Kompozicionalni hierarhični model za pridobivanje informacij iz glasbe

In recent years, deep architectures, most commonly based on neural networks, have advanced the state of the art in many research areas. Due to the popularity and the success of deep neural-networks, other deep architectures, including compositional models, have been put aside from mainstream research. This dissertation presents the compositional hierarchical model as a novel deep architecture for music processing. Our main motivation was to develop and explore an alternative non-neural deep architecture for music processing which would be transparent, meaning that the encoded knowledge would be interpretable, trained in an unsupervised manner and on small datasets, and useful as a feature extractor for classification tasks, as well as a transparent model for unsupervised pattern discovery. We base our work on compositional models, as compositionality is inherent in music. The proposed compositional hierarchical model learns a multi-layer hierarchical representation of the analyzed music signals in an unsupervised manner. It provides transparent insights into the learned concepts and their structure. It can be used as a feature extractor---its output can be used for classification tasks using existing machine learning techniques. Moreover, the model\u27s transparency enables an interpretation of the learned concepts, so the model can be used for analysis (exploration of the learned hierarchy) or discovery-oriented (inferring the hierarchy) tasks, which is difficult with most neural network based architectures. The proposed model uses relative coding of the learned concepts, which eliminates the need for large annotated training datasets that are essential in deep architectures with a large number of parameters. Relative coding contributes to slim models, which are fast to execute and have low memory requirements. The model also incorporates several biologically-inspired mechanisms that are modeled according to the mechanisms that exists at the lower levels of human perception (eg~ lateral inhibition in the human ear) and that significantly affect perception. The proposed model is evaluated on several music information retrieval tasks and its results are compared to the current state of the art. The dissertation is structured as follows. In the first chapter we present the motivation for the development of the new model. In the second chapter we elaborate on the related work in music information retrieval and review other compositional and transparent models. Chapter three introduces a thorough description of the proposed model. The model structure, its learning and inference methods are explained, as well as the incorporated biologically-inspired mechanisms. The model is then applied to several different music domains, which are divided according to the type of input data. In this we follow the timeline of the development and the implementation of the model. In chapter four, we present the model\u27s application to audio recordings, specifically for two tasks: automatic chord estimation and multiple fundamental frequency estimation. In chapter five, we present the model\u27s application to symbolic music representations. We concentrate on pattern discovery, emphasizing the model\u27s ability to tackle such problems. We also evaluate the model as a feature generator for tune family classification. Finally, in chapter six, we show the latest progress in developing the model for representing rhythm and show that it exhibits a high degree of robustness in extracting high-level rhythmic structures from music signals. We conclude the dissertation by summarizing our work and the results, elaborating on