MR connectomics: a conceptual framework for studying the developing brain

The combination of advanced neuroimaging techniques and major developments in complex network science, have given birth to a new framework for studying the brain: “connectomics.” This framework provides the ability to describe and study the brain as a dynamic network and to explore how the coordination and integration of information processing may occur. In recent years this framework has been used to investigate the developing brain and has shed light on many dynamic changes occurring from infancy through adulthood. The aim of this article is to review this work and to discuss what we have learned from it. We will also use this body of work to highlight key technical aspects that are necessary in general for successful connectome analysis using today's advanced neuroimaging techniques. We look to identify current limitations of such approaches, what can be improved, and how these points generalize to other topics in connectome research

Une nouvelle approche pour l’identification des états dynamiques de la parcellisation fonctionnelle cérébrale individuelle

Les parcellations cérébrales sont appliquées en neuroimagerie pour aider les chercheurs à ré- duire la haute dimensionnalité des données d’IRM fonctionnelle. L’objectif principal est une meilleure compréhension de l’organisation fonctionnelle du cerveau tant chez les sujets sains que chez les sujets souffrant de troubles neurologiques, dont la maladie d’Alzheimer. Malgré la vague d’approches de parcellations précédentes, les mesures de performance doivent en- core être améliorées pour générer des parcellations fiables, même avec de longues acquisitions. Autrement dit, une reproductibilité plus élevée qui permet aux chercheurs de reproduire des parcellations et de comparer leurs études. Il est également important de minimiser la perte d’informations entre les données compressées et les données brutes pour représenter avec précision l’organisation d’un cerveau individuel. Dans cette thèse, j’ai développé une nou- velle approche pour parcellaire le cerveau en reconfigurations spatiales distinctes appelées «états dynamiques de parcellations». J’ai utilisé une méthode d’agrégation de cluster simple DYPAC1.0 de parcelles basées sur des semences sur plusieurs fenêtres de temps. J’ai émis l’hypothèse que cette nouvelle façon de formaliser le problème de parcellisation améliorera les mesures de performance par rapport aux parcellations statiques. Le premier chapitre de ce document est une introduction générale au contexte des réseaux à grande échelle du cerveau humain. Je montre également l’importance des parcellations pour une meilleure compréhension du cerveau humain à l’aide de connectomes fonctionnels afin de prédire les schémas de progression de la maladie. Ensuite, j’explique pourquoi le problème de parcelli- sation cérébrale est difficile et les différentes questions de recherche ouvertes associées à ce domaine. Mes contributions à la recherche sont subdivisées en deux articles. Les deuxième et troisième chapitres sont consacrés au premier article principal et à son supplément publié dans Network Neuroscience Journal. Le quatrième chapitre représente le deuxième document en préparation. Le cinquième chapitre conclut mes contributions et ses implications dans le domaine de la neuroimagerie, ainsi que des orientations de recherche ouvertes. En un mot, la principale conclusion de ce travail est l’existence de reconfigurations spatiales distinctes dans tout le cerveau avec des scores de reproductibilité presque parfaits sur les données de test-retest (jusqu’à 0,9 coefficient de corrélation de Pearson). Un algorithme d’agrégation de cluster simple et évolutif appelé DYPAC 1.0 est expliqué pour identifier ces reconfigu- rations ou «états dynamiques de parcellations» pour des sous-réseaux de départ spécifiques (deuxième chapitre). L’analyse de ces états a montré l’existence d’un répertoire plus riche «d’états dynamiques» dans le cas des cortex hétéromodaux (ex: cortex cingulaire posté- rieur et cortex cingulaire antérieur dorsal) par rapport aux cortex unimodaux (ex: cortex visuel). En outre, les résultats de l’analyse de reproductibilité ont montré que DYPAC 1.0 a de meilleurs résultats de reproductibilité (en termes de corrélation de Pearson) par rapport aux parcelles statiques (deuxième chapitre). Plusieurs analyses démontrent que DYPAC 1.0 est robuste au choix de ses paramètres (troisième chapitre). Ces résultats et l’évolutivité de DYPAC 1.0 ont motivé une analyse complète du niveau cérébral. Je présente DYPAC 2.0 comme une approche au niveau cérébral complet pour fragmenter le cerveau en «états dynamiques de parcellations». Des reconfigurations spatiales distinctes et se chevauchant ou «états dynamiques» sont identifiées pour différentes régions du cerveau (quatrième chapitre). Ces états ont des scores de compression prometteurs qui montrent une faible perte d’infor- mations entre les cartes de stabilité d’état réduit et les données d’origine dans les cortex cérébraux, c’est-à-dire jusqu’à seulement 20% de perte de la variance expliquée. Cette thèse présente ainsi de nouvelles contributions dans le domaine de la parcellisation fonctionnelle qui pourraient avoir un impact sur la manière dont les chercheurs modélisent les interactions riches et dynamiques entre les réseaux cérébraux dans la santé et la maladie.Brain parcellations are applied in neuroimaging to help researchers reduce the high dimen- sionality of the functional MRI data. The main objective is a better understanding of the brain functional organization in both healthy subjects and subjects having neurological dis- orders, including Alzheimer disease. Despite the flurry of previous parcellation approaches, the performance measures still need improvement to generate reliable parcellations even with long acquisitions. That is, a higher reproducibility that allows researchers to replicate par- cellations and compare their studies. It is also important to minimize the information loss between the compressed data and the raw data to accurately represent the organization of an individual brain. In this thesis, I developed a new approach to parcellate the brain into distinct spatial reconfigurations called “dynamic states of parcellations”. I used a simple cluster aggregation method DYPAC1.0 of seed based parcels over multiple time windows. I hypothesized this new way to formalize the parcellation problem will improve performance measures over static parcellations. The first chapter of this document is a general context introduction to the human brain large scale networks. I also show the importance of par- cellations for a better understanding of the human brain using functional connectomes in order to predict patterns of disease progression. Then, I explain why the brain parcellation problem is hard and the different open research questions associated with this field. My research contributions are subdivided into two papers. The second and the third chapters are dedicated to the first main paper and its supplementary published in Network Neuro- science Journal. The fourth chapter represents the second paper under preparation. The fifth chapter concludes my contributions and its implications in the neuroimaging field, along with open research directions. In a nutshell, the main finding of this work is the existence of distinct spatial reconfigurations throughout the brain with near perfect reproducibility scores across test-retest data (up to .9 Pearson correlation coefficient). A simple and scalable clus- ter aggregation algorithm called DYPAC 1.0 is explained to identify these reconfigurations or “dynamic states of parcellations” for specific seed subnetworks (second chapter). The analysis of these states showed the existence of a richer repertoire of “dynamic states” in the case of heteromodal cortices (e.g., posterior cingulate cortex and the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex) compared to unimodal cortices (e.g., visual cortex). Also, the reproducibility analysis results showed that DYPAC 1.0 has better reproducibility results (in terms of Pearson corre- lation) compared to static parcels (second chapter). Several analyses demonstrate DYPAC 1.0 is robust to the choice of its parameters (third chapter). These findings and the scalabil- ity of DYPAC 1.0 motivated a full brain level analysis. I present DYPAC 2.0 as the full brain level approach to parcellate the brain into “dynamic states of parcellations”. Distinct and overlapping spatial reconfigurations or “dynamic states” are identified for different regions throughout the brain (fourth chapter). These states have promising compression scores that show low information loss between the reduced state stability maps and the original data throughout the cerebral cortices, i.e. up to only 20% loss in explained variance. This thesis thus presents new contributions in the functional parcellation field that may impact how researchers model the rich and dynamic interactions between brain networks in health and disease

