Assessment of the worthwhileness of efficient driving in railway systems with high-receptivity power supplies

Eco-driving is one of the most important strategies for significantly reducing the energy consumption of railways with low investments. It consists of designing a way of driving a train to fulfil a target running time, consuming the minimum amount of energy. Most eco-driving energy savings come from the substitution of some braking periods with coasting periods. Nowadays, modern trains can use regenerative braking to recover the kinetic energy during deceleration phases. Therefore, if the receptivity of the railway system to regenerate energy is high, a question arises: is it worth designing eco-driving speed profiles? This paper assesses the energy benefits that eco-driving can provide in different scenarios to answer this question. Eco-driving is obtained by means of a multi-objective particle swarm optimization algorithm, combined with a detailed train simulator, to obtain realistic results. Eco-driving speed profiles are compared with a standard driving that performs the same running time. Real data from Spanish high-speed lines have been used to analyze the results in two case studies. Stretches fed by 1 × 25 kV and 2 × 25 kV AC power supply systems have been considered, as they present high receptivity to regenerate energy. Furthermore, the variations of the two most important factors that affect the regenerative energy usage have been studied: train motors efficiency ratio and catenary resistance. Results indicate that the greater the catenary resistance, the more advantageous eco-driving is. Similarly, the lower the motor efficiency, the greater the energy savings provided by efficient driving. Despite the differences observed in energy savings, the main conclusion is that eco-driving always provides significant energy savings, even in the case of the most receptive power supply network. Therefore, this paper has demonstrated that efforts in improving regenerated energy usage must not neglect the role of eco-driving in railway efficiency

Multi Objective Ant Colony Optimisation to obtain efficient metro speed profiles

[EN] Obtaining efficient speed profiles for metro trains is a multi- objective optimisation problem where energy consumption and travel time must be balanced. Automatic Train Operation (ATO) systems may handle a great number of possible speed profiles; hence optimisation algorithms are required find efficient ones in a timely manner. This paper aims to assess the performance of a particular meta-heuristic optimisation algorithm, a variation of the traditional Ant Colony (ACO) modified to deal with multi-objective problems with continuous variables: MOACOr. This algorithm is used to obtain efficient speed profiles in up to 32 interstation sections in the metro network of Valencia (Spain), and the convergence and diversity of these solution sets is evaluated through metrics such as Inverse Generational Distance (GD) and Normalised Hypervolume (NH). The results are then compared to those obtained with a conventional genetic algorithm (NSGA-II), including a statistical analysis to identify significant differences. It has been found that MOACOr shows a better performance than NSGA-II in terms of convergence, regularity and diversity of the solution. These results indicate that MOACOr is a good alternative to the widely used genetic algorithm and could be a better tool for rail operation managers trying to improve energy efficiency.The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article: This work was supported by the Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness grant number TRA2011-26602.Martínez Fernández, P.; Font Torres, JB.; Villalba Sanchis, I.; Insa Franco, R. (2023). Multi Objective Ant Colony Optimisation to obtain efficient metro speed profiles. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers Part F Journal of Rail and Rapid Transit. 237(2):232-242. https://doi.org/10.1177/09544097221103351232242237

A review of modelling and optimisation methods applied to railways energy consumption

[EN] Railways are a rather efficient transport mean, and yet there is increasing interest in reducing their energy consumption and making them more sustainable in the current context of climate change. Many studies try to model, analyse and optimise the energy consumed by railways, and there is a wide diversity of methods, techniques and approaches regarding how to formulate and solve this problem. This paper aims to provide insight into this topic by reviewing up to 52 papers related to railways energy consumption. Two main areas are analysed: modelling techniques used to simulate train(s) movement and energy consumption, and optimisation methods used to achieve more efficient train circulations in railway networks. The most used methods in each case are briefly described and the main trends found are analysed. Furthermore, a statistical study has been carried out to recognise relationships between methods and optimisation variables. It was found that deterministic models based on the Davis equation are by far (85% of the papers reviewed) the most common in terms of modelling. As for optimisation, meta-heuristic methods are the preferred choice (57.8%), particularly Genetic Algorithms.Martínez Fernández, P.; Villalba Sanchis, I.; Yepes, V.; Insa Franco, R. (2019). A review of modelling and optimisation methods applied to railways energy consumption. Journal of Cleaner Production. 222:153-162. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.03.037S15316222

