Throughput Analysis of Primary and Secondary Networks in a Shared IEEE 802.11 System

In this paper, we analyze the coexistence of a primary and a secondary (cognitive) network when both networks use the IEEE 802.11 based distributed coordination function for medium access control. Specifically, we consider the problem of channel capture by a secondary network that uses spectrum sensing to determine the availability of the channel, and its impact on the primary throughput. We integrate the notion of transmission slots in Bianchi's Markov model with the physical time slots, to derive the transmission probability of the secondary network as a function of its scan duration. This is used to obtain analytical expressions for the throughput achievable by the primary and secondary networks. Our analysis considers both saturated and unsaturated networks. By performing a numerical search, the secondary network parameters are selected to maximize its throughput for a given level of protection of the primary network throughput. The theoretical expressions are validated using extensive simulations carried out in the Network Simulator 2. Our results provide critical insights into the performance and robustness of different schemes for medium access by the secondary network. In particular, we find that the channel captures by the secondary network does not significantly impact the primary throughput, and that simply increasing the secondary contention window size is only marginally inferior to silent-period based methods in terms of its throughput performance.Comment: To appear in IEEE Transactions on Wireless Communication

On the Behavior of the Distributed Coordination Function of IEEE 802.11 with Multirate Capability under General Transmission Conditions

The aim of this paper is threefold. First, it presents a multi-dimensional Markovian state transition model characterizing the behavior of the IEEE 802.11 protocol at the Medium Access Control layer which accounts for packet transmission failures due to channel errors modeling both saturated and non-saturated traffic conditions. Second, it provides a throughput analysis of the IEEE 802.11 protocol at the data link layer in both saturated and non-saturated traffic conditions taking into account the impact of both the physical propagation channel and multirate transmission in Rayleigh fading environment. The general traffic model assumed is M/M/1/K. Finally, it shows that the behavior of the throughput in non-saturated traffic conditions is a linear combination of two system parameters; the payload size and the packet rates, $\lambda^{(s)}$, of each contending station. The validity interval of the proposed model is also derived. Simulation results closely match the theoretical derivations, confirming the effectiveness of the proposed models.Comment: Submitted to IEEE Transactions on Wireless Communications, October 21, 200

Decentralised Learning MACs for Collision-free Access in WLANs

By combining the features of CSMA and TDMA, fully decentralised WLAN MAC schemes have recently been proposed that converge to collision-free schedules. In this paper we describe a MAC with optimal long-run throughput that is almost decentralised. We then design two \changed{schemes} that are practically realisable, decentralised approximations of this optimal scheme and operate with different amounts of sensing information. We achieve this by (1) introducing learning algorithms that can substantially speed up convergence to collision free operation; (2) developing a decentralised schedule length adaptation scheme that provides long-run fair (uniform) access to the medium while maintaining collision-free access for arbitrary numbers of stations

Cooperative communication in wireless local area networks

The concept of cooperative communication has been proposed to improve link capacity, transmission reliability and network coverage in multiuser wireless communication networks. Different from conventional point-to-point and point-to-multipoint communications, cooperative communication allows multiple users or stations in a wireless network to coordinate their packet transmissions and share each other’s resources, thus achieving high performance gain and better service coverage. According to the IEEE 802.11 standards, Wireless Local Area Networks (WLANs) can support multiple transmission data rates, depending on the instantaneous channel condition between a source station and an Access Point (AP). In such a multi-rate WLAN, those low data-rate stations will occupy the shared communication channel for a longer period for transmitting a fixed-size packet to the AP, thus reducing the channel efficiency and overall system performance. This thesis addresses this challenging problem in multi-rate WLANs by proposing two cooperative Medium Access Control (MAC) protocols, namely Busy Tone based Cooperative MAC (BTAC) protocol and Cooperative Access with Relay’s Data (CARD) protocol. Under BTAC, a low data-rate sending station tries to identify and use a close-by intermediate station as its relay to forward its data packets at higher data-rate to the AP through a two-hop path. In this way, BTAC can achieve cooperative diversity gain in multi-rate WLANs. Furthermore, the proposed CARD protocol enables a relay station to transmit its own data packets to the AP immediately after forwarding its neighbour’s packets, thus minimising the handshake procedure and overheads for sensing and reserving the common channel. In doing so, CARD can achieve both cooperative diversity gain and cooperative multiplexing gain. Both BTAC and CARD protocols are backward compatible with the existing IEEE 802.11 standards. New cross-layer mathematical models have been developed in this thesis to study the performance of BTAC and CARD under different channel conditions and for saturated and unsaturated traffic loads. Detailed simulation platforms were developed and are discussed in this thesis. Extensive simulation results validate the mathematical models developed and show that BTAC and CARD protocols can significantly improve system throughput, service delay, and energy efficiency for WLANs operating under realistic communication scenarios

