The potential utility of age, triage score, and disposition data contained in emergency department electronic records for influenza-like illness surveillance in Montreal

La surveillance de l’influenza s’appuie sur un large spectre de données, dont les données de surveillance syndromique provenant des salles d’urgences. De plus en plus de variables sont enregistrées dans les dossiers électroniques des urgences et mises à la disposition des équipes de surveillance. L’objectif principal de ce mémoire est d’évaluer l’utilité potentielle de l’âge, de la catégorie de triage et de l’orientation au départ de l’urgence pour améliorer la surveillance de la morbidité liée aux cas sévères d’influenza. Les données d’un sous-ensemble des hôpitaux de Montréal ont été utilisées, d’avril 2006 à janvier 2011. Les hospitalisations avec diagnostic de pneumonie ou influenza ont été utilisées comme mesure de la morbidité liée aux cas sévères d’influenza, et ont été modélisées par régression binomiale négative, en tenant compte des tendances séculaires et saisonnières. En comparaison avec les visites avec syndrome d’allure grippale (SAG) totales, les visites avec SAG stratifiées par âge, par catégorie de triage et par orientation de départ ont amélioré le modèle prédictif des hospitalisations avec pneumonie ou influenza. Avant d’intégrer ces variables dans le système de surveillance de Montréal, des étapes additionnelles sont suggérées, incluant l’optimisation de la définition du syndrome d’allure grippale à utiliser, la confirmation de la valeur de ces prédicteurs avec de nouvelles données et l’évaluation de leur utilité pratique.Surveillance of influenza relies on a wide array of data, including emergency department based syndromic surveillance data. An increasing number of variables are recorded in emergency department electronic records and are available for surveillance. The main objective of this research is to evaluate the potential utility of age, triage scores, and disposition data for enhanced monitoring of the burden of severe influenza cases. Data from a subset of Montreal hospitals was used, from April 2006 to January 2011. Pneumonia and influenza hospitalizations were taken as a measure of the burden of severe influenza cases, and were modeled using a negative binomial regression approach, taking into account seasonal and secular trends. Age-, triage score-, and disposition-stratified influenza-like illness visits improved the fit of predictive models for pneumonia and influenza hospitalization, as compared to overall influenza-like illness visits. Before integration of these variables into the Montreal surveillance system, additional steps are suggested, including the optimization of an influenza-like illness syndrome definition, the confirmation of the value of these predictors using new data, and the evaluation of their practical utility

Developing useful early warning and prognostic scores for COVID-19

Abstract Early recognition of high-risk or deteriorating patients with COVID-19 allows timely treatment escalation and optimises allocation of scarce resources across overstretched healthcare systems. Since the late 1990s, physiological scoring systems have been used in hospital settings to provide an objective signal of clinical deterioration prompting urgent clinical review. Several early warning scores (EWS) accurately predict the need for intensive care unit admission and survival in hospitalised patients with sepsis and other acute illnesses, and their routine use is now recommended in secondary care settings in high and low income countries alike. However, there are widespread concerns that existing EWS, which place a premium on the cardiovascular instability seen in severe sepsis, may fail to identify the deteriorating COVID-19 patient. Dozens of research groups have now assessed the predictive value of existing EWS in hospitalised adults with COVID-19, and used sophisticated statistical methods to develop novel early warning and prognostic scores incorporating vital signs, laboratory tests and imaging results. However, many of these novel scores are at high risk of bias and few have been adopted in routine clinical practice. In this education and learning article, we will discuss key pitfalls of existing prognostic and EWS in hospitalised adults with COVID-19; outline promising novel scores for this patient group; and describe the ideal properties of scoring systems suitable for use in low and middle income settings

