FPGA-Based PUF Designs: A Comprehensive Review and Comparative Analysis

Field-programmable gate arrays (FPGAs) have firmly established themselves as dynamic platforms for the implementation of physical unclonable functions (PUFs). Their intrinsic reconfigurability and profound implications for enhancing hardware security make them an invaluable asset in this realm. This groundbreaking study not only dives deep into the universe of FPGA-based PUF designs but also offers a comprehensive overview coupled with a discerning comparative analysis. PUFs are the bedrock of device authentication and key generation and the fortification of secure cryptographic protocols. Unleashing the potential of FPGA technology expands the horizons of PUF integration across diverse hardware systems. We set out to understand the fundamental ideas behind PUF and how crucially important it is to current security paradigms. Different FPGA-based PUF solutions, including static, dynamic, and hybrid systems, are closely examined. Each design paradigm is painstakingly examined to reveal its special qualities, functional nuances, and weaknesses. We closely assess a variety of performance metrics, including those related to distinctiveness, reliability, and resilience against hostile threats. We compare various FPGA-based PUF systems against one another to expose their unique advantages and disadvantages. This study provides system designers and security professionals with the crucial information they need to choose the best PUF design for their particular applications. Our paper provides a comprehensive view of the functionality, security capabilities, and prospective applications of FPGA-based PUF systems. The depth of knowledge gained from this research advances the field of hardware security, enabling security practitioners, researchers, and designers to make wise decisions when deciding on and implementing FPGA-based PUF solutions.publishedVersio

Compact Field Programmable Gate Array Based Physical Unclonable Functions Circuits

The Physical Unclonable Functions (PUFs) is a candidate to provide a secure solid root source for identification and authentication applications. It is precious for FPGA-based systems, as FPGA designs are vulnerable to IP thefts and cloning. Ideally, the PUFs should have strong random variations from one chip to another, and thus each PUF is unique and hard to replicate. Also, the PUFs should be stable over time so that the same challenge bits always yield the same result. Correspondingly, one of the major challenges for FPGA-based PUFs is the difficulty of avoiding systematic bias in the integrated circuits but also pulling out consistent characteristics as the PUF at the same time. This thesis discusses several compact PUF structures relying on programmable delay lines (PDLs) and our novel intertwined programmable delays (IPD). We explore the strategy to extract the genuinely random PUF from these structures by minimizing the systematic biases. Yet, our methods still maintain very high reliability. Furthermore, our proposed designs, especially the TERO-based PUFs, show promising resilience to machine learning (ML) attacks. We also suggest the bit-bias metric to estimate PUF’s complexity quickly

A Physical Unclonable Function Based on Inter-Metal Layer Resistance Variations and an Evaluation of its Temperature and Voltage Stability

Keying material for encryption is stored as digital bistrings in non-volatile memory (NVM) on FPGAs and ASICs in current technologies. However, secrets stored this way are not secure against a determined adversary, who can use probing attacks to steal the secret. Physical Unclonable functions (PUFs) have emerged as an alternative. PUFs leverage random manufacturing variations as the source of entropy for generating random bitstrings, and incorporate an on-chip infrastructure for measuring and digitizing the corresponding variations in key electrical parameters, such as delay or voltage. PUFs are designed to reproduce a bitstring on demand and therefore eliminate the need for on-chip storage. In this dissertation, I propose a kind of PUF that measures resistance variations in inter-metal layers that define the power grid of the chip and evaluate its temperature and voltage stability. First, I introduce two implementations of a power grid-based PUF (PG-PUF). Then, I analyze the quality of bit strings generated without considering environmental variations from the PG-PUFs that leverage resistance variations in: 1) the power grid metal wires in 60 copies of a 90 nm chip and 2) in the power grid metal wires of 58 copies of a 65 nm chip. Next, I carry out a series of experiments in a set of 63 chips in IBM\u27s 90 nm technology at 9 TV corners, i.e., over all combination of 3 temperatures: -40oC, 25oC and 85oC and 3 voltages: nominal and +/-10% of the nominal supply voltage. The randomness, uniqueness and stability characteristics of bitstrings generated from PG-PUFs are evaluated. The stability of the PG-PUF and an on-chip voltage-to-digital (VDC) are also evaluated at 9 temperature-voltage corners. I introduce several techniques that have not been previously described, including a mechanism to eliminate voltage trends or \u27bias\u27 in the power grid voltage measurements, as well as a voltage threshold, Triple-Module-Redundancy (TMR) and majority voting scheme to identify and exclude unstable bits

