Model Predictive Control Allocation of Systems with Different Dynamics

International audienceSeveral systems are integrated in passenger cars. Some of them are just redundant systems due to safety requirements. Others, are completely different and can interact with each other as long as they are operating inside the same vehicle. Control allocation methods have been successfully implemented in advanced aircrafts to avoid conflicts, especially in the context of redundant systems. In this paper, we will rather focus on coordinating non-redundant advanced chassis systems with different dynamics. This difference in dynamics can be especially problematic when systems exhibit different communication delays. Model Predictive Control Allocation (MPCA) methods are therefore investigated in order to activate the right system at the right moment. Results show that particularly when the most effective system is saturated, another system with a different time delay can be activated few steps before saturation to instantly take over the maneuver. With good knowledge of actuator dynamics and higher computation power, MPCA methods are able to solve complex problems in severe situations

Integration of anti-lock braking system and regenerative braking for hybrid/electric vehicles

Vehicle electrification aims at improving energy efficiency and reducing pollutant emissions which creates an opportunity to use the electric machines (EM) as Regenerative Braking System (RBS) to support the friction brake system. Anti-lock Braking System (ABS) is part of the active safety systems that help drivers to stop safely during panic braking while ensuring the vehicle’s stability and steerability. Nevertheless, the RBS is deactivated at a safe (low) deceleration threshold in favour of ABS. This safety margin results in significantly less energy recuperation than what would be possible if both RBS and ABS were able to operate simultaneously. Vehicle energy efficiency can be improved by integrating RBS and friction brakes to enable more frequent energy recuperation activations, especially during high deceleration demands. The main aim of this doctoral research is to design and implement new wheel slip control with torque blending strategies for various vehicle topologies using four, two and one EM. The integration between the two braking actuators will improve the braking performance and energy efficiency of the vehicle. It also enables ABS by pure EM in certain situations where the regenerative brake torque is sufficient. A novelmethod for integrating the wheel slip control and torque blending is developed using Nonlinear Model Predictive Control (NMPC). The method is well known for the optimal performance and enforcement of critical control and state constraints. A linear MPC strategy is also developed for comparison purpose. A pragmatic brake torque blending algorithm using Daisy-Chain with sliding mode slip control is also developed based on a pre-defined energy recuperation priority. Simulation using high fidelity model using co-simulation in Matlab/Simulink and CarMaker is used to validate the developed strategies. Different test patterns are used to evaluate the controllers’ performance which includes longitudinal and lateral motions of the vehicle. Comparison analysis is done for the proposed strategies for each case. The capability for real-time implementation of the MPC controllers is assessed in simulation testing using dSPACE hardware

Optimal Vehicle Motion Control to Mitigate Secondary Crashes after an Initial Impact.

Statistical data of road traffic fatalities show that fatalities in multiple-event crashes are higher than in single-event crashes. Most vehicle safety systems were developed to mitigate first crash events. Few active safety systems can deal with subsequent crash events. After a first crash event, drivers may not react in a timely or correct manner, which can have devastating consequences. Production active safety systems such as Electronic Stability Control (ESC) may not react to a first crash event properly unless such events are within their design specifications. The goal of this thesis is to propose control strategies that bring the vehicle state back to regions where drivers and ESC can easily take over the control, so that the severity of possible subsequent (secondary) crashes can be reduced. Because the most contributing causes of fatal secondary crashes are large lateral deviations and heading angle changes, the proposed algorithms consider both lateral displacement and heading of the vehicle. To characterize the vehicle motion after a crash event, a collision force estimation method and a vehicle motion prediction scheme are proposed. The model-based algorithm uses sensing information from the early stage of a collision process, so that the collision force can be predicted and the desired vehicle state can be determined promptly. The final heading angles are determined off-line and results are stored in a look-up table for faster implementation. Linear Time Varying Model Predictive Control (LTV-MPC) method is used to obtain the control signals, with the key tire nonlinearities captured through linearization. This algorithm considers tire force constraints based on the combined-slip tire model. The computed high-level control signals are realized through a control allocation problem which maps vehicle motion commands to tire braking forces. For real-time implementation, a rule-based control strategy is obtained. Several rules were constructed, and results under the rule-based control are similar to those under the optimal control (LTV-MPC) method while avoiding heavy on-board computations. Lastly, this thesis proposes a preemptive steering control concept. By assessing the expected strength of an imminent collision force from another vehicle, a preemptive steering control is applied to mitigate the imminent impact.PhDMechanical EngineeringUniversity of Michigan, Horace H. Rackham School of Graduate Studieshttp://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/111343/1/bjukim_1.pd

Human Motion Trajectory Prediction: A Survey

With growing numbers of intelligent autonomous systems in human environments, the ability of such systems to perceive, understand and anticipate human behavior becomes increasingly important. Specifically, predicting future positions of dynamic agents and planning considering such predictions are key tasks for self-driving vehicles, service robots and advanced surveillance systems. This paper provides a survey of human motion trajectory prediction. We review, analyze and structure a large selection of work from different communities and propose a taxonomy that categorizes existing methods based on the motion modeling approach and level of contextual information used. We provide an overview of the existing datasets and performance metrics. We discuss limitations of the state of the art and outline directions for further research.Comment: Submitted to the International Journal of Robotics Research (IJRR), 37 page

Torque Vectoring Predictive Control of a Four In-Wheel Motor Drive Electric Vehicle

