, S S 
0 
0 a 
.- 
CI 
E .-  
W 
A 
E 
(u 
I r" cn 3 
A 
a, 
L 
0 
I- P m n A A 
+ + 
2 
0 
a, 
II 
Y- 
h *. 
v) 
0 
0 
(Y 
d 
*. 
I 
n 
CD 
rn 
U a 
0 -
r 
E 
0 
7 
.- 
A 
G u
v) 
S 
0 
0 
a, 
U 
.I 
CI 
L 
.I 
3 
S 
c 
0 m 
a, 
a, 
> 
a, 
.I 
Ui 
tij 
.I 
$ 
cn 
S 
0 
cn 
0 n 
U 
>s 
rn 
I 
+ 
.I 
c, 
.I 
5 -
U 
a, > 
E 
A 
S .- 
2 a > 
0 
CI 
L 
E m  
A 
n 
F 
U 
U 
a, 
m > 
.- 
L. 
cn 
0 
Q 
+ 
.- 
v) 
0 
2 b  
I-CL 
A 
U 
a, 
73 a 
0 
S 
-
A 
x -I 
3 cn 
a, cn 
S 
0 
Q cn 
2 
m 
0 
I. 
S 
0 
rn 
a, 
.- + 
6 
E 
a, -c.r 
E m 
a t5 
A 
a, 
23) 
S co 
a, c 
L 
L .- 
c., 
A a A A  
t 
v) 
a, 
v) 
0 
0 
a, 
.- 
c. 
-
k 
5 
c. m 
c -- -- a, 
g 3  
A 
.- E 
\ i! 
.- E 
x 
t .- 
E - m 
0 
0 
0 
a, 
t 
Q 
-
+I, 
Q 
2 
E 
e 
% 
2 
b t 
E 
v) 
a, 
0 
3 
0 
.- 
t 
0 
Q 
v) 
a 
a, 
d 
cn a, 
tn c 
0 " 
tn 
a, 
a, 
I C  
L 
CI 
8 
Y- 
tn 
tn m a 
a, 
c 
U 
a, 
73 
' 3  
0 
S 
tn 
.- 
-c.r 
.- 
- 
.- 
.- 
d Q> 
3 
t 
-c.r 
.- 
€ 
m 
c .- 
a 
E s! 
3 
Q 
v) 
v) 
v) m 
4 
a 
0 
.  
9 
a, 
0 
v) 
cn .- m 
9 3 v) - -  m .- 3 3  a, 0 
3 
v) 
+! 
a, cn 
S 
0 a. cn 
2 
cn 3 
v) 
a 
v, 
t 
0 
Q 
v) 
a, 
Q) c 
L 
CI 
cn 
a, 
0 
S 
v) 
+! 
3 
(" a, 
v) 
t 
0 
0 
73 
a, 
a, 
v) 
S 
0 
a, ul 
v) 
a, L 
3 
i 
U 
a, 
U 
S 
- 
v) tn 
a, 
3 
o> 
v) 
a, L 
S 
0 
c 
3 L 
e m 
v) 
a, 
0 
m a m Q x 
a, 
a, c 
c, 
v) .- S 
0 3 .t" 
3 
( " n c u  
C 
0 .- 
-Y 
~ 
Y 
'Z  
b 
E 
N 
.I 
.I 
CI 
Q 
0 
t 
3 
5 
E 
+ 
a, c 
.c-r 
a, 
0 
S 
N .- 
E 
rc 
0 .- 
0 
Q 
tn 
a, 
a 
L 
i-' 
A 
L 
.cI cn m 
+-i n. 
0 
3 a 
t 
7 
m e c 3 <r: 
A A A  A 
+ 

