Reduction of Uncertainties for Damage Identification of Bridge Based on Fuzzy Nearness and Modal Data

To avoid the false results of deterministic identification methods induced by uncertainties, a fuzzy nearness-based method is proposed for the damage identification of bridge. An improved index based on ratios of modal shape components is used as identification measurements. The knowledge base for damage identification is established through corresponding relationship between fuzzified measurements and damage severities. The damage condition of test samples can be assessed based on approaching principle through fuzzy nearness with rules in knowledge base. A numerical analysis on a multigirder bridge considering uncertainty is presented to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method. The results indicate that the fuzzy nearness-based method can achieve an accurate identification with success rate up to 93.75%. Antinoise analysis and the ability for dealing with incomplete information reveal its robustness

Condition assessment of bridge structures using statistical analysis of wavelets

La surveillance à distance des structures a émergé comme une préoccupation importante pour les ingénieurs afin de maintenir la sécurité et la fiabilité des infrastructures civiles pendant leur durée de vie. Les techniques de surveillance structurale (SHM) sont de plus en plus populaires pour fournir un diagnostic de "l'état" des structures en raison de leur vieillissement, de la dégradation des matériaux ou de défauts survenus pendant leur construction. Les limites de l'inspection visuelle et des techniques non destructives, qui sont couramment utilisées pour détecter des défauts extrêmes sur les parties accessibles des structures, ont conduit à la découverte de nouvelles technologies qui évaluent d’un seul tenant l'état global d'une structure surveillée. Les techniques de surveillance globale ont été largement utilisées pour la reconnaissance d'endommagement dans les grandes infrastructures civiles, telles que les ponts, sur la base d'une analyse modale de la réponse dynamique structurale. Cependant, en raison des caractéristiques complexes des structures oeuvrant sous des conditions environnementales variables et des incertitudes statistiques dans les paramètres modaux, les techniques de diagnostic actuelles n'ont pas été concluantes pour conduire à une méthodologie robuste et directe pour détecter les incréments de dommage avant qu'ils n'atteignent un stade critique. C’est ainsi que des techniques statistiques de reconnaissance de formes sont incorporées aux méthodes de détection d'endommagement basées sur les vibrations pour fournir une meilleure estimation de la probabilité de détection des dommages dans des applications in situ, ce qui est habituellement difficile compte tenu du rapport bruit à signal élevé. Néanmoins, cette partie du SHM est encore à son stade initial de développement et, par conséquent, d'autres tentatives sont nécessaires pour parvenir à une méthodologie fiable de détection de l'endommagement. Une stratégie de détection de dommages basée sur des aspects statistiques a été proposée pour détecter et localiser de faibles niveaux incrémentiels d'endommagement dans une poutre expérimentale pour laquelle tant le niveau d'endommagement que les conditions de retenue sont réglables (par exemple ancastrée-ancastrée et rotulée-rotulée). Premièrement, des expériences ont été effectuées dans des conditions de laboratoire contrôlées pour détecter de faibles niveaux d'endommagement induits (par exemple une fissure correspondant à 4% de la hauteur d’une section rectangulaire équivalente) simulant des scénarios d'endommagement de stade précoce pour des cas réels. Différents niveaux d'endommagement ont été simulés à deux endroits distincts le long de la poutre. Pour chaque série d'endommagement incrémentiel, des mesures répétées (~ 50 à 100) ont été effectuées pour tenir compte de l'incertitude et de la variabilité du premier mode de vibration de la structure en raison d'erreurs expérimentales et du bruit. Une technique d'analyse par ondelette basée sur les modes a été appliquée pour détecter les changements anormaux survenant dans les modes propres causées par le dommage. La réduction du bruit ainsi que les caractéristiques des agrégats ont été obtenues en mettant en œuvre l'analyse des composantes principales (PCA) pour l'ensemble des coefficients d'ondelettes calculés à des nœuds (ou positions) régulièrement espacés le long du mode propre. En rejetant les composantes qui contribuent le moins à la variance globale, les scores PCA correspondant aux premières composantes principales se sont révélés très corrélés avec de faibles niveaux d'endommagement incrémentiel. Des méthodes classiques d'essai d'hypothèses ont été effectuées sur les changements des paramètres de localisation des scores pour conclure objectivement et statistiquement, à un niveau de signification donné, sur la présence du dommage. Lorsqu'un dommage statistiquement significatif a été détecté, un nouvel algorithme basé sur les probabilités a été développé pour déterminer l'emplacement le plus probable de l'endommagement le long de la structure. Deuxièmement, se basant sur l'approche probabiliste, une série de tests a été effectuée dans une chambre environnementale à température contrôlée pour étudier les contributions relatives des effets de l’endommagement et de la température sur les propriétés dynamiques de la poutre afin d’estimer un facteur de correction pour l'ajustement des scores extraits. Il s'est avéré que la température avait un effet