Better subset regression

To find efficient screening methods for high dimensional linear regression models, this paper studies the relationship between model fitting and screening performance. Under a sparsity assumption, we show that a subset that includes the true submodel always yields smaller residual sum of squares (i.e., has better model fitting) than all that do not in a general asymptotic setting. This indicates that, for screening important variables, we could follow a "better fitting, better screening" rule, i.e., pick a "better" subset that has better model fitting. To seek such a better subset, we consider the optimization problem associated with best subset regression. An EM algorithm, called orthogonalizing subset screening, and its accelerating version are proposed for searching for the best subset. Although the two algorithms cannot guarantee that a subset they yield is the best, their monotonicity property makes the subset have better model fitting than initial subsets generated by popular screening methods, and thus the subset can have better screening performance asymptotically. Simulation results show that our methods are very competitive in high dimensional variable screening even for finite sample sizes.Comment: 24 pages, 1 figur

Exhuming nonnegative garrote from oblivion using suitable initial estimates- illustration in low and high-dimensional real data

The nonnegative garrote (NNG) is among the first approaches that combine variable selection and shrinkage of regression estimates. When more than the derivation of a predictor is of interest, NNG has some conceptual advantages over the popular lasso. Nevertheless, NNG has received little attention. The original NNG relies on least-squares (OLS) estimates, which are highly variable in data with a high degree of multicollinearity (HDM) and do not exist in high-dimensional data (HDD). This might be the reason that NNG is not used in such data. Alternative initial estimates have been proposed but hardly used in practice. Analyzing three structurally different data sets, we demonstrated that NNG can also be applied in HDM and HDD and compared its performance with the lasso, adaptive lasso, relaxed lasso, and best subset selection in terms of variables selected, regression estimates, and prediction. Replacing OLS by ridge initial estimates in HDM and lasso initial estimates in HDD helped NNG select simpler models than competing approaches without much increase in prediction errors. Simpler models are easier to interpret, an important issue for descriptive modelling. Based on the limited experience from three datasets, we assume that the NNG can be a suitable alternative to the lasso and its extensions. Neutral comparison simulation studies are needed to better understand the properties of variable selection methods, compare them and derive guidance for practice

Extreme Value Analysis of Empirical Frame Coefficients and Implications for Denoising by Soft-Thresholding

Denoising by frame thresholding is one of the most basic and efficient methods for recovering a discrete signal or image from data that are corrupted by additive Gaussian white noise. The basic idea is to select a frame of analyzing elements that separates the data in few large coefficients due to the signal and many small coefficients mainly due to the noise \epsilon_n. Removing all data coefficients being in magnitude below a certain threshold yields a reconstruction of the original signal. In order to properly balance the amount of noise to be removed and the relevant signal features to be kept, a precise understanding of the statistical properties of thresholding is important. For that purpose we derive the asymptotic distribution of max_{\omega \in \Omega_n} || for a wide class of redundant frames (\phi_\omega^n: \omega \in \Omega_n}. Based on our theoretical results we give a rationale for universal extreme value thresholding techniques yielding asymptotically sharp confidence regions and smoothness estimates corresponding to prescribed significance levels. The results cover many frames used in imaging and signal recovery applications, such as redundant wavelet systems, curvelet frames, or unions of bases. We show that `generically' a standard Gumbel law results as it is known from the case of orthonormal wavelet bases. However, for specific highly redundant frames other limiting laws may occur. We indeed verify that the translation invariant wavelet transform shows a different asymptotic behaviour.Comment: [Content: 39 pages, 4 figures] Note that in this version 4 we have slightely changed the title of the paper and we have rewritten parts of the introduction. Except for corrected typos the other parts of the paper are the same as the original versions

Convex and non-convex regularization methods for spatial point processes intensity estimation

This paper deals with feature selection procedures for spatial point processes intensity estimation. We consider regularized versions of estimating equations based on Campbell theorem derived from two classical functions: Poisson likelihood and logistic regression likelihood. We provide general conditions on the spatial point processes and on penalty functions which ensure consistency, sparsity and asymptotic normality. We discuss the numerical implementation and assess finite sample properties in a simulation study. Finally, an application to tropical forestry datasets illustrates the use of the proposed methods

Feature selection when there are many influential features

Recent discussion of the success of feature selection methods has argued that focusing on a relatively small number of features has been counterproductive. Instead, it is suggested, the number of significant features can be in the thousands or tens of thousands, rather than (as is commonly supposed at present) approximately in the range from five to fifty. This change, in orders of magnitude, in the number of influential features, necessitates alterations to the way in which we choose features and to the manner in which the success of feature selection is assessed. In this paper, we suggest a general approach that is suited to cases where the number of relevant features is very large, and we consider particular versions of the approach in detail. We propose ways of measuring performance, and we study both theoretical and numerical properties of the proposed methodology.Comment: Published in at http://dx.doi.org/10.3150/13-BEJ536 the Bernoulli (http://isi.cbs.nl/bernoulli/) by the International Statistical Institute/Bernoulli Society (http://isi.cbs.nl/BS/bshome.htm