Using the Xeon Phi platform to run speculatively-parallelized codes

Producción CientíficaIntel Xeon Phi accelerators are one of the newest devices used in the field of parallel computing. However, there are comparatively few studies concerning their performance when using most of the existing parallelization techniques. One of them is thread-level speculation, a technique that optimistically tries to extract parallelism of loops without the need of a compile-time analysis that guarantees that the loop can be executed in parallel. In this article we evaluate the performance delivered by an Intel Xeon Phi coprocessor when using a software, state-of-the-art thread-level speculative parallelization library in the execution of well-known benchmarks. We describe both the internal characteristics of the Xeon Phi platform and the particularities of the thread-level speculation library being used as benchmark. Our results show that, although the Xeon Phi delivers a relatively good speedup in comparison with a shared-memory architecture in terms of scalability, the relatively low computing power of its computational units when specific vectorization and SIMD instructions are not fully exploited makes this first generation of Xeon Phi architectures not competitive (in terms of absolute performance) with respect to conventional multicore systems for the execution of speculatively parallelized code.2018-04-01Castilla-Leon Regional Government (VA172A12-2); MICINN (Spain) and the European Union FEDER (MOGECOPP project TIN2011-25639, HomProg-HetSys project TIN2014-58876-P, CAPAP-H5 network TIN2014-53522-REDT)

Design and evaluation of a Thread-Level Speculation runtime library

En los próximos años es más que probable que máquinas con cientos o incluso miles de procesadores sean algo habitual. Para aprovechar estas máquinas, y debido a la dificultad de programar de forma paralela, sería deseable disponer de sistemas de compilación o ejecución que extraigan todo el paralelismo posible de las aplicaciones existentes. Así en los últimos tiempos se han propuesto multitud de técnicas paralelas. Sin embargo, la mayoría de ellas se centran en códigos simples, es decir, sin dependencias entre sus instrucciones. La paralelización especulativa surge como una solución para estos códigos complejos, posibilitando la ejecución de cualquier tipo de códigos, con o sin dependencias. Esta técnica asume de forma optimista que la ejecución paralela de cualquier tipo de código no de lugar a errores y, por lo tanto, necesitan de un mecanismo que detecte cualquier tipo de colisión. Para ello, constan de un monitor responsable que comprueba constantemente que la ejecución no sea errónea, asegurando que los resultados obtenidos de forma paralela sean similares a los de cualquier ejecución secuencial. En caso de que la ejecución fuese errónea los threads se detendrían y reiniciarían su ejecución para asegurar que la ejecución sigue la semántica secuencial. Nuestra contribución en este campo incluye (1) una nueva librería de ejecución especulativa fácil de utilizar; (2) nuevas propuestas que permiten reducir de forma significativa el número de accesos requeridos en las peraciones especulativas, así como consejos para reducir la memoria a utilizar; (3) propuestas para mejorar los métodos de scheduling centradas en la gestión dinámica de los bloques de iteraciones utilizados en las ejecuciones especulativas; (4) una solución híbrida que utiliza memoria transaccional para implementar las secciones críticas de una librería de paralelización especulativa; y (5) un análisis de las técnicas especulativas en uno de los dispositivos más vanguardistas del momento, los coprocesadores Intel Xeon Phi. Como hemos podido comprobar, la paralelización especulativa es un campo de investigación activo. Nuestros resultados demuestran que esta técnica permite obtener mejoras de rendimiento en un gran número de aplicaciones. Así, esperamos que este trabajo contribuya a facilitar el uso de soluciones especulativas en compiladores comerciales y/o modelos de programación paralela de memoria compartida.Departamento de Informática (Arquitectura y Tecnología de Computadores, Ciencias de la Computación e Inteligencia Artificial, Lenguajes y Sistemas Informáticos

Automatic Parallelization of Affine Loops using Dependence and Cache analysis in a Binary Rewriter