réversible sur la distribution des scores et que cet effet était plus grand lorsque le niveau d'endommagement était plus élevé. Les résultats obtenus pour les scores ajustés indiquent que la correction des effets réversibles de la température peut améliorer la probabilité de détection et minimiser les fausses alarmes. Les résultats expérimentaux indiquent que la contribution combinée des algorithmes utilisés dans cette étude était très efficace pour détecter de faibles niveaux d'endommagement incrémentiel à plusieurs endroits le long de la poutre tout en minimisant les effets indésirables du bruit et de la température dans les résultats. Les résultats de cette recherche démontrent que l'approche proposée est prometteuse pour la surveillance des structures. Cependant, une quantité importante de travail de validation est attendue avant sa mise en œuvre sur des structures réelles. Mots-clés : Détection et localisation des dommages, Poutre, Mode propre, Ondelette, Analyse des composantes principales, Rapport de probabilité, TempératureRemote monitoring of structures has emerged as an important concern for engineers to maintain safety and reliability of civil infrastructure during its service life. Structural Health Monitoring (SHM) techniques are increasingly becoming popular to provide ideas for diagnosis of the "state" of potential defects in structures due to aging, deterioration and fault during construction. The limitations of visual inspection and non-destructive techniques, which were commonly used to detect extreme defects on only accessible portions of structures, led to the discovery of new technologies which assess the "global state" of a monitored structure at once. Global monitoring techniques have been used extensively for the recognition of damage in large civil infrastructure, such as bridges, based on modal analysis of structural dynamic response. However, because of complicated features of real-life structures under varying environmental conditions and statistical uncertainties in modal parameters, current diagnosis techniques have not been conclusive in ascertaining a robust and straightforward methodology to detect damage increments before it reaches its critical stage. Statistical pattern recognition techniques are incorporated with vibration-based damage detection methods to provide a better estimate for the probability of the detection of damage in field applications, which is usually challenging given the high noise to signal ratio. Nevertheless, this part of SHM is still in its initial stage of development and, hence, further attempts are required to achieve a reliable damage detection methodology. A statistical-based damage detection strategy was proposed to detect and localize low levels of incremental damage in an experimental beam in which the level of damage and beam restraint conditions are adjustable (e.g. fixed-fixed and pinned-pinned). First, experiments were performed in controlled laboratory conditions to detect small levels of induced-damage (e.g. 4% crack height for an equivalent rectangular section) simulated for early stage damage scenarios in real cases. Various levels of damage were simulated at two distinct locations along the beam. For each sate of incremental damage, repeat measurements (~ 50 to 100) were performed to account for uncertainty and variability in the first vibration mode of the structure due to experimental errors and noise. A modal-based wavelet analysis technique was applied to detect abnormal changes occurring in the mode shapes caused by damage. Noise reduction as well as aggregate characteristics were obtained by implementing the Principal Component Analysis (PCA) into the set of wavelet coefficients computed at regularly spaced nodes along the mode shape. By discarding components that contribute least to the overall variance, the PCA scores corresponding to the first few PCs were found to be highly correlated with low levels of incremental damage. Classical hypothesis testing methods were performed on changes on the location parameters of the scores to conclude damage objectively and statistically at a given significance level. When a statistically significant damage was detected, a novel Likelihood-based algorithm was developed to determine the most likely location of damage along the structure. Secondly, given the likelihood approach, a series of tests were carried out in a climate-controlled room to investigate the relative contributions of damage and temperature effects on the dynamic properties of the beam and to estimate a correction factor for the adjustment of scores extracted. It was found that the temperature had a reversible effect on the distribution of scores and that the effect was larger when the damage level was higher. The resulted obtained for the adjusted scores indicated that the correction for reversible effects of temperature can improve the probability of detection and minimize false alarms. The experimental results indicate that the combined contribution of the algorithms used in this study were very efficient to detect small-scale levels of incremental damage at multiple locations along the beam, while minimizing undesired effects of noise and temperature in the results. The results of this research demonstrate that the proposed approach may be used as a promising tool for SHM of actual structures. However, a significant amount of challenging work is expected for implementing it on real structures. Key-words: Damage Detection and Localization, Beam, Mode Shape, Wavelet, Principal Component Analysis, Likelihood Ratio, Temperatur