Within-Die Delay Variation Measurement And Analysis For Emerging Technologies Using An Embedded Test Structure

Both random and systematic within-die process variations (PV) are growing more severe with shrinking geometries and increasing die size. Escalation in the variations in delay and power with reductions in feature size places higher demands on the accuracy of variation models. Their availability can be used to improve yield, and the corresponding profitability and product quality of the fabricated integrated circuits (ICs). Sources of within-die variations include optical source limitations, and layout-based systematic effects (pitch, line-width variability, and microscopic etch loading). Unfortunately, accurate models of within-die PVs are becoming more difficult to derive because of their increasingly sensitivity to design-context. Embedded test structures (ETS) continue to play an important role in the development of models of PVs and as a mechanism to improve correlations between hardware and models. Variations in path delays are increasing with scaling, and are increasingly affected by neighborhood\u27 interactions. In order to fully characterize within-die variations, delays must be measured in the context of actual core-logic macros. Doing so requires the use of an embedded test structure, as opposed to traditional scribe line test structures such as ring oscillators (RO). Accurate measurements of within-die variations can be used, e.g., to better tune models to actual hardware (model-to-hardware correlations). In this research project, I propose an embedded test structure called REBEL (Regional dELay BEhavior) that is designed to measure path delays in a minimally invasive fashion; and its architecture measures the path delays more accurately. Design for manufacture-ability (DFM) analysis is done on the on 90 nm ASIC chips and 28nm Zynq 7000 series FPGA boards. I present ASIC results on within-die path delay variations in a floating-point unit (FPU) fabricated in IBM\u27s 90 nm technology, with 5 pipeline stages, used as a test vehicle in chip experiments carried out at nine different temperature/voltage (TV) corners. Also experimental data has been analyzed for path delay variations in short vs long paths. FPGA results on within-die variation and die-to-die variations on Advanced Encryption System (AES) using single pipelined stage are also presented. Other analysis that have been performed on the calibrated path delays are Flip Flop propagation delays for both rising and falling edge (tpHL and tpLH), uncertainty analysis, path distribution analysis, short versus long path variations and mid-length path within-die variation. I also analyze the impact on delay when the chips are subjected to industrial-level temperature and voltage variations. From the experimental results, it has been established that the proposed REBEL provides capabilities similar to an off-chip logic analyzer, i.e., it is able to capture the temporal behavior of the signal over time, including any static and dynamic hazards that may occur on the tested path. The ASIC results further show that path delays are correlated to the launch-capture (LC) interval used to time them. Therefore, calibration as proposed in this work must be carried out in order to obtain an accurate analysis of within-die variations. Results on ASIC chips show that short paths can vary up to 35% on average, while long paths vary up to 20% at nominal temperature and voltage. A similar trend occurs for within-die variations of mid-length paths where magnitudes reduced to 20% and 5%, respectively. The magnitude of delay variations in both these analyses increase as temperature and voltage are changed to increase performance. The high level of within-die delay variations are undesirable from a design perspective, but they represent a rich source of entropy for applications that make use of \u27secrets\u27 such as authentication, hardware metering and encryption. Physical unclonable functions (PUFs) are a class of primitives that leverage within-die-variations as a means of generating random bit strings for these types of applications, including hardware security and trust. Zynq FPGAs Die-to-Die and within-die variation study shows that on average there is 5% of within-Die variation and the range of die-to-Die variation can go upto 3ns. The die-to-Die variations can be explored in much further detail to study the variations spatial dependance. Additionally, I also carried out research in the area data mining to cater for big data by focusing the work on decision tree classification (DTC) to speed-up the classification step in hardware implementation. For this purpose, I devised a pipelined architecture for the implementation of axis parallel binary decision tree classification for meeting up with the requirements of execution time and minimal resource usage in terms of area. The motivation for this work is that analyzing larger data-sets have created abundant opportunities for algorithmic and architectural developments, and data-mining innovations, thus creating a great demand for faster execution of these algorithms, leading towards improving execution time and resource utilization. Decision trees (DT) have since been implemented in software programs. Though, the software implementation of DTC is highly accurate, the execution times and the resource utilization still require improvement to meet the computational demands in the ever growing industry. On the other hand, hardware implementation of DT has not been thoroughly investigated or reported in detail. Therefore, I propose a hardware acceleration of pipelined architecture that incorporates the parallel approach in acquiring the data by having parallel engines working on different partitions of data independently. Also, each engine is processing the data in a pipelined fashion to utilize the resources more efficiently and reduce the time for processing all the data records/tuples. Experimental results show that our proposed hardware acceleration of classification algorithms has increased throughput, by reducing the number of clock cycles required to process the data and generate the results, and it requires minimal resources hence it is area efficient. This architecture also enables algorithms to scale with increasingly large and complex data sets. We developed the DTC algorithm in detail and explored techniques for adapting it to a hardware implementation successfully. This system is 3.5 times faster than the existing hardware implementation of classification.\u2

