On the complementarity between human translators and machine translation

Many translators are fearful of the impact of Machine Translation (MT) on their profession, broadly speaking, and on their livelihoods more specifically. We contend that their concern is misplaced, as human translators have a range of skills, many of which are currently – with no signs of any imminent breakthroughs on the horizon – impossible to replicate by automatic means. Nonetheless, in this paper, we will show that MT engines have considerable potential to improve translators’ productivity and ensure that the output translations are more consistent. Furthermore, we will investigate what machines are good at, where they break down, and why the human is likely to remain the most critical component in the translation pipeline for many years to com

On the Complementarity between Human Translators and Machine Translation

Many translators are fearful of the impact of Machine Translation (MT) on their profession, broadly speaking, and on their livelihoods more specifically. We contend that their concern is misplaced, as human translators have a range of skills, many of which are currently – with no signs of any imminent breakthroughs on the horizon – impossible to replicate by automatic means. Nonetheless, in this paper, we will show that MT engines have considerable potential to improve translators’ productivity and ensure that the output translations are more consistent. Furthermore, we will investigate what machines are good at, where they break down, and why the human is likely to remain the most critical component in the translation pipeline for many years to come

Gender bias in natural language processing

(English) Gender bias is a dangerous form of social bias impacting an essential group of people. The effect of gender bias is propagated to our data, causing the accuracy of the predictions in models to be different depending on gender. In the deep learning era, our models are highly impacted by the training data transferring the negative biases in the data to the models. Natural Language Processing models encounter this amplification of bias in the data. Our thesis is devoted to studying the issue of gender bias in NLP applications from different points of view. To understand and manage the effect of bias amplification, evaluation and mitigation approaches have to be explored. The scientific society has exerted significant efforts in these two directions to enable proposing solutions to the problem. Our thesis is devoted to these two main directions; proposing evaluation schemes, whether as datasets or mechanisms, besides suggesting mitigation techniques. For evaluation, we proposed techniques for evaluating bias in contextualized embeddings and multilingual translation models. Besides, we presented benchmarks for evaluating bias for speech translation and multilingual machine translation models. For mitigation direction, we proposed different approaches in machine translation models by adding contextual text, contextual embeddings, or relaxing the architecture’s constraints. Our evaluation studies concluded that gender bias is encoded strongly in contextual embeddings representing professions and stereotypical nouns. We also unveiled that algorithms amplify the bias and that the system’s architecture impacts the behavior. For the evaluation purposes, we contributed to creating several benchmarks for the evaluation purpose; we introduced a benchmark that evaluates gender bias in speech translation systems. This research suggests that the current state of speech translation systems does not enable us to evaluate gender bias accurately because of the low quality of speech translation systems. Additionally, we proposed a toolkit for building multilingual balanced datasets for training and evaluating NMT models. These datasets are balanced within the gender occupation-wise. We found out that high-resource languages usually tend to predict more precise male translations. Our mitigation studies in NMT suggest that the nature of datasets and languages needs to be considered to apply the right approach. Mitigating bias can rely on adding contextual information. However, in other cases, we need to rethink the model and relax some influencing conditions to the bias that do not affect the general performance but reduce the effect of bias amplification.(Español) El prejuicio de género es una forma peligrosa de sesgo social que afecta a un grupo esencial de personas. El efecto del prejuicio de género se propaga a nuestros datos, lo que hace quela precisión de las predicciones en los modelos sea diferente según el género. En la era del aprendizaje profundo, nuestros modelos se ven afectados por los datos de entrenamiento que transfieren los prejuicios de los datos a los modelos. Los modelos de procesamiento del lenguaje natural pueden además amplificar este sesgo en los datos. Para comprender el efecto de la amplificación del prejuicio de género, se deben explorar enfoques de evaluación y mitigación. La sociedad científica ha visto la importancía de estas dos direcciones para posibilitar la propuesta de soluciones al problema. Nuestra tesis está dedicada a estas dos direcciones principales; proponiendo esquemas de evaluación, ya sea como conjuntos de datos y mecanismos de evaluación, además de sugerir técnicas de mitigación. Para la evaluación, propusimos técnicas para evaluar el prejuicio en representaciones vectoriales contextualizadas y modelos de traducción multilingüe. Además, presentamos puntos de referencia para evaluar el prejuicio de la traducción de voz y los modelos de traducción automática multilingüe. Para la dirección de mitigación, propusimos diferentes enfoques en los modelos de traducción automática agregando texto contextual, incrustaciones contextuales o relajando las restricciones de la arquitectura. Nuestros estudios de evaluación concluyeron que el prejuicio de género está fuertemente codificado en representaciones vectoriales contextuales que representan profesiones y sustantivos estereotipados. También revelamos que los algoritmos amplifican el sesgo y que la arquitectura del sistema afecta el comportamiento. Para efectos de evaluación, contribuimos a la creación de varios datos de referencia para fines de evaluación; presentamos un conjunto de datos que evalúa el sesgo de género en los sistemas de traducción de voz. Esta investigación sugiere que el estado actual de los sistemas de traducción del habla no nos permite evaluar con precisión el sesgo de género debido a la baja calidad de los sistemas de traducción del habla. Además, propusimos un conjunto de herramientas para construir conjuntos de datos equilibrados multilingües para entrenar y evaluar modelos NMT. Estos conjuntos de datos están equilibrados dentro de la ocupación de género. Descubrimos que los idiomas con muchos recursos generalmente tienden a predecir traducciones masculinas más precisas. Nuestros estudios de mitigación en NMT sugieren que se debe considerar la naturaleza de los conjuntos de datos y los idiomas para aplicar el enfoque correcto. La mitigación del sesgo puede basarse en agregar información contextual. Sin embargo, en otros casos, necesitamos repensar el modelo y relajar algunas condiciones que influyen en el sesgo que no afectan el rendimiento general pero reducen el efecto de la amplificación del sesgo.Postprint (published version