The recent integration of vehicles with electrified powertrains in the automotive sector provides higher energy efficiency, lower pollution levels and increased controllability. These features have led to an increasing interest in the development of Advanced Driver- Assistance Systems (ADAS) that enhance not only the vehicle dynamic behaviour, but also its efficiency and energy consumption. This master’s thesis presents some contributions to the vehicle modeling, parameter estimation, model predictive control and reference generation applied to electric vehicles, paying particular attention to both model and controller validation, leveraging offline simulations and a real-time driving simulator. The objective of this project is focused on the Nonlinear Model Predictive Controller (NMPC) technique developing torque distribution strategies, specifically Torque Vectoring (TV) for a four-in wheel motor drive electric vehicle. A real-time TV-NMPC algorithm will be implemented, which maximizes the wheels torque usage and distribution to enhance vehicle stability and improve handling capabilities. In order to develop this control system, throughout this thesis the whole process carried out including the implementation requirements and considerations are described in detail. As the NMPC is a model-based approach, a nonlinear vehicle model is proposed. The vehicle model, the estimated parameters and the controller will be validated through the design of open and closed loop driving maneuvers for offline simulations performed in a simulation plant (VI-CarRealTime) and by means of a real-time driving simulator (VI-Grade Compact Simulator) to test the vehicle performance through various dynamic driving conditions

Torque Vectoring Predictive Control of a Four In-Wheel Motor Drive Electric Vehicle

The recent integration of vehicles with electrified powertrains in the automotive sector provides higher energy efficiency, lower pollution levels and increased controllability. These features have led to an increasing interest in the development of Advanced Driver- Assistance Systems (ADAS) that enhance not only the vehicle dynamic behaviour, but also its efficiency and energy consumption. This master’s thesis presents some contributions to the vehicle modeling, parameter estimation, model predictive control and reference generation applied to electric vehicles, paying particular attention to both model and controller validation, leveraging offline simulations and a real-time driving simulator. The objective of this project is focused on the Nonlinear Model Predictive Controller (NMPC) technique developing torque distribution strategies, specifically Torque Vectoring (TV) for a four-in wheel motor drive electric vehicle. A real-time TV-NMPC algorithm will be implemented, which maximizes the wheels torque usage and distribution to enhance vehicle stability and improve handling capabilities. In order to develop this control system, throughout this thesis the whole process carried out including the implementation requirements and considerations are described in detail. As the NMPC is a model-based approach, a nonlinear vehicle model is proposed. The vehicle model, the estimated parameters and the controller will be validated through the design of open and closed loop driving maneuvers for offline simulations performed in a simulation plant (VI-CarRealTime) and by means of a real-time driving simulator (VI-Grade Compact Simulator) to test the vehicle performance through various dynamic driving conditions

Reconfigurable Integrated Vehicle Stability Control Using Optimal Control Techniques

The motivation for the development of vehicle stability control systems comes from the fact that vehicle dynamic behavior in unfavorable driving conditions such as low road-tire adhesion and high speed differs greatly from its nominal behavior. Due to this unexpected behavior, a driver may not be successful in controlling the vehicle in challenging driving situations based only on her/his everyday driving experience. Several noteworthy research works have been conducted on stability control systems over the last two decades to prevent car accidents due to human error. Most of the resultant stability controllers contain individual modules, where each perform a particular task such as yaw tracking, sideslip control, or wheel slip control. These design requirements may contradict each other in some driving scenarios. In such situations, inconsistent control actions can be generated with individual modules. The development of a stability controller that can satisfy diverse and often contradictory requirements is a great challenge. In general, transferring a control structure from one vehicle to another with a different drivetrain layout and actuation system configuration requires remarkable rectifications and repetition of tuning processes from the beginning to achieve a similar performance. This can be considered to be a serious drawback for car manufacturing companies since it results in extra effort, time, and expenses in redesigning and retuning the controller. In this thesis, an integrated controller with a modular structure has been designed to concurrently provide control of the vehicle chassis (yaw rate and sideslip control) and wheel stability (wheel slip ratio control). The proposed control structure incorporates longitudinal and lateral vehicle dynamics to decide on a unified control action. This control action is an outcome of solving an optimization problem that considers all the control objectives in a single cost function, so integrated wheel and vehicle stability is guaranteed. Moreover, according to the particular modular design of the proposed control structure, it can be easily reconfigured to work with different drivetrain layouts such as all-wheel-drive, front-wheel-drive, and rear-wheel-drive, as well as various actuators such as torque vectoring, differential braking, and active steering systems. The high-level control module provides a Center of Gravity (CG) based error analysis and determines the required longitudinal forces and yaw moment adjustments. The low-level control module utilizes this information to allocate control actions optimally at each vehicle corner (wheel) through a single or multi-actuator regime. In order to consider the effect of the actuator dynamics, a mathematical description of the auction system is included in distribution objective function. Therefore, a legitimate control performance is promised in situations requiring shifting from one configuration to another with minimal modifications. The performance of the proposed modular control structure is examined in simulations with a high-fidelity model of an electric GM Equinox vehicle. The high-fidelity model has been developed and provided by GM and the use of the model is to reduce the number of labor-intensive vehicle test and is to test extreme and dangerous driving conditions. Several driving scenarios with severe steering and throttle commands, then, are designed to evaluate the capability of the proposed control structure in integrated longitudinal and lateral vehicle stabilization on slippery road condition. Experimental tests also have been performed with two different electric vehicles for real-time implementation as well as validation purposes. The observations verified the performance qualifications of the proposed control structure to preserve integrated wheel and vehicle chassis stability in all track tests