Use of Text Data in Identifying and Prioritizing Potential Drug Repositioning Candidates

New drug development costs between 500 million and 2 billion dollars and takes 10-15 years, with a success rate of less than 10%. Drug repurposing (defined as discovering new indications for existing drugs) could play a significant role in drug development, especially considering the declining success rates of developing novel drugs. In the period 2007-2009, drug repurposing led to the launching of 30-40% of new drugs. Typically, new indications for existing medications are identified by accident. However, new technologies and a large number of available resources enable the development of systematic approaches to identify and validate drug-repurposing candidates with significantly lower cost. A variety of resources have been utilized to identify novel drug repurposing candidates such as biomedical literature, clinical notes, and genetic data. In this dissertation, we focused on using text data in identifying and prioritizing drug repositioning candidates and conducted five studies. In the first study, we aimed to assess the feasibility of using patient reviews from social media to identify potential candidates for drug repurposing. We retrieved patient reviews of 180 medications from an online forum, WebMD. Using dictionary-based and machine learning approaches, we identified disease names in the reviews. Several publicly available resources were used to exclude comments containing known indications and adverse drug effects. After manually reviewing some of the remaining comments, we implemented a rule-based system to identify beneficial effects. The dictionary-based system and machine learning system identified 2178 and 6171 disease names respectively in 64,616 patient comments. We provided a list of 10 common patterns that patients used to report any beneficial effects or uses of medication. After manually reviewing the comments tagged by our rule-based system, we identified five potential drug repurposing candidates. To our knowledge, this was the first study to consider using social media data to identify drug-repurposing candidates. We found that even a rule-based system, with a limited number of rules, could identify beneficial effect mentions in the comments of patients. Our preliminary study shows that social media has the potential to be used in drug repurposing. In the second study, we investigated the significance of extracting information from multiple sentences specifically in the context of drug-disease relation discovery. We used multiple resources such as Semantic Medline, a literature-based resource, and Medline search (for filtering spurious results) and inferred 8,772 potential drug-disease pairs. Our analysis revealed that 6,450 (73.5%) of the 8,772 potential drug-disease relations did not occur in a single sentence. Moreover, only 537 of the drug-disease pairs matched the curated gold standard in the Comparative Toxicogenomics Database (CTD), a trusted resource for drug-disease relations. Among the 537, nearly 75% (407) of the drug-disease pairs occur in multiple sentences. Our analysis revealed that the drug-disease pairs inferred from Semantic Medline or retrieved from CTD could be extracted from multiple sentences in the literature. This highlights the significance of the need for discourse-level analysis in extracting the relations from biomedical literature. In the third and fourth study, we focused on prioritizing drug repositioning candidates extracted from biomedical literature which we refer to as Literature-Based Discovery (LBD). In the third study, we used drug-gene and gene-disease semantic predications extracted from Medline abstracts to generate a list of potential drug-disease pairs. We further ranked the generated pairs, by assigning scores based on the predicates that qualify drug-gene and gene-disease relationships. On comparing the top-ranked drug-disease pairs against the Comparative Toxicogenomics Database, we found that a significant percentage of top-ranked pairs appeared in CTD. Co-occurrence of these high-ranked pairs in Medline abstracts is then used to improve the rankings of the inferred drug-disease relations. Finally, manual evaluation of the top-ten pairs ranked by our approach revealed that nine of them have good potential for biological significance based on expert judgment. In the fourth study, we proposed a method, utilizing information surrounding causal findings, to prioritize discoveries generated by LBD systems. We focused on discovering drug-disease relations, which have the potential to identify drug repositioning candidates or adverse drug reactions. Our LBD system used drug-gene and gene-disease semantic predication in SemMedDB as causal findings and Swanson’s ABC model to generate potential drug-disease relations. Using sentences, as a source of causal findings, our ranking method trained a binary classifier to classify generated drug-disease relations into desired classes. We trained and tested our classifier for three different purposes: a) drug repositioning b) adverse drug-event detection and c) drug-disease relation detection. The classifier obtained 0.78, 0.86, and 0.83 F-measures respectively for these tasks. The number of causal findings of each hypothesis, which were classified as positive by the classifier, is the main metric for ranking hypotheses in the proposed method. To evaluate the ranking method, we counted and compared the number of true relations in the top 100 pairs, ranked by our method and one of the previous methods. Out of 181 true relations in the test dataset, the proposed method ranked 20 of them in the top 100 relations while this number was 13 for the other method. In the last study, we used biomedical literature and clinical trials in ranking potential drug repositioning candidates identified by Phenome-Wide Association Studies (PheWAS). Unlike previous approaches, in this study, we did not limit our method to LBD. First, we generated a list of potential drug repositioning candidates using PheWAS. We retrieved 212,851 gene-disease associations from PheWAS catalog and 14,169 gene-drug relationships from DrugBank. Following Swanson’s model, we generated 52,966 potential drug repositioning candidates. Then, we developed an information retrieval system to retrieve any evidence of those candidates co-occurring in the biomedical literature and clinical trials. We identified nearly 14,800 drug-disease pairs with some evidence of support. In addition, we identified more than 38,000 novel candidates for re-purposing, encompassing hundreds of different disease states and over 1,000 individual medications. We anticipate that these results will be highly useful for hypothesis generation in the field of drug repurposing