Modeling contextual information in neural machine translation

Machine translation has provided impressive translation quality for many language pairs. The improvements over the past few years are largely due to the introduction of neural networks to the field, resulting in the modern sequence-to-sequence neural machine translation models. NMT is at the core of many largescale industrial tools for automatic translation such as Google Translate, Microsoft Translator, Amazon Translate and many others. Current NMT models work on the sentence-level, meaning they are used to translate individual sentences. However, for most practical use-cases, a user is interested in translating a document. In these cases, an MT tool splits a document into individual sentences and translates them independently. As a result, any dependencies between the sentences are ignored. This is likely to result in an incoherent document translation, mainly because of inconsistent translation of ambiguous source words or wrong translation of anaphoric pronouns. For example, it is undesirable to translate “bank” as a “financial bank” in one sentence and then later as a “river bank”. Furthermore, the translation of, e.g., the English third person pronoun “it” into German depends on the grammatical gender of the English antecedent’s German translation. NMT has shown that it has impressive modeling capabilities, but is nevertheless unable to model discourse-level phenomena as it needs access to contextual information. In this work, we study discourse-level phenomena in context-aware NMT. To facilitate the particular studies of interest, we propose several models capable of incorporating contextual information into standard sentence-level NMT models. We direct our focus on several discourse phenomena, namely, coreference (anaphora) resolution, coherence and cohesion. We discuss these phenomena in terms of how well can they be modeled by context-aware NMT, how can we improve upon current state-of-the-art as well as the optimal granularity at which these phenomena should be modeled. We further investigate domain as a factor in context-aware NMT. Finally, we investigate existing challenge sets for anaphora resolution evaluation and provide a robust alternative. We make the following contributions: i) We study the importance of coreference (anaphora) resolution and coherence for context-aware NMT by making use of oracle information specific to these phenomena. ii) We propose a method for improving performance on anaphora resolution based on curriculum learning which is inspired by the way humans organize learning. iii) We investigate the use of contextual information for better handling of domain information, in particular in the case of modeling multiple domains at once and when applied to zero-resource domains. iv) We present several context-aware models to enable us to examine the specific phenomena of interest we already mentioned. v) We study the optimal way of modeling local and global context and present a model theoretically capable of using very large document context. vi) We study the robustness of challenge sets for evaluation of anaphora resolution in MT by means of adversarial attacks and provide a template test set that robustly evaluates specific steps of an idealized coreference resolution pipeline for MT

