6 research outputs found
Social pedagogical perspectives on fidelity to a manual: Professional principles and dilemmas in everyday expertise
Manualised interventions, in use across the UK for decades and increasingly in use in Denmark, aim
to support change through professional practitioners following detailed prescriptions of what they must
do to affect a particular change in the target group. Social pedagogy, a strong professional tradition in
Denmark and an emerging profession in the UK, takes an approach that responds to the individual’s
experience of the immediate situation, seeks to nurture relational opportunities and to empower people
to fully participate in their lives and society. Harbo’s research reveals that this approach can be at odds
with manualised interventions for a variety of reasons. A social pedagogically informed programme
has been developed in London that uses a clear ethical stance and key theories as its foundation, and
upon which structures have been developed, but no manual. This article explores the use of these
manualised and non-manualised interventions in Denmark and the UK and the roles of social pedagogues
in supporting change through programmatic interventions. Harbo’s doctoral research findings on practice surrounding the highly prescriptive manual Aggression Replacement Training in Denmark
(Harbo, 2019) is explored alongside Kemp’s reflections on the social pedagogically informed Family
Learning Intervention Programme in England, examining the tensions and synergies that emerge around
each programme when they meet reality and the individual characteristics of day-to-day situations.
The perspectives presented emerge from practice research and reflections, and as such are based in an
experiential research tradition. Finally, we draw together our learning and openings for further research
and policy development
Interventions that address institutional child maltreatment: an evidence and gap map.
Purpose: This evidence and gap map collates evidence reporting on the effectiveness of interventions aimed to prevent, disclose, respond to, or treat child maltreatment occurring in institutional settings.
Methods: A comprehensive and systematic literature search identified primary studies and systematic reviews meeting the review’s eligibility criteria. Literature screening, data extraction and critical appraisals were undertaken independently by multiple reviewers. Data extracted and reported from the included studies included information about the institutional setting, target population, type of maltreatment, intervention type and outcomes.
Results: Seventy-three studies were identified, including 11 systematic reviews and 62 primary studies. Overall, the methodological quality of the studies was low to moderate. Most evaluated curriculum-based interventions delivered in educational settings, primarily aimed at preventing sexual abuse. Fewer studies examined other institutional settings or intervention types.
Conclusions: This review highlights a need for high-quality studies evaluating a more diverse range of interventions across more varied institutional contexts