Drug repurposing using biological networks

Drug repositioning is a strategy to identify new uses for existing, approved, or research drugs that are outside the scope of its original medical indication. Drug repurposing is based on the fact that one drug can act on multiple targets or that two diseases can have molecular similarities, among others. Currently, thanks to the rapid advancement of high-performance technologies, a massive amount of biological and biomedical data is being generated. This allows the use of computational methods and models based on biological networks to develop new possibilities for drug repurposing. Therefore, here, we provide an in-depth review of the main applications of drug repositioning that have been carried out using biological network models. The goal of this review is to show the usefulness of these computational methods to predict associations and to find candidate drugs for repositioning in new indications of certain diseases

The Infectious Disease Ontology in the Age of COVID-19

The Infectious Disease Ontology (IDO) is a suite of interoperable ontology modules that aims to provide coverage of all aspects of the infectious disease domain, including biomedical research, clinical care, and public health. IDO Core is designed to be a disease and pathogen neutral ontology, covering just those types of entities and relations that are relevant to infectious diseases generally. IDO Core is then extended by a collection of ontology modules focusing on specific diseases and pathogens. In this paper we present applications of IDO Core within various areas of infectious disease research, together with an overview of all IDO extension ontologies and the methodology on the basis of which they are built. We also survey recent developments involving IDO, including the creation of IDO Virus; the Coronaviruses Infectious Disease Ontology (CIDO); and an extension of CIDO focused on COVID-19 (IDO-CovID-19).We also discuss how these ontologies might assist in information-driven efforts to deal with the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, to accelerate data discovery in the early stages of future pandemics, and to promote reproducibility of infectious disease research

Enabling Web-scale data integration in biomedicine through Linked Open Data

The biomedical data landscape is fragmented with several isolated, heterogeneous data and knowledge sources, which use varying formats, syntaxes, schemas, and entity notations, existing on the Web. Biomedical researchers face severe logistical and technical challenges to query, integrate, analyze, and visualize data from multiple diverse sources in the context of available biomedical knowledge. Semantic Web technologies and Linked Data principles may aid toward Web-scale semantic processing and data integration in biomedicine. The biomedical research community has been one of the earliest adopters of these technologies and principles to publish data and knowledge on the Web as linked graphs and ontologies, hence creating the Life Sciences Linked Open Data (LSLOD) cloud. In this paper, we provide our perspective on some opportunities proffered by the use of LSLOD to integrate biomedical data and knowledge in three domains: (1) pharmacology, (2) cancer research, and (3) infectious diseases. We will discuss some of the major challenges that hinder the wide-spread use and consumption of LSLOD by the biomedical research community. Finally, we provide a few technical solutions and insights that can address these challenges. Eventually, LSLOD can enable the development of scalable, intelligent infrastructures that support artificial intelligence methods for augmenting human intelligence to achieve better clinical outcomes for patients, to enhance the quality of biomedical research, and to improve our understanding of living systems

Reply to: Soils need to be considered when assessing the impacts of land-use change on carbon sequestration