Syndromic surveillance: reports from a national conference, 2003

Overview of Syndromic Surveillance -- What is Syndromic Surveillance? -- Linking Better Surveillance to Better Outcomes -- Review of the 2003 National Syndromic Surveillance Conference - Lessons Learned and Questions To Be Answered -- -- System Descriptions -- New York City Syndromic Surveillance Systems -- Syndrome and Outbreak Detection Using Chief-Complaint Data - Experience of the Real-Time Outbreak and Disease Surveillance Project -- Removing a Barrier to Computer-Based Outbreak and Disease Surveillance - The RODS Open Source Project -- National Retail Data Monitor for Public Health Surveillance -- National Bioterrorism Syndromic Surveillance Demonstration Program -- Daily Emergency Department Surveillance System - Bergen County, New Jersey -- Hospital Admissions Syndromic Surveillance - Connecticut, September 2001-November 2003 -- BioSense - A National Initiative for Early Detection and Quantification of Public Health Emergencies -- Syndromic Surveillance at Hospital Emergency Departments - Southeastern Virginia -- -- Research Methods -- Bivariate Method for Spatio-Temporal Syndromic Surveillance -- Role of Data Aggregation in Biosurveillance Detection Strategies with Applications from ESSENCE -- Scan Statistics for Temporal Surveillance for Biologic Terrorism -- Approaches to Syndromic Surveillance When Data Consist of Small Regional Counts -- Algorithm for Statistical Detection of Peaks - Syndromic Surveillance System for the Athens 2004 Olympic Games -- Taming Variability in Free Text: Application to Health Surveillance -- Comparison of Two Major Emergency Department-Based Free-Text Chief-Complaint Coding Systems -- How Many Illnesses Does One Emergency Department Visit Represent? Using a Population-Based Telephone Survey To Estimate the Syndromic Multiplier -- Comparison of Office Visit and Nurse Advice Hotline Data for Syndromic Surveillance - Baltimore-Washington, D.C., Metropolitan Area, 2002 -- Progress in Understanding and Using Over-the-Counter Pharmaceuticals for Syndromic Surveillance -- -- Evaluation -- Evaluation Challenges for Syndromic Surveillance - Making Incremental Progress -- Measuring Outbreak-Detection Performance By Using Controlled Feature Set Simulations -- Evaluation of Syndromic Surveillance Systems - Design of an Epidemic Simulation Model -- Benchmark Data and Power Calculations for Evaluating Disease Outbreak Detection Methods -- Bio-ALIRT Biosurveillance Detection Algorithm Evaluation -- ESSENCE II and the Framework for Evaluating Syndromic Surveillance Systems -- Conducting Population Behavioral Health Surveillance by Using Automated Diagnostic and Pharmacy Data Systems -- Evaluation of an Electronic General-Practitioner-Based Syndromic Surveillance System -- National Symptom Surveillance Using Calls to a Telephone Health Advice Service - United Kingdom, December 2001-February 2003 -- Field Investigations of Emergency Department Syndromic Surveillance Signals - New York City -- Should We Be Worried? Investigation of Signals Generated by an Electronic Syndromic Surveillance System - Westchester County, New York -- -- Public Health Practice -- Public Health Information Network - Improving Early Detection by Using a Standards-Based Approach to Connecting Public Health and Clinical Medicine -- Information System Architectures for Syndromic Surveillance -- Perspective of an Emergency Physician Group as a Data Provider for Syndromic Surveillance -- SARS Surveillance Project - Internet-Enabled Multiregion Surveillance for Rapidly Emerging Disease -- Health Information Privacy and Syndromic Surveillance SystemsPapers from the second annual National Syndromic Surveillance Conference convened by the New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, the New York Academy of Medicine, and the CDC in New York City during Oct. 23-24, 2003. Published as the September 24, 2004 supplement to vol. 53 of MMWR. Morbidity and mortality weekly report.1571461

International Society for Disease Surveillance Conference 2011: Building the Future of Public Health Surveillance: Building the Future of Public Health Surveillance

Daniel Reidpath - ORCID: 0000-0002-8796-0420 https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8796-04204pubpub1117

Derivation and validation of a severity scoring tool for COVID-19 illness in low-resource setting