forthcoming work in the development of the model and its future applications.S porastom globokih arhitektur, ki temeljijo na nevronskih mrežah, so se v zadnjem času bistveno izboljšali rezultati pri reševanju problemov na več področjih. Zaradi popularnosti in uspešnosti teh globokih pristopov, temelječih na nevronskih mrežah, so bili drugi, predvsem kompozicionalni pristopi, odmaknjeni od središča pozornosti raziskav. V pričujoči disertaciji se posvečamo vprašanju, ali je mogoče razviti globoko arhitekturo, ki bo presegla obstoječe probleme globokih arhitektur. S tem namenom se vračamo h kompozicionalnim modelom in predstavimo kompozicionalni hierarhični model kot alternativno globoko arhitekturo, ki bo imela naslednje značilnosti: transparentnost, ki omogoča enostavno razlago naučenih konceptov, nenadzorovano učenje in zmožnost učenja na majhnih podatkovnih bazah, uporabnost modela kot izluščevalca značilk, kot tudi zmožnost uporabe transparentnosti modela za odkrivanje vzorcev. Naše delo temelji na kompozicionalnih modelih, ki so v glasbi intuitivni. Predlagani kompozicionalni hierarhični model je zmožen nenadzorovanega učenja večnivojske predstavitve glasbenega vhoda. Model omogoča pregled naučenih konceptov skozi transparentne strukture. Lahko ga uporabimo kot generator značilk -- izhod modela lahko uporabimo za klasifikacijo z drugimi pristopi strojnega učenja. Hkrati pa lahko transparentnost predlaganega modela uporabimo za analizo (raziskovanje naučene hierarhije) pri odkrivanju vzorcev, kar je težko izvedljivo z ostalimi pristopi, ki temeljijo na nevronskih mrežah. Relativno kodiranje konceptov v samem modelu pripomore k precej manjšim modelom in posledično zmanjšuje potrebo po velikih podatkovnih zbirkah, potrebnih za učenje modela. Z vpeljavo biološko navdahnjenih mehanizmov želimo model še bolj približati človeškemu načinu zaznave. Za nekatere mehanizme, na primer inhibicijo, vemo, da so v človeški percepciji prisotni na nižjih nivojih v ušesu in bistveno vplivajo na način zaznave. V modelu uvedemo prve korake k takšnemu načinu procesiranja proti končnemu cilju izdelave modela, ki popolnoma odraža človeško percepcijo. V prvem poglavju disertacije predstavimo motivacijo za razvoj novega modela. V drugem poglavju se posvetimo dosedanjim objavljenim dosežkom na tem področju. V nadaljnjih poglavjih se osredotočimo na sam model. Sprva opišemo teoretično zasnovo modela in način učenja ter delovanje biološko-navdahnjenih mehanizmov. V naslednjem koraku model apliciramo na več različnih glasbenih domen, ki so razdeljene glede na tip vhodnih podatkov. Pri tem sledimo časovnici razvoja in implementacijam modela tekom doktorskega študija. Najprej predstavimo aplikacijo modela za časovno-frekvenčne signale, na katerem model preizkusimo za dve opravili: avtomatsko ocenjevanje harmonij in avtomatsko transkripcijo osnovnih frekvenc. V petem poglavju predstavimo drug način aplikacije modela, tokrat na simbolne vhodne podatke, ki predstavljajo glasbeni zapis. Pri tem pristopu se osredotočamo na odkrivanje vzorcev, s čimer poudarimo zmožnost modela za reševanje tovrstnih problemov, ki je ostalim pristopom še nedosegljivo. Model prav tako evalviramo v vlogi generatorja značilk. Pri tem ga evalviramo na problemu melodične podobnosti pesmi in razvrščanja v variantne tipe. Nazadnje, v šestem poglavju, pokažemo zadnji dosežek razvoja modela, ki ga apliciramo na problem razumevanja ritma v glasbi. Prilagojeni model analiziramo in pokažemo njegovo zmožnost učenja različnih ritmičnih oblik in visoko stopnjo robustnosti pri izluščevanju visokonivojskih struktur v ritmu. V zaključkih disertacije povzamemo vloženo delo in rezultate ter nakažemo nadaljnje korake za razvoj modela v prihodnosti