Today, nearly all general-purpose computers are parallel, but nearly all software running on them is serial. Bridging this disconnect by manually rewriting source code in parallel is prohibitively expensive. Automatic parallelization technology is therefore an attractive alternative. We present a method to perform automatic parallelization in a binary rewriter. The input to the binary rewriter is the serial binary executable program and the output is a parallel binary executable. The advantages of parallelization in a binary rewriter versus a compiler include (i) compatibility with all compilers and languages; (ii) high economic feasibility from avoiding repeated compiler implementation; (iii) applicability to legacy binaries; and (iv) applicability to assembly-language programs. Adapting existing parallelizing compiler methods that work on source code to work on binary programs instead is a significant challenge. This is primarily because symbolic and array index information used in existing compiler parallelizers is not available in a binary. We show how to adapt existing parallelization methods to achieve equivalent parallelization from a binary without such information. We have also designed a affine cache reuse model that works inside a binary rewriter building on the parallelization techniques. It quantifies cache reuse in terms of the number of cache lines that will be required when a loop dimension is considered for the innermost position in a loop nest. This cache metric can be used to reason about affine code that results when affine code is transformed using affine transformations. Hence, it can be used to evaluate candidate transformation sequences to improve run-time directly from a binary. Results using our x86 binary rewriter called SecondWrite on a suite of dense- matrix regular programs from Polybench suite of benchmarks shows an geomean speedup of 6.81X from binary and 8.9X from source with 8 threads compared to the input serial binary on a x86 Xeon E5530 machine; and 8.31X from binary and 9.86X from source with 24 threads compared to the input serial binary on a x86 E7450 machine. Such regular loops are an important component of scientific and multi- media workloads, and are even present to a limited extent in otherwise non-regular programs. Further in this thesis we present a novel algorithm that enhances the past techniques significantly for loops with unknown loop bounds by guessing the loop bounds using only the memory expressions present in a loop. It then inserts run-time checks to see if these guesses were indeed correct and if correct executes the parallel version of the loop, else the serial version executes. These techniques are applied to the large affine benchmarks in SPEC2006 and OMP2001 and unlike previous methods the speedups from binary are as good as from source. We also present results on the number of loops parallelized directly from a binary with and without this algorithm. Among the 8 affine benchmarks among these suites, the best existing binary parallelization method achieves an geo-mean speedup of 1.33X, whereas our method achieves a speedup of 2.96X. This is close to the speedup from source code of 2.8X

Un framework pour l'exécution efficace d'applications sur GPU et CPU+GPU

Technological limitations faced by the semi-conductor manufacturers in the early 2000's restricted the increase in performance of the sequential computation units. Nowadays, the trend is to increase the number of processor cores per socket and to progressively use the GPU cards for highly parallel computations. Complexity of the recent architectures makes it difficult to statically predict the performance of a program. We describe a reliable and accurate parallel loop nests execution time prediction method on GPUs based on three stages: static code generation, offline profiling, and online prediction. In addition, we present two techniques to fully exploit the computing resources at disposal on a system. The first technique consists in jointly using CPU and GPU for executing a code. In order to achieve higher performance, it is mandatory to consider load balance, in particular by predicting execution time. The runtime uses the profiling results and the scheduler computes the execution times and adjusts the load distributed to the processors. The second technique, puts CPU and GPU in a competition: instances of the considered code are simultaneously executed on CPU and GPU. The winner of the competition notifies its completion to the other instance, implying the termination of the latter.Les verrous technologiques rencontrés par les fabricants de semi-conducteurs au début des années deux-mille ont abrogé la flambée des performances des unités de calculs séquentielles. La tendance actuelle est à la multiplication du nombre de cœurs de processeur par socket et à l'utilisation progressive des cartes GPU pour des calculs hautement parallèles. La complexité des architectures récentes rend difficile l'estimation statique des performances d'un programme. Nous décrivons une méthode fiable et précise de prédiction du temps d'exécution de nids de boucles parallèles sur GPU basée sur trois étapes : la génération de code, le profilage offline et la prédiction online. En outre, nous présentons deux techniques pour exploiter l'ensemble des ressources disponibles d'un système pour la performance. La première consiste en l'utilisation conjointe des CPUs et GPUs pour l'exécution d'un code. Afin de préserver les performances il est nécessaire de considérer la répartition de charge, notamment en prédisant les temps d'exécution. Le runtime utilise les résultats du profilage et un ordonnanceur calcule des temps d'exécution et ajuste la charge distribuée aux processeurs. La seconde technique présentée met le CPU et le GPU en compétition : des instances du code cible sont exécutées simultanément sur CPU et GPU. Le vainqueur de la compétition notifie sa complétion à l'autre instance, impliquant son arrêt