Background The COVID-19 pandemic has profoundly impacted some of the most vulnerable populations in lowresource settings (LRS) across the globe. These settings tend to have underdeveloped healthcare systems that are exceptionally vulnerable to the strain of an outbreak such as SARS-CoV-2. LRS-based clinicians are in need of effective and contextually appropriate triage and assessment tools that have been purpose-designed to aid in evaluating the severity of potential COVID-19 patients. In the context of the COVID-19 crisis, a low-input severity scoring tool could be a cornerstone of ensuring timely access to appropriate care and justified use of critically limited resources. Aim and objectives The aim of this research was to develop and validate a tool to assist frontline providers in rapidly predicting severe COVID-19 disease in LRS. To achieve this aim, the following objectives were defined: identify existing methods of risk stratification of suspected COVID-19 patients worldwide; establish predictors of severe COVID-19 illness measurable in LRS; derive a risk stratification tool to assist facility-based healthcare providers in LRS in evaluating in-hospital mortality risk; and validate tool SST in the African setting using real-world data. Methods To achieve the aim of this dissertation, quantitative and review methodologies were employed across four studies. First, a scoping review was conducted to identify all studies describing screening, triage, and severity scoring of suspected COVID-19 patients worldwide. These tools were then compared to usability and feasibility standards for LRS emergency units, to determine viable tool options for such settings. Following this, a systematic review and meta-analysis were undertaken to evaluate existing literature for associations between COVID-19 illness severity, and historical characteristics, clinical presentations, and investigations measurable in LRS. Three online databases were searched to identify all studies assessing potential associations between clinical characteristics and investigations, and COVID-19 illness severity. Data for all variables that were statistically analysed in relation to COVID19 disease severity were extracted and a meta-analysis was conducted to generate pooled odds ratios for individual variables' predictive abilities. In the third study, machine learning was used on data from a retrospective cohort of Sudanese COVID-19 patients to derive the AFEM COVID-19 Mortality Score (AFEM-CMS), a contextually appropriate mortality index for COVID-19. Following this, a fourth study was conducted with a more recent Sudanese dataset to validate the tool. Results The scoping review identified COVID-19 risk stratification 23 tools with potential feasibility for use in LRS. Of these, none had been validated in LRS. The systematic review then identified 79 eligible articles, including data from 27713 individual patients with laboratory-confirmed COVID-19. A total of 202 features were studied in relation to COVID-19 severity across these articles, of which 81 were deemed feasible for assessment in LRS. Meta-analysis of two demographic features, 21 comorbidities, and 21 presenting signs and symptoms with appropriate data available identified 19 significant predictors of severe COVID-19, including: past medical history of stroke (pOR: 3.08 (95% CI [1.95, 4.88])), shortness of breath (pOR: 2·78 (95% CI [2·24-3·46])), chronic kidney disease (pOR: 2.55 (95% CI [1.52-4.29])), and presence of any comorbidity (pOR: 2.41 (95% CI [2.01-2.89])). These significant predictors of severe COVID-19 were then considered for inclusion in the AFEM-CMS. Data from 467 COVID-19 patientsin Sudan were used to derive two versions of the tool. Both include age, sex, number of comorbidities, Glasgow Coma Scale, respiratory rate, and systolic blood pressure; in settings with pulse oximetry, oxygen saturation is included and, in settings without access, heart rate is included. The AFEM-CMS showed good discrimination: The model including pulse oximetry had a C-statistic of 0.775 (95% CI: 0.737-0.813) and the model excluding it had a C-statistic of 0.719 (95% CI: 0.678- 0.760). The tool was then validated against a second set of data from Sudan and found to once again have reasonable discriminatory power in identifying those at greatest risk of death from COVID-19: The model including pulse oximetry had a C-statistic of 0.732 (95% CI: 0.687-0.777) and the model excluding pulse oximetry had a C-statistic of 0.696 (0.645-0.747). Conclusions and relevance This dissertation establishes what is, to our knowledge, the first COVID-19 mortality prediction tool intentionally designed for frontline providers in LRS and validated in such a setting. The derivation and validation of the AFEM-CMS highlight the feasibility and potential impact of real-time development of clinical tools to improve patient care, even in times of surge in LRS. This study is just one of hundreds of efforts across all resource levels suggesting that rapid use of machine learning methodologies holds promise in improving responses to pandemics and other emergencies. It is our hope that, in future health crises, LRS-based clinicians and researchers can refer to these techniques to inform contextually and situationally appropriate clinical tools and reduce morbidity and mortality

The use of emergency department electronic health data for syndromic surveillance to enhance public health surveillance programmes in England

Public health surveillance allows for the identification and monitoring of trends in human health. Syndromic surveillance is a relatively recent addition to these activities, offering the potential to monitor trends on a (near) real-time basis and is often more timely than may be possible through other, traditional, surveillance routes. Emergency department (ED) syndromic surveillance systems have been developed and successfully operated worldwide. The Public Health England Emergency Department Syndromic Surveillance System (EDSSS) was developed in preparation for the London 2012 Olympic and Paralympic Games and remains as a public health legacy of the Games. This thesis aimed to describe and provide evidence of how emergency department syndromic surveillance (as performed by EDSSS) provides additional benefit to public health surveillance and added value to emergency care services in England. Additionally the potential for further development and future improvements to public health surveillance is described. The EDSSS is shown here to have been successfully used to describe the impact of the rotavirus vaccine, indicating that EDSSS has the potential to be used for future rapid, stand alone, investigation of impact of vaccines in England. In the first cross-national study of its kind, the EDSSS (alongside OSCOUR, its counterpart in France) was successfully used to describe the changes in human health indicators during periods of poor air quality. In addition to reporting on both infectious and non-infectious disease, emergency department syndromic surveillance also successfully described the impacts of human behaviour on ED attendances. During the EURO 2016 football tournament ED attendances were found to differ from the expected during match periods, not only in France the host country, but also in the UK home nations where fans followed team progress from home. The EDSSS is also the first example of a syndromic surveillance system having input into the development of a standardised national dataset, which has been mandated across EDs in England. Primarily aimed to improve patient care and the wider workings of EDs, this improved data collection has resulted in improvements in the EDSSS itself, which was subsequently expanded from a small sentinel to truly national surveillance system. The standardisation of ED data collection and reporting, alongside improved geographical coverage and near real-time surveillance reporting, enabled rapid feedback on the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on ED attendances in England. EDSSS described general trends in ED attendances, encompassing both infectious and non-infectious indicators, prompting the refinement of public health messaging, encouraging continued use of emergency care as required by the general public. The evidence presented in this thesis has demonstrated where the ED syndromic surveillance has added value for public health surveillance in England, utilising the system flexibility and timeliness of reporting. Successful collaborative working has provided the potential for future cross-system learning for further system development, as well as the ability to work at local, national and potentially international scales