Default mode resting-state functional connectivity of the aging brain

The term functional connectivity is used to describe which parts of the brain work together on a process, and might aid the understanding of how the processing systems in the human brain are fundamentally organised. The default mode network (DMN) is a constellation of cortical structures that has shown remarkable reliability as a resting-state network(RSN). It has often been referred to as a task-negative network, because it typically exhibits amplified activation patterns during rest. Numerous studies have documented DMN alterations in various clinical conditions, including mild cognitive impairment and Alzheimer’s disease. However, little is known about the impact of normal aging on this network. The present study investigates age–differences in DMN functional connectivity and further, whether the effects of age are modulated by the allelic variation of the alipoprotein E-gene, APOE. Based on current theories of cognitive aging and the few existing previous studies on restingstate patterns and APOE, we have two hypotheses: 1) an elevated co-activation in the DMN with increasing age, and 2) different effects for ε4-carriers compared to non-carriers in the MTL structures, including the hippocampus. We tested these hypotheses on resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) data from 182 healthy participants aged 20-78 years, including 63 carriers of the ε4-allele. Using a combination of independent component analysis (ICA) and dual-regression, we document regionally specific escalations in DMN synchronicity with increased age, especially in frontal brain areas. Additionally, we observed a moderate negative effect of the ε4-allele in the posterior cingulate cortex (PCC) of the posterior parts of the DMN, indicating lower co-activity in carriers compared to non-carriers in areas spanning core parts of the DMN. These findings are discussed in light of theories of cognitive aging, and we argue that the amplified DMN functional connectivity with age is indicative of an age-related decrease in neural differentiation manifested as decreased decoupling between task-negative and task-positive brain networks during rest

Big Data Analytics and Information Science for Business and Biomedical Applications II