N 3.- 
E .- 
'E' * 
> . 
. . 
. 
I 
z? 
e 
Q, 
U 
E" 
m 
Q 
c m 
v) m c 
L - - 
0 L 
,o 
I .- I .- 
I 
Y 
5- 
. . 
I......... 
a, 
0 3 
m 
U 
3 
- .- 
v) 
8 
l i j 
L . 
Ij 
s 
Q, 
S 
v) cu 
7 
P * 4 
z 
W 
LL 
al cn 
L m -
0 
cf) 
CCT 
$3 cn 
a, 
3-.r 
cn 
0 .- 
E m c 
0" 
€ 
a, 
cn 
% 
+ 
cf) 
c 
0 .- 
v, 
3 
0 
C 
-
8 
w 
Y- 
d. 
.Clr 
S m 
U m 
L 
6 
8 
I. 
m 
G 
a, 
3 
0 
u, 
L 
+-r 
2 
+-r 
a, 
-r: 
t 
0 
cn 
t 
0 
Q 
S 
CI 
+ 
.- 
T3 
a, 
0 
S 
a, 
a, 
cn 
E? 
Y- 
L 
.- 
m 
m 
U 
- 
0 a 
a, 
f 
a A A  
E a 
v) 
h 
v) 
c, 
a, 
m 
t 
CI 
.- 
U 
0 
0 
8 
a, 
II: 
-cI 
m 
t 
CCI 
a, 
-t 
-c.i 
S 
U 
a, 
U 
3 
0 
C 
.- 
-
.- 
0 
A 
d 
a, 
-I= 
S 
0 
-cI 
v) 
S 
0 
Q 
+ 
.I 
m 
Q 
E 
0 
0 
a, 
rc 
a, 
U 
a, 
Ff 
v) 
3 
v) 
CI -
2 
L 
rc O 
v) 
v) >r 
m s 
m 
.- 
-
U c 
m 
v) 
Q) 
* 
c, 
0 
m 
u3 
t: 
0 
a 
t' 
v, 
3 
' v ,  
CI -
2 
& u- 
v) 
3 
v, 
c. -
2 
c, 
Q) 
m E? 
c, 
c, 
v) 
0 -
0 
c, 
E 
0 
k 
Q) 
5 
v) .- 
5 
Q 
Q) 
U 
x m 
Q) 
Q 
Q 
nl. 
1 
E 
i 
L 
h 
(Y 
1 
a, 
II 
+-, a, c 
c, 
0 +-r 
U 
a, 
U 
> 
a 
.- 
e 
U 
a, 
123 
a, 
w 
123 
CI 
6 
3 
rc 
0 cn t 
0 
cn 
t 
a> 
.I - 
U 
123 
a, 
cn 
S 
CI 
.- 
a 
Q 
a, 
G 
a 
L 
i U a, > 0 
Q m 
U 
I= 
123 
cn 
U 
123 
0 -
U 
a, 
3 cn m 
L 
E 
v) 
S cn 
a, 
.clr -
L 
m i =  
3 
.- a 
)* a 
U 
a, 
U 
a, 
cn m 
v) 
a, 
tr 
a, a 
0 
Q 
.- 
L 
t 
0 
3 
0 
u) 
.- 
CI -
~ 
.II 
a, 
Q 
0 
k 
cn m a, 
S .-  cn a, 
‘Icl 
a, a 
0 
a 
.- 
L 
123 
0 
c 
a, 
U 
.I 
CI 
.- 
a, 
-n a 
cn 
S 
S 
>1 
-
+-r 
cn cu - .I 
123 ‘cn 
U 
123 
0 -
a 
0 
0 
& 
d- 
S 
U m 
3 
ZT 
+-r 
E! 
.- 
co 
a, 
I= 
a, 
a, 
d 
.cI 
8 rc 
2 
0 
0 
m 
S 
0 
S 
a 
I: 
a 
a cn 
cn 
U m 
0 
.- 
E 
+-r 
+-r 
+-r 
-
U 
h 
123 
5 -
- .- 
a 
u) m 
S U a, 
m 
U 
Q 
+-r 
U 
a, II- 
a, c 
c, 
.- cn a 
0 r= 
2 
.- 
U 
a, 
S 
a, > 
Q 
c, 
2 
U 
a, 
0) 
S a 
L 
U 
m a 
a, 
E2 
k 
t5 0 
a, 
U 
c, 
E 
3 
v) rn c 
;cJ 
a, cn m 
d 
cn 
a, 
v) 
3 
v) 
U cu 
0 
_. 
- 
a, 
U 
0 
a 
0 .- a 0 0 
Q 
cn u) m 
3 cn m 
3 
a, 
U 
E 
E E 
U 
a, 
Y 
cn 
U a 
0 -
- 
a, 
U 
E 
if 
a, 
A 
-sE m 
=-I 
m 
Iz 
(0 
S 
0” 
r m 73 
S 
0 
0 
a, cn 
A 
- 
123 tu U a a, c 
A 
a, 
II 
t- 
a, 
Iz 
t- 
a, 
L E 3 
2 
a, 
E 
I 
A a A A A A 
;+ 
og 
N 
In 
0 
0 
N 
v, 
0 
m c 
.I 
E 
0" 
E 
m 
0 
0 
0 
a, 
v) 
3 
- 
m 
m 
v) 
c, 
n 
? 
-c-r 
.cI 
3 
0 
I- 
A 
m 
S 
0 
U 
S 
a, 
# 
a, 
.- 
.cI .- 
8 
5 
2 
c, 
0 
a, 
G= 
0 
m 
a, 
[u 
0 
v) 
CI 
c, 
2 
s 
a 
- 
a, 
U 
A 
c, 
Y $
a, 
c, - L 
c, 
0 
E 
0 
c, 
0 
0 
a A 
8 
2 
C s 
- 
3 
N 
r 
UJ 
0 
0 
hl 
# c 
0 
# c 
a, 
.- 
.c.r 
a, a m 
a, > m 
L 
.cI 
S 
a, 
a, 
U 
L 
!E 
a, 
I= 
I- 
+ 
- 
a, 
U 
E 
E 
C 
0 
0 
d 
a, 
5 
rn 
C 
U 
C 
a, 
12 
.- 
E 
0 
0 a 
A 
cn 
a, 
0 
S m 
m >s 
m 
5 
S 
a, rn 
S a 
1= 
0 
a 
cn 
a, cn 
3 a o 
-
e 
-
.- 
E 
0 
0 
4 
a, 
5 
O 
a 
C 
U 
C 
a, cn 
A 
c, 
Y- 
.- 
cn 
a cn 
- .- 
0 c 
c, 
S 
0 
