Topology of the Universe: background and recent observational approaches

Is the Universe (a spatial section thereof) finite or infinite? Knowing the global geometry of a Friedmann-Lema\^{\i}tre (FL) universe requires knowing both its curvature and its topology. A flat or hyperbolic (``open'') FL universe is {\em not} necessarily infinite in volume. Multiply connected flat and hyperbolic models are, in general, as consistent with present observations on scales of 1-20{\hGpc} as are the corresponding simply connected flat and hyperbolic models. The methods of detecting multiply connected models (MCM's) are presently in their pioneering phase of development and the optimal observationally realistic strategy is probably yet to be calculated. Constraints against MCM's on ~1-4 h^{-1} Gpc scales have been claimed, but relate more to inconsistent assumptions on perturbation statistics rather than just to topology. Candidate 3-manifolds based on hypothesised multiply imaged objects are being offered for observational refutation. The theoretical and observational sides of this rapidly developing subject have yet to make any serious contact, but the prospects of a significant detection in the coming decade may well propel the two together.Comment: 5 pages, proceedings of the Workshop ``Cosmology: Observations Confront Theories,'' 11-17 Jan 1999, IIT Kharagpur, West Bengal, to appear in Pramana - Journal of Physic

The optimal phase of the generalised Poincare dodecahedral space hypothesis implied by the spatial cross-correlation function of the WMAP sky maps

Several studies have proposed that the shape of the Universe may be a Poincare dodecahedral space (PDS) rather than an infinite, simply connected, flat space. Both models assume a close to flat FLRW metric of about 30% matter density. We study two predictions of the PDS model. (i) For the correct model, the spatial two-point cross-correlation function, \ximc, of temperature fluctuations in the covering space, where the two points in any pair are on different copies of the surface of last scattering (SLS), should be of a similar order of magnitude to the auto-correlation function, \xisc, on a single copy of the SLS. (ii) The optimal orientation and identified circle radius for a "generalised" PDS model of arbitrary twist $\phi$, found by maximising \ximc relative to \xisc in the WMAP maps, should yield $\phi \in \{\pm 36\deg\}$. We optimise the cross-correlation at scales < 4.0 h^-1 Gpc using a Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) method over orientation, circle size and $\phi$. Both predictions were satisfied: (i) an optimal "generalised" PDS solution was found, with a strong cross-correlation between points which would be distant and only weakly correlated according to the simply connected hypothesis, for two different foreground-reduced versions of the WMAP 3-year all-sky map, both with and without the kp2 Galaxy mask: the face centres are $(l,b)_{i=1,6}\approx (184d, 62d), (305d, 44d), (46d, 49d), (117d, 20d), (176d, -4d), (240d, 13d) to within ~2d, and their antipodes; (ii) this solution has twist \phi= (+39 \pm 2.5)d, in agreement with the PDS model. The chance of this occurring in the simply connected model, assuming a uniform distribution$\phi \in [0,2\pi]$, is about 6-9%.Comment: 20 pages, 22 figures, accepted in Astronomy & Astrophysics, software available at http://adjani.astro.umk.pl/GPLdownload/dodec/ and MCMCs at http://adjani.astro.umk.pl/GPLdownload/MCM

Transverse Galaxy Velocities from Multiple Topological Images

The study of the kinematics of galaxies within clusters or groups has the limitation that only one of the three velocity components and only two of the three spatial components of a galaxy position in six-dimensional phase space can normally be measured. However, if multiple topological images of a cluster exist, then the radial positions and sky plane mean velocities of galaxies in the cluster may also be measurable from photometry of the two cluster images. The vector arithmetic and principles of the analysis are presented. These are demonstrated by assuming the suggested topological identification of the clusters RX J1347.5-1145 and CL 09104+4109 to be correct and deducing the sky-plane relative velocity component along the axis common to both images of this would-be single cluster. Three out of four of the inferred transverse velocities are consistent with those expected in a rich cluster. A control sample of random `common' sky-plane axes, independent of the topological hypothesis, implies that this is not surprising. This shows that while galaxy kinematics are deducible from knowledge of cosmological topology, it is not easy to use them to refute a specific candidate manifold.Comment: 13 pages, 7 figures, accepted for MNRA

A test of the Poincare dodecahedral space topology hypothesis with the WMAP CMB data

It has been suggested by Roukema and coworkers (hereafter R04) that the topology of the Universe as probed by the ``matched circles'' method using the first year release of the WMAP CMB data, might be that of the Poincar\'e dodecahedral space (PDS) model. An excess in the correlation of the ``identified circles'' was reported by R04, for circles of angular radius of ~11 deg for a relative phase twist -36deg, hinting that this could be due to a Clifford translation, if the hypothesized model were true. R04 did not however specify the statistical significance of the correlation signal. We investigate the statistical significance of the signal using Monte Carlo CMB simulations in a simply connected Universe, and present an updated analysis using the three-year WMAP data. We find that our analyses of the first and three year WMAP data provide results that are consistent with the simply connected space at a confidence level as low as 68%.Comment: 8 pages, 6 figures, typo corrected/replaced to match version published in A&

A weak acceleration effect due to residual gravity in a multiply connected universe

Could cosmic topology imply dark energy? We use a weak field (Newtonian) approximation of gravity and consider the gravitational effect from distant, multiple copies of a large, collapsed (virialised) object today (i.e. a massive galaxy cluster), taking into account the finite propagation speed of gravity, in a flat, multiply connected universe, and assume that due to a prior epoch of fast expansion (e.g. inflation), the gravitational effect of the distant copies is felt locally, from beyond the naively calculated horizon. We find that for a universe with a $T^1xR^2$ spatial section, the residual Newtonian gravitational force (to first order) provides an anisotropic effect that repels test particles from the cluster in the compact direction, in a way algebraically similar to that of dark energy. For a typical test object at comoving distance $\chi$ from the nearest dense nodes of the cosmic web of density perturbations, the pressure-to-density ratio $w$ of the equation of state in an FLRW universe, is w \sim - (\chi/L)^3, where $L$ is the size of the fundamental domain, i.e. of the universe. Clearly, |w|<<1. For a T^3 spatial section of exactly equal fundamental lengths, the effect cancels to zero. For a T^3 spatial section of unequal fundamental lengths, the acceleration effect is anisotropic in the sense that it will *tend to equalise the three fundamental lengths*. Provided that at least a modest amount of inflation occurred in the early Universe, and given some other conditions, multiple connectedness does generate an effect similar to that of dark energy, but the amplitude of the effect at the present epoch is too small to explain the observed dark energy density and its anisotropy makes it an unrealistic candidate for the observed dark energy.Comment: 12 pages, 8 figures, accepted by Astronomy & Astrophysics; v2 includes 3D calculation and result; v3 includes analysis of numerical simulation, matches accepted versio

Does gravity prefer the Poincare dodecahedral space?

The missing fluctuations problem in cosmic microwave background observations is naturally explained by well-proportioned small universe models. Among the well-proportioned models, the Poincare dodecahedral space is empirically favoured. Does gravity favour this space? The residual gravity effect is the residual acceleration induced by weak limit gravity from multiple topological images of a massive object on a nearby negligible mass test object. At the present epoch, the residual gravity effect is about a million times weaker in three of the well-proportioned spaces than in ill-proportioned spaces. However, in the Poincare space, the effect is 10,000 times weaker still, i.e. the Poincare space is about 10^{10} times "better balanced" than ill-proportioned spaces. Both observations and weak limit dynamics select the Poincare space to be special.Comment: 6 pages, Honorable Mention in 2009 Gravity Research Foundation essay competitio