Is Quality Control Pointless?

Intrinsic to the transition towards, and necessary for the success of digital platforms as a service (at scale) is the notion of human computation. Going beyond ‘the wisdom of the crowd’, human computation is the engine that powers platforms and services that are now ubiquitous like Duolingo and Wikipedia. In spite of increasing research and population interest, several issues remain open and in debate on large-scale human computation projects. Quality control is first among these discussions. We conducted an experiment with three different tasks of varying complexity and five different methods to distinguish and protect against constantly under-performing contributors. We illustrate that minimal quality control is enough to repel constantly under-performing contributors and that this effect is constant across tasks of varying complexity

Fluent Translations from Disfluent Speech in End-to-End Speech Translation

Spoken language translation applications for speech suffer due to conversational speech phenomena, particularly the presence of disfluencies. With the rise of end-to-end speech translation models, processing steps such as disfluency removal that were previously an intermediate step between speech recognition and machine translation need to be incorporated into model architectures. We use a sequence-to-sequence model to translate from noisy, disfluent speech to fluent text with disfluencies removed using the recently collected `copy-edited' references for the Fisher Spanish-English dataset. We are able to directly generate fluent translations and introduce considerations about how to evaluate success on this task. This work provides a baseline for a new task, the translation of conversational speech with joint removal of disfluencies.Comment: Accepted at NAACL 201

Results of the WMT19 metrics shared task: segment-level and strong MT systems pose big challenges

This paper presents the results of the WMT19 Metrics Shared Task. Participants were asked to score the outputs of the translations systems competing in the WMT19 News Translation Task with automatic metrics. 13 research groups submitted 24 metrics, 10 of which are reference-less "metrics" and constitute submissions to the joint task with WMT19 Quality Estimation Task, "QE as a Metric". In addition, we computed 11 baseline metrics, with 8 commonly applied baselines (BLEU, SentBLEU, NIST, WER, PER, TER, CDER, and chrF) and 3 reimplementations (chrF+, sacreBLEU-BLEU, and sacreBLEU-chrF). Metrics were evaluated on the system level, how well a given metric correlates with the WMT19 official manual ranking, and segment level, how well the metric correlates with human judgements of segment quality. This year, we use direct assessment (DA) as our only form of manual evaluation

平易なコーパスを用いないテキスト平易化

首都大学東京, 2018-03-25, 博士（工学）首都大学東

Understanding and Enhancing the Use of Context for Machine Translation

To understand and infer meaning in language, neural models have to learn complicated nuances. Discovering distinctive linguistic phenomena from data is not an easy task. For instance, lexical ambiguity is a fundamental feature of language which is challenging to learn. Even more prominently, inferring the meaning of rare and unseen lexical units is difficult with neural networks. Meaning is often determined from context. With context, languages allow meaning to be conveyed even when the specific words used are not known by the reader. To model this learning process, a system has to learn from a few instances in context and be able to generalize well to unseen cases. The learning process is hindered when training data is scarce for a task. Even with sufficient data, learning patterns for the long tail of the lexical distribution is challenging. In this thesis, we focus on understanding certain potentials of contexts in neural models and design augmentation models to benefit from them. We focus on machine translation as an important instance of the more general language understanding problem. To translate from a source language to a target language, a neural model has to understand the meaning of constituents in the provided context and generate constituents with the same meanings in the target language. This task accentuates the value of capturing nuances of language and the necessity of generalization from few observations. The main problem we study in this thesis is what neural machine translation models learn from data and how we can devise more focused contexts to enhance this learning. Looking more in-depth into the role of context and the impact of data on learning models is essential to advance the NLP field. Moreover, it helps highlight the vulnerabilities of current neural networks and provides insights into designing more robust models.Comment: PhD dissertation defended on November 10th, 202

Monolingual Sentence Rewriting as Machine Translation: Generation and Evaluation

In this thesis, we investigate approaches to paraphrasing entire sentences within the constraints of a given task, which we call monolingual sentence rewriting. We introduce a unified framework for monolingual sentence rewriting, and apply it to three representative tasks: sentence compression, text simplification, and grammatical error correction. We also perform a detailed analysis of the evaluation methodologies for each task, identify bias in common evaluation techniques, and propose more reliable practices. Monolingual rewriting can be thought of as translating between two types of English (such as from complex to simple), and therefore our approach is inspired by statistical machine translation. In machine translation, a large quantity of parallel data is necessary to model the transformations from input to output text. Parallel bilingual data naturally occurs between common language pairs (such as English and French), but for monolingual sentence rewriting, there is little existing parallel data and annotation is costly. We modify the statistical machine translation pipeline to harness monolingual resources and insights into task constraints in order to drastically diminish the amount of annotated data necessary to train a robust system. Our method generates more meaning-preserving and grammatical sentences than earlier approaches and requires less task-specific data. Once candidate sentences are generated, it is crucial to have reliable evaluation methods. Sentential paraphrases must fulfill a variety of requirements: preserve the meaning of the original sentence, be grammatical, and meet any stylistic or task-specific constraints. We analyze common evaluation practices and propose better methods that more accurately measure the quality of output. Often overlooked, robust automatic evaluation methodology is necessary for improving systems, and this work presents new metrics and outlines important considerations for reliably measuring the quality of the generated text

