6,078 research outputs found
Topologies for intermediate logics
We investigate the problem of characterizing the classes of Grothendieck
toposes whose internal logic satisfies a given assertion in the theory of
Heyting algebras, and introduce natural analogues of the double negation and De
Morgan topologies on an elementary topos for a wide class of intermediate
logics.Comment: 21 page
Propositional logic with short-circuit evaluation: a non-commutative and a commutative variant
Short-circuit evaluation denotes the semantics of propositional connectives
in which the second argument is evaluated only if the first argument does not
suffice to determine the value of the expression. Short-circuit evaluation is
widely used in programming, with sequential conjunction and disjunction as
primitive connectives.
We study the question which logical laws axiomatize short-circuit evaluation
under the following assumptions: compound statements are evaluated from left to
right, each atom (propositional variable) evaluates to either true or false,
and atomic evaluations can cause a side effect. The answer to this question
depends on the kind of atomic side effects that can occur and leads to
different "short-circuit logics". The basic case is FSCL (free short-circuit
logic), which characterizes the setting in which each atomic evaluation can
cause a side effect. We recall some main results and then relate FSCL to MSCL
(memorizing short-circuit logic), where in the evaluation of a compound
statement, the first evaluation result of each atom is memorized. MSCL can be
seen as a sequential variant of propositional logic: atomic evaluations cannot
cause a side effect and the sequential connectives are not commutative. Then we
relate MSCL to SSCL (static short-circuit logic), the variant of propositional
logic that prescribes short-circuit evaluation with commutative sequential
connectives.
We present evaluation trees as an intuitive semantics for short-circuit
evaluation, and simple equational axiomatizations for the short-circuit logics
mentioned that use negation and the sequential connectives only.Comment: 34 pages, 6 tables. Considerable parts of the text below stem from
arXiv:1206.1936, arXiv:1010.3674, and arXiv:1707.05718. Together with
arXiv:1707.05718, this paper subsumes most of arXiv:1010.367
A Direct Version of Veldman's Proof of Open Induction on Cantor Space via Delimited Control Operators
First, we reconstruct Wim Veldman's result that Open Induction on Cantor
space can be derived from Double-negation Shift and Markov's Principle. In
doing this, we notice that one has to use a countable choice axiom in the proof
and that Markov's Principle is replaceable by slightly strengthening the
Double-negation Shift schema. We show that this strengthened version of
Double-negation Shift can nonetheless be derived in a constructive intermediate
logic based on delimited control operators, extended with axioms for
higher-type Heyting Arithmetic. We formalize the argument and thus obtain a
proof term that directly derives Open Induction on Cantor space by the shift
and reset delimited control operators of Danvy and Filinski
Classical Mathematics for a Constructive World
Interactive theorem provers based on dependent type theory have the
flexibility to support both constructive and classical reasoning. Constructive
reasoning is supported natively by dependent type theory and classical
reasoning is typically supported by adding additional non-constructive axioms.
However, there is another perspective that views constructive logic as an
extension of classical logic. This paper will illustrate how classical
reasoning can be supported in a practical manner inside dependent type theory
without additional axioms. We will see several examples of how classical
results can be applied to constructive mathematics. Finally, we will see how to
extend this perspective from logic to mathematics by representing classical
function spaces using a weak value monad.Comment: v2: Final copy for publicatio
The Fan Theorem, its strong negation, and the determinacy of games
IIn the context of a weak formal theory called Basic Intuitionistic
Mathematics , we study Brouwer's Fan Theorem and a strong
negation of the Fan Theorem, Kleene's Alternative (to the Fan Theorem). We
prove that the Fan Theorem is equivalent to contrapositions of a number of
intuitionistically accepted axioms of countable choice and that Kleene's
Alternative is equivalent to strong negations of these statements. We also
discuss finite and infinite games and introduce a constructively useful notion
of determinacy. We prove that the Fan Theorem is equivalent to the
Intuitionistic Determinacy Theorem, saying that every subset of Cantor space
is, in our constructively meaningful sense, determinate, and show that Kleene's
Alternative is equivalent to a strong negation of a special case of this
theorem. We then consider a uniform intermediate value theorem and a
compactness theorem for classical propositional logic, and prove that the Fan
Theorem is equivalent to each of these theorems and that Kleene's Alternative
is equivalent to strong negations of them. We end with a note on a possibly
important statement, provable from principles accepted by Brouwer, that one
might call a Strong Fan Theorem.Comment: arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:1106.273
Intuitionism and the Modal Logic of Vagueness
Intuitionistic logic provides an elegant solution to the Sorites Paradox. Its acceptance has been hampered by two factors. First, the lack of an accepted semantics for languages containing vague terms has led even philosophers sympathetic to intuitionism to complain that no explanation has been given of why intuitionistic logic is the correct logic for such languages. Second, switching from classical to intuitionistic logic, while it may help with the Sorites, does not appear to offer any advantages when dealing with the so-called paradoxes of higher-order vagueness. We offer a proposal that makes strides on both issues. We argue that the intuitionist’s characteristic rejection of any third alethic value alongside true and false is best elaborated by taking the normal modal system S4M to be the sentential logic of the operator ‘it is clearly the case that’. S4M opens the way to an account of higher-order vagueness which avoids the paradoxes that have been thought to infect the notion. S4M is one of the modal counterparts of the intuitionistic sentential calculus and we use this fact to explain why IPC is the correct sentential logic to use when reasoning with vague statements. We also show that our key results go through in an intuitionistic version of S4M. Finally, we deploy our analysis to reply to Timothy Williamson’s objections to intuitionistic treatments of vagueness
Adding Logical Operators to Tree Pattern Queries on Graph-Structured Data
As data are increasingly modeled as graphs for expressing complex
relationships, the tree pattern query on graph-structured data becomes an
important type of queries in real-world applications. Most practical query
languages, such as XQuery and SPARQL, support logical expressions using
logical-AND/OR/NOT operators to define structural constraints of tree patterns.
In this paper, (1) we propose generalized tree pattern queries (GTPQs) over
graph-structured data, which fully support propositional logic of structural
constraints. (2) We make a thorough study of fundamental problems including
satisfiability, containment and minimization, and analyze the computational
complexity and the decision procedures of these problems. (3) We propose a
compact graph representation of intermediate results and a pruning approach to
reduce the size of intermediate results and the number of join operations --
two factors that often impair the efficiency of traditional algorithms for
evaluating tree pattern queries. (4) We present an efficient algorithm for
evaluating GTPQs using 3-hop as the underlying reachability index. (5)
Experiments on both real-life and synthetic data sets demonstrate the
effectiveness and efficiency of our algorithm, from several times to orders of
magnitude faster than state-of-the-art algorithms in terms of evaluation time,
even for traditional tree pattern queries with only conjunctive operations.Comment: 16 page
- …