Industrial Ecolog

Information Outlook, September/October 2019

Volume 23, Issue 5https://scholarworks.sjsu.edu/sla_io_2019/1004/thumbnail.jp

Network-driven strategies to integrate and exploit biomedical data

[eng] In the quest for understanding complex biological systems, the scientific community has been delving into protein, chemical and disease biology, populating biomedical databases with a wealth of data and knowledge. Currently, the field of biomedicine has entered a Big Data era, in which computational-driven research can largely benefit from existing knowledge to better understand and characterize biological and chemical entities. And yet, the heterogeneity and complexity of biomedical data trigger the need for a proper integration and representation of this knowledge, so that it can be effectively and efficiently exploited. In this thesis, we aim at developing new strategies to leverage the current biomedical knowledge, so that meaningful information can be extracted and fused into downstream applications. To this goal, we have capitalized on network analysis algorithms to integrate and exploit biomedical data in a wide variety of scenarios, providing a better understanding of pharmacoomics experiments while helping accelerate the drug discovery process. More specifically, we have (i) devised an approach to identify functional gene sets associated with drug response mechanisms of action, (ii) created a resource of biomedical descriptors able to anticipate cellular drug response and identify new drug repurposing opportunities, (iii) designed a tool to annotate biomedical support for a given set of experimental observations, and (iv) reviewed different chemical and biological descriptors relevant for drug discovery, illustrating how they can be used to provide solutions to current challenges in biomedicine.[cat] En la cerca d’una millor comprensió dels sistemes biològics complexos, la comunitat científica ha estat aprofundint en la biologia de les proteïnes, fàrmacs i malalties, poblant les bases de dades biomèdiques amb un gran volum de dades i coneixement. En l’actualitat, el camp de la biomedicina es troba en una era de “dades massives” (Big Data), on la investigació duta a terme per ordinadors se’n pot beneficiar per entendre i caracteritzar millor les entitats químiques i biològiques. No obstant, la heterogeneïtat i complexitat de les dades biomèdiques requereix que aquestes s’integrin i es representin d’una manera idònia, permetent així explotar aquesta informació d’una manera efectiva i eficient. L’objectiu d’aquesta tesis doctoral és desenvolupar noves estratègies que permetin explotar el coneixement biomèdic actual i així extreure informació rellevant per aplicacions biomèdiques futures. Per aquesta finalitat, em fet servir algoritmes de xarxes per tal d’integrar i explotar el coneixement biomèdic en diferents tasques, proporcionant un millor enteniment dels experiments farmacoòmics per tal d’ajudar accelerar el procés de descobriment de nous fàrmacs. Com a resultat, en aquesta tesi hem (i) dissenyat una estratègia per identificar grups funcionals de gens associats a la resposta de línies cel·lulars als fàrmacs, (ii) creat una col·lecció de descriptors biomèdics capaços, entre altres coses, d’anticipar com les cèl·lules responen als fàrmacs o trobar nous usos per fàrmacs existents, (iii) desenvolupat una eina per descobrir quins contextos biològics corresponen a una associació biològica observada experimentalment i, finalment, (iv) hem explorat diferents descriptors químics i biològics rellevants pel procés de descobriment de nous fàrmacs, mostrant com aquests poden ser utilitzats per trobar solucions a reptes actuals dins el camp de la biomedicina

Solving the Problem of New Uses

One of the most dramatic public-policy failures in biomedical research is the lack of incentives for industry to develop new therapeutic uses (“indications”) for existing drugs once generics are available. Policymakers and commentators are well aware of this “problem of new uses,” but fail to appreciate its magnitude. Over the past decade, this gap in the incentives for pharmaceutical R&D has become one of the greatest barriers to medical progress. Recent technological advances have allowed researchers to identify hundreds of potential new indications for older drugs that could address critical unmet medical needs. And researchers are poised to discover hundreds more. Developing new indications for existing drugs is much faster, cheaper, and less risky than developing new drugs, and therefore offers the single most promising avenue for delivering new medical treatments to the public. However, pharmaceutical companies invariably lose interest in developing new uses for existing drugs when patients have access to low-cost generics. This article explores the nature and source of this gap in the incentives for developing new medical treatments, showing that it ultimately stems from a simple information problem. At present, the government encourages drug development by granting firms temporary monopoly rights that block generic manufacturers from making or selling imitations of their drugs. The government also makes available an alternative type of monopoly protection for new indications that applies to the act of taking or administering a drug for a new therapeutic use. The latter monopoly rights could provide the appropriate incentives for developing new uses of existing drugs. However, pharmaceutical companies cannot enforce these rights without knowing when physicians prescribe the drug for the patented indication as opposed to some other use. If the government established an infrastructure for pharmaceutical companies to monitor the prescribed indications when pharmacists fill a prescription, those firms would possess the information necessary to enforce patents on new indications, thereby solving the problem of new uses. This article argues that the government could easily create such an infrastructure through the expanding use of eprescribing software and electronic medical records