The sensitivity of the Statistical Multifragmentation Model to the underlying
statistical assumptions is investigated. We concentrate on its micro-canonical,
canonical, and isobaric formulations. As far as average values are concerned,
our results reveal that all the ensembles make very similar predictions, as
long as the relevant macroscopic variables (such as temperature, excitation
energy and breakup volume) are the same in all statistical ensembles. It also
turns out that the multiplicity dependence of the breakup volume in the
micro-canonical version of the model mimics a system at (approximately)
constant pressure, at least in the plateau region of the caloric curve.
However, in contrast to average values, our results suggest that the
distributions of physical observables are quite sensitive to the statistical
assumptions. This finding may help deciding which hypothesis corresponds to the
best picture for the freeze-out stageComment: 20 pages, 7 figure