Dynamic-based damage identification using neural network ensembles and damage index method

This paper presents a vibration-based damage identification method that utilises a "damage fingerprint" of a structure in combination with Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and neural network techniques to identify defects. The Damage Index (DI) method is used to extract unique damage patterns from a damaged beam structure with the undamaged structure as baseline. PCA is applied to reduce the effect of measurement noise and optimise neural network training. PCA-compressed DI values are, then, used as inputs for a hierarchy of neural network ensembles to estimate locations and severities of various damage cases. The developed method is verified by a laboratory structure and numerical simulations in which measurement noise is taken into account with different levels of white Gaussian noise added. The damage identification results obtained from the neural network ensembles show that the presented method is capable of overcoming problems inherent in the conventional DI method. Issues associated with field testing conditions are successfully dealt with for numerical and the experimental simulations. Moreover, it is shown that the neural network ensemble produces results that are more accurate than any of the outcomes of the individual neural networks

Spectral-based damage identification technique on an earthen mock-up construction tested on a shaking table

Conservation of ancient built heritage plays a leading role for modern societies. Knowledge about ancient building methods, essentially based on the use of natural materials such as earth, stone and wood, is fundamental to plan interventions aimed at preserving the architectural heritage. Due to the growing research on sustainable technologies, the interest in structural systems built using natural materials has been rising more and more. Taking an earthen mock-up construction as model, the paper focuses on the dynamic behaviour of such a system tested on a shaking table. Detailed descriptions of the model, its mechanical features, the seismic test performed and the damage pattern obtained are first presented. Then, the dynamic identification of the structure during damage occurrence is performed through the decomposition of the power spectral density matrix. Damage evolution and localization are also analyzed by an index based on the complex eigenvectors estimated from the matrix. Finally, comparisons between experimental and analytical results are addressed

Frequency response function based structural damage detection using artificial neural networks

Damage detection in structures has become increasingly important in recent years. While a number of damage detection and localization methods have been proposed, few attempts have been made to explore the structure damage with frequency response functions (FRFs). This paper illustrates the damage identification and condition assessment of a beam structure using a new frequency response functions (FRFs) based damage index and Artificial Neural Networks (ANNs). In practice, usage of all available FRF data as an input to artificial neural networks makes the training and convergence impossible. Therefore one of the data reduction techniques Principal Component Analysis (PCA) is introduced in the algorithm. In the proposed procedure, a large set of FRFs are divided into sub-sets in order to find the damage indices for different frequency points of different damage scenarios. The basic idea of this method is to establish features of damaged structure using FRFs from different measurement points of different sub-sets of intact structure. Then using these features, damage indices of different damage cases of the structure are identified after reconstructing of available FRF data using PCA. The obtained damage indices corresponding to different damage locations and severities are introduced as input variable to developed artificial neural networks. Finally, the effectiveness of the proposed method is illustrated and validated by using the finite element model of a beam structure. The illustrated results show that the PCA based damage index is suitable and effective for structural damage detection and condition assessment of building structures

Structural identification through continuous monitoring: data cleansing using temperature variations

The aim of structural performance monitoring is to infer the state of a structure from measurements and thereby support decisions related to structural management. Complex structures may be equipped with hundreds of sensors that measure quantities such as temperature, acceleration and strain. However, meaningful interpretation of data collected from continuous monitoring remains a challenge. MPCA (Moving principal component analysis) is a model-free data interpretation method which compares characteristics of a moving window of measurements against those derived from a reference period. This paper explores a data cleansing approach to improve the performance of MPCA. The approach uses a smoothing procedure or a low-pass filter (moving average) to exclude the effects of seasonal temperature variations. Consequently MPCA can use a smaller moving window and therefore detect anomalies more rapidly. Measurements from a numerical model and a prestressed beam are used to illustrate the approach. Results show that removal of seasonal temperature effects can improve the performance of MPCA. However, improvement may not be significant and there remains a trade off when choosing the window size. A small window increases the risk of false-positives while a large window increases the time to detect damage