An FPGA implementation of an investigative many-core processor, Fynbos : in support of a Fortran autoparallelising software pipeline

Includes bibliographical references.In light of the power, memory, ILP, and utilisation walls facing the computing industry, this work examines the hypothetical many-core approach to finding greater compute performance and efficiency. In order to achieve greater efficiency in an environment in which Moore’s law continues but TDP has been capped, a means of deriving performance from dark and dim silicon is needed. The many-core hypothesis is one approach to exploiting these available transistors efficiently. As understood in this work, it involves trading in hardware control complexity for hundreds to thousands of parallel simple processing elements, and operating at a clock speed sufficiently low as to allow the efficiency gains of near threshold voltage operation. Performance is there- fore dependant on exploiting a new degree of fine-grained parallelism such as is currently only found in GPGPUs, but in a manner that is not as restrictive in application domain range. While removing the complex control hardware of traditional CPUs provides space for more arithmetic hardware, a basic level of control is still required. For a number of reasons this work chooses to replace this control largely with static scheduling. This pushes the burden of control primarily to the software and specifically the compiler, rather not to the programmer or to an application specific means of control simplification. An existing legacy tool chain capable of autoparallelising sequential Fortran code to the degree of parallelism necessary for many-core exists. This work implements a many-core architecture to match it. Prototyping the design on an FPGA, it is possible to examine the real world performance of the compiler-architecture system to a greater degree than simulation only would allow. Comparing theoretical peak performance and real performance in a case study application, the system is found to be more efficient than any other reviewed, but to also significantly under perform relative to current competing architectures. This failing is apportioned to taking the need for simple hardware too far, and an inability to implement static scheduling mitigating tactics due to lack of support for such in the compiler

A Unified Framework for Parallel Anisotropic Mesh Adaptation

Finite-element methods are a critical component of the design and analysis procedures of many (bio-)engineering applications. Mesh adaptation is one of the most crucial components since it discretizes the physics of the application at a relatively low cost to the solver. Highly scalable parallel mesh adaptation methods for High-Performance Computing (HPC) are essential to meet the ever-growing demand for higher fidelity simulations. Moreover, the continuous growth of the complexity of the HPC systems requires a systematic approach to exploit their full potential. Anisotropic mesh adaptation captures features of the solution at multiple scales while, minimizing the required number of elements. However, it also introduces new challenges on top of mesh generation. Also, the increased complexity of the targeted cases requires departing from traditional surface-constrained approaches to utilizing CAD (Computer-Aided Design) kernels. Alongside the functionality requirements, is the need of taking advantage of the ubiquitous multi-core machines. More importantly, the parallel implementation needs to handle the ever-increasing complexity of the mesh adaptation code. In this work, we develop a parallel mesh adaptation method that utilizes a metric-based approach for generating anisotropic meshes. Moreover, we enhance our method by interfacing with a CAD kernel, thus enabling its use on complex geometries. We evaluate our method both with fixed-resolution benchmarks and within a simulation pipeline, where the resolution of the discretization increases incrementally. With the Telescopic Approach for scalable mesh generation as a guide, we propose a parallel method at the node (multi-core) for mesh adaptation that is expected to scale up efficiently to the upcoming exascale machines. To facilitate an effective implementation, we introduce an abstract layer between the application and the runtime system that enables the use of task-based parallelism for concurrent mesh operations. Our evaluation indicates results comparable to state-of-the-art methods for fixed-resolution meshes both in terms of performance and quality. The integration with an adaptive pipeline offers promising results for the capability of the proposed method to function as part of an adaptive simulation. Moreover, our abstract tasking layer allows the separation of different aspects of the implementation without any impact on the functionality of the method

Generalized database index structures on massively parallel processor architectures