A Group-Based Ring Oscillator Physical Unclonable Function

Silicon Physical Unclonable Function (PUF) is a physical structure of the chip which has functional characteristics that are hard to predict before fabrication but are expected to be unique after fabrication. This is caused by the random fabrication variations. The secret characteristics can only be extracted through physical measurement and will vanish immediately when the chip is powered down. PUF promises a securer means for cryptographic key generation and storage among many other security applications. However, there are still many practical challenges to cost effectively build secure and reliable PUF secrecy. This dissertation proposes new architectures for ring oscillator (RO) PUFs to answer these challenges. First, our temperature-aware cooperative (TAC) RO PUF can utilize certain ROs that were otherwise discarded due to their instability. Second, our novel group-based algorithm can generate secrecy higher than the theoretical upper bound of the conventional pairwise comparisons approach. Third, we build the first regression-based entropy distiller that can turn the PUF secrecy statistically random and robust, meeting the NIST standards. Fourth, we develop a unique Kendall syndrome coding (KSC) that makes the PUF secrecy error resilient against potential environmental fluctuations. Each of these methods can improve the hardware efficiency of the RO PUF implementation by 1.5X to 8X while improving the security and reliability of the PUF secrecy

Design of secure and trustworthy system-on-chip architectures using hardware-based root-of-trust techniques