Damage identification and seismic vulnerability assessment of a historic masonry chimney

The present paper deals with the dynamic characterisation of a historical masonry chimney aimed at identifying the structural damage and assessing its seismic performance. The structure was severely damaged by a lightning accident and in-depth repair works were executed to re-instate its sound configuration. The case study is fully detailed, including the aspects of survey, inspection, diagnosis, and evolution of the dynamic properties of the system throughout the structural intervention. Considering the explicit dependence of the power spectral densities of measured nodal processes on their frequency content, a spectrum-driven algorithm is used to detect and locate the damage. The paper shows that the eigenparameters obtained from the decomposition of the response power spectrum matrix are sensitive to system's changes caused by evolutionary damage scenarios, thereby resulting excellent indicators for assessing both the presence and position of structural vulnerabilities. The results are compared with the ones from other modal-based damage identification methods and the strengths/limitations of the tools currently available in literature are extensively discussed. Finally, based on the crack pattern surveyed before the repair works, the weakest links of the chimney are identified and the most meaningful collapse mechanisms are analysed to verify the seismic capacity of the structure. According to the results of the kinematic analysis, the chimney does withstand the maximum site peak ground acceleration.info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersio

Fukunaga-Koontz feature transformation for statistical structural damage detection and hierarchical neuro-fuzzy damage localisation

Piotr Omenzetter and Simon Hoell’s work on this paper within the Lloyd’s Register Foundation Centre for Safety and Reliability Engineering at the University of Aberdeen was supported by Lloyd’s Register Foundation. The Foundation helps to protect life and property by supporting engineering-related education, public engagement and the application of research.Peer reviewedPostprin

Hybrid structural health monitoring using data-driven modal analysis and model-based Bayesian inference.

Civil infrastructures that are valuable assets for the public and owners must be adequately and periodically maintained to guarantee safety, continuous service, and avoid economic losses. Vibration-based structural health monitoring (VBSHM) has been a significant tool to assess the structural performance of civil infrastructures over the last decades. Challenges in VBSHM exist in two aspects: operational modal analysis (OMA) and Finite element model updating (FEMU). The former aims to extract natural frequency, damping ratio, and mode shapes using vibrational data under normal operation; the latter focuses on minimizing the discrepancies between measurements and model prediction. The main impediments to real-world application of VBSHM include 1) uncertainties are inevitably involved due to measurement noise and modeling error; 2) computational burden in analyzing massive data and high-fidelity model; 3) updating structural coupled parameters, e.g., mass and stiffness. Bayesian model updating approach (BMUA) is an advanced FEMU technique to update structural parameters using modal data and account for underlying uncertainties. However, traditional BMUA generally assumes mass is precisely known and only updating stiffness to circumvent the coupling effect of mass and stiffness. Simultaneously updating mass and stiffness is necessary to fully understand the structural integrity, especially when the mass has a relatively large variation. To tackle these challenges, this dissertation proposed a hybrid framework using data-driven and model-based approaches in two sequential phases: automated OMA and a BMUA with added mass/stiffness. Automated stochastic subspace identification (SSI) and Bayesian modal identification are firstly developed to acquire modal properties. Following by a novel BMUA, new eigen-equations based on two sets of modal data from the original and modified system with added mass or stiffness are derived to address the coupling effect of structural parameters, e.g., mass and stiffness. To avoid multi-dimensional integrals, an asymptotic optimization method and Differential Evolutionary Adaptive Metropolis (DREAM) sampling algorithm are employed for Bayesian inference. To alleviate computational burden, variance-based global sensitivity analysis to reduce model dimensionality and Kriging model to substitute time-consuming FEM are integrated into BMUA. The proposed VBSHM are verified and illustrated using numerical, laboratory and field test data, achieving following goals: 1) properly treating parameter uncertainties; 2) substantially reducing the computational cost; 3) simultaneously updating structural parameters with addressing the coupling effect; 4) performing the probabilistic damage identification at an accurate level