Event structures in knowledge, pictures and text

This thesis proposes new techniques for mining scripts. Scripts are essential pieces of common sense knowledge that contain information about everyday scenarios (like going to a restaurant), namely the events that usually happen in a scenario (entering, sitting down, reading the menu...), their typical order (ordering happens before eating), and the participants of these events (customer, waiter, food...). Because many conventionalized scenarios are shared common sense knowledge and thus are usually not described in standard texts, we propose to elicit sequential descriptions of typical scenario instances via crowdsourcing over the internet. This approach overcomes the implicitness problem and, at the same time, is scalable to large data collections. To generalize over the input data, we need to mine event and participant paraphrases from the textual sequences. For this task we make use of the structural commonalities in the collected sequential descriptions, which yields much more accurate paraphrases than approaches that do not take structural constraints into account. We further apply the algorithm we developed for event paraphrasing to parallel standard texts for extracting sentential paraphrases and paraphrase fragments. In this case we consider the discourse structure in a text as a sequential event structure. As for event paraphrasing, the structure-aware paraphrasing approach clearly outperforms systems that do not consider discourse structure. As a multimodal application, we develop a new resource in which textual event descriptions are grounded in videos, which enables new investigations on action description semantics and a more accurate modeling of event description similarities. This grounding approach also opens up new possibilities for applying the computed script knowledge for automated event recognition in videos.Die vorliegende Dissertation schlägt neue Techniken zur Berechnung von Skripten vor. Skripte sind essentielle Teile des Allgemeinwissens, die Informationen über alltägliche Szenarien (wie im Restaurant essen) enthalten, nämlich die Ereignisse, die typischerweise in einem Szenario vorkommen (eintreten, sich setzen, die Karte lesen...), deren typische zeitliche Abfolge (man bestellt bevor man isst), und die Teilnehmer der Ereignisse (ein Gast, der Kellner, das Essen,...). Da viele konventionalisierte Szenarien implizit geteiltes Allgemeinwissen sind und üblicherweise nicht detailliert in Texten beschrieben werden, schlagen wir vor, Beschreibungen von typischen Szenario-Instanzen durch sog. “Crowdsourcing” über das Internet zu sammeln. Dieser Ansatz löst das Implizitheits-Problem und lässt sich gleichzeitig zu großen Daten-Sammlungen hochskalieren. Um über die Eingabe-Daten zu generalisieren, müssen wir in den Text-Sequenzen Paraphrasen für Ereignisse und Teilnehmer finden. Hierfür nutzen wir die strukturellen Gemeinsamkeiten dieser Sequenzen, was viel präzisere Paraphrasen-Information ergibt als Standard-Ansätze, die strukturelle Einschränkungen nicht beachten. Die Techniken, die wir für die Ereignis-Paraphrasierung entwickelt haben, wenden wir auch auf parallele Standard-Texte an, um Paraphrasen auf Satz-Ebene sowie Paraphrasen-Fragmente zu extrahieren. Hier betrachten wir die Diskurs-Struktur eines Textes als sequentielle Ereignis-Struktur. Auch hier liefert der strukturell informierte Ansatz klar bessere Ergebnisse als herkömmliche Systeme, die Diskurs-Struktur nicht in die Berechnung mit einbeziehen. Als multimodale Anwendung entwickeln wir eine neue Ressource, in der Text-Beschreibungen von Ereignissen mittels zeitlicher Synchronisierung in Videos verankert sind. Dies ermöglicht neue Ansätze für die Erforschung der Semantik von Ereignisbeschreibungen, und erlaubt außerdem die Modellierung treffenderer Ereignis-Ähnlichkeiten. Dieser Schritt der visuellen Verankerung von Text in Videos eröffnet auch neue Möglichkeiten für die Anwendung des berechneten Skript-Wissen bei der automatischen Ereigniserkennung in Videos

Adapting Automatic Summarization to New Sources of Information

English-language news articles are no longer necessarily the best source of information. The Web allows information to spread more quickly and travel farther: first-person accounts of breaking news events pop up on social media, and foreign-language news articles are accessible to, if not immediately understandable by, English-speaking users. This thesis focuses on developing automatic summarization techniques for these new sources of information. We focus on summarizing two specific new sources of information: personal narratives, first-person accounts of exciting or unusual events that are readily found in blog entries and other social media posts, and non-English documents, which must first be translated into English, often introducing translation errors that complicate the summarization process. Personal narratives are a very new area of interest in natural language processing research, and they present two key challenges for summarization. First, unlike many news articles, whose lead sentences serve as summaries of the most important ideas in the articles, personal narratives provide no such shortcuts for determining where important information occurs in within them; second, personal narratives are written informally and colloquially, and unlike news articles, they are rarely edited, so they require heavier editing and rewriting during the summarization process. Non-English documents, whether news or narrative, present yet another source of difficulty on top of any challenges inherent to their genre: they must be translated into English, potentially introducing translation errors and disfluencies that must be identified and corrected during summarization. The bulk of this thesis is dedicated to addressing the challenges of summarizing personal narratives found on the Web. We develop a two-stage summarization system for personal narrative that first extracts sentences containing important content and then rewrites those sentences into summary-appropriate forms. Our content extraction system is inspired by contextualist narrative theory, using changes in writing style throughout a narrative to detect sentences containing important information; it outperforms both graph-based and neural network approaches to sentence extraction for this genre. Our paraphrasing system rewrites the extracted sentences into shorter, standalone summary sentences, learning to mimic the paraphrasing choices of human summarizers more closely than can traditional lexicon- or translation-based paraphrasing approaches. We conclude with a chapter dedicated to summarizing non-English documents written in low-resource languages – documents that would otherwise be unreadable for English-speaking users. We develop a cross-lingual summarization system that performs even heavier editing and rewriting than does our personal narrative paraphrasing system; we create and train on large amounts of synthetic errorful translations of foreign-language documents. Our approach produces fluent English summaries from disdisfluent translations of non-English documents, and it generalizes across languages