308 research outputs found
Erratum to “Estimating the burden of COVID-19 on the Australian healthcare workers and health system during the first six months of the pandemic” [International Journal of Nursing Studies, 114 (2021), 103811] (International Journal of Nursing Studies (2021) 114, (S0020748920302972), (10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2020.103811))
The publisher regrets to inform that due to a typesetter error during the correction of the proofs, the following errors were missed: In Table 2: National HCW should be 2.69 with a 95% Cl of 2.48-2.93, as indicated in the text. On page 9, the duplicate word “suggests” was not removed. The Publisher apologises for these errors and any inconvenience caused
Automated monitoring of tweets for early detection of the 2014 Ebola epidemic
First reported in March 2014, an Ebola epidemic impacted West Africa, most notably Liberia, Guinea and Sierra Leone. We demonstrate the value of social media for automated surveillance of infectious diseases such as the West Africa Ebola epidemic. We experiment with two variations of an existing surveillance architecture: the first aggregates tweets related to different symptoms together, while the second considers tweets about each symptom separately and then aggregates the set of alerts generated by the architecture. Using a dataset of tweets posted from the affected region from 2011 to 2014, we obtain alerts in December 2013, which is three months prior to the official announcement of the epidemic. Among the two variations, the second, which produces a restricted but useful set of alerts, can potentially be applied to other infectious disease surveillance and alert systems
Screening and prevention of Tuberculosis : the impact of screening policy and practice on public health outcomes
Tuberculosis (TB) is a disease of public health importance due to the associated
morbidity and mortality as well as the potential for transmission of infection to
uninfected contacts. Tuberculosis can be prevented by screening of high risk groups and
targeted prophylaxis with isoniazid (INH). Screening programs with structured
guidelines exist for the screening of many groups at risk for TB, including refugees,
contacts, health workers and prisoners, with some run by health authorities and others
by employers.
Screening programs for TB may focus on case finding, prevention or a combination of
both, and may differ in their aims, guidelines, practice and resources. The outcomes and
effectiveness of such programs may also differ, and may be influenced by a number of
factors. These include the nature of screening guidelines and whether such guidelines
are evidence based, the consistency between policy and practice of screening by health
professionals, and external factors such as structural or political change and financial
restrictions. The null hypothesis is that TB screening programs operate under evidence based
guidelines, have good implementation of guidelines and have optimal outcomes.
Aims
To examine screening programs for contacts, refugees and prisoners in selected programs in Australia and the USA. Because of the differences in screening methods
and policy outlined above, I aimed to examine the rationale of screening policies and
their scientific basis, the efficacy of screening practice, whether screening guidelines are
properly implemented by medical and nursing staff, what intrinsic and extrinsic
problems may have hindered the implementation of guidelines, and the outcomes of
screening programs as measured by the incidence of active TB and skin test conversion,
and the prevention of active TB.
Methods
I undertook a series of separate studies in order to address the aims above. The studies
are outlined below. The first chapter presents background and a general literature
review, but more specific literature reviews are contained in the subsequent chapters.
1) The first study retrospectively estimates missed opportunities for prevention of TB in
notified cases of active TB in Victoria, Australia. All notified cases of active TB in
1991 in Victoria (n=231) were reviewed for any past screening for TB. If such
screening or indications for screening were documented, each case was evaluated as to
whether appropriate preventive action was taken. Missed opportunities for prevention of
TB were quantified for each case.
2) The next chapter is a retrospective cohort study of 1,142 contacts of tuberculosis
screened in 1991. This cohort was screened by health authorities in Victoria, Australia,
and had two years of follow up for the development of active disease. The study
describes the two-year incidence of TB in recent contacts. Skin test reaction sizes were correlated with risk of developing active disease in order to provide data to select
appropriate criteria for the interpretation of the test. Preventability of incident cases of
TB was quantified retrospectively.
3) The third study is a detailed analysis of each step of screening and prevention in the
1,142 recent contacts described in item (2) above. This study compares recommended
guidelines with actual practice.
4) The cost effectiveness of contact screening per case prevented and per case found was
estimated for three different models. The first model describes cost effectiveness of
contact screening as it was conducted in 1991; the second model describes cost
effectiveness of contact screening had the 1991 guidelines been followed closely; and
the final model describes the cost effectiveness of contact screening practised according
to hypothetical, evidence-based guidelines.
5) This study is a retrospective cohort study of 1,101 Indo-Chinese refugees screened
between 1989-1990 in Victoria, Australia. The study included five years of follow up
for the development of active disease. Skin test reaction sizes were correlated with risk
of developing active disease in order to provide data to select appropriate criteria for the
interpretation of the test. Preventability of incident cases was assessed retrospectively.
6) This study is a detailed analysis of each step of screening and prevention in the 1,1 01
refugees, comparing recommended guidelines with actual practice. 7) This study is a comparison of tuberculin skin test distributions in a number of
Victorian populations of varying degree of risk for TB. The skin test distributions are
used to assess the sensitivity and specificity of the cut-off points used in Victoria at the
time for defining a positive reaction.
8) This is a study to determine the incidence of skin test conversion during annual
screening of inmates of Maryland prisons, with an analysis of the impact of TB control
measures and risk factors on the incidence of skin test conversion.
9) A study of the skin test converters identified in (8) above was then conducted to
determine exposure to undetected TB within the correctional system. The movements
within the correctional system of skin test converters were matched with those of
inmates with documented infectious TB. This was supplemented by a linkage study
with the State TB registry to identify cases of active TB which may have been missed
within the prison system.
1 0) In the same group, I studied implementation of screening guidelines by prison
medical and nursing staff and the utilisation of INH prophylaxis.
