Quality assessment of expert answers to lay questions about cystic fibrosis from various language zones in Europe: the ECORN-CF project

Background: The European Centres of Reference Network for Cystic Fibrosis (ECORN-CF) established an Internet forum which provides the opportunity for CF patients and other interested people to ask experts questions about CF in their mother language. The objectives of this study were to: 1. develop a detailed quality assessment tool to analyze quality of expert answers, 2. evaluate the intra- and inter-rater agreement of this tool, and 3. explore changes in the quality of expert answers over the time frame of the project. Methods: The quality assessment tool was developed by an expert panel. Five experts within the ECORN-CF project used the quality assessment tool to analyze the quality of 108 expert answers published on ECORN-CF from six language zones. 25 expert answers were scored at two time points, one year apart. Quality of answers was also assessed at an early and later period of the project. Individual rater scores and group mean scores were analyzed for each expert answer. Results: A scoring system and training manual were developed analyzing two quality categories of answers: content and formal quality. For content quality, the grades based on group mean scores for all raters showed substantial agreement between two time points, however this was not the case for the grades based on individual rater scores. For formal quality the grades based on group mean scores showed only slight agreement between two time points and there was also poor agreement between time points for the individual grades. The inter-rater agreement for content quality was fair (mean kappa value 0.232+/-0.036, p<0.001) while only slight agreement was observed for the grades of the formal quality (mean kappa value 0.105+/-0.024, p<0.001). The quality of expert answers was rated high (four language zones) or satisfactory (two language zones) and did not change over time. Conclusions: The quality assessment tool described in this study was feasible and reliable when content quality was assessed by a group of raters. Within ECORN-CF, the tool will help ensure that CF patients all over Europe have equal possibility of access to high quality expert advice on their illness

Is sweat testing for cystic fibrosis feasible in patients with down syndrome?

Background: Recurrent airway infections are common in patients with Down’s syndrome (DS). Hence, ruling out Cystic Fibrosis (CF) in these patients is often required. In the past, the value of sweat testing – the gold standard to diagnose CF – has been questioned in DS as false positive results have been reported. However, these reports are based on measurements of sweat osmolality or sodium concentrations, not chloride concentrations. This study analyses sweat secretion rate and chloride concentration in sweat samples of patients with DS in comparison to healthy controls. Methods: We assessed sweat samples in 16 patients with DS and 16 healthy controls regarding sweat secretion rate (SSR) and sweat chloride concentration. Results: All measured chloride concentrations were within the normal range. The chloride concentrations were slightly, but not significantly lower in patients with DS (15,54 mmol/l (±4,47)) compared to healthy controls (18,31 mmol/l (±10,12)). While no gender gap in chloride concentration could be found, chloride concentration increased with age in both groups. Insufficient sweat was collected in 2 females with DS (12.5% of the study group) but not in an individual of the control group. A significant lower sweat secretion rate was found in the DS group (27,6 μl/30 min (± 12,18)) compared to the control group (42,7 μl/30 min (± 21,22)). In a sub-analysis, female patients produced significantly less sweat (20,8 ± 10,6 μl/30 min) than male patients with DS (36,4 ± 7,8 μl/30 min), which accounts for the difference between patients and controls. Furthermore, while the sweating secretion rate increased with age in the control group, it did not do so in the DS group. Once again this was due to female patients with DS, who did not show a significant increase of sweat secretion rate with age. Conclusions: Sweat chloride concentrations were within the normal range in patients with DS and therefore seem to be a reliable tool for testing for CF in these patients. Interestingly, we found a reduced sweat secretion rate in the DS group. Whether the last one has a functional and clinical counterpart, possibly due to a disturbed thermoregulation in DS patients, requires further investigation

Self-gated non-contrast-enhanced functional lung MR imaging for quantitative ventilation assessment in patients with cystic fibrosis

Purpose: To assess the clinical feasibility of self-gated non-contrast-enhanced functional lung (SENCEFUL) magnetic resonance (MR) imaging for quantitative ventilation (QV) imaging in patients with cystic fibrosis (CF). Materials and Methods: Twenty patients with CF and 20 matched healthy volunteers underwent functional 1.5-T lung MR imaging with the SENCEFUL imaging approach, in which a two-dimensional fast low-angle shot sequence is used with quasi-random sampling. The lungs were manually segmented on the ventilation-weighted images to obtain QV measurements, which were compared between groups. QV values of the patients were correlated with results of pulmonary function testing. Three radiologists rated the images for presence of ventilation deficits by means of visual inspection. Mann-Whitney U tests, receiver operating characteristic analyses, Spearman correlations, and Gwet agreement coefficient analyses were used for statistical analysis. Results: QV of the entire lungs was lower for patients with CF than for control subjects (mean ± standard deviation, 0.09 mL/mL ± 0.03 vs 0.11 mL/mL ± 0.03, respectively; P = .007). QV ratios of upper to lower lung halves were lower in patients with CF than in control subjects (right, 0.84 ± 0.2 vs 1.16 ± 0.2, respectively [P < .001]; left, 0.88 ± 0.3 vs 1.11 ± 0.1, respectively [P = .017]). Accordingly, ventilation differences between the groups were larger in the upper halves (Δ = 0.04 mL/mL, P ≤ .001-.002). QV values of patients with CF correlated with forced vital capacity (r = 0.7; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.21, 0.91), residual volume (static hyperinflation, r = -0.8; 95% CI: -0.94, 0.42), and forced expiratory volume in 1 second (airway obstruction, r = 0.7; 95% CI: 0.21, 0.91). Disseminated small ventilation deficits were the most frequent involvement pattern, present in 40% of the functional maps in CF versus 8% in the control subjects (P < .001). Conclusion: SENCEFUL MR imaging is feasible for QV assessment. Less QV, especially in upper lung parts, and correlation to vital capacity and to markers for hyperinflation and airway obstruction were found in patients with CF