Assai: historical contexts of a contested musical term

This study seeks to establish the feasibility of assai as a moderating term in more cases than is typically assumed. Since evidence of concurrent competing definitions for the term assai exists from the mid- to late-18th century, understanding and putting into practice a composer’s indications according to his own understanding of the term becomes murky where the word assai is concerned during and beyond the time when the two definitions exist concurrently. Through investigation of musical scores, examining such features as ornamentation, the relative brilliance of the work, tonality, meter, and structure, the characteristics of a piece of music that are crucial to navigating the multivalent qualities of the word assai are identified and tested against the actual musical content of examples from works of J. S. Bach, Domenico Scarlatti, W. F. Bach, J. C. F. Bach, Johann Friedrich Agricola, C. P. E. Bach, W. A. Mozart, F. J. Haydn, Ludwig van Beethoven, Frédéric Chopin, and Franz Liszt

Conducting Elgar\u27s Wand of Youth suites : programming possibilities and perspectives on performance

The purpose of this monograph is to provide a performer’s guide and conductor’s analysis for both of Sir Edward Elgar’s suites op. 1a and 1b, titled The Wand of Youth: Music to a Child’s Play. Sources for this work draw from the extensive scholarly writings on Elgar’s biography, compositional practice, and recordings, as well as from sources discussing issues of conducting analysis, gesture, and concert programming. As common techniques in formal and harmonic analysis are a standard component of performance guides, this work also includes commentary to that effect. The first section of this work briefly situates the composition of Elgar’s Wand of Youth suites into the already well-established biography of that composer. This section also provides readers with an account of the works’ compositional genesis, placement within Elgar’s oeuvre, and a review of literature for current scholarly debate regarding these works. The second section gives a conductor’s analysis of both of Elgar’s Wand of Youth suites based on the conductor’s analytical perspective used in Norman Del Mar’s performance guides. This perspective uses a narrative description of a piece of music as a framework to discuss the necessary shifts of attention required from a well-prepared conductor while rehearsing or performing a work. In addition to a narrative description of events, this perspective also offers practical commentary on effective gestures tailored to the musical material at hand, as well as warnings of potential difficulties in rehearsal or performance. This analysis also discusses issues of pacing and of compositional architecture. The conclusion of this work is a discussion of programming possibilities for the Wand of Youth suites as part of symphonic, youth outreach, or mixed media concert programming. This section also discusses relevant performance practices and revisions or reductions that may be taken from Elgar’s own performances as a conductor and recordings of the works

Computational analysis of world music corpora

PhDThe comparison of world music cultures has been considered in musicological research since the end of the 19th century. Traditional methods from the field of comparative musicology typically involve the process of manual music annotation. While this provides expert knowledge, the manual input is timeconsuming and limits the potential for large-scale research. This thesis considers computational methods for the analysis and comparison of world music cultures. In particular, Music Information Retrieval (MIR) tools are developed for processing sound recordings, and data mining methods are considered to study similarity relationships in world music corpora. MIR tools have been widely used for the study of (mainly) Western music. The first part of this thesis focuses on assessing the suitability of audio descriptors for the study of similarity in world music corpora. An evaluation strategy is designed to capture challenges in the automatic processing of world music recordings and different state-of-the-art descriptors are assessed. Following this evaluation, three approaches to audio feature extraction are considered, each addressing a different research question. First, a study of singing style similarity is presented. Singing is one of the most common forms of musical expression and it has played an important role in the oral transmission of world music. Hand-designed pitch descriptors are used to model aspects of the singing voice and clustering methods reveal singing style similarities in world music. Second, a study on music dissimilarity is performed. While musical exchange is evident in the history of world music it might be possible that some music cultures have resisted external musical influence. Low-level audio features are combined with machine learning methods to find music examples that stand out in a world music corpus, and geographical patterns are examined. The last study models music similarity using descriptors learned automatically with deep neural networks. It focuses on identifying music examples that appear to be similar in their audio content but share no (obvious) geographical or cultural links in their metadata. Unexpected similarities modelled in this way uncover possible hidden links between world music cultures. This research investigates whether automatic computational analysis can uncover meaningful similarities between recordings of world music. Applications derive musicological insights from one of the largest world music corpora studied so far. Computational analysis as proposed in this thesis advances the state-of-the-art in the study of world music and expands the knowledge and understanding of musical exchange in the world.Queen Mary Principal’s research studentship