Results
The study of all notified cases of active TB in 1991 identified that nearly half of all
notified cases of TB have been screened for TB in the past, and yet this screening had
failed to prevent the development of active TB. Over 70% of those screened were found
to be at risk for TB, but rates of preventive therapy were low. Nearly 30% of cases may have been prevented.
There was evidence that the guidelines for screening and prevention used in Victoria for
refugees and contacts required updating. These guidelines emphasise case finding rather
than identification of asymptomatic infection and prevention, and rely more on chest
radiograph (CXR) screening than skin testing. In addition, the guidelines were poorly
implemented . This was partly explained by devolution of TB screening programs in the
1970s and 1980s and lack of resources.
In nearly 60% of contacts, the presence or absence of infection could not be determined
because a skin test was not done, and a CXR, if done, was clear. The rate of preventive
therapy for eligible contacts and refugees was low. The two year incidence of active
pulmonary TB was 5311100,000 per year for contacts, and 110/100,000 per year for
refugees. Of the incident cases, many were considered "not infected" at the time of
screening because of they had received BCG vaccine in the past and had a skin test
reaction of 1 0-19mm. In logistic regression models testing various skin test cut-off
points, a reading of 15mm or more was the strongest predictor of the development of
active TB for contacts. The use of a 20mm cut-off excludes most individuals who are at
risk. The incidence of active TB increased with increasing skin test reaction size.
The direct cost of contact screening as it was actually performed in 1991 was
A248,708 per case found and A81 ,892 per case prevented, A1 ,004 per contact traced. In an alternative model which I propose, the costs would be A319 ,670 per case found and A$793 per contact traced.
The guidelines used in Maryland prisons, in contrast, are well supported by the
literature. However, I found a poor implementation of guidelines by prison medical and
nursing staff, and a low rate of preventive therapy for eligible inmates. Skin test
conversions occurred at a rate of 6.3/100 person-years, and the rate of preventive
therapy was lowest for this high risk group. Reasons for not giving, or prematurely
ceasing INH were largely unfounded. The rate of true side effects was low. There was a
wide variation in skin test conversion rates and in rates of giving INH, between different
prisons and prison types. The highest risk of conversion was in the intake institution. A
strong positive correlation existed between prison crowding and skin test conversion,
and a strong negative correlation with rates of INH use and skin test conversion.
Exposure to TB was only found for 30% of skin test converters. Linkage with the State
TB registry identified cases of TB that occurred in inmates but were undiagnosed during
incarceration.
Discussion
The lack of adherence to screening guidelines and the inadequate use of preventive
therapy were problems common to all screening programs. Although under-use of
preventive therapy in different settings has been reported in the literature, this is a poorly
studied area. The low rates of preventive therapy and the low threshold for
discontinuing it once started, suggest that confusion and fear about the use of INH may
be prevalent, and that there is a need for education of providers. The guidelines used for contact and refugee screening in Victoria are not well supported
by scientific rationale and exclude a large proportion of individuals who are at high risk.
This was confirmed by the high incidence of active TB at follow up, and by examining
the features of each incident case. It was further confirmed by finding the high rate of
preventability of notified cases of active TB. I found a lack of cost effectiveness of the
contact screening program, largely because intervention in the form of prevention was
an unlikely outcome at the end of a sequence of screening tests. The findings also
emphasise that in a low prevalence setting, case finding is an expensive exercise and
should not be the main focus of screening. In the Maryland prisons, whilst the
guidelines used were well founded, a wide variation was found in adherence to
guidelines and in rates of preventive therapy. Evidence was also found that significant
transmission ofTB may go undetected in prisons, due to high population turnover.
For the Victorian contact and refugee programs, the recommendation that more sensitive
skin test criteria be adopted, that age should not be considered for contacts of TB when
skin testing or offering preventive therapy, that CXR screening needs to be rationalised,
and that contacts of non-infectious TB need not be screened en masse, have been
accepted and adopted. These data contributed to significant revision of the screening
guidelines in 1994. It would be prudent to conduct a follow up study of the application
and impact of these changes. In Maryland prisons, it was recommended that efforts be
made to standardise preventive efforts across different prisons, and to prioritize TB
control measures according to the level of risk of the prison. Crowding is not a risk
factor which is readily amenable to change, but maximal use of preventive therapy can
diminish that risk. Guidelines used by screening programs are variable. In the case of Victoria, there was
no convincing evidence or data for the use of their screening guidelines. This study
provided sound data for decision making and had a favourable impact on the revision of
guidelines. This in itself is a public health exercise which proves that long standing
policies should be questioned for validity, and if those policies are not supported by
evidence, the collection of required evidence for change is indicated. The major
problem faced by the screening programs studied, however, is not a lack of policies, but
a failure to apply structured guidelines in the practice of prevention. In the case of
Victoria, this is partly explained by factors extrinsic to the TB program, such the
devolution of TB services in the 1970s and 1980s, and lack of adequate resources and
support for TB program staff. There is, nonetheless, considerable opportunity to
improve the outcome of screening, which should not be carried out unless there is a
commitment to intervention that makes a positive public health impact. Screening
without an end point of change in outcome is not good practice. In the case of TB,
intervention in the form of INH preventive therapy is available, and as such, should be
used
The effectiveness of non-pharmaceutical interventions on outbreaks of COVID-19 in aged care and long-term care facilities: A meta-analysis
A review on the use of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPI) was conducted in long-term care facilities. The use of personal protective equipment, isolation and re-testing of COVID-19 were protective against the infection. Facilities which implemented NPIs prior to the outbreak had fewer COVID-19 outbreaks, odds ratio=0.70. Re-testing of asymptomatic people during outbreaks is crucial
- …