Cyber-security is now a critical concern in a wide range of embedded computing modules, communications systems, and connected devices. These devices are used in medical electronics, automotive systems, power grid systems, robotics, and avionics. The general consensus today is that conventional approaches and software-only schemes are not sufficient to provide desired security protections and trustworthiness. Comprehensive hardware-software security solutions so far have remained elusive. One major challenge is that in current system-on-chip (SoCs) designs, processing elements (PEs) and executable codes with varying levels of trust, are all integrated on the same computing platform to share resources. This interdependency of modules creates a fertile attack ground and represents the Achilles’ heel of heterogeneous SoC architectures. The salient research question addressed in this dissertation is “can one design a secure computer system out of non-secure or untrusted computing IP components and cores?”. In response to this question, we establish a generalized, user/designer-centric set of design principles which intend to advance the construction of secure heterogeneous multi-core computing systems. We develop algorithms, models of computation, and hardware security primitives to integrate secure and non-secure processing elements into the same chip design while aiming for: (a) maintaining individual core’s security; (b) preventing data leakage and corruption; (c) promoting data and resource sharing among the cores; and (d) tolerating malicious behaviors from untrusted processing elements and software applications. The key contributions of this thesis are: 1. The introduction of a new architectural model for integrating processing elements with different security and trust levels, i.e., secure and non-secure cores with trusted and untrusted provenances; 2. A generalized process isolation design methodology for the new architecture model that covers both the software and hardware layers to (i) create hardware-assisted virtual logical zones, and (ii) perform both static and runtime security, privilege level and trust authentication checks; 3. A set of secure protocols and hardware root-of-trust (RoT) primitives to support the process isolation design and to provide the following functionalities: (i) hardware immutable identities – using physical unclonable functions, (ii) core hijacking and impersonation resistance – through a blind signature scheme, (iii) threshold-based data access control – with a robust and adaptive secure secret sharing algorithm, (iv) privacy-preserving authorization verification – by proposing a group anonymous authentication algorithm, and (v) denial of resource or denial of service attack avoidance – by developing an interconnect network routing algorithm and a memory access mechanism according to user-defined security policies. 4. An evaluation of the security of the proposed hardware primitives in the post-quantum era, and possible extensions and algorithmic modifications for their post-quantum resistance. In this dissertation, we advance the practicality of secure-by-construction methodologies in SoC architecture design. The methodology allows for the use of unsecured or untrusted processing elements in the construction of these secure architectures and tries to extend their effectiveness into the post-quantum computing era

Comprehensive study of physical unclonable functions on FPGAs: correlation driven Implementation, deep learning modeling attacks, and countermeasures

For more than a decade and a half, Physical Unclonable Functions (PUFs) have been presented as a promising hardware security primitive. The idea of exploiting variabilities in hardware fabrication to generate a unique fingerprint for every silicon chip introduced a more secure and cheaper alternative. Other solutions using non-volatile memory to store cryptographic keys, require additional processing steps to generate keys externally, and secure environments to exchange generated keys, which introduce many points of attack that can be used to extract the secret keys. PUFs were addressed in the literature from different perspectives. Many publications focused on proposing new PUF architectures and evaluation metrics to improve security properties like response uniqueness per chip, response reproducibility of the same PUF input, and response unpredictability using previous input/response pairs. Other research proposed attack schemes to clone the response of PUFs, using conventional machine learning (ML) algorithms, side-channel attacks using power and electromagnetic traces, and fault injection using laser beams and electromagnetic pulses. However, most attack schemes to be successful, imposed some restrictions on the targeted PUF architectures, which make it simpler and easier to attack. Furthermore, they did not propose solid and provable enhancements on these architectures to countermeasure the attacks. This leaves many open questions concerning how to implement perfect secure PUFs especially on FPGAs, how to extend previous modeling attack schemes to be successful against more complex PUF architectures (and understand why modeling attacks work) and how to detect and countermeasure these attacks to guarantee that secret data are safe from the attackers. This Ph.D. dissertation contributes to the state of the art research on physical unclonable functions in several ways. First, the thesis provides a comprehensive analysis of the implementation of secure PUFs on FPGAs using manual placement and manual routing techniques guided by new performance metrics to overcome FPGAs restrictions with minimum hardware and area overhead. Then the impact of deep learning (DL) algorithms is studied as a promising modeling attack scheme against complex PUF architectures, which were reported immune to conventional (ML) techniques. Furthermore, it is shown that DL modeling attacks successfully overcome the restrictions imposed by previous research even with the lack of accurate mathematical models of these PUF architectures. Finally, this comprehensive analysis is completed by understanding why deep learning attacks are successful and how to build new PUF architectures and extra circuitry to thwart these types of attacks. This research is important for deploying cheap and efficient hardware security primitives in different fields, including IoT applications, embedded systems, automotive and military equipment. Additionally, it puts more focus on the development of strong intrinsic PUFs which are widely proposed and deployed in many security protocols used for authentication, key establishment, and Oblivious transfer protocols