HMM word graph based keyword spotting in handwritten document images

[EN] Line-level keyword spotting (KWS) is presented on the basis of frame-level word posterior probabilities. These posteriors are obtained using word graphs derived from the recogni- tion process of a full-fledged handwritten text recognizer based on hidden Markov models and N-gram language models. This approach has several advantages. First, since it uses a holistic, segmentation-free technology, it does not require any kind of word or charac- ter segmentation. Second, the use of language models allows the context of each spotted word to be taken into account, thereby considerably increasing KWS accuracy. And third, the proposed KWS scores are based on true posterior probabilities, taking into account all (or most) possible word segmentations of the input image. These scores are properly bounded and normalized. This mathematically clean formulation lends itself to smooth, threshold-based keyword queries which, in turn, permit comfortable trade-offs between search precision and recall. Experiments are carried out on several historic collections of handwritten text images, as well as a well-known data set of modern English handwrit- ten text. According to the empirical results, the proposed approach achieves KWS results comparable to those obtained with the recently-introduced "BLSTM neural networks KWS" approach and clearly outperform the popular, state-of-the-art "Filler HMM" KWS method. Overall, the results clearly support all the above-claimed advantages of the proposed ap- proach.This work has been partially supported by the Generalitat Valenciana under the Prometeo/2009/014 project grant ALMA-MATER, and through the EU projects: HIMANIS (JPICH programme, Spanish grant Ref. PCIN-2015-068) and READ (Horizon 2020 programme, grant Ref. 674943).Toselli, AH.; Vidal, E.; Romero, V.; Frinken, V. (2016). HMM word graph based keyword spotting in handwritten document images. Information Sciences. 370:497-518. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ins.2016.07.063S49751837

Survey of the State of the Art in Natural Language Generation: Core tasks, applications and evaluation

This paper surveys the current state of the art in Natural Language Generation (NLG), defined as the task of generating text or speech from non-linguistic input. A survey of NLG is timely in view of the changes that the field has undergone over the past decade or so, especially in relation to new (usually data-driven) methods, as well as new applications of NLG technology. This survey therefore aims to (a) give an up-to-date synthesis of research on the core tasks in NLG and the architectures adopted in which such tasks are organised; (b) highlight a number of relatively recent research topics that have arisen partly as a result of growing synergies between NLG and other areas of artificial intelligence; (c) draw attention to the challenges in NLG evaluation, relating them to similar challenges faced in other areas of Natural Language Processing, with an emphasis on different evaluation methods and the relationships between them.Comment: Published in Journal of AI Research (JAIR), volume 61, pp 75-170. 118 pages, 8 figures, 1 tabl

Learning Morphological Normalization for Translation from Morphologically Rich Languages

Learning Morphological Normalization for Translation from Morphologically Rich Languages When translating from a morphologically rich language into English, source side word forms encode grammatical information that can be considered as redundant with respect to English, leading to data sparsity issues. A well-known way to mitigate this problem is to remove irrelevant information from the source through normalization. This pre-processing is usually performed in a deterministic fashion, using hand-crafted rules. This normalization is, in essence, suboptimal and needs to be adapted for each new language pair. We introduce here a simple way to automatically search for an optimal normalization of the source morphology with respect to the target-side language and show that it can improve machine translation.Lorsqu'ils sont traduits depuis une langue à morphologie riche vers l'anglais, les mots-formes sources contiennent des marques d'informations grammaticales pouvant être jugées redondantes par rapport à l'anglais, causant une variabilité formelle qui nuit à l'estimation des modèles probabilistes. Un moyen bien documenté pour atténuer ce problème consiste à supprimer l'information non pertinente de la source en la normalisant. Ce pré-traitement est généralement effectué de manière déterministe, à l'aide de règles produites manuellement. Une telle normalisationest, par essence, sous-optimale et doit être adaptée pour chaque paire de langues. Nous présentons, dans cet article, une méthode simple pour rechercher automatiquement une normalisation optimale de la morphologie source par rapport à la langue cible et montrons que celle-ci peut améliorer la traduction automatique