Compositional hierarchical model for music information retrieval

In recent years, deep architectures, most commonly based on neural networks, have advanced the state of the art in many research areas. Due to the popularity and the success of deep neural-networks, other deep architectures, including compositional models, have been put aside from mainstream research. This dissertation presents the compositional hierarchical model as a novel deep architecture for music processing. Our main motivation was to develop and explore an alternative non-neural deep architecture for music processing which would be transparent, meaning that the encoded knowledge would be interpretable, trained in an unsupervised manner and on small datasets, and useful as a feature extractor for classification tasks, as well as a transparent model for unsupervised pattern discovery. We base our work on compositional models, as compositionality is inherent in music. The proposed compositional hierarchical model learns a multi-layer hierarchical representation of the analyzed music signals in an unsupervised manner. It provides transparent insights into the learned concepts and their structure. It can be used as a feature extractor—its output can be used for classification tasks using existing machine learning techniques. Moreover, the model’s transparency enables an interpretation of the learned concepts, so the model can be used for analysis (exploration of the learned hierarchy) or discovery-oriented (inferring the hierarchy) tasks, which is difficult with most neural network based architectures. The proposed model uses relative coding of the learned concepts, which eliminates the need for large annotated training datasets that are essential in deep architectures with a large number of parameters. Relative coding contributes to slim models, which are fast to execute and have low memory requirements. The model also incorporates several biologically-inspired mechanisms that are modeled according to the mechanisms that exists at the lower levels of human perception (e.g. lateral inhibition in the human ear) and that significantly affect perception. The proposed model is evaluated on several music information retrieval tasks and its results are compared to the current state of the art. The dissertation is structured as follows. In the first chapter we present the motivation for the development of the new model. In the second chapter we elaborate on the related work in music information retrieval and review other compositional and transparent models. Chapter three introduces a thorough description of the proposed model. The model structure, its learning and inference methods are explained, as well as the incorporated biologically-inspired mechanisms. The model is then applied to several different music domains, which are divided according to the type of input data. In this we follow the timeline of the development and the implementation of the model. In chapter four, we present the model’s application to audio recordings, specifically for two tasks: automatic chord estimation and multiple fundamental frequency estimation. In chapter five, we present the model’s application to symbolic music representations. We concentrate on pattern discovery, emphasizing the model’s ability to tackle such problems. We also evaluate the model as a feature generator for tune family classification. Finally, in chapter six, we show the latest progress in developing the model for representing rhythm and show that it exhibits a high degree of robustness in extracting high-level rhythmic structures from music signals. We conclude the dissertation by summarizing our work and the results, elaborating on forthcoming work in the development of the model and its future applications

Compositional hierarchical model for music information retrieval

In recent years, deep architectures, most commonly based on neural networks, have advanced the state of the art in many research areas. Due to the popularity and the success of deep neural-networks, other deep architectures, including compositional models, have been put aside from mainstream research. This dissertation presents the compositional hierarchical model as a novel deep architecture for music processing. Our main motivation was to develop and explore an alternative non-neural deep architecture for music processing which would be transparent, meaning that the encoded knowledge would be interpretable, trained in an unsupervised manner and on small datasets, and useful as a feature extractor for classification tasks, as well as a transparent model for unsupervised pattern discovery. We base our work on compositional models, as compositionality is inherent in music. The proposed compositional hierarchical model learns a multi-layer hierarchical representation of the analyzed music signals in an unsupervised manner. It provides transparent insights into the learned concepts and their structure. It can be used as a feature extractor—its output can be used for classification tasks using existing machine learning techniques. Moreover, the model’s transparency enables an interpretation of the learned concepts, so the model can be used for analysis (exploration of the learned hierarchy) or discovery-oriented (inferring the hierarchy) tasks, which is difficult with most neural network based architectures. The proposed model uses relative coding of the learned concepts, which eliminates the need for large annotated training datasets that are essential in deep architectures with a large number of parameters. Relative coding contributes to slim models, which are fast to execute and have low memory requirements. The model also incorporates several biologically-inspired mechanisms that are modeled according to the mechanisms that exists at the lower levels of human perception (e.g. lateral inhibition in the human ear) and that significantly affect perception. The proposed model is evaluated on several music information retrieval tasks and its results are compared to the current state of the art. The dissertation is structured as follows. In the first chapter we present the motivation for the development of the new model. In the second chapter we elaborate on the related work in music information retrieval and review other compositional and transparent models. Chapter three introduces a thorough description of the proposed model. The model structure, its learning and inference methods are explained, as well as the incorporated biologically-inspired mechanisms. The model is then applied to several different music domains, which are divided according to the type of input data. In this we follow the timeline of the development and the implementation of the model. In chapter four, we present the model’s application to audio recordings, specifically for two tasks: automatic chord estimation and multiple fundamental frequency estimation. In chapter five, we present the model’s application to symbolic music representations. We concentrate on pattern discovery, emphasizing the model’s ability to tackle such problems. We also evaluate the model as a feature generator for tune family classification. Finally, in chapter six, we show the latest progress in developing the model for representing rhythm and show that it exhibits a high degree of robustness in extracting high-level rhythmic structures from music signals. We conclude the dissertation by summarizing our work and the results, elaborating on forthcoming work in the development of the model and its future applications