Height-balanced search trees are ubiquitous in database management systems as well as in other applications that require efficient access methods in order to identify entries in large data volumes. They can be configured with various strategies for structuring the search space for a given data set and for pruning it when different kinds of search queries are answered. In order to facilitate the development of application-specific tree variants, index frameworks, such as GiST, exist that provide a reusable library of commonly shared tree management functionality. By specializing internal data organization strategies, the framework can be customized to create an index that is efficient for an application's data access characteristics. Because the majority of the framework's code can be reused development and testing efforts are significantly lower, compared to an implementation from scratch. However, none of the existing frameworks supports the execution of index operations on massively parallel processor architectures, such as GPUs. Enabling the use of such processors for generalized index frameworks is the goal of this thesis. By compiling state-of-the-art techniques from a wide range of CPU- and GPU-optimized indexes, a GiST extension is developed that abstracts the physical execution aspect of generic, tree-based search queries. Tree traversals are broken-down into vectorized processing primitives that can be scheduled to one of the available (co-)processors for execution. Further, a CPU-based implementation is provided as well as a new GPU-based algorithm that, unlike prior art in this area, does not require that the index is fully stored inside a GPU's main memory buffer. The applicability of the extended framework is assessed for image rendering engines and, based on microbenchmarks, the parallelized algorithm performance is compared for different CPU and GPU generations. It will be shown that cases exist, where the GPU clearly outperforms the CPU and vice versa. In order to leverage the strengths of each processor type, an adaptive scheduler is presented that can be calibrated to schedule index operations to the best-fitting device in a hybrid system. With the help of a tree traversal simulation different scheduling strategies are evaluated and it will be shown that the adaptive scheduler can be used to make near-optimal decisions.Suchbäume sind allgegenwärtig in Datenbanksystemen und anderen Anwendungen, die eine effiziente Möglichkeit benötigen um in großen Datensätzen nach Einträgen zu suchen, die bestimmte Suchkriterien erfüllen. Sie können mit verschiedenen Strategien konfiguriert werden um den Suchraum zu strukturieren und die für ein Suchergebnis irrelevante Bereiche von der Bearbeitung auszuschließen. Die Entwicklung von anwendungsspezifischen Indexen wird durch Frameworks wie GiST unterstützt. Jedoch unterstützt keines der heute bereits existierenden Frameworks die Verwendung von hochgradig parallelen Prozessorarchitekturen wie GPUs. Solche Prozessoren für generische Index Frameworks nutzbar zu machen, ist Ziel dieser Arbeit. Dazu werden Techniken aus verschiedensten CPU- und GPU-optimierten Indexen analysiert und für die Entwicklung einer GiST-Erweiterung verwendet, welche die für eine Suche in Suchbäumen nötigen Berechnungen abstrahiert. Traversierungsoperationen werden dabei auf vektorisierte Primitive abgebildet, die auf parallelen Prozessoren implementiert werden können. Die Verwendung dieser Erweiterung wird beispielhaft an einem CPU Algorithmus demonstriert. Weiterhin wird ein neuer GPU-basierter Algorithmus vorgestellt, der im Vergleich zu bisherigen Verfahren, ein dynamisches Nachladen der Index Daten in den Hauptspeicher der GPU unterstützt. Die Praktikabilität des erweiterten Frameworks wird am Beispiel von Anwendungen aus der Computergrafik untersucht und die Performanz der verwendeten Algorithmen mit Hilfe eines Benchmarks auf verschiedenen CPU- und GPU-Modellen analysiert. Dabei wird gezeigt, unter welchen Bedingungen die parallele GPU-basierte Ausführung schneller ist als die CPU-basierte Variante - und umgekehrt. Um die Stärken beider Prozessortypen in einem hybriden System ausnutzen zu können, wird ein Scheduler entwickelt, der nach einer Kalibrierungsphase für eine gegebene Operation den geeignetsten Prozessor wählen kann. Mit Hilfe eines Simulators für Baumtraversierungen werden verschiedenste Scheduling Strategien verglichen. Dabei wird gezeigt, dass die Entscheidungen des Schedulers kaum vom Optimum abweichen und, abhängig von der simulierten Last, die erzielbaren Durchsätze für die parallele Ausführung mehrerer Suchoperationen durch hybrides Scheduling um eine Größenordnung und mehr erhöht werden können