Is) 
S .- 
L m 
cn 
a, cn 
23 
cn .- 
Ff 
A 
cn 
a, 
U 
-
E 
cn 
cn 
% 
a 
C a 
.- 
-
a, c 
c, 
Y- 
O 
> 
+-r .- .- 
12 m 
cn 
a, 
II: 
cn 
a, cn m 
a, 
a, 
cl 
c, 
w 
t3 
A 
cn 
0, 
a, 
E 
3 
.I 
a, 
E 
+ 
E 
0 
0 
4 
a, 
If 
c, 
c ts 
0 
c, 
m 
cn 
a, 
0 
3 
73 
0 
r? 
A 
d .- 
8 I
I 
L 
(Ij 
Q) 
0 
P) 
a, 
.- 
L 
c, 
8 
B 
c 
c 
0 
0 
.- 
.- 
c, 
E 
w c 
([I 
0 
C 
P) 
v) 
U 
Q) 
([I 
E 
.- 
c, 
v) 
Q) 
U 
0 
U 
a, 
([I c 
0 
v) 
([I 
a, 
€ 
c, 
.- 
E 
-? 
E 
s 
6 
* 
U 
3 
c 
P) 
w .- 
E 
Y- 
O 
b e 
0 
c 
([I 
h 
v) 
([I 
v) 
n 
- .- 
U 
Q) 
m c, 
c 1 t 
v) 
0 
0 
hl 
E 
L 
L 
N 
I 
cv 
d- 
7 
o 
UJ 
0 
0 
(Y 
LL - .- m 
v) 
L m 
0 
c/) 
-
L 
a, 
a, 
.clr 
E 
0 
c\I 
U 
S 
5 
a, 
CL m c 
u) 
0 
m 
*- + 
Zi 
a, 
Q m c cn 
+ + + +  
cn 
0 .- 
E m 
zz 
>r n 
E 
2 
E 
E 
S cn + +  
v) 
0 
0 
v) 
a, 
0 
S 
a, 
3 
W 
a, 
t 
a, 
.- 
5 
U 
S m a a, 
> 
.- 
2 
B a 
3 a 
Ts 
m 
- 
a, 
U 
ca a 
3 
E 
(I) 
5 co co 
'13 
v) 
a, 
c, 
c, 
c, 
U a 
a, 
>r 
= .- 0 TJ 0 .c.r 
c m 
5 
cn a 
a, 
cn L. 
8 cn a 
t: m a. 
E a, cn 
S 
0 
Q 
v) 
2 U t m S 0 0 TJ 
a, 
v) m 
8 
Y- 
S 
0 cn 
m 
.- 
L 
e 
8 
U 
a, 
N .- 
E .- 
c, a. 
0 
a 
t= a 
11 a, 
Q m 
8 
cn 
t 
CI 
E 
a, 
a - t 0 
0 a 
4= 
a, 
.- 
CI 
n 
2 
2 
t- m 
A A  A A A 
+ 


20 Meter Solar Sail Analysis and Correlation

This paper describes finite element analyses and correlation studies to predict deformations and vibration modes/frequencies of a 20-meter solar sail system developed by ATK Space Systems. Under the programmatic leadership of NASA Marshall Space Flight Center's In-Space Propulsion activity, the 20-meter solar sail program objectives were to verify the design, to assess structural responses of the sail system, to implement lessons learned from a previous 10-meter quadrant system analysis and test program, and to mature solar sail technology to a technology readiness level (TRL) of 5. For this 20 meter sail system, static and ground vibration tests were conducted in NASA Glenn Research Center's 100 meter diameter vacuum chamber at Plum Brook station. Prior to testing, a preliminary analysis was performed to evaluate test conditions and to determine sensor and actuator locations. After testing was completed, an analysis of each test configuration was performed. Post-test model refinements included updated properties to account for the mass of sensors, wiring, and other components used for testing. This paper describes the development of finite element models (FEM) for sail membranes and masts in each of four quadrants at both the component and system levels, as well as an optimization procedure for the static test/analyses correlation

20 Meter Solar Sail Analysis and Correlation

Abstract

Similar works

Full text

Available Versions

NASA Technical Reports Server

NASA Technical Reports Server