The analysis of big data in biomedical, business and financial research has drawn much attention from researchers worldwide. This collection of articles aims to provide a platform for an in-depth discussion of novel statistical methods developed for the analysis of Big Data in these areas. Both applied and theoretical contributions to these areas are showcased

Social Cognitive and Affective Neural Substrates of Adolescent Transdiagnostic Symptoms

Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis (IUPUI)The social cognitive ability to identify another’s internal state and social affective ability to share another’s emotional experience, known as empathy, are integral to healthy social functioning. During tasks, neural systems active when adolescents empathize include cognitive (medial prefrontal cortex and posterior cingulate cortex with the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex) and affective (anterior insula and anterior cingulate cortex) regions that are consistent with the adult task-based literature implicating the default mode, salience, and frontoparietal networks. However, task-based studies are limited to examining neural regions probed by the task; thus, do not capture broader patterns of information processing associated with complex processes, such as empathy. Methods of functional connectivity capture broader patterns of information processing at the level of network connectivity. Although it has clear advantages in identifying neural vulnerabilities to disorder, functional connectivity has yet to be used in adolescent investigations of empathy. Via parent- and self-report, deficits in either cognitive or affective processes central to empathy associate with the most widely agreed on classifications of behavioral disorders in adolescents – transdiagnostic symptoms of internalizing and externalizing. However, this evidence relies exclusively on self-report measures and research has yet to examine the neural connectivity underlying transdiagnostic symptoms in relation to cognitive and affective empathy. What has yet to be known is (1) how the social cognitive and affective processes of empathy are functionally connected across a heterogeneous sample of adolescents and (2) the association of cognitive, affective, and imbalanced empathy with transdiagnostic symptoms. Addressing these gaps in knowledge is an important incremental step for specifying vulnerabilities not fully captured via subjective report alone. This information can be used to improve prevention and intervention strategies. The present study will examine the functional connectivity of neural networks underlying empathy in early to mid-adolescents and their association with transdiagnostic symptoms

Doctor of Philosophy

dissertationThe human brain is the seat of cognition and behavior. Understanding the brain mechanistically is essential for appreciating its linkages with cognitive processes and behavioral outcomes in humans. Mechanisms of brain function categorically represent rich and widely under-investigated biological substrates for neural-driven studies of psychiatry and mental health. Research examining intrinsic connectivity patterns across whole brain systems utilizes functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) to trace spontaneous fluctuations in blood oxygen-level dependent (BOLD) signals. In the first study presented, we reveal patterns of dynamic attractors in resting state functional connectivity data corresponding to well-documented biological networks. We introduce a novel simulation for whole brain dynamics that can be adapted to either group-level analysis or single-subject level models. We describe stability of intrinsic functional architecture in terms of transient and global steady states resembling biological networks. In the second study, we demonstrate plasticity in functional connectivity following a minimum six-week intervention to train cognitive performance in a speed reading task. Long-term modulation of connectivity with language regions indicate functional connectivity as a candidate biomarker for tracking and measuring functional changes in neural systems as outcomes of cognitive training. The third study demonstrates utility of functional biomarkers in predicting individual differences in behavioral and cognitive features. We successfully predict three major domains of personality psychologyintelligence, agreeableness, and conscientiousnessin individual subjects using a large (N=475) open source data sample compiled by the National Institutes of Healths Human Connectome Project

Developmental Changes in the Organization of Functional Connections between the Basal Ganglia and Cerebral Cortex

The basal ganglia (BG) comprise a set of subcortical nuclei with sensorimotor, cognitive, and limbic subdivisions, indicative of functional organization. BG dysfunction in several developmental disorders suggests the importance of the healthy maturation of these structures. However, few studies have investigated the development of BG functional organization. Using resting-state functional connectivity MRI (rs-fcMRI), we compared human child and adult functional connectivity of the BG with rs-fcMRI-defined cortical systems. Because children move more than adults, customized preprocessing, including volume censoring, was used to minimize motion-induced rsfcMRI artifact. Our results demonstrated functional organization in the adult BG consistent with subdivisions previously identified in anatomical tracing studies. Group comparisons revealed a developmental shift in bilateral posterior putamen/pallidum clusters from preferential connectivity with the somatomotor “face” system in childhood to preferential connectivity with control/attention systems (frontoparietal, ventral attention) in adulthood. This shift was due to a decline in the functional connectivity of these clusters with the somatomotor face system over development, and no change with control/attention systems. Applying multivariate pattern analysis, we were able to reliably classify individuals as children or adults based on BG–cortical system functional connectivity. Interrogation of the features driving this classification revealed, in addition to the somatomotor face system, contributions by the orbitofrontal, auditory, and somatomotor hand systems. These results demonstrate that BG–cortical functional connectivity evolves over development, and may lend insight into developmental disorders that involve BG dysfunction, particularly those involving motor systems (e.g., Tourette syndrome)