Hardness of submodular cost allocation : lattice matching and a simplex coloring conjecture

We consider the Minimum Submodular Cost Allocation (MSCA) problem. In this problem, we are given k submodular cost functions f1, ... , fk: 2V -> R+ and the goal is to partition V into k sets A1, ..., Ak so as to minimize the total cost sumi = 1,k fi(Ai). We show that MSCA is inapproximable within any multiplicative factor even in very restricted settings; prior to our work, only Set Cover hardness was known. In light of this negative result, we turn our attention to special cases of the problem. We consider the setting in which each function fi satisfies fi = gi + h, where each gi is monotone submodular and h is (possibly non-monotone) submodular. We give an O(k log |V|) approximation for this problem. We provide some evidence that a factor of k may be necessary, even in the special case of HyperLabel. In particular, we formulate a simplex-coloring conjecture that implies a Unique-Games-hardness of (k - 1 - epsilon) for k-uniform HyperLabel and label set [k]. We provide a proof of the simplex-coloring conjecture for k=3

Spectral Detection on Sparse Hypergraphs

We consider the problem of the assignment of nodes into communities from a set of hyperedges, where every hyperedge is a noisy observation of the community assignment of the adjacent nodes. We focus in particular on the sparse regime where the number of edges is of the same order as the number of vertices. We propose a spectral method based on a generalization of the non-backtracking Hashimoto matrix into hypergraphs. We analyze its performance on a planted generative model and compare it with other spectral methods and with Bayesian belief propagation (which was conjectured to be asymptotically optimal for this model). We conclude that the proposed spectral method detects communities whenever belief propagation does, while having the important advantages to be simpler, entirely nonparametric, and to be able to learn the rule according to which the hyperedges were generated without prior information.Comment: 8 pages, 5 figure

Rainbow Coloring Hardness via Low Sensitivity Polymorphisms

A k-uniform hypergraph is said to be r-rainbow colorable if there is an r-coloring of its vertices such that every hyperedge intersects all r color classes. Given as input such a hypergraph, finding a r-rainbow coloring of it is NP-hard for all k >= 3 and r >= 2. Therefore, one settles for finding a rainbow coloring with fewer colors (which is an easier task). When r=k (the maximum possible value), i.e., the hypergraph is k-partite, one can efficiently 2-rainbow color the hypergraph, i.e., 2-color its vertices so that there are no monochromatic edges. In this work we consider the next smaller value of r=k-1, and prove that in this case it is NP-hard to rainbow color the hypergraph with q := ceil[(k-2)/2] colors. In particular, for k <=6, it is NP-hard to 2-color (k-1)-rainbow colorable k-uniform hypergraphs. Our proof follows the algebraic approach to promise constraint satisfaction problems. It proceeds by characterizing the polymorphisms associated with the approximate rainbow coloring problem, which are rainbow colorings of some product hypergraphs on vertex set [r]^n. We prove that any such polymorphism f: [r]^n -> [q] must be C-fixing, i.e., there is a small subset S of C coordinates and a setting a in [q]^S such that fixing x_{|S} = a determines the value of f(x). The key step in our proof is bounding the sensitivity of certain rainbow colorings, thereby arguing that they must be juntas. Armed with the C-fixing characterization, our NP-hardness is obtained via a reduction from smooth Label Cover

A New Multilayered PCP and the Hardness of Hypergraph Vertex Cover

Given a $k$-uniform hyper-graph, the E$k$-Vertex-Cover problem is to find the smallest subset of vertices that intersects every hyper-edge. We present a new multilayered PCP construction that extends the Raz verifier. This enables us to prove that E$k$-Vertex-Cover is NP-hard to approximate within factor $(k-1-\epsilon)$ for any $k \geq 3$ and any $\epsilon>0$. The result is essentially tight as this problem can be easily approximated within factor $k$. Our construction makes use of the biased Long-Code and is analyzed using combinatorial properties of $s$-wise $t$-intersecting families of subsets

Independent Set, Induced Matching, and Pricing: Connections and Tight (Subexponential Time) Approximation Hardnesses