Performance Evaluation of Wireless Medium Access Control Protocols for Internet of Things

The Internet of Things makes the residents in Smart Cities enjoy a more efficient and high-quality lifestyle by wirelessly interconnecting the physical and visual world. However, the performance of wireless networks is challenged by the ever-growing wireless traffic data, the complexity of the network structures, and various requirements of Quality of Service (QoS), especially on the Internet of Vehicle and wireless sensor networks. Consequently, the IEEE 802.11p and 802.11ah standards were designed to support effective inter-vehicle communications and large-scale sensor networks, respectively. Although their Medium Access Control protocols have attracted much research interest, they have yet to fully consider the influences of channel errors and buffer sizes on the performance evaluation of these Medium Access Control (MAC) protocols. Therefore, this thesis first proposed a new analytical model based on a Markov chain and Queuing analysis to evaluate the performance of IEEE 802.11p under imperfect channels with both saturated and unsaturated traffic. All influential factors of the Enhanced Distributed Channel Access (EDCA) mechanism in IEEE 802.11p are considered, including the backoff counter freezing, Arbitration Inter-Frame Spacing (AIFS) defers, the internal collision, and finite MAC buffer sizes. Furthermore, this proposed model considers more common and actual conditions with the influence of channel errors and finite MAC buffer sizes. The effectiveness and accuracy of the developed model have been validated through extensive ns-3 simulation experiments. Second, this thesis proposes a developed analytical model based on Advanced Queuing Analysis and the Gilbert-Elliot model to analyse the performance of IEEE 802.11p with burst error transmissions. This proposed analytical model simultaneously describes transmission queues for all four Access Categories (AC) queues with the influence of burst errors. Similarly, this presented model can analyse QoS performance, including throughputs and end-to-end delays with the unsaturated or saturated load traffics. Furthermore, this model operates under more actual bursty error channels in vehicular environments. In addition, a series of simulation experiments with a natural urban environment is designed to validate the efficiency and accuracy of the presented model. The simulation results reflect the reliability and effectiveness of the presented model in terms of throughput and end-to-end delays under various channel conditions. Third, this thesis designed and implemented a simulation experiment to analyse the performance of IEEE 802.11ah. These simulation experiments are based on ns-3 and an extension. These simulation experiments' results indicate the Restricted Access Window (RAW) mechanism's influence on the throughputs, end-to-end delays, and packet loss rates. Furthermore, the influences of channel errors and bursty errors are considered in the simulations. The results also show the strong impact of channel errors on the performance of IEEE 802.11ah due to urban environments. Finally, the potential future work based on the proposed models and simulations is analysed in this thesis. The proposed models of IEEE 802.11p can be an excellent fundamental to optimise the QoS due to the precise evaluation of the influence of factors on the performance of IEEE 802.11p. Moreover, it is possible to migrate the analytical models of IEEE 802.11p to evaluate the performance of IEEE 802.11ah