Analytical Query Execution Optimized for all Layers of Modern Hardware

Analytical database queries are at the core of business intelligence and decision support. To analyze the vast amounts of data available today, query execution needs to be orders of magnitude faster. Hardware advances have made a profound impact on database design and implementation. The large main memory capacity allows queries to execute exclusively in memory and shifts the bottleneck from disk access to memory bandwidth. In the new setting, to optimize query performance, databases must be aware of an unprecedented multitude of complicated hardware features. This thesis focuses on the design and implementation of highly efficient database systems by optimizing analytical query execution for all layers of modern hardware. The hardware layers include the network across multiple machines, main memory and the NUMA interconnection across multiple processors, the multiple levels of caches across multiple processor cores, and the execution pipeline within each core. For the network layer, we introduce a distributed join algorithm that minimizes the network traffic. For the memory hierarchy, we describe partitioning variants aware to the dynamics of the CPU caches and the NUMA interconnection. To improve the memory access rate of linear scans, we optimize lightweight compression variants and evaluate their trade-offs. To accelerate query execution within the core pipeline, we introduce advanced SIMD vectorization techniques generalizable across multiple operators. We evaluate our algorithms and techniques on both mainstream hardware and on many-integrated-core platforms, and combine our techniques in a new query engine design that can better utilize the features of many-core CPUs. In the era of hardware becoming increasingly parallel and datasets consistently growing in size, this thesis can serve as a compass for developing hardware-conscious databases with truly high-performance analytical query execution

Productive Programming Systems for Heterogeneous Supercomputers

The majority of today's scientific and data analytics workloads are still run on relatively energy inefficient, heavyweight, general-purpose processing cores, often referred to in the literature as latency-oriented architectures. The flexibility of these architectures and the programmer aids included (e.g. large and deep cache hierarchies, branch prediction logic, pre-fetch logic) makes them flexible enough to run a wide range of applications fast. However, we have started to see growth in the use of lightweight, simpler, energy-efficient, and functionally constrained cores. These architectures are commonly referred to as throughput-oriented. Within each shared memory node, the computational backbone of future throughput-oriented HPC machines will consist of large pools of lightweight cores. The first wave of throughput-oriented computing came in the mid 2000's with the use of GPUs for general-purpose and scientific computing. Today we are entering the second wave of throughput-oriented computing, with the introduction of NVIDIA Pascal GPUs, Intel Knights Landing Xeon Phi processors, the Epiphany Co-Processor, the Sunway MPP, and other throughput-oriented architectures that enable pre-exascale computing. However, while the majority of the FLOPS in designs for future HPC systems come from throughput-oriented architectures, they are still commonly paired with latency-oriented cores which handle management functions and lightweight/un-parallelizable computational kernels. Hence, most future HPC machines will be heterogeneous in their processing cores. However, the heterogeneity of future machines will not be limited to the processing elements. Indeed, heterogeneity will also exist in the storage, networking, memory, and software stacks of future supercomputers. As a result, it will be necessary to combine many different programming models and libraries in a single application. How to do so in a programmable and well-performing manner is an open research question. This thesis addresses this question using two approaches. First, we explore using managed runtimes on HPC platforms. As a result of their high-level programming models, these managed runtimes have a long history of supporting data analytics workloads on commodity hardware, but often come with overheads which make them less common in the HPC domain. Managed runtimes are also not supported natively on throughput-oriented architectures. Second, we explore the use of a modular programming model and work-stealing runtime to compose the programming and scheduling of multiple third-party HPC libraries. This approach leverages existing investment in HPC libraries, unifies the scheduling of work on a platform, and is designed to quickly support new programming model and runtime extensions. In support of these two approaches, this thesis also makes novel contributions in tooling for future supercomputers. We demonstrate the value of checkpoints as a software development tool on current and future HPC machines, and present novel techniques in performance prediction across heterogeneous cores