SmartDrive: Traction Energy Optimization and Applications in Rail Systems

This paper presents the development of SmartDrive package to achieve the application of energy-efficient driving strategy. The results are from collaboration between Ricardo Rail and the Birmingham Centre for Railway Research and Education (BCRRE). Advanced tram and train trajectory optimization techniques developed by BCRRE as part of the UKTRAM More Energy Efficiency Tram project have been now incorporated in Ricardo's SmartDrive product offering. The train trajectory optimization method, associated driver training and awareness package (SmartDrive) has been developed for use on tram, metro, and some heavy rail systems. A simulator was designed that can simulate the movement of railway vehicles and calculate the detailed power system energy consumption with different train trajectories when implemented on a typical AC or DC powered route. The energy evaluation results from the simulator will provide several potential energy-saving solutions for the existing route. An enhanced Brute Force algorithm was developed to achieve the optimization quickly and efficiently. Analysis of the results showed that by implementing an optimal speed trajectory, the energy usage in the network can be significantly reduced. A driver practical training system and the optimized lineside driving control signage, based on the optimized trajectory were developed for testing. This system instructed drivers to maximize coasting in segregated sections of the network and to match optimal speed limits in busier street sections. The field trials and real daily operations in the Edinburgh Tram Line, U.K., have shown that energy savings of 10%-20% are achievable

System energy optimisation strategies for DC railway traction power networks

Energy and environmental sustainability in transportation are becoming ever more important. In Europe, the transportation sector is responsible for about 32% of the final energy consumption. Electrified railway systems play an important role in contributing to the reduction of energy usage and C0$_2$ emissions compared with other transport modes. Previous studies have investigated train driving strategies for traction energy saving. However, few of them consider the overall system energy optimisation. This thesis analyses the energy consumption of urban systems with regenerating trains, including the energy supplied by substations, used in power transmission networks, consumed by monitoring trains, and regenerated by braking trains. This thesis proposes an approach to searching energy-efficient driving strategies with coasting controls. A Driver Advisory System is designed and implemented in a field test on Beijing Yizhuang Subway Line. The driver guided by the DAS achieves 16% of traction energy savings, compared with normal driving. This thesis also proposes an approach to global system energy consumption optimisation, based on a Monte Carlo Algorithm. The case study indicates that the substation energy is reduced by around 38.6% with the system optimised operations. The efficiency of using regenerative braking energy is improved to from 80.6 to 95.5%

System energy optimisation strategies for metros with regeneration

Energy and environmental sustainability in transportation are becoming ever more important. In Europe, the transportation sector is responsible for about 30% of the final end use of energy. Electrified railway systems play an important role in contributing to the reduction of energy usage and CO2 emissions compared with other transport modes. For metro-transit systems with frequently motoring and braking trains, the effective use of regenerated braking energy is a significant way to reduce the net energy consumption. Although eco-driving strategies have been studied for some time, a comprehensive understanding of how regeneration affects the overall system energy consumption has not been developed. This paper proposes a multi-train traction power network modelling method to determine the system energy flow of the railway system with regenerating braking trains. The initial results show that minimising traction energy use is not the same as minimising the system energy usage in a metro system. An integrated optimisation method is proposed to solve the system energy-saving problem, which takes train movement and electrical power flow into consideration. The results of a study of the Beijing Yizhuang metro line indicate that optimised operation could reduce the energy consumption at the substations by nearly 38.6% compared to that used with the existing ATO operation

Automatic Train Operation Speed Profile Optimization and Tracking with Multi-Objective in Urban Railway

Besides energy-efficiency, people also want train operation to be comfortable, punctual and parking precise. In this paper, a multi-objective model for automatic train operation in urban railway is proposed by unifying dimensions of different objectives firstly. This model is built by applying multi-objective decision with the penalty function, based on the analysis of train performance and its operation environment. Then a genetic algorithm is developed to solve this model and obtain the optimal recommended speed profiles. Thirdly, fuzzy controller is designed to achieve track recommended speed profiles. Finally, with the help of Matlab software, control effect is verified based on simulation. From the simulation results, it can be seen this strategy can meet the requirement of multi-objective, which are energy-saving, parking precisely, running punctually and comfort

Energy-saving strategies for electric railway systems in the next generation by advanced control of onboard DC/DC converters and enhanced powering acceleration

学位の種別: 修士University of Tokyo(東京大学