We present a series of almost settled inapproximability results for three fundamental problems. The first in our series is the subexponential-time inapproximability of the maximum independent set problem, a question studied in the area of parameterized complexity. The second is the hardness of approximating the maximum induced matching problem on bounded-degree bipartite graphs. The last in our series is the tight hardness of approximating the k-hypergraph pricing problem, a fundamental problem arising from the area of algorithmic game theory. In particular, assuming the Exponential Time Hypothesis, our two main results are: - For any r larger than some constant, any r-approximation algorithm for the maximum independent set problem must run in at least 2^{n^{1-\epsilon}/r^{1+\epsilon}} time. This nearly matches the upper bound of 2^{n/r} (Cygan et al., 2008). It also improves some hardness results in the domain of parameterized complexity (e.g., Escoffier et al., 2012 and Chitnis et al., 2013) - For any k larger than some constant, there is no polynomial time min (k^{1-\epsilon}, n^{1/2-\epsilon})-approximation algorithm for the k-hypergraph pricing problem, where n is the number of vertices in an input graph. This almost matches the upper bound of min (O(k), \tilde O(\sqrt{n})) (by Balcan and Blum, 2007 and an algorithm in this paper). We note an interesting fact that, in contrast to n^{1/2-\epsilon} hardness for polynomial-time algorithms, the k-hypergraph pricing problem admits n^{\delta} approximation for any \delta >0 in quasi-polynomial time. This puts this problem in a rare approximability class in which approximability thresholds can be improved significantly by allowing algorithms to run in quasi-polynomial time.Comment: The full version of FOCS 201

A class of index coding problems with rate 1/3

An index coding problem with $n$ messages has symmetric rate $R$ if all $n$ messages can be conveyed at rate $R$. In a recent work, a class of index coding problems for which symmetric rate $\frac{1}{3}$ is achievable was characterised using special properties of the side-information available at the receivers. In this paper, we show a larger class of index coding problems (which includes the previous class of problems) for which symmetric rate $\frac{1}{3}$ is achievable. In the process, we also obtain a stricter necessary condition for rate $\frac{1}{3}$ feasibility than what is known in literature.Comment: Shorter version submitted to ISIT 201

Approximate Hypergraph Coloring under Low-discrepancy and Related Promises

A hypergraph is said to be $\chi$-colorable if its vertices can be colored with $\chi$ colors so that no hyperedge is monochromatic. $2$-colorability is a fundamental property (called Property B) of hypergraphs and is extensively studied in combinatorics. Algorithmically, however, given a $2$-colorable $k$-uniform hypergraph, it is NP-hard to find a $2$-coloring miscoloring fewer than a fraction $2^{-k+1}$ of hyperedges (which is achieved by a random $2$-coloring), and the best algorithms to color the hypergraph properly require $\approx n^{1-1/k}$ colors, approaching the trivial bound of $n$ as $k$ increases. In this work, we study the complexity of approximate hypergraph coloring, for both the maximization (finding a $2$-coloring with fewest miscolored edges) and minimization (finding a proper coloring using fewest number of colors) versions, when the input hypergraph is promised to have the following stronger properties than $2$-colorability: (A) Low-discrepancy: If the hypergraph has discrepancy $\ell \ll \sqrt{k}$, we give an algorithm to color the it with $\approx n^{O(\ell^2/k)}$ colors. However, for the maximization version, we prove NP-hardness of finding a $2$-coloring miscoloring a smaller than $2^{-O(k)}$ (resp. $k^{-O(k)}$) fraction of the hyperedges when $\ell = O(\log k)$ (resp. $\ell=2$). Assuming the UGC, we improve the latter hardness factor to $2^{-O(k)}$ for almost discrepancy-$1$ hypergraphs. (B) Rainbow colorability: If the hypergraph has a $(k-\ell)$-coloring such that each hyperedge is polychromatic with all these colors, we give a $2$-coloring algorithm that miscolors at most $k^{-\Omega(k)}$ of the hyperedges when $\ell \ll \sqrt{k}$, and complement this with a matching UG hardness result showing that when $\ell =\sqrt{k}$, it is hard to even beat the $2^{-k+1}$ bound achieved by a random coloring.Comment: Approx 201