Effects of Data Frame Size Distribution on Wireless Lans

The continuous need to replace cables and deploy mobile devices in the communications industry has led to very active research on the utilization of wireless networks. IEEE 802.11 WLAN is known to achieve relatively small throughput performance compared to the underlying physical layer’s transmission rate and this is as a result of large overhead information composed of medium access control header, physical layer preamble information back-off duration control frames (ACK) transmissions and even inter-frame spaces. This paper provides an overview of frame size distribution using the dual fixed frame size as a case in point and subsequently a performance evaluation in a multi-user transmission channel condition is carried out. The distribution of frame size and its effect on the throughput is also investigated. This is done through comparison of various scenarios such as fixed frame size distribution and dual-fixed frame size distribution. The dual- fixed frame size distribution case has both equality and inequality cases and both are investigated. The case of equal frames was found to have improved marginal throughput compared to the other cases. The analysis and measurement results from OPNET simulation has shown that an equal fixed frame size distribution can be efficient in optimizing useful data

Enhanced Collision Resolution for the IEEE 802.11 Distributed Coordination Function

The IEEE 802.11 standard relies on the Distributed Coordination Function (DCF) as the fundamental medium access control method. DCF uses the Binary Exponential Backoff (BEB) algorithm to regulate channel access. The backoff period determined by BEB depends on a contention window (CW) whose size is doubled if a station suffers a collision and reset to its minimum value after a successful transmission. BEB doubles the CW size upon collision to reduce the collision probability in retransmission. However, this CW increase reduces channel access time because stations will spend more time sensing the channel rather than accessing it. Although resetting the CW to its minimum value increases channel access, it negatively affects fairness because it favours successfully transmitting stations over stations suffering from collisions. Moreover, resetting CW leads to increasing the collision probability and therefore increases the number of collisions. % Quality control editor: Please ensure that the intended meaning has been maintained in the edits of the previous sentence. Since increasing channel access time and reducing the probability of collisions are important factors to improve the DCF performance, and they conflict with each other, improving one will have an adverse effect on the other and consequently will harm the DCF performance. We propose an algorithm, \gls{ECRA}, that solves collisions once they occur without instantly increasing the CW size. Our algorithm reduces the collision probability without affecting channel access time. We also propose an accurate analytical model that allows comparing the theoretical saturation and maximum throughputs of our algorithm with those of benchmark algorithms. Our model uses a collision probability that is dependent on the station transmission history and thus provides a precise estimation of the probability that a station transmits in a random timeslot, which results in a more accurate throughput analysis. We present extensive simulations for fixed and mobile scenarios. The results show that on average, our algorithm outperformed BEB in terms of throughput and fairness. Compared to other benchmark algorithms, our algorithm improved, on average, throughput and delay performance

Performance Prediction and Tuning for Symmetric Coexistence of WiFi and ZigBee Networks

Due to the explosive deployment of WiFi and ZigBee wireless networks, 2.4GHz ISM bands (2.4GHz-2.5GHz) are becoming increasingly crowded, and the co-channel coexistence of these two networks is inevitable. For coexistence networks, people always want to predict their performance (e.g. throughput, energy consumption, etc.) before deployment, or even want to tune parameters to compensate unnecessary performance degradation (owing to the huge differences between these two MAC protocols) or to satisfy some performance requirements (e.g., priority, delay constraint, etc.) of them. However, predicting and tuning performance of coexisting WiFi and ZigBee networks has been a challenging task, primarily due to the lack of corresponding simulators and analytical models. In this dissertation, we addressed the aforementioned problems by presenting simulators and models for the coexistence of WiFi and ZigBee devices. Specifically, based on the energy efficiency and traffic pattern of three practical coexistence scenarios: disaster rescue site, smart hospital and home automation. We first of all classify them into three classes, which are non-sleeping devices with saturated traffic (SAT), non-sleeping devices with unsaturated traffic (UNSAT) and duty-cycling devices with unsaturated traffic (DC-UNSAT). Then a simulator and an analytical model are proposed for each class, where each simulator is verified by simple hardware based experiment. Next, we derive the expressions for performance metrics like throughput, delay etc., and predict them using both the proposed simulator and the model. Due to the higher accuracy of the simulator, the results from them are used as the ground truth to validate the accuracy of the model. Last, according to some common performance tuning requirements for each class, we formulate them into optimization problems and propose the corresponding solving methods. The results show that the proposed simulators have high accuracy in performance prediction, while the models, although are less accurate than the former, can be used in fast prediction. In particular, the models can also be easily used in optimization problems for performance tuning, and the results prove its high efficiency