Sequential decision making in artificial musical intelligence

Over the past 60 years, artificial intelligence has grown from a largely academic field of research to a ubiquitous array of tools and approaches used in everyday technology. Despite its many recent successes and growing prevalence, certain meaningful facets of computational intelligence have not been as thoroughly explored. Such additional facets cover a wide array of complex mental tasks which humans carry out easily, yet are difficult for computers to mimic. A prime example of a domain in which human intelligence thrives, but machine understanding is still fairly limited, is music. Over the last decade, many researchers have applied computational tools to carry out tasks such as genre identification, music summarization, music database querying, and melodic segmentation. While these are all useful algorithmic solutions, we are still a long way from constructing complete music agents, able to mimic (at least partially) the complexity with which humans approach music. One key aspect which hasn't been sufficiently studied is that of sequential decision making in musical intelligence. This thesis strives to answer the following question: Can a sequential decision making perspective guide us in the creation of better music agents, and social agents in general? And if so, how? More specifically, this thesis focuses on two aspects of musical intelligence: music recommendation and human-agent (and more generally agent-agent) interaction in the context of music. The key contributions of this thesis are the design of better music playlist recommendation algorithms; the design of algorithms for tracking user preferences over time; new approaches for modeling people's behavior in situations that involve music; and the design of agents capable of meaningful interaction with humans and other agents in a setting where music plays a roll (either directly or indirectly). Though motivated primarily by music-related tasks, and focusing largely on people's musical preferences, this thesis also establishes that insights from music-specific case studies can also be applicable in other concrete social domains, such as different types of content recommendation. Showing the generality of insights from musical data in other contexts serves as evidence for the utility of music domains as testbeds for the development of general artificial intelligence techniques. Ultimately, this thesis demonstrates the overall usefulness of taking a sequential decision making approach in settings previously unexplored from this perspectiveComputer Science

Thematic Interconnectivity as an Innate Musical Quality: An Investigation of Jandek's "European Jewel" Guitar Riffs

This dissertation is divided into two main areas. The first of these explores Jandek-related discourse and contextualizes the project. Also discussed is the interconnectivity that runs through the project through the self-citation of various lyrical, visual, and musical themes. The second main component of this dissertation explores one of these musical themes in detail: the guitar riffs heard in the “European Jewel” song-set and the transmigration/migration of the riff material used in the song to other non-“European Jewel” tracks. Jandek is often described in related discourse as an “outsider musician.” A significant point of discussion in the first area of this dissertation is the outsider music genre as it relates to Jandek. In part, this dissertation responds to an article by Martin James and Mitzi Waltz which was printed in the periodical Popular Music where it was suggested that the marketing of a musician as an outsider risks diminishing the “innate qualities” of the so-called outsider musicians’ works. While the outsider label is in itself problematic—this is discussed at length in Chapter Two—the analysis which comprises the second half of this dissertation delves into self-citation and thematic interconnection as innate qualities within the project. Explored at length in this dissertation are the guitar riffs of the Jandek song “European Jewel,” the closing track appearing on the artist’s debut album, Ready for the House (1978). The riffs are heard 37 times over the course of five different versions of the song. Elements of the riffs also appear in tracks that are not labeled as “European Jewel” variants. A larger structural form in which the song-set is situated has been observed. When heard outside of the “European Jewel” song-set the riffs appear in fragmented form. Continued use of the “European Jewel” riff material lasts until the album One Foot in the North (1991). Much attention has been given to the interconnection between certain visual and lyrical ideas present in the project by Jandek fans; however, Jandek has not been investigated at any great length in music scholarship, popular or otherwise. In part, this investigation contributes to the breadth of popular music scholarship by exploring this underrepresented act. It also delves into the sonic qualities which are intrinsic to Jandek. This type of sonic analysis is performed in order to separate Jandek’s sonic qualities from non-sonic discussions of the project. Finally, this dissertation poses the question of whether or not